Table.Briefing: Europe (English)

Rethinking network charges + Lithuania’s controversial coalition + Romania’s run-off election

Dear reader,

In the past, cabinet members of commissioners with security-related portfolios did not have to pass a security check. At the national level, this check has been common practice for a long time. In the Von der Leyen Commission II, this check will now take place for the first time.

The national intelligence services are responsible. Applicants for cabinet posts must provide them with complete information about their curriculum vitae for example with the President of the Commission, the Commissioner for Defense or the Commissioner for Home Affairs. In this way, the Commission wants to ensure that no submarines from hostile secret services are hired by the Berlaymont.

When the new Commission takes office on December 1, it will be weeks before all application procedures and – if necessary – security checks have been completed and the cabinets are fully operational. The appointments are still ongoing.

The personal details of two former prominent MEPs in the new Commission were announced on Monday. Former EPP deputy group leader Esther de Lange from the Netherlands will become head of the cabinet of Agriculture Commissioner Christophe Hansen – her former group colleague.

And Philippe Lamberts, co-leader of the Green Party until the election, will be an advisor to Ursula von der Leyen and the Commission for the Transformation of Industry to CO2 neutrality. Von der Leyen chose him because he is not only a politician, but also has experience as a manager in industry (IBM). He is supposed to be the Von der Leyen Commission’s “bridge” to industry, NGOs, politics and administration. It is certainly no coincidence that von der Leyen made this appointment public on the same day that the Green parliamentary group was debating how to vote on the new Commission tomorrow.

Have an exciting day!

Your
Markus Grabitz
Image of Markus  Grabitz

Feature

DG Energy: Rethinking financing through network charges

The increase in network charges has also alarmed the EU Commission. “In view of the expected burden on consumers, the current financing system, in which end consumers pay the bill via network charges, may need to be reconsidered.” These are the words of the Directorate-General for Energy’s July briefing book for the future Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen, which was made available to Table.Briefings on Monday. The Commission does not mention any alternative sources of financing.

However, the announced investment plan for energy should provide for separate funding for distribution grids, as the upcoming Polish Council Presidency is aiming for. However, the Commission is already certain that additional pots will be needed in the upcoming Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) alongside the Connecting Europe Facility (CEF).

Russia: possible tariffs on gas and nuclear fuel

The Commission is considering alternatives to sanctions to make the import of gas and nuclear fuel from Russia more difficult. “The Commission is ready to examine the benefits of a possible import duty or price cap [on natural gas],” says the briefing book from the Directorate-General for Energy. Tariffs on Russian nuclear fuel are also being considered.

“One challenge is to prevent Russian gas from retaining or increasing its market share by increasing supplies via Turkey,” it continues. On the one hand, Russian gas still flows into the EU via TurkStream. However, this may also refer to gas from Azerbaijan, which the country could increasingly purchase from Russia according to media reports. As far as the conversion and enrichment of uranium and spare parts for Russian-designed reactors are concerned, “the Commission is prepared to do more to promote diversification.”

The Polish Council Presidency is also seeking Council conclusions on Russian gas by the time the energy ministers meet in June, an EU diplomat told Table Briefings.

Energy security: flexibility requirements as a risk

Surprisingly, the Directorate-General has announced more legislative proposals for the area of energy security than for any other subject area.

  • The announced revision of the framework for energy security should be available around the turn of the year 2025/26. The revision of two regulations on gas supply security and risk provisioning in the electricity sector will be at the heart of this. Hydrogen and climate risks in particular will apparently also be taken into account.
  • In the first quarter of 2025, there will initially be a “strategy for a genuine energy union” with announcements on strategic autonomy.
  • An initiative on energy storage including system flexibility and stocks of critical raw materials for the energy transition. The need for grid flexibility clearly identified as a challenge for energy security.
  • Extension of the directive on offshore safety for oil and gas infrastructure to include CCS and renewable energies.
  • Revision of the Governance Regulation so that Member States add indicators and “possibly targets” on energy security in their energy and climate plans (NECP).
  • Revision of the Oil Stockpiling Directive, “in anticipation of the decline in oil demand and the gradual introduction of carbon-free liquid fuels.”

Electricity market: fast Bidding Zone Review

The European report on the reallocation of electricity bidding zones may not be available until the first quarter of 2025, according to reports in Brussels. After that, however, the Commission wants to act quickly. In the briefing, it writes of the “need to push for a timely reorganization as part of the ongoing review of the bidding zones and strict compliance with the 70 percent requirement” for cross-border electricity trading. The division of Germany into two electricity price zones is still under discussion, as was recently reported.

As Jørgensen already announced in his hearing, the Commission is not aiming to reform the electricity market again for the time being. In the briefing book, however, the Directorate-General holds out the prospect of a white paper for 2025. White papers contain initial ideas that will be consulted on for some time to come.

Energy efficiency: EIB to promote contracting

According to the briefing book, a separate strategy is planned to promote energy efficiency more strongly: “This could include a financing mechanism at the EU level to top up Member States’ national contributions to the binding EU energy efficiency target.” The EU could use this to finance loan guarantees for energy service providers and efficiency auctions.

The auctions are likely to be aimed primarily at industry. The BMWK is already carrying out tenders with the federal funding for energy and resource efficiency in industry so that companies can switch to lower-CO2 systems or process heat from renewable energies. Energy service providers offer to pre-finance such investments with contracting models. In Germany, there used to be state guarantees for SMEs in this market, but these were hardly ever used. The Commission is now aiming for guarantees from the European Investment Bank (EIB) on a larger scale.

Renewables: guarantees for the solar industry

In the briefing book, the Directorate-General announces legislative proposals for renewable energy policy after 2030. Jørgensen had already announced a renewables target for 2040 in his hearing. “Whether it will be mandatory or indicative remains to be seen,” was heard from the EPP group in Parliament afterward.

The already familiar electrification strategy is also to help renewables. Due to inflexible demand, there is an increasing number of hours with negative prices and wind and solar parks are finding it more difficult to refinance themselves on the market. “A debate is needed at the EU level on a common approach to make electricity more attractive as an energy source,” the briefing states.

Support from the EIB has been announced for the solar industry to promote European production facilities. In July, the EIB had already issued a counter-guarantee to Deutsche Bank to secure the production of wind turbines.

  • CCS
  • Energiepreise
Translation missing.

Controversial coalition: Lithuania’s social democrats want to contain populists

Last week, people in Lithuania once again took to the streets. In Vilnius, thousands demonstrated in front of parliament due to the appointment of social democrat Gintautas Paluckas as prime minister. The protest was sparked less by Paluckas himself than by his plan to bring the nationalist and populist party Nemuno aušra (Dawn of Nemunas) into the government.

Its leader, Remigijus Žemaitaitis, has been heavily criticized for alleged anti-Semitic comments. In the spring, the Constitutional Court ruled that Žemaitaitis had broken his oath as a member of parliament and violated the constitution with his comments. He subsequently resigned as a member of parliament. He thus escaped impeachment proceedings and an election ban and was able to take part in the parliamentary elections with the newly founded Nemuno aušra. Criminal investigations into his statements are still ongoing.

Grand coalition was out of the question

Many people in Lithuania see the behavior of the Social Democrats as a serious breach of trust. During the election campaign, the Lithuanian Social Democratic Party (LSDP) had ruled out forming a coalition with Nemuno aušra, and its leader Vilija Blinkevičiūtė had promised to take over as head of government if she won. However, after the election, Blinkevičiūtė remained a member of the European Parliament. Paluckas became a candidate for the office of Prime Minister and decided in favor of the coalition, which was also internationally controversial.

Other alliance options were apparently out of the question for the Social Democrats. A grand coalition with the Fatherland Alliance (TS-LKD, part of the EPP), which has led the government so far and lost voter support, would have been possible. Together with the center-left party Democratic Union for Lithuania (DSVL), the three-party alliance now has a majority of 86 of the 141 seats in the Seimas.

The LSDP is hoping that Žemaitaitis and his party colleagues can be contained in such a way that they do not cause any damage. Although the party leader has been in politics for a long time, Nemuno aušra is a young party that was hastily formed for this year’s elections. Its structures are unstable.

Red line for Europe’s social democrats

Sharp criticism came from politicians from the USA, Israel, Poland and Germany. “It is a disgrace that the Social Democrats in Lithuania are entering into an alliance with an anti-Semitic, homophobic and nationalist party,” wrote SPD politician Michael Roth, Chairman of the Bundestag’s Foreign Affairs Committee, on Platform X.

The social democratic partners in Europe view the actions of the LSDP with concern. “Formal alliances with radical nationalists, especially if they have anti-Semitic overtones, are out of the question for members of the social democratic party family,Kai-Olaf Lang, an expert on the EU and Eastern Europe at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, told Table.Briefings.

The situation is particularly delicate in light of the ongoing conflict in the European Parliament. There, the S&D accuses the EPP of making common cause with the far right. That the LSDP is now taking precisely this path after its spectacular election victory is a problem for Europe’s social democrats.

Government wants to continue hard line against Russia

The Lithuanian social democrats are now primarily concerned with leaving no doubt about their reliability in foreign policy. This is also significant in view of the German brigade, which is to be permanently stationed in Lithuania from 2027. On the day of his election as Prime Minister, Paluckas assured that Lithuania’s policy towards Russia and Belarus would not change. In the coalition agreement, cooperation with NATO partners and defense funding are at the top of the three parties’ list of priorities.

Nemuno aušra is also not to be given access to government positions in the area of foreign and security policy. This is significant insofar as Žemaitaitis is feared to be close to Russian and Belarusian positions.

Better cooperation with President Nausėda

Kęstutis Budrys, previously advisor to President Gitanas Nausėda, is to become foreign minister. The Social Democrat Dovilė Šakalienė is to be appointed Minister of Defense. Both are in favor of supporting Ukraine and taking a firm stance against Russia.

In terms of foreign policy, the new faces could even be good news: “In some ways, foreign and security policy could become a little more effective than before,” says Kai-Olaf Lang. After all, the cooperation between the President and the previous Foreign Minister Gabrielius Landsbergis was not always free of tensions. The fact that Kęstutis Budrys, a man from Nausėda’s immediate circle, is to become foreign minister indicates that the government and head of state are now coordinating more closely.

This could also be seen as a concession to the president. Nausėda, who is popular with the population, has openly criticized the planned coalition and announced that he will not appoint any members of Nemuno aušra as ministers. Prime Minister Paluckas now has until the beginning of December to put together his cabinet.

  • Außenpolitik
  • EVP
Translation missing.

Events

November 27-29, 2024, online
ERA Annual Conference on European Copyright Law 2024
The Academy of European Law (ERA) gives an update on the ongoing EU initiatives and recent case law adopted by the CJEU in the field of copyright law. INFO & REGISTRATION

November 28-29, 2024, Florence (Italy)
FSR Climate Annual Conference
The Florence School of Regulation (FSR) covers some of the main climate policies at the EU and national and subnational levels. INFO & REGISTRATION

News

Romania: hard-right extremist and conservatives in the run-off election

A hard-right critic of NATO, who has repeatedly praised Russia, will run against the conservative opposition leader in Romania in a run-off election on December 8. The result could undermine the country’s pro-Western stance after an unexpected outcome in the first round of voting.

Until our Monday edition’s editorial deadline, it still looked like a neck-and-neck race with the incumbent prime minister. But the tide has turned: The independent hard-right politician Calin Georgescu won 22.94 percent of votes in Sunday’s election, according to the electoral authority. Elena Lasconi from the conservative-liberal reform party USR lay second with 19.18 percent.

The result is surprising, as pre-election opinion polls had made Social Democratic Prime Minister Marcel Ciolacu the clear frontrunner. He missed the second round of voting by less than 3,000 votes. Ciolacu announced that he would resign as party leader, but would remain in office as prime minister until the parliamentary elections on December 1.

Election campaign characterized by rising cost of living

Campaigning focused largely on the soaring cost of living in Romania. The country has the biggest share of people at risk of poverty in the EU. “I voted for the wronged, the humiliated, those who feel they do not matter in this world,” said Georgescu on Sunday. “Today, the vote is a prayer for the nation.” Georgescu had been polling in single digits before the vote and ran a campaign-oriented strategy with a focus on TikTok.

Asked about the election outcome, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said: “I would not make any predictions yet. We probably cannot say that we are that familiar with the worldview of this candidate as far as relations with our country are concerned.”

Georgescu’s success in the parliamentary elections on December 1, in which 19 million citizens are taking part, is likely to give an additional boost to hard-right groupings. Mainstream parties have not officially endorsed either presidential candidate.

Georgescu calls NATO missile debt ‘a shame of diplomacy’

Georgescu described a NATO ballistic missile defense shield in Romania as a “shame of diplomacy” and questioned whether the Western military alliance would protect any of its members in the event of a Russian attack. He stated that Romania’s best chance lay with “Russian wisdom,” but has refused to say explicitly whether he supports Russia.

Romania, which was under communist rule for four decades until 1989, shares a 650-kilometer (400-mile) border with Ukraine. Since the Russian attack on Ukraine in 2022, the country has enabled the export of millions of tons of grain through its Black Sea port of Constanța and provided military aid, including the donation of a Patriot air defense battery.

The president, who is limited to two five-year terms, has a semi-executive role which includes heading Romania’s armed forces and chairing the Supreme Defense Council that decides on military aid. He represents Romania at EU and NATO summits and appoints the Prime Minister, chief judges, public prosecutors and the heads of the secret services. The current president, Klaus Iohannis, won power in 2014 on a promise to bolster the fight against endemic corruption. rtr

  • Europa

Tariffs: EU Commission appeals to WTO over brandy

The EU Commission has officially challenged China’s provisional anti-dumping measures against brandy imports at the World Trade Organization (WTO). “China’s provisional measures on EU brandy are not in line with WTO rules,” said a statement from the Brussels authority on Monday, adding it “has not proven that there is any threat of injury to its brandy industry.” The formal request for consultations with the WTO is the first step in the dispute settlement procedure.

The Chinese Ministry of Commerce said China would handle the matter per WTO rules. The EU’s move follows Chinese anti-dumping measures of up to 39 percent on EU brandy in response to EU countervailing duties on Chinese EVs.

The trade dispute has caused particular concern in France, whose cognac producers regard China as an important export market. The French Ministry of Trade had announced that it was working with the European Commission to challenge Beijing’s tariffs. French President Emmanuel Macron had previously described China’s investigation as “pure retaliation.”

Considerations by manufacturer Hennessy to start bottling in China had led to a strike at a plant in southwestern France. Meanwhile, cognac producer Remy announced plans to increase prices in China and lower costs in areas such as production and advertising. ari

  • Emmanuel Macron
  • Europäische Kommission
  • WTO
  • Zölle

Food labeling: European Court of Auditors criticizes gaps in EU law

European consumers are being bombarded with more and more promises, logos, slogans, seals of approval and ratings that are not only confusing but can be downright misleading. This is the conclusion reached by the European Court of Auditors in its special report on food labeling in the EU published on Monday, based on surveys in Lithuania, Belgium and Italy. “Companies are very creative when it comes to the information on packaging. However, EU regulations have not kept pace with the constantly evolving market,” said Keit Pentus-Rosimannus, the member of the European Court of Auditors responsible for the audit, summarizing the results.

The auditors found that companies could sometimes even emphasize nutritional and health-related benefits on products with a high fat, salt and sugar content. Claims such as “fresh” or “natural” as well as environmental claims that are tantamount to greenwashing cannot be stopped with the current regulations, they regret. At the same time, the use of the labels “vegan” or “vegetarian” is not regulated as there are no EU-wide definitions.

List of authorized health claims on herbal preparations is missing

Against this background, the EU Court of Auditors calls on the Commission to close the gaps in the EU legal framework on food labeling – in particular via the outstanding updates to the Food Information Regulation (FIR) and the Regulation on nutrition and health claims. At the same time, many questions regarding origin labeling and alcoholic beverages are still open and the Commission should take action in this regard, according to the report. The Commission has not yet presented a reform of the EU rules on food labeling that was announced for the last term of office.

The Court’s auditors also criticize the lack of “a list of EU-approved health claims on herbal preparations and EU regulations on the labeling of foods suitable for vegetarians and vegans.” At the same time, they call on the Commission to better analyze labeling practices and improve consumer understanding of food labeling

‘Fines not dissuasive, effective or proportionate’

Although the controls generally work well for mandatory disclosures, they are lacking for voluntary disclosures, the report states. In addition, the fines imposed for non-compliance are often not dissuasive, effective or proportionate, according to the auditors.

Despite all this, the EU only provided around €5.5 million between 2021 and 2025 for awareness-raising campaigns on food labeling, which many EU countries only carried out sporadically, according to the Court of Auditors’ report. heu

  • Greenwashing

Corning: Commission requests comments on commitments

The European Commission is inviting companies and interested parties to comment on proposals by the US group Corning aimed at resolving antitrust concerns. The commitments are intended to ensure that competition in the market for specialty glass is maintained. Corning’s alkaline aluminosilicate glass, known under the Gorilla Glass brand, is primarily used in smartphones, tablets and similar devices.

Since November 6, 2024, the Commission has been investigating whether Corning has abused its dominant market position. The focus is on exclusive supply agreements with device manufacturers and glass processors that may have excluded competitors from the market and thus harmed consumer interests.

To dispel these concerns, Corning is proposing to waive exclusive clauses in contracts worldwide and to limit dependence on customers to a maximum of 50 percent of their demand. The commitments are to apply for nine years and be monitored by an independent body. Interested parties can submit comments until six weeks after publication of the commitments in the Official Journal of the EU. vis

  • Wettbewerbsverfahren

New Commission: Greens divided ahead of vote

In an extraordinary group meeting on Monday evening, the members of the Greens/EFA group discussed whether they will vote for or against the new Commission in the European Parliament on Wednesday. No clear decision was reached.

According to information from Table.Briefings, 26 group members want to vote for the Commission and 20 against. Six group members are still undecided. However, Commission President Ursula von der Leyen will probably not need the votes of the Greens/EFA to get her proposal through this time. vis

  • Europäische Kommission
Translation missing.

Europe.table editorial team

EUROPE.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    In the past, cabinet members of commissioners with security-related portfolios did not have to pass a security check. At the national level, this check has been common practice for a long time. In the Von der Leyen Commission II, this check will now take place for the first time.

    The national intelligence services are responsible. Applicants for cabinet posts must provide them with complete information about their curriculum vitae for example with the President of the Commission, the Commissioner for Defense or the Commissioner for Home Affairs. In this way, the Commission wants to ensure that no submarines from hostile secret services are hired by the Berlaymont.

    When the new Commission takes office on December 1, it will be weeks before all application procedures and – if necessary – security checks have been completed and the cabinets are fully operational. The appointments are still ongoing.

    The personal details of two former prominent MEPs in the new Commission were announced on Monday. Former EPP deputy group leader Esther de Lange from the Netherlands will become head of the cabinet of Agriculture Commissioner Christophe Hansen – her former group colleague.

    And Philippe Lamberts, co-leader of the Green Party until the election, will be an advisor to Ursula von der Leyen and the Commission for the Transformation of Industry to CO2 neutrality. Von der Leyen chose him because he is not only a politician, but also has experience as a manager in industry (IBM). He is supposed to be the Von der Leyen Commission’s “bridge” to industry, NGOs, politics and administration. It is certainly no coincidence that von der Leyen made this appointment public on the same day that the Green parliamentary group was debating how to vote on the new Commission tomorrow.

    Have an exciting day!

    Your
    Markus Grabitz
    Image of Markus  Grabitz

    Feature

    DG Energy: Rethinking financing through network charges

    The increase in network charges has also alarmed the EU Commission. “In view of the expected burden on consumers, the current financing system, in which end consumers pay the bill via network charges, may need to be reconsidered.” These are the words of the Directorate-General for Energy’s July briefing book for the future Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen, which was made available to Table.Briefings on Monday. The Commission does not mention any alternative sources of financing.

    However, the announced investment plan for energy should provide for separate funding for distribution grids, as the upcoming Polish Council Presidency is aiming for. However, the Commission is already certain that additional pots will be needed in the upcoming Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) alongside the Connecting Europe Facility (CEF).

    Russia: possible tariffs on gas and nuclear fuel

    The Commission is considering alternatives to sanctions to make the import of gas and nuclear fuel from Russia more difficult. “The Commission is ready to examine the benefits of a possible import duty or price cap [on natural gas],” says the briefing book from the Directorate-General for Energy. Tariffs on Russian nuclear fuel are also being considered.

    “One challenge is to prevent Russian gas from retaining or increasing its market share by increasing supplies via Turkey,” it continues. On the one hand, Russian gas still flows into the EU via TurkStream. However, this may also refer to gas from Azerbaijan, which the country could increasingly purchase from Russia according to media reports. As far as the conversion and enrichment of uranium and spare parts for Russian-designed reactors are concerned, “the Commission is prepared to do more to promote diversification.”

    The Polish Council Presidency is also seeking Council conclusions on Russian gas by the time the energy ministers meet in June, an EU diplomat told Table Briefings.

    Energy security: flexibility requirements as a risk

    Surprisingly, the Directorate-General has announced more legislative proposals for the area of energy security than for any other subject area.

    • The announced revision of the framework for energy security should be available around the turn of the year 2025/26. The revision of two regulations on gas supply security and risk provisioning in the electricity sector will be at the heart of this. Hydrogen and climate risks in particular will apparently also be taken into account.
    • In the first quarter of 2025, there will initially be a “strategy for a genuine energy union” with announcements on strategic autonomy.
    • An initiative on energy storage including system flexibility and stocks of critical raw materials for the energy transition. The need for grid flexibility clearly identified as a challenge for energy security.
    • Extension of the directive on offshore safety for oil and gas infrastructure to include CCS and renewable energies.
    • Revision of the Governance Regulation so that Member States add indicators and “possibly targets” on energy security in their energy and climate plans (NECP).
    • Revision of the Oil Stockpiling Directive, “in anticipation of the decline in oil demand and the gradual introduction of carbon-free liquid fuels.”

    Electricity market: fast Bidding Zone Review

    The European report on the reallocation of electricity bidding zones may not be available until the first quarter of 2025, according to reports in Brussels. After that, however, the Commission wants to act quickly. In the briefing, it writes of the “need to push for a timely reorganization as part of the ongoing review of the bidding zones and strict compliance with the 70 percent requirement” for cross-border electricity trading. The division of Germany into two electricity price zones is still under discussion, as was recently reported.

    As Jørgensen already announced in his hearing, the Commission is not aiming to reform the electricity market again for the time being. In the briefing book, however, the Directorate-General holds out the prospect of a white paper for 2025. White papers contain initial ideas that will be consulted on for some time to come.

    Energy efficiency: EIB to promote contracting

    According to the briefing book, a separate strategy is planned to promote energy efficiency more strongly: “This could include a financing mechanism at the EU level to top up Member States’ national contributions to the binding EU energy efficiency target.” The EU could use this to finance loan guarantees for energy service providers and efficiency auctions.

    The auctions are likely to be aimed primarily at industry. The BMWK is already carrying out tenders with the federal funding for energy and resource efficiency in industry so that companies can switch to lower-CO2 systems or process heat from renewable energies. Energy service providers offer to pre-finance such investments with contracting models. In Germany, there used to be state guarantees for SMEs in this market, but these were hardly ever used. The Commission is now aiming for guarantees from the European Investment Bank (EIB) on a larger scale.

    Renewables: guarantees for the solar industry

    In the briefing book, the Directorate-General announces legislative proposals for renewable energy policy after 2030. Jørgensen had already announced a renewables target for 2040 in his hearing. “Whether it will be mandatory or indicative remains to be seen,” was heard from the EPP group in Parliament afterward.

    The already familiar electrification strategy is also to help renewables. Due to inflexible demand, there is an increasing number of hours with negative prices and wind and solar parks are finding it more difficult to refinance themselves on the market. “A debate is needed at the EU level on a common approach to make electricity more attractive as an energy source,” the briefing states.

    Support from the EIB has been announced for the solar industry to promote European production facilities. In July, the EIB had already issued a counter-guarantee to Deutsche Bank to secure the production of wind turbines.

    • CCS
    • Energiepreise
    Translation missing.

    Controversial coalition: Lithuania’s social democrats want to contain populists

    Last week, people in Lithuania once again took to the streets. In Vilnius, thousands demonstrated in front of parliament due to the appointment of social democrat Gintautas Paluckas as prime minister. The protest was sparked less by Paluckas himself than by his plan to bring the nationalist and populist party Nemuno aušra (Dawn of Nemunas) into the government.

    Its leader, Remigijus Žemaitaitis, has been heavily criticized for alleged anti-Semitic comments. In the spring, the Constitutional Court ruled that Žemaitaitis had broken his oath as a member of parliament and violated the constitution with his comments. He subsequently resigned as a member of parliament. He thus escaped impeachment proceedings and an election ban and was able to take part in the parliamentary elections with the newly founded Nemuno aušra. Criminal investigations into his statements are still ongoing.

    Grand coalition was out of the question

    Many people in Lithuania see the behavior of the Social Democrats as a serious breach of trust. During the election campaign, the Lithuanian Social Democratic Party (LSDP) had ruled out forming a coalition with Nemuno aušra, and its leader Vilija Blinkevičiūtė had promised to take over as head of government if she won. However, after the election, Blinkevičiūtė remained a member of the European Parliament. Paluckas became a candidate for the office of Prime Minister and decided in favor of the coalition, which was also internationally controversial.

    Other alliance options were apparently out of the question for the Social Democrats. A grand coalition with the Fatherland Alliance (TS-LKD, part of the EPP), which has led the government so far and lost voter support, would have been possible. Together with the center-left party Democratic Union for Lithuania (DSVL), the three-party alliance now has a majority of 86 of the 141 seats in the Seimas.

    The LSDP is hoping that Žemaitaitis and his party colleagues can be contained in such a way that they do not cause any damage. Although the party leader has been in politics for a long time, Nemuno aušra is a young party that was hastily formed for this year’s elections. Its structures are unstable.

    Red line for Europe’s social democrats

    Sharp criticism came from politicians from the USA, Israel, Poland and Germany. “It is a disgrace that the Social Democrats in Lithuania are entering into an alliance with an anti-Semitic, homophobic and nationalist party,” wrote SPD politician Michael Roth, Chairman of the Bundestag’s Foreign Affairs Committee, on Platform X.

    The social democratic partners in Europe view the actions of the LSDP with concern. “Formal alliances with radical nationalists, especially if they have anti-Semitic overtones, are out of the question for members of the social democratic party family,Kai-Olaf Lang, an expert on the EU and Eastern Europe at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, told Table.Briefings.

    The situation is particularly delicate in light of the ongoing conflict in the European Parliament. There, the S&D accuses the EPP of making common cause with the far right. That the LSDP is now taking precisely this path after its spectacular election victory is a problem for Europe’s social democrats.

    Government wants to continue hard line against Russia

    The Lithuanian social democrats are now primarily concerned with leaving no doubt about their reliability in foreign policy. This is also significant in view of the German brigade, which is to be permanently stationed in Lithuania from 2027. On the day of his election as Prime Minister, Paluckas assured that Lithuania’s policy towards Russia and Belarus would not change. In the coalition agreement, cooperation with NATO partners and defense funding are at the top of the three parties’ list of priorities.

    Nemuno aušra is also not to be given access to government positions in the area of foreign and security policy. This is significant insofar as Žemaitaitis is feared to be close to Russian and Belarusian positions.

    Better cooperation with President Nausėda

    Kęstutis Budrys, previously advisor to President Gitanas Nausėda, is to become foreign minister. The Social Democrat Dovilė Šakalienė is to be appointed Minister of Defense. Both are in favor of supporting Ukraine and taking a firm stance against Russia.

    In terms of foreign policy, the new faces could even be good news: “In some ways, foreign and security policy could become a little more effective than before,” says Kai-Olaf Lang. After all, the cooperation between the President and the previous Foreign Minister Gabrielius Landsbergis was not always free of tensions. The fact that Kęstutis Budrys, a man from Nausėda’s immediate circle, is to become foreign minister indicates that the government and head of state are now coordinating more closely.

    This could also be seen as a concession to the president. Nausėda, who is popular with the population, has openly criticized the planned coalition and announced that he will not appoint any members of Nemuno aušra as ministers. Prime Minister Paluckas now has until the beginning of December to put together his cabinet.

    • Außenpolitik
    • EVP
    Translation missing.

    Events

    November 27-29, 2024, online
    ERA Annual Conference on European Copyright Law 2024
    The Academy of European Law (ERA) gives an update on the ongoing EU initiatives and recent case law adopted by the CJEU in the field of copyright law. INFO & REGISTRATION

    November 28-29, 2024, Florence (Italy)
    FSR Climate Annual Conference
    The Florence School of Regulation (FSR) covers some of the main climate policies at the EU and national and subnational levels. INFO & REGISTRATION

    News

    Romania: hard-right extremist and conservatives in the run-off election

    A hard-right critic of NATO, who has repeatedly praised Russia, will run against the conservative opposition leader in Romania in a run-off election on December 8. The result could undermine the country’s pro-Western stance after an unexpected outcome in the first round of voting.

    Until our Monday edition’s editorial deadline, it still looked like a neck-and-neck race with the incumbent prime minister. But the tide has turned: The independent hard-right politician Calin Georgescu won 22.94 percent of votes in Sunday’s election, according to the electoral authority. Elena Lasconi from the conservative-liberal reform party USR lay second with 19.18 percent.

    The result is surprising, as pre-election opinion polls had made Social Democratic Prime Minister Marcel Ciolacu the clear frontrunner. He missed the second round of voting by less than 3,000 votes. Ciolacu announced that he would resign as party leader, but would remain in office as prime minister until the parliamentary elections on December 1.

    Election campaign characterized by rising cost of living

    Campaigning focused largely on the soaring cost of living in Romania. The country has the biggest share of people at risk of poverty in the EU. “I voted for the wronged, the humiliated, those who feel they do not matter in this world,” said Georgescu on Sunday. “Today, the vote is a prayer for the nation.” Georgescu had been polling in single digits before the vote and ran a campaign-oriented strategy with a focus on TikTok.

    Asked about the election outcome, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said: “I would not make any predictions yet. We probably cannot say that we are that familiar with the worldview of this candidate as far as relations with our country are concerned.”

    Georgescu’s success in the parliamentary elections on December 1, in which 19 million citizens are taking part, is likely to give an additional boost to hard-right groupings. Mainstream parties have not officially endorsed either presidential candidate.

    Georgescu calls NATO missile debt ‘a shame of diplomacy’

    Georgescu described a NATO ballistic missile defense shield in Romania as a “shame of diplomacy” and questioned whether the Western military alliance would protect any of its members in the event of a Russian attack. He stated that Romania’s best chance lay with “Russian wisdom,” but has refused to say explicitly whether he supports Russia.

    Romania, which was under communist rule for four decades until 1989, shares a 650-kilometer (400-mile) border with Ukraine. Since the Russian attack on Ukraine in 2022, the country has enabled the export of millions of tons of grain through its Black Sea port of Constanța and provided military aid, including the donation of a Patriot air defense battery.

    The president, who is limited to two five-year terms, has a semi-executive role which includes heading Romania’s armed forces and chairing the Supreme Defense Council that decides on military aid. He represents Romania at EU and NATO summits and appoints the Prime Minister, chief judges, public prosecutors and the heads of the secret services. The current president, Klaus Iohannis, won power in 2014 on a promise to bolster the fight against endemic corruption. rtr

    • Europa

    Tariffs: EU Commission appeals to WTO over brandy

    The EU Commission has officially challenged China’s provisional anti-dumping measures against brandy imports at the World Trade Organization (WTO). “China’s provisional measures on EU brandy are not in line with WTO rules,” said a statement from the Brussels authority on Monday, adding it “has not proven that there is any threat of injury to its brandy industry.” The formal request for consultations with the WTO is the first step in the dispute settlement procedure.

    The Chinese Ministry of Commerce said China would handle the matter per WTO rules. The EU’s move follows Chinese anti-dumping measures of up to 39 percent on EU brandy in response to EU countervailing duties on Chinese EVs.

    The trade dispute has caused particular concern in France, whose cognac producers regard China as an important export market. The French Ministry of Trade had announced that it was working with the European Commission to challenge Beijing’s tariffs. French President Emmanuel Macron had previously described China’s investigation as “pure retaliation.”

    Considerations by manufacturer Hennessy to start bottling in China had led to a strike at a plant in southwestern France. Meanwhile, cognac producer Remy announced plans to increase prices in China and lower costs in areas such as production and advertising. ari

    • Emmanuel Macron
    • Europäische Kommission
    • WTO
    • Zölle

    Food labeling: European Court of Auditors criticizes gaps in EU law

    European consumers are being bombarded with more and more promises, logos, slogans, seals of approval and ratings that are not only confusing but can be downright misleading. This is the conclusion reached by the European Court of Auditors in its special report on food labeling in the EU published on Monday, based on surveys in Lithuania, Belgium and Italy. “Companies are very creative when it comes to the information on packaging. However, EU regulations have not kept pace with the constantly evolving market,” said Keit Pentus-Rosimannus, the member of the European Court of Auditors responsible for the audit, summarizing the results.

    The auditors found that companies could sometimes even emphasize nutritional and health-related benefits on products with a high fat, salt and sugar content. Claims such as “fresh” or “natural” as well as environmental claims that are tantamount to greenwashing cannot be stopped with the current regulations, they regret. At the same time, the use of the labels “vegan” or “vegetarian” is not regulated as there are no EU-wide definitions.

    List of authorized health claims on herbal preparations is missing

    Against this background, the EU Court of Auditors calls on the Commission to close the gaps in the EU legal framework on food labeling – in particular via the outstanding updates to the Food Information Regulation (FIR) and the Regulation on nutrition and health claims. At the same time, many questions regarding origin labeling and alcoholic beverages are still open and the Commission should take action in this regard, according to the report. The Commission has not yet presented a reform of the EU rules on food labeling that was announced for the last term of office.

    The Court’s auditors also criticize the lack of “a list of EU-approved health claims on herbal preparations and EU regulations on the labeling of foods suitable for vegetarians and vegans.” At the same time, they call on the Commission to better analyze labeling practices and improve consumer understanding of food labeling

    ‘Fines not dissuasive, effective or proportionate’

    Although the controls generally work well for mandatory disclosures, they are lacking for voluntary disclosures, the report states. In addition, the fines imposed for non-compliance are often not dissuasive, effective or proportionate, according to the auditors.

    Despite all this, the EU only provided around €5.5 million between 2021 and 2025 for awareness-raising campaigns on food labeling, which many EU countries only carried out sporadically, according to the Court of Auditors’ report. heu

    • Greenwashing

    Corning: Commission requests comments on commitments

    The European Commission is inviting companies and interested parties to comment on proposals by the US group Corning aimed at resolving antitrust concerns. The commitments are intended to ensure that competition in the market for specialty glass is maintained. Corning’s alkaline aluminosilicate glass, known under the Gorilla Glass brand, is primarily used in smartphones, tablets and similar devices.

    Since November 6, 2024, the Commission has been investigating whether Corning has abused its dominant market position. The focus is on exclusive supply agreements with device manufacturers and glass processors that may have excluded competitors from the market and thus harmed consumer interests.

    To dispel these concerns, Corning is proposing to waive exclusive clauses in contracts worldwide and to limit dependence on customers to a maximum of 50 percent of their demand. The commitments are to apply for nine years and be monitored by an independent body. Interested parties can submit comments until six weeks after publication of the commitments in the Official Journal of the EU. vis

    • Wettbewerbsverfahren

    New Commission: Greens divided ahead of vote

    In an extraordinary group meeting on Monday evening, the members of the Greens/EFA group discussed whether they will vote for or against the new Commission in the European Parliament on Wednesday. No clear decision was reached.

    According to information from Table.Briefings, 26 group members want to vote for the Commission and 20 against. Six group members are still undecided. However, Commission President Ursula von der Leyen will probably not need the votes of the Greens/EFA to get her proposal through this time. vis

    • Europäische Kommission
    Translation missing.

    Europe.table editorial team

    EUROPE.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen