Table.Briefing: Europe (English)

The new climate team + ACEA changes direction + Tasks of the parliamentary Vice-Presidents

Dear reader,

Some are talking about new commissioners or executive vice presidents, others are talking about cars. Fleet limits are one topic, while punitive tariffs on Chinese EVs are another hotly debated issue in the automotive industry.

Valdis Dombrovskis, the current Vice-President of the Commission and Trade Commissioner, met with the CEOs of automotive companies on Wednesday afternoon. What exactly the participants discussed was initially not made public.

Today, Dombrovskis is meeting the head of the Chinese Ministry of Commerce, Wang Wentao. The two are discussing the Commission’s anti-subsidy investigation into electric vehicles from China. China calls the planned measure by the Brussels authority protectionism. The Union calls it fair compensation for unfair subsidies. But nothing has been decided yet, which is why Wentao is making the trip.

I wish you an exciting Thursday.

Your
Corinna Visser
Image of Corinna  Visser

Feature

Von der Leyen’s climate team: Green Deal and industrial policy become one

EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has put together a promising team of Commissioners to continue the climate policy agenda over the next five years. Spain’s Teresa Ribera will be the new Commissioner for Competition. What does not initially sound like a climate portfolio actually involves the task of aligning the European Union’s state aid law with the EU’s climate targets – specifically, the expansion of renewables and industrial decarbonization.

According to a senior Commission official, Ribera’s competitive portfolio is the key to achieving the 2030 climate targets. The five-year mandate of this Commission ends shortly before the greenhouse gas reduction target of 55 percent compared to 1990 must be achieved. Consequently, the new Commission is “fully focussed” on the EU’s 2030 climate target, the official added.

Ribera, Séjourné and Hoekstra lead the ‘Clean Industrial Deal’

The plan is to be brought to life with a Green Deal 2.0 named “Clean Industrial Deal.”
The ambitious and experienced climate politician Ribera and the French liberal industrial commissioner Stéphane Séjourné will oversee it. This shows that there is no room for regression, but rather the intention to step up the ambition for more climate action in industrial and economic policy, says Chiara Martinelli, Director of Climate Action Network Europe (CAN). Europe must undoubtedly continue to be a climate champion and achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, but also remain competitive along the way – that is the signal that von der Leyen sent out on Tuesday.

Reporting to Ribera will be Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra, Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen and Environment Commissioner Jessika Roswall. Hoekstra and Jørgensen are also experienced climate politicians – one as current Climate Commissioner, the other as former Energy and Environment Minister in Denmark.

Von der Leyen’s mandate to combine climate action with industrial and economic policy is also reflected here in the allocation of tasks. The legislative work for the “Clean Industrial Deal” comes from the Directorates-General for Climate Action (DG CLIMA) and Internal Market and Industry (DG GROW). This means that Hoekstra and Séjourné are tasked with jointly driving forward industrial decarbonization, the ramp-up of clean technologies and investment incentives.

Hoekstra could get serious about the kerosene tax

Hoekstra’s nomination also ensures continuity. As he did last year in Dubai, he will also lead the international climate negotiations at COP29 in Baku this November. If Hoekstra’s portfolio had changed, the EU would have appeared headless, given Hungary’s unambitious climate policy presidency in Baku. Von der Leyen has found an elegant and satisfactory solution for both Hoekstra and the Dutch government.

He and his subordinate DG CLIMA are also responsible for drafting the legislative package for the EU’s 2040 climate target, whose reduction target of 90 percent Hoekstra himself presented back in February. Moreover, he has been assigned the tax portfolio – the economic task the Netherlands had hoped for. Among other things, he will work on aligning value-added taxes with environmental criteria. Hoekstra could also drive the introduction of climate taxes and end environmentally harmful subsidies and tax privileges. For example, he could now tackle the issue of the kerosene tax, which was announced a year ago.

Jørgensen to promote CCS and nuclear power

Danish national Jørgensen also has a relevant climate profile, but will now be Energy Commissioner. The economic aspects of his portfolio are obvious: Low energy prices are essential for economic recovery. However, von der Leyen insists that energy sources must become cleaner. According to the Commission President, small modular nuclear power plants and CO2 capture technologies, which Jørgensen is supposed to help ramp up, will also help.

Jørgensen is a solid choice as Energy Commissioner, says Linda Kalcher, Director of the Brussels-based think tank Strategic Perspectives. “I expect him to be immune to greenwashing, that blue hydrogen or various carbon capture technologies will solve all our problems of tomorrow, and that he will be pragmatic about nuclear energy.”

Remaining doubts about Roswall

Although Environment Commissioner-designate Jessika Roswall has no experience in her new area of responsibility, she is a clever political compromise. The EPP party family had recently focussed its criticism primarily on nature conservation and is now getting a responsible Commissioner from its own ranks.

Von der Leyen will certainly not give her free rein. Her department will have to make a significant contribution to the planned European climate adaptation plan and revise the controversial EU chemicals regulation REACH, which some in the EPP will not be happy about and is likely to greatly impact the chemical industry.

She will have an easier time selling environmental protection in her party family than her Green predecessor, Virginijus Sinkevičius. But the Environment Committee could make life difficult for her. Sweden voted against the Nature Restoration Law and did not support the anti-deforestation regulation, liberal environmental politician Pascal Canfin posted on X. Commissioners usually jointly represent Commission proposals. Now, Canfin suggests, there is a risk that Roswall will go against the Commission’s line. “We will have to make sure she acts as true EU commissioner.”

Séjourné is to create lead markets for clean tech

In addition, Séjourné has been tasked with proposing an “Industrial Decarbonization Accelerator Act” to promote “European lead markets for the development, production and diffusion in industry of clean tech” and accelerating planning, tendering and approval procedures, especially for energy-intensive industries. The European Commission has thus taken up an idea that German Economy Minister Robert Habeck had previously put forward with his concept for green lead markets.

At a panel discussion on Wednesday, Director-General Kerstin Jorna (DG GROW) and Director-General Kurt Vandenberghe (DG CLIMA) gave an initial insight into the new Commission’s industrial strategy: “The real question will be how to make the business case of the transition a good business case,” said Jorna. This business case does not yet exist in Europe, especially in energy-intensive industries such as steel, glass, cement and chemicals. While the Net Zero Industry Act (NZIA) of the last mandate has improved the approval processes for sustainable energy technologies, this has not yet been done for the customers of these technologies, she said.

Public procurement should prioritize European suppliers

In parallel with the Accelerator Act, Séjourné has also taken on the task of adapting public procurement rules in favor of European companies. The explicitly formulated goal of favoring European producers is new. Such “buy European” clauses have been included in draft versions of the NZIA in the past – but they were then omitted from the Commission’s final proposal.

The Commissioners-designate will now have to attend hearings before the relevant committees in the EU Parliament. They will be questioned about their qualifications for the job as well as potential political conflicts. The committee coordinators of the political groups then vote on the appointment. Finally, the plenary of the EU Parliament will vote on the entire college of the new EU Commission.

  • Climate & Environment
  • COP29
  • EU climate policy
  • EU climate target 2040
  • EVP
  • Fit for 55
  • Green Deal
  • Industrial policy
  • Net Zero Industry Act
Translation missing.

Events

Sept. 23-27, 2024; Vienna (Austria)
Conference EU PVSEC 2024
This conference discusses the latest developments in photovoltaics. INFO & REGISTRATION

Sept. 24, 2024; 10 a.m.-4 p.m., online
ESC Worskhop on Methodology for Flexibility Needs Assessments
The Energy Storage Coalition (ESC) discusses how methodology could be shaped to ensure it is future-proof and supports the appropriate deployment of energy storage technologies and renewables. INFO & REGISTRATION

Translation missing.

News

European Parliament: Competences of the Vice-Presidents have been determined

Parliament President Roberta Metsola has assigned the 14 Vice-Presidents and five Quaestors of the European Parliament their areas of responsibility. Two German MEPs are members of the Bureau:

Sabine Verheyen (CDU), who received the most votes in her election as Vice-President of Parliament, will be responsible for the working areas in the Presidium:

  • Communication and public relations
  • Parties and foundations
  • Household
  • Artificial intelligence
  • Building
  • Luxembourg as a parliamentary seat
  • Lux price

Katarina Barley (SPD), who achieved 450 votes in the election and thus the fourth-best result, will be responsible for:

  • Relations with national parliaments
  • European Parliament Week
  • Arbitration
  • Relations with civil society organizations
  • Ethics committee
  • Audit Committee
  • Artistic Committee
  • Representation of the President of Parliament at the twinning meeting with the British Parliament

The Bureau has also decided to implement the plans for the reform of the parliamentary administration. The former DG for Internal Strategies (IPOL) is to be split into four new DGs. mgr

  • Europäisches Parlament

CO2 fleet limits: MEPs bring earlier review into play

The automotive umbrella organization ACEA does not want to call on the Commission to use the emergency clause of the European Treaties, Article 122, to suspend fines for fleet limits and postpone them for two years. According to reports in Brussels, there was not enough support among manufacturers for ACEA President Luca de Meo’s proposal.

Instead, ACEA is calling on the Commission to take “urgent measures to facilitate (the industry)” before the new limits come into force. In addition, the reviews of fleet legislation for both passenger cars and commercial vehicles provided for in the law should be brought forward. This was agreed between the CEOs and the lobby association. The idea of bringing forward the review of the CO2 fleet legislation by one year and proposing changes to targets and penalties had also been proposed by VDA President Hildegard Müller.

In 2025, the fleet limits will fall from an average of 95 grams of CO2 per kilometer driven and new car to 93.6 grams. As the proportion of battery-electric vehicles (EVs) is not increasing as assumed, several manufacturers will miss the OEM-specific targets. The industry is threatened with fines totaling €15 billion for 2025 alone. Volkswagen and Renault in particular could be hit with high penalties.

Bypassing Parliament

If the CO2 fleet regulation were to be amended via Article 122, there would be no regular legislative procedure. Instead, the Commission would declare that the industry could suffer significant economic damage if the law were not amended immediately. Parliament would not be involved. The Commission would make a proposal to the Council, which the Council would then have to adopt. According to a non-paper from the Renault environment, which is available to Table.Media, the demand should be made to postpone the entry into force of the 2025 limits by two years.

Transport politicians warn that now is not the right time for the industry to demand the suspension of limit values through emergency legislation. At the upcoming hearings of candidates for the posts of Commissioner for Transport and Environment in the coming weeks, questions from MEPs would put future Commissioners in a difficult position. Should they speak out in favor of bypassing Parliament as co-legislators?

Jens Gieseke (CDU), coordinator in the Transport Committee, has submitted a written question to the Commission calling for the review of fleet limits to be brought forward from 2026 to 2025. The written question is available to Table.Briefings and is supported by several members of the CDU/CSU group. The Commission now has six weeks to respond. mgr

  • Autoindustrie
  • Climate & Environment
  • EU Parliament
  • European Commission
  • Flottengrenzwerte
Translation missing.

Hungary: Millions in fines to be deducted from EU funds

Because Hungary has not paid a €200 million fine, the European Commission wants to deduct the money from future EU payments to Budapest. The fine was imposed by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in June due to violations of EU asylum law by the government in Budapest.

The 15-day deadline for Hungary to pay the €200 million expired on Tuesday, a Commission spokesperson said. A so-called compensation procedure will therefore be initiated. “We will now deduct the €200 million from upcoming payments from the EU budget to Hungary.”

In the summer, the ECJ found an exceptionally serious violation of EU law by the government of conservative head of government Viktor Orbán. The ECJ had already declared significant parts of the Hungarian asylum system to be unlawful in previous rulings. The European Commission has also been accusing Hungary of disregarding EU standards and fundamental values for years and has already frozen billions in funding for the country as a result.

Daily penalty payment

In addition, Hungary must pay a daily penalty of €1 million for each day of delay following a ruling by the ECJ. The fine was imposed on Budapest more than 90 days ago. A spokesperson for the EU Commission said that the Commission had asked Hungary to pay the fine. The Hungarian authorities now have 45 days to do so.

Following the ECJ ruling, Budapest threatened to bring refugees and migrants to Brussels. “If Brussels wants the migrants, it should get them”, said Hungarian Chancellery Minister Gergely Gulyas, a close associate of Orbán.

Green MEP Daniel Freund welcomed the Commission’s decision. “The Commission must remain firm”, he said. EU money should only flow to Hungary again in full once EU law is enforced. dpa

  • EU-Haushalt
  • Ungarn

Google AdSense: EGC overturns billion-euro fine

Margrethe Vestager’s triumph was short-lived. After winning two cases before the ECJ last week, the EU Commission has now suffered a defeat in another legal dispute with Google. The General Court of the European Union has annulled a fine of €1.49 billion imposed on Google by the Commission. The Commission had accused Google of hindering competition with its AdSense Search advertising service. However, the court found fault with the assessment of the duration of these clauses and annulled the decision.

In 2019, the EU Commission accused Google of suppressing competition in the field of search engine advertising through exclusivity, placement and approval clauses in contracts with website operators. The clauses would have made it more difficult for competitors to place ads on the sites of these operators. Google had amended the relevant clauses in 2016 before the Commission concluded its investigation. The Court’s decision raises doubts as to whether the Commission correctly assessed the impact of the clauses on competition.

Evidence from the Commission not sufficient

The court criticized the fact that the Commission had incorrectly assessed the duration of the disputed contractual clauses. Many of the contracts in question had only been concluded for a short period of time and contained options for termination or renegotiation. In addition, the Commission was unable to provide sufficient evidence that the clauses had significantly impeded competitors’ access to the market. The Commission has two months to appeal against the current decision.

Markus Ferber (CSU), spokesperson for the EPP Group in the Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee, criticized the fact that an EU court has once again overturned a competition fine imposed by the Commission. “The record of Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, who has declared herself a champion against big tech companies, remains more than sobering“, said the EPP politician. Vestager’s record raises questions as to whether the Commission has always worked thoroughly enough. “The new Competition Commissioner would do well to be more down-to-earth.”

Commission likely to remain confrontational

Ferber’s parliamentary group colleague Andreas Schwab (CDU) argues differently and expects the Commission to take the case to the ECJ. “There is no doubt about Google’s anti-competitive behavior“, says Schwab. The court had confirmed the majority of the Commission’s findings. “This case shows that fairness has not yet been achieved in the digital markets. Abuses of dominant market positions are destroying our internal market.”

Sarah Blazek from the law firm Noerr also called the current ruling a setback: “Even if many of the Commission’s findings have been confirmed: The EGC makes it clear that even in the case of Big Tech, no separate standards are to be applied.” The Commission made technical errors“. Nevertheless, it is to be expected that the Commission will “continue to pursue its confrontational course against Big Tech”. Blazek: “The Digital Markets Act, which is now in force, is likely to play a major role in this.” vis

  • Wettbewerbspolitik

Federal government’s raw materials fund can start

The German government’s raw materials fund, which has been planned for some time, can now begin: Federal Minister for Economic Affairs Robert Habeck and Federal Minister of Finance Christian Lindner have instructed the state development bank KfW to set up the fund. This was reported by Handelsblatt, referring to a letter from the two ministers to KfW CEO Stefan Wintels. According to the letter, the bank is to use the fund to promote raw materials projects in order to secure the supply of raw materials to German companies, reduce their dependence on other countries and strengthen the resilience of supply chains and the national economy.

The fund, with which KfW is to provide around €1 billion for strategic raw materials projects from 2024 to 2028, had already been ready for some time. According to information from Table.Briefings, the ministries had also long since agreed on the content. However, the BMF had not released the funds. As reported by Handelsblatt, this was due to the controversial issue of whether raw materials projects should be funded with loans or equity. Habeck and his ministry had pushed for the equity option and ultimately prevailed: It is now possible for the federal government to participate in the funded projects with equity. leo

  • Lieferketten

Must Reads

Heads

Henna Virkkunen – Finland’s Ironwoman in the new Commission

With Henna Virkkunen, Finland is sending a Member of the European Parliament with an industrial policy profile to the Commission.

Henna Virkkunen’s list of duties is more extensive than the mission letters that Ursula von der Leyen sent to other members of the new Commission. The Finnish woman’s remit is very broad: As Executive Vice-President for Technical Sovereignty, Security and Democracy, she is to ensure that digital technologies are developed in line with European values, improve cyber security, tackle disinformation, and protect the EU’s democratic institutions. Provided that the European Parliament approves her nomination, but there is little doubt about that.

For the first time, Virkkunen will be responsible for both internal and external security. Another new aspect is that both DG CNECT and DG DIGIT will report directly to her. The development of an AI strategy is one of her tasks, as is supporting the establishment of a European AI Research Council.

The tasks match their profile and the interests of their country. “The most important European policy issues for Finland are security and the internal market“, says Manuel Müller, EU expert at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs. Virkkunen has made a name for himself in the area of the economy, but not in security policy.

The topic of platform regulation discovered early on

In the European Parliament, Virkkunen has been a member of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (ITRE) since 2014 and was also a member of the Committee on Transport and Tourism (TRAN). She was Chair of the EPP’s SME Group, which monitors the impact of European legislation on small and medium-sized enterprises.

In her ten years in the European Parliament, the 52-year-old has worked on numerous industrial policy issues, often with a digital focus. As co-rapporteur for an EP own-initiative report on online platforms and the digital single market, she was one of the first parliamentarians to deal intensively with the topic of platform regulation.

Cyber Resilience Act, DSA and Connecting Europe

She was rapporteur for the Cybersecurity Regulation for the EU institutions, worked on the Cyber Resilience Act and the Digital Services Act, and was also a member of the Committee of Inquiry into the Pegasus affair. As rapporteur, she was also responsible for the regulation of the Connecting Europe facility and was involved in the report on Horizon Europe. In addition, she was involved in numerous regulations in the transport sector.

Henna Virkkunen also has experience in government. She first entered the Finnish parliament in 2007. In 2008, she became Minister, first for Education and then for Public Administration. She was Minister of Transport for a short time before moving to the European Parliament. In von der Leyen’s view, this experience qualifies her for the higher tasks in the Commission. Especially as Finland was one of the few member states to nominate a woman.

As Finland’s largest governing party, the National Coalition Party (Kokoomus, KOK) has decided who it wants to send to the new Commission. Prime Minister Petteri Orpo had announced that the party would be someone who had stood as a candidate in the European elections. It had long been considered likely that his party colleague would be chosen. “Virkkunen is the face of Kokoomus in Brussels“, says expert Müller. “From a party perspective, she is an obvious choice.”

While she is now preparing for the hearing before the European Parliament, she has appointed Antti Timonen, the deputy spokesperson of Parliament President Roberta Metsola, as head of her transition team. This team will become Virkkunen’s cabinet if her appointment is confirmed.

Participant in reality show

“I’m a European reformer who grew up with porridge”, says Henna Virkkunen about herself. She lives with her husband and son in Jyväskylä, a city with around 150,000 inhabitants in central Finland. She studied journalism and has worked as a journalist and in communications. Virkkunen describes herself as a “horse girl” and likes to show herself in photos in the forest and doing sports. She runs marathons and takes part in the Ironman.

She also demonstrated her fitness in the reality TV show “Erikoisjoukot” in 2022. In the show, prominent participants complete exercises based on selection tests for the Finnish special forces. The German public would probably react to the participation of a nationally known politician in such a format with amusement and ridicule, if not outrage. In Finland, on the other hand, this is no big deal. But an MEP jumping out of a helicopter into a lake in full gear is unlikely to be an everyday sight there either. Sarah Schaefer, Corinna Visser

  • CRA
  • EU-Binnenmarkt

Europe.Table Editorial Team

EUROPE.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    Some are talking about new commissioners or executive vice presidents, others are talking about cars. Fleet limits are one topic, while punitive tariffs on Chinese EVs are another hotly debated issue in the automotive industry.

    Valdis Dombrovskis, the current Vice-President of the Commission and Trade Commissioner, met with the CEOs of automotive companies on Wednesday afternoon. What exactly the participants discussed was initially not made public.

    Today, Dombrovskis is meeting the head of the Chinese Ministry of Commerce, Wang Wentao. The two are discussing the Commission’s anti-subsidy investigation into electric vehicles from China. China calls the planned measure by the Brussels authority protectionism. The Union calls it fair compensation for unfair subsidies. But nothing has been decided yet, which is why Wentao is making the trip.

    I wish you an exciting Thursday.

    Your
    Corinna Visser
    Image of Corinna  Visser

    Feature

    Von der Leyen’s climate team: Green Deal and industrial policy become one

    EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has put together a promising team of Commissioners to continue the climate policy agenda over the next five years. Spain’s Teresa Ribera will be the new Commissioner for Competition. What does not initially sound like a climate portfolio actually involves the task of aligning the European Union’s state aid law with the EU’s climate targets – specifically, the expansion of renewables and industrial decarbonization.

    According to a senior Commission official, Ribera’s competitive portfolio is the key to achieving the 2030 climate targets. The five-year mandate of this Commission ends shortly before the greenhouse gas reduction target of 55 percent compared to 1990 must be achieved. Consequently, the new Commission is “fully focussed” on the EU’s 2030 climate target, the official added.

    Ribera, Séjourné and Hoekstra lead the ‘Clean Industrial Deal’

    The plan is to be brought to life with a Green Deal 2.0 named “Clean Industrial Deal.”
    The ambitious and experienced climate politician Ribera and the French liberal industrial commissioner Stéphane Séjourné will oversee it. This shows that there is no room for regression, but rather the intention to step up the ambition for more climate action in industrial and economic policy, says Chiara Martinelli, Director of Climate Action Network Europe (CAN). Europe must undoubtedly continue to be a climate champion and achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, but also remain competitive along the way – that is the signal that von der Leyen sent out on Tuesday.

    Reporting to Ribera will be Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra, Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen and Environment Commissioner Jessika Roswall. Hoekstra and Jørgensen are also experienced climate politicians – one as current Climate Commissioner, the other as former Energy and Environment Minister in Denmark.

    Von der Leyen’s mandate to combine climate action with industrial and economic policy is also reflected here in the allocation of tasks. The legislative work for the “Clean Industrial Deal” comes from the Directorates-General for Climate Action (DG CLIMA) and Internal Market and Industry (DG GROW). This means that Hoekstra and Séjourné are tasked with jointly driving forward industrial decarbonization, the ramp-up of clean technologies and investment incentives.

    Hoekstra could get serious about the kerosene tax

    Hoekstra’s nomination also ensures continuity. As he did last year in Dubai, he will also lead the international climate negotiations at COP29 in Baku this November. If Hoekstra’s portfolio had changed, the EU would have appeared headless, given Hungary’s unambitious climate policy presidency in Baku. Von der Leyen has found an elegant and satisfactory solution for both Hoekstra and the Dutch government.

    He and his subordinate DG CLIMA are also responsible for drafting the legislative package for the EU’s 2040 climate target, whose reduction target of 90 percent Hoekstra himself presented back in February. Moreover, he has been assigned the tax portfolio – the economic task the Netherlands had hoped for. Among other things, he will work on aligning value-added taxes with environmental criteria. Hoekstra could also drive the introduction of climate taxes and end environmentally harmful subsidies and tax privileges. For example, he could now tackle the issue of the kerosene tax, which was announced a year ago.

    Jørgensen to promote CCS and nuclear power

    Danish national Jørgensen also has a relevant climate profile, but will now be Energy Commissioner. The economic aspects of his portfolio are obvious: Low energy prices are essential for economic recovery. However, von der Leyen insists that energy sources must become cleaner. According to the Commission President, small modular nuclear power plants and CO2 capture technologies, which Jørgensen is supposed to help ramp up, will also help.

    Jørgensen is a solid choice as Energy Commissioner, says Linda Kalcher, Director of the Brussels-based think tank Strategic Perspectives. “I expect him to be immune to greenwashing, that blue hydrogen or various carbon capture technologies will solve all our problems of tomorrow, and that he will be pragmatic about nuclear energy.”

    Remaining doubts about Roswall

    Although Environment Commissioner-designate Jessika Roswall has no experience in her new area of responsibility, she is a clever political compromise. The EPP party family had recently focussed its criticism primarily on nature conservation and is now getting a responsible Commissioner from its own ranks.

    Von der Leyen will certainly not give her free rein. Her department will have to make a significant contribution to the planned European climate adaptation plan and revise the controversial EU chemicals regulation REACH, which some in the EPP will not be happy about and is likely to greatly impact the chemical industry.

    She will have an easier time selling environmental protection in her party family than her Green predecessor, Virginijus Sinkevičius. But the Environment Committee could make life difficult for her. Sweden voted against the Nature Restoration Law and did not support the anti-deforestation regulation, liberal environmental politician Pascal Canfin posted on X. Commissioners usually jointly represent Commission proposals. Now, Canfin suggests, there is a risk that Roswall will go against the Commission’s line. “We will have to make sure she acts as true EU commissioner.”

    Séjourné is to create lead markets for clean tech

    In addition, Séjourné has been tasked with proposing an “Industrial Decarbonization Accelerator Act” to promote “European lead markets for the development, production and diffusion in industry of clean tech” and accelerating planning, tendering and approval procedures, especially for energy-intensive industries. The European Commission has thus taken up an idea that German Economy Minister Robert Habeck had previously put forward with his concept for green lead markets.

    At a panel discussion on Wednesday, Director-General Kerstin Jorna (DG GROW) and Director-General Kurt Vandenberghe (DG CLIMA) gave an initial insight into the new Commission’s industrial strategy: “The real question will be how to make the business case of the transition a good business case,” said Jorna. This business case does not yet exist in Europe, especially in energy-intensive industries such as steel, glass, cement and chemicals. While the Net Zero Industry Act (NZIA) of the last mandate has improved the approval processes for sustainable energy technologies, this has not yet been done for the customers of these technologies, she said.

    Public procurement should prioritize European suppliers

    In parallel with the Accelerator Act, Séjourné has also taken on the task of adapting public procurement rules in favor of European companies. The explicitly formulated goal of favoring European producers is new. Such “buy European” clauses have been included in draft versions of the NZIA in the past – but they were then omitted from the Commission’s final proposal.

    The Commissioners-designate will now have to attend hearings before the relevant committees in the EU Parliament. They will be questioned about their qualifications for the job as well as potential political conflicts. The committee coordinators of the political groups then vote on the appointment. Finally, the plenary of the EU Parliament will vote on the entire college of the new EU Commission.

    • Climate & Environment
    • COP29
    • EU climate policy
    • EU climate target 2040
    • EVP
    • Fit for 55
    • Green Deal
    • Industrial policy
    • Net Zero Industry Act
    Translation missing.

    Events

    Sept. 23-27, 2024; Vienna (Austria)
    Conference EU PVSEC 2024
    This conference discusses the latest developments in photovoltaics. INFO & REGISTRATION

    Sept. 24, 2024; 10 a.m.-4 p.m., online
    ESC Worskhop on Methodology for Flexibility Needs Assessments
    The Energy Storage Coalition (ESC) discusses how methodology could be shaped to ensure it is future-proof and supports the appropriate deployment of energy storage technologies and renewables. INFO & REGISTRATION

    Translation missing.

    News

    European Parliament: Competences of the Vice-Presidents have been determined

    Parliament President Roberta Metsola has assigned the 14 Vice-Presidents and five Quaestors of the European Parliament their areas of responsibility. Two German MEPs are members of the Bureau:

    Sabine Verheyen (CDU), who received the most votes in her election as Vice-President of Parliament, will be responsible for the working areas in the Presidium:

    • Communication and public relations
    • Parties and foundations
    • Household
    • Artificial intelligence
    • Building
    • Luxembourg as a parliamentary seat
    • Lux price

    Katarina Barley (SPD), who achieved 450 votes in the election and thus the fourth-best result, will be responsible for:

    • Relations with national parliaments
    • European Parliament Week
    • Arbitration
    • Relations with civil society organizations
    • Ethics committee
    • Audit Committee
    • Artistic Committee
    • Representation of the President of Parliament at the twinning meeting with the British Parliament

    The Bureau has also decided to implement the plans for the reform of the parliamentary administration. The former DG for Internal Strategies (IPOL) is to be split into four new DGs. mgr

    • Europäisches Parlament

    CO2 fleet limits: MEPs bring earlier review into play

    The automotive umbrella organization ACEA does not want to call on the Commission to use the emergency clause of the European Treaties, Article 122, to suspend fines for fleet limits and postpone them for two years. According to reports in Brussels, there was not enough support among manufacturers for ACEA President Luca de Meo’s proposal.

    Instead, ACEA is calling on the Commission to take “urgent measures to facilitate (the industry)” before the new limits come into force. In addition, the reviews of fleet legislation for both passenger cars and commercial vehicles provided for in the law should be brought forward. This was agreed between the CEOs and the lobby association. The idea of bringing forward the review of the CO2 fleet legislation by one year and proposing changes to targets and penalties had also been proposed by VDA President Hildegard Müller.

    In 2025, the fleet limits will fall from an average of 95 grams of CO2 per kilometer driven and new car to 93.6 grams. As the proportion of battery-electric vehicles (EVs) is not increasing as assumed, several manufacturers will miss the OEM-specific targets. The industry is threatened with fines totaling €15 billion for 2025 alone. Volkswagen and Renault in particular could be hit with high penalties.

    Bypassing Parliament

    If the CO2 fleet regulation were to be amended via Article 122, there would be no regular legislative procedure. Instead, the Commission would declare that the industry could suffer significant economic damage if the law were not amended immediately. Parliament would not be involved. The Commission would make a proposal to the Council, which the Council would then have to adopt. According to a non-paper from the Renault environment, which is available to Table.Media, the demand should be made to postpone the entry into force of the 2025 limits by two years.

    Transport politicians warn that now is not the right time for the industry to demand the suspension of limit values through emergency legislation. At the upcoming hearings of candidates for the posts of Commissioner for Transport and Environment in the coming weeks, questions from MEPs would put future Commissioners in a difficult position. Should they speak out in favor of bypassing Parliament as co-legislators?

    Jens Gieseke (CDU), coordinator in the Transport Committee, has submitted a written question to the Commission calling for the review of fleet limits to be brought forward from 2026 to 2025. The written question is available to Table.Briefings and is supported by several members of the CDU/CSU group. The Commission now has six weeks to respond. mgr

    • Autoindustrie
    • Climate & Environment
    • EU Parliament
    • European Commission
    • Flottengrenzwerte
    Translation missing.

    Hungary: Millions in fines to be deducted from EU funds

    Because Hungary has not paid a €200 million fine, the European Commission wants to deduct the money from future EU payments to Budapest. The fine was imposed by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in June due to violations of EU asylum law by the government in Budapest.

    The 15-day deadline for Hungary to pay the €200 million expired on Tuesday, a Commission spokesperson said. A so-called compensation procedure will therefore be initiated. “We will now deduct the €200 million from upcoming payments from the EU budget to Hungary.”

    In the summer, the ECJ found an exceptionally serious violation of EU law by the government of conservative head of government Viktor Orbán. The ECJ had already declared significant parts of the Hungarian asylum system to be unlawful in previous rulings. The European Commission has also been accusing Hungary of disregarding EU standards and fundamental values for years and has already frozen billions in funding for the country as a result.

    Daily penalty payment

    In addition, Hungary must pay a daily penalty of €1 million for each day of delay following a ruling by the ECJ. The fine was imposed on Budapest more than 90 days ago. A spokesperson for the EU Commission said that the Commission had asked Hungary to pay the fine. The Hungarian authorities now have 45 days to do so.

    Following the ECJ ruling, Budapest threatened to bring refugees and migrants to Brussels. “If Brussels wants the migrants, it should get them”, said Hungarian Chancellery Minister Gergely Gulyas, a close associate of Orbán.

    Green MEP Daniel Freund welcomed the Commission’s decision. “The Commission must remain firm”, he said. EU money should only flow to Hungary again in full once EU law is enforced. dpa

    • EU-Haushalt
    • Ungarn

    Google AdSense: EGC overturns billion-euro fine

    Margrethe Vestager’s triumph was short-lived. After winning two cases before the ECJ last week, the EU Commission has now suffered a defeat in another legal dispute with Google. The General Court of the European Union has annulled a fine of €1.49 billion imposed on Google by the Commission. The Commission had accused Google of hindering competition with its AdSense Search advertising service. However, the court found fault with the assessment of the duration of these clauses and annulled the decision.

    In 2019, the EU Commission accused Google of suppressing competition in the field of search engine advertising through exclusivity, placement and approval clauses in contracts with website operators. The clauses would have made it more difficult for competitors to place ads on the sites of these operators. Google had amended the relevant clauses in 2016 before the Commission concluded its investigation. The Court’s decision raises doubts as to whether the Commission correctly assessed the impact of the clauses on competition.

    Evidence from the Commission not sufficient

    The court criticized the fact that the Commission had incorrectly assessed the duration of the disputed contractual clauses. Many of the contracts in question had only been concluded for a short period of time and contained options for termination or renegotiation. In addition, the Commission was unable to provide sufficient evidence that the clauses had significantly impeded competitors’ access to the market. The Commission has two months to appeal against the current decision.

    Markus Ferber (CSU), spokesperson for the EPP Group in the Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee, criticized the fact that an EU court has once again overturned a competition fine imposed by the Commission. “The record of Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, who has declared herself a champion against big tech companies, remains more than sobering“, said the EPP politician. Vestager’s record raises questions as to whether the Commission has always worked thoroughly enough. “The new Competition Commissioner would do well to be more down-to-earth.”

    Commission likely to remain confrontational

    Ferber’s parliamentary group colleague Andreas Schwab (CDU) argues differently and expects the Commission to take the case to the ECJ. “There is no doubt about Google’s anti-competitive behavior“, says Schwab. The court had confirmed the majority of the Commission’s findings. “This case shows that fairness has not yet been achieved in the digital markets. Abuses of dominant market positions are destroying our internal market.”

    Sarah Blazek from the law firm Noerr also called the current ruling a setback: “Even if many of the Commission’s findings have been confirmed: The EGC makes it clear that even in the case of Big Tech, no separate standards are to be applied.” The Commission made technical errors“. Nevertheless, it is to be expected that the Commission will “continue to pursue its confrontational course against Big Tech”. Blazek: “The Digital Markets Act, which is now in force, is likely to play a major role in this.” vis

    • Wettbewerbspolitik

    Federal government’s raw materials fund can start

    The German government’s raw materials fund, which has been planned for some time, can now begin: Federal Minister for Economic Affairs Robert Habeck and Federal Minister of Finance Christian Lindner have instructed the state development bank KfW to set up the fund. This was reported by Handelsblatt, referring to a letter from the two ministers to KfW CEO Stefan Wintels. According to the letter, the bank is to use the fund to promote raw materials projects in order to secure the supply of raw materials to German companies, reduce their dependence on other countries and strengthen the resilience of supply chains and the national economy.

    The fund, with which KfW is to provide around €1 billion for strategic raw materials projects from 2024 to 2028, had already been ready for some time. According to information from Table.Briefings, the ministries had also long since agreed on the content. However, the BMF had not released the funds. As reported by Handelsblatt, this was due to the controversial issue of whether raw materials projects should be funded with loans or equity. Habeck and his ministry had pushed for the equity option and ultimately prevailed: It is now possible for the federal government to participate in the funded projects with equity. leo

    • Lieferketten

    Must Reads

    Heads

    Henna Virkkunen – Finland’s Ironwoman in the new Commission

    With Henna Virkkunen, Finland is sending a Member of the European Parliament with an industrial policy profile to the Commission.

    Henna Virkkunen’s list of duties is more extensive than the mission letters that Ursula von der Leyen sent to other members of the new Commission. The Finnish woman’s remit is very broad: As Executive Vice-President for Technical Sovereignty, Security and Democracy, she is to ensure that digital technologies are developed in line with European values, improve cyber security, tackle disinformation, and protect the EU’s democratic institutions. Provided that the European Parliament approves her nomination, but there is little doubt about that.

    For the first time, Virkkunen will be responsible for both internal and external security. Another new aspect is that both DG CNECT and DG DIGIT will report directly to her. The development of an AI strategy is one of her tasks, as is supporting the establishment of a European AI Research Council.

    The tasks match their profile and the interests of their country. “The most important European policy issues for Finland are security and the internal market“, says Manuel Müller, EU expert at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs. Virkkunen has made a name for himself in the area of the economy, but not in security policy.

    The topic of platform regulation discovered early on

    In the European Parliament, Virkkunen has been a member of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (ITRE) since 2014 and was also a member of the Committee on Transport and Tourism (TRAN). She was Chair of the EPP’s SME Group, which monitors the impact of European legislation on small and medium-sized enterprises.

    In her ten years in the European Parliament, the 52-year-old has worked on numerous industrial policy issues, often with a digital focus. As co-rapporteur for an EP own-initiative report on online platforms and the digital single market, she was one of the first parliamentarians to deal intensively with the topic of platform regulation.

    Cyber Resilience Act, DSA and Connecting Europe

    She was rapporteur for the Cybersecurity Regulation for the EU institutions, worked on the Cyber Resilience Act and the Digital Services Act, and was also a member of the Committee of Inquiry into the Pegasus affair. As rapporteur, she was also responsible for the regulation of the Connecting Europe facility and was involved in the report on Horizon Europe. In addition, she was involved in numerous regulations in the transport sector.

    Henna Virkkunen also has experience in government. She first entered the Finnish parliament in 2007. In 2008, she became Minister, first for Education and then for Public Administration. She was Minister of Transport for a short time before moving to the European Parliament. In von der Leyen’s view, this experience qualifies her for the higher tasks in the Commission. Especially as Finland was one of the few member states to nominate a woman.

    As Finland’s largest governing party, the National Coalition Party (Kokoomus, KOK) has decided who it wants to send to the new Commission. Prime Minister Petteri Orpo had announced that the party would be someone who had stood as a candidate in the European elections. It had long been considered likely that his party colleague would be chosen. “Virkkunen is the face of Kokoomus in Brussels“, says expert Müller. “From a party perspective, she is an obvious choice.”

    While she is now preparing for the hearing before the European Parliament, she has appointed Antti Timonen, the deputy spokesperson of Parliament President Roberta Metsola, as head of her transition team. This team will become Virkkunen’s cabinet if her appointment is confirmed.

    Participant in reality show

    “I’m a European reformer who grew up with porridge”, says Henna Virkkunen about herself. She lives with her husband and son in Jyväskylä, a city with around 150,000 inhabitants in central Finland. She studied journalism and has worked as a journalist and in communications. Virkkunen describes herself as a “horse girl” and likes to show herself in photos in the forest and doing sports. She runs marathons and takes part in the Ironman.

    She also demonstrated her fitness in the reality TV show “Erikoisjoukot” in 2022. In the show, prominent participants complete exercises based on selection tests for the Finnish special forces. The German public would probably react to the participation of a nationally known politician in such a format with amusement and ridicule, if not outrage. In Finland, on the other hand, this is no big deal. But an MEP jumping out of a helicopter into a lake in full gear is unlikely to be an everyday sight there either. Sarah Schaefer, Corinna Visser

    • CRA
    • EU-Binnenmarkt

    Europe.Table Editorial Team

    EUROPE.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen