Table.Briefing: Europe

Berlin without EU billions + Metals from China + DMA

Dear reader,

It would be the epitome of speed: Negotiations in Parliament on the electricity market reform could be over as early as tomorrow – almost two weeks before the vote in the Industry Committee on July 19. At least that’s what the Greens hope. But the question is whether the race beyond the fast lane won’t lead to a bang on the energy markets.

The Spanish Socialists are desperate to score a success before the elections on the 23rd. Voters suffering from energy poverty are to be reassured by a profit levy on high electricity prices. If implemented incorrectly, however, this could discourage investment in renewables, which would reduce prices most sustainably.

Some people, such as Luxembourg’s Claude Turmes, even see the entire domestic market threatened by the French nuclear course. Where there’s a lot of nuclear power, there’s no competition – again, the price-cutting renewables could end up on the hard shoulder.

One would like to wish the negotiators a not-too-cramped step on the electric pedal. They can see in real-time from their parliamentary colleagues in Berlin what kind of muddle results from overly rapid negotiations. The Bundestag also plans to pass the “heating law” on Thursday.

Your
Manuel Berkel
Image of Manuel  Berkel

Feature

Reconstruction fund: Germany leaves €28 billion unused

At issue are grants to which Germany is entitled from the Corona Recovery and Resilience Facility. So far, the German government has not succeeded in clearing the way for even the first partial payment. According to information from Table.Media, the “Operational Agreement” with the EU Commission has not even been signed yet. The document regulates the formalities and burden of proof requirements and is a prerequisite for the EU funds to flow. In addition, the German government has not yet implemented some reforms that it must provide for the funds to be disbursed.

Other member states are faster: So far, the Commission has already approved 26 applications from 18 member states for payment of billions. Especially in countries such as Spain, Italy and Greece, which German politicians have frequently accused of reform fatigue in the past, large amounts in the billions have already been invested from Next Generation EU. However, the money pledged to these member states also represents a higher share in terms of economic output.

€338 billion for post-pandemic reconstruction

Time is pressing. The billions must be spent by the end of 2026. After the pandemic, the restructuring of the national economy is to be driven forward in the spirit of the Green Deal and digitization accelerated. The aim is also to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.

To this end, the EU is making a total of €338 billion in grants available to the member states. Germany is entitled to around €30 billion. €2.3 billion was disbursed to Berlin in August 2021 as advance funding, with no conditions attached.

The disbursement of the next tranches, on the other hand, depends on the government achieving the milestones agreed individually with the Commission. Here, the German government has so far failed to deliver. The basis for this is the National Recovery and Resilience Plan. According to this plan, 42 percent of the funds in Germany are to be allocated to climate protection measures, while 52 percent of the funds are to benefit digitization.

Less bureaucracy, sustainable solutions in transport

The Federal Ministry of Finance is responsible for applying for the billions in funds from the EU budget. The ministry confirmed on request that Germany has not yet submitted a payment application. The first Reconstruction and Resilience Plan (DARP), which was already approved by the Council in July 2021, had to be amended again. However, an initial application for payment is to be submitted “before the end of the year”.

Of the 129 milestones and targets agreed with the Commission, 58 have been achieved so far, the spokesman said. What the spokesman does not say is that for some reforms that Germany must complete, the federal government has so far failed to provide proof.

These include faster approval procedures. In concrete terms, the aim is to reduce investment barriers and bureaucracy in administrative processes. Measures for decarbonization, the development of an economy with green hydrogen and sustainable solutions in transport are also required of Germany. The Commission does not provide any information on what specific reforms are involved and which of them have not yet been implemented.

Greece demonstrates willingness to reform

Other member states are much further ahead. The government of Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis, for example, has given top political priority to disbursing the funds. In September 2022, the government laid the groundwork for applying to the Commission for the second installment of €3.6 billion. Three months later, the billions flowed. In mid-May, Athens requested the third disbursement of the funds. By September at the latest, the Council should give the green light and transfer the next €1.72 billion.

Italy is entitled to grants of €68 billion, €28.95 billion of which have already been paid out. Spain is entitled to €69.5 billion in grants, of which €37 billion have already been paid out. Behind closed doors and with certain malice one speaks in these weeks in Brussels about Germany. Countries that were described by German politicians as unwilling to reform, not least during the debt crisis, have meanwhile been acting in an exemplary manner: They have completed the reforms demanded of them by the EU Commission as part of the European Semester, for example in the judiciary and tax administration, and are therefore already benefiting from the Brussels billions.

Berlin works on RePowerEU chapter

German consumers and companies are suffering particularly from high energy prices. The Commission has grants of €2.1 billion available for Germany under RePowerEU. The aim is to drive forward decarbonization. To access the Brussels billions, each member state must submit a plan to the EU as a chapter of the national build-up and resilience plan.

According to reports in Brussels, plans have already been received from seven member states, including Portugal, France, Malta, Denmark, Estonia and Slovakia. About a handful of plans have already been reviewed and adopted. Here, too, Germany is lagging behind. When will Germany deliver? A ministry spokesman can’t give a specific date: “Germany is currently in the process of preparing and voting on a revised plan, including a RePowerEU chapter.” The deadline for applications is December.

  • Germany
  • NextGenerationEU
  • REPowerEU
  • Wiederaufbaufonds

Trade dispute with China affects important industrial metals

China’s Ministry of Commerce Mofcom has made exports of the key industrial metals gallium and germanium subject to approval. As of August 1, exporters will require a license to ship these elements to other countries. The basis for the ministry’s directive is the Export Control Law of 2020. According to the ministry, the purpose of the controls is to protect “national security”.

“This mirrors the strategic use of export control measures by the US,” writes Mathieu Duchâtel, an expert on the Chinese economy at the French think tank Institut Montaigne. So far, however, it is not an export ban: Any exporter can still request a license.

Nevertheless, “European semiconductor companies will consider themselves again in the crossfire of US-China competition“, adds Duchâtel. After all, China is the biggest producer of both metals. The new regulation already creates uncertainty about availability and prices. Gallium is particularly vital for a new, more cost-effective generation of semiconductors.

Gallium nitride is the future of car chips

Germany has a high interest in the availability of both metals. This is because gallium is a raw material for power semiconductor devices, which are necessary for the automotive industry. Power semiconductors are chips capable of switching high current voltages, thus an essential part of EV electronics. They can adjust the current seamlessly and are not affected by high temperatures.

Power semiconductors can also be made from silicon, the traditional material for microchips. However, gallium nitride is currently becoming very attractive as a cost-effective and energy-saving alternative. One important manufacturer of gallium nitride-based power semiconductors is Infineon. The company already operates a plant for power semiconductors in Malaysia. It has now also absorbed Canadian special manufacturer GaN Systems to strengthen this area.

Applications include laser and solar

The EU currently promotes the development of gallium-based electronic components. Apart from vehicle manufacturing, gallium nitride chips are also used in many other advanced technologies, for example, in

  • chargers,
  • data centers,
  • radar equipment,
  • laser,
  • LEDs or
  • solar panels.

At present, around 98 percent of the gallium consumed worldwide is imported from China. The EU imports over 70 percent of its gallium and almost half of its germanium from China. But the reason for this is not that the metal is not found elsewhere – gallium is also found in Japan, South Korea, Russia or Kazakhstan. The decisive factor for the high market share is China’s low export price.

Germany seeks new gallium sources

Germany also used to be a gallium producer but ceased production in 2016 as it was no longer lucrative given the surpluses on the global market. However, plans to resume producing gallium emerged in late 2021 as part of efforts to reduce strategic dependencies.

Research is currently underway on how to achieve this. But it will take time before a significant yield can be achieved. Experts believe Europe will require another ten years to reduce its dependence on industrial metals.

Response to US tech sanctions

The Chinese export controls are part of the trade dispute between the US and China. Presidents Trump and Biden have imposed a long list of sanctions on China’s tech companies. On the one hand, they are hardly allowed to do business in the US anymore; on the other hand, Washington has cut off the Chinese economy from advanced US semiconductors and their production facilities.

China now responds by using the leverage at its disposal. If the United States no longer supplies chips, China, in turn, no longer supplies raw materials. However, the US is completely dependent on imported metals. In this respect, China’s controls are not new. The export of rare earth elements has already been regulated since 2010.

EU calls for moderate application

Due to the technical and industrial significance of gallium and germanium, both elements are included on the EU’s list of strategic raw materials for the digital economy and the energy transition. On Tuesday, a spokesperson for the Commission in Brussels expressed “concern” about the Chinese trade measure.

The EU urged China to only deny export licenses over “genuine security concerns”. The Brussels authority currently examines the impact of China’s decision – and whether it is compatible with WTO trade rules.

German industry urges diversification

The Federation of German Industries (BDI) regards the new regulations as a wake-up call to accelerate de-risking. “Beijing’s announced export control measures for the raw materials gallium and germanium, which are important for the semiconductor industry, illustrate the urgency of quickly reducing dependence on critical raw materials now,” according to Wolfgang Niedermark, member of the BDI’s Executive Board. This is why it is positive that the EU is progressing toward securing the supply of critical raw materials. he said.

Companies seeking to apply for export licenses in China must specify the country of destination and the intended industrial application of the shipment. This allows Mofcom to very precisely regulate the export restrictions. For instance, exports to certain EU countries could be denied and permitted to others. However, the law’s main addressee is the United States, which buys almost all its gallium on the global market.

  • E-Autos

News

DMA: Gatekeepers make themselves known

Seven companies say they meet the new EU criteria for gatekeepers under the Digital Markets Act (DMA). “We will now review their applications and appoint gatekeepers for certain platform services by Sep. 6“, Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton said Tuesday. After that, the gatekeepers will have six months to comply with the DMA regulations.

The following companies have declared that they will meet the thresholds:

  • Alphabet (Google)
  • Amazon
  • Apple
  • Bytedance (Tiktok)
  • Meta (Facebook, Instagram)
  • Microsoft
  • Samsung

Under the DMA, which came into force in November, companies with more than 45 million monthly active users and a market capitalization of €75 billion are considered gatekeepers if they offer a core platform service. Stricter rules will apply to these platforms in the future.

“Consumers will have more services to choose from, more opportunities to switch providers, and they will benefit from better prices and higher quality of service“, Breton said. In addition, innovative companies would no longer be prevented from reaching new customers.

Tiktok does not see itself as gatekeeper

Surprisingly, Samsung and Tiktok owner Bytedance have also come forward. According to Tiktok, the company meets the quantitative criteria of the DMA, but not the general requirements of the directive. Those stipulate that the gatekeeper has an “unavoidable platform for conducting online business in the EU” and be a “fixed” link between consumers and businesses.

Booking.com expects to fall into the gatekeeper category next year. In the reference period, Booking had suffered revenue losses due to the Corona pandemic.

Commission to examine other companies

“We want competition and want the best offer to win in the EU in the end, not the monopolist with the best networking options for customers”, Andreas Schwab (CDU) told Table.Media. The rapporteur for the DMA in the European Parliament said the Commission must now look at each company and say what the DMA means for the individual platforms.

Example: Google Maps. If the service were considered part of Google Search, then Google’s commitments to the search engine would also apply to Google Maps. “And that would be desirable from my point of view”, Schwab said.

The Commission also examines companies that have not made themselves known. If it finds that these companies have a de facto role as gatekeepers, even though they may fall short of the thresholds by a few euros, the commission can classify them as gatekeepers under Article 3(8), Schwab said. Even if they don’t meet the formal requirements. As an example, Schwab cited Vivendi or Alibaba. vis

ECJ strengthens antitrust authorities and data protection

Data protection violations may be part of audits under competition law. This was decided by the European Court of Justice in a ruling published yesterday. The background is a dispute between Meta Ireland and the German Federal Cartel Office. In addition, the Luxembourg judges also ruled on a second important issue: Tracking on third-party sites could now be on the verge of being outlawed.

This was prompted by proceedings brought by the German Federal Cartel Office against Facebook on the grounds of suspected abuse of a dominant market position. The Facebook parent company had argued that the antitrust authorities were not competent in the area of personal data processing and in particular the company’s terms of use and accordingly could not base their decisions on them.

Cooperation with supervisory authorities

The ECJ took a different view and emphasized that the antitrust authorities are obliged to cooperate loyally with the competent data protection supervisory authorities. They may not deviate from their assessment without first consulting the data protection supervisory authority, the judges said. In this specific case, the competent supervisory authority was the controversial Irish data protection supervisory authority.

The president of the German Federal Cartel Office, Andreas Mundt, sees the ruling as a breakthrough in the application of antitrust law to digital companies, saying, “The ruling will have far-reaching effects on the business models of the data economy.” At stake, he said, is the data-based market power of companies. Ramona Pop, executive director of the Federation of German Consumer Organizations, spoke of an “important interim success in curbing the data collection frenzy of the big platforms”. The consumer advocates were involved in the Luxembourg case as parties to the proceedings.

CDU MEP Andreas Schwab was also pleased with the ruling: “We are moving in the right direction: cooperation and coordination between different authoritiesas already provided for by the DMA – is becoming increasingly important.” Due to the large number of competent authorities for individual sub-areas of digital regulation, a different ruling would have foreseeably caused greater problems for the EU competition and digital regulation system.

Tracking on third-party sites massively restricted

The effects of a second aspect of yesterday’s ECJ decision are still barely foreseeable: The judges determined that data derived from cookies is not “manifestly public” in the sense of the General Data Protection Regulation. This concerns, among other things, the integration of Like buttons and other elements on third-party sites. This is only to be assumed if a user “has previously, if necessary by means of individual settings made in full knowledge of the facts, explicitly expressed his decision to make the data concerning him publicly accessible to an unlimited number of persons”.

The judges also stated that the merging of data originating from embedded elements in third-party websites or other offers is only justified within a very narrow legal framework: in the case of a legal obligation, when it is actually necessary and the processing is proportionate to the objective and, moreover, is also limited to what is absolutely necessary. This concerns, among other things, the merging of Whatsapp, which was taken over by Facebook, where Meta was happy to merge user data for advertising purposes.

“Today’s landmark ruling by the European Court of Justice likely means the end of this commonly used surfing logging“, said Patrick Breyer, a member of the Pirate Party in the European Parliament. fst

DIW study: Regulators must classify data more strongly as competitive advantage

Through network and scale effects, platforms with data can gain an unassailable competitive advantage. Google probably benefits the most from additional data. This was the finding of a recent study by DIW Berlin. “In the past, competition authorities and regulators have not paid sufficient attention to the value of data“, says study author Hannes Ullrich, a research fellow at DIW’s Enterprise and Markets department. This is how Google, among others, has been able to secure advantages in the market.

“Competition authorities should consider access to data as a key factor when they want to regulate new technologies such as artificial intelligence“, says Ullrich. “Otherwise, undesirable market power can accumulate, for example, even in large-scale voice models such as ChatGPT.”

All companies benefit from having larger amounts of data at their disposal. But in the study, Ullrich and colleagues show that Google derives a greater advantage from additional data than others. “So far, there is very little empirical evidence in the area because Google, Meta and others don’t let us look at their cards”, Ullrich explains. But the DIW study shows that companies could use their data volumes to lead digital markets to tipping points that create insurmountable hurdles for competitors.

DIW uses novel analysis dataset

For users, this means they have fewer choices and poorer offers than in markets without barriers to competition. “We therefore welcome the fact that the EU Commission is taking more and more steps to require companies to share data“, says Ullrich. “Even if the implementation is not trivial in many cases.”

Using a novel analytics dataset, the researchers say they were able to measure for the first time how the quantity of data relates to the quality of predictions about user characteristics. The study shows that all companies in the tracking market benefit from additional data – both in terms of the number of users tracked and the number of websites tracked. The quality of the predictions is improving, but the more data is added, the lower this quality increases.

However, Google stands out from the crowd: Thanks to the enormous volumes and depth of data to which the company has access, it can systematically assess users more precisely. This competitive advantage could potentially mean that Google can no longer be caught up by other market players. vis

DIW publishes the study in its weekly report at 9 a.m. here.

Commission wants to standardize GDPR procedural rights

EU Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders wants to improve enforcement of the General Data Protection Regulation across Europe by means of a small reform. At the heart of the project are rules for the parties involved in the procedure, cooperation between the data protection supervisory authorities and the introduction of fixed deadlines. Even the question of when a deadline begins and what constitutes a working day is addressed in a separate article. In addition, a procedure for the peaceful resolution of disputes is to be introduced, whereby the original complainant would have to object within one month and can also challenge the discontinuation of the procedure in court.

With the proposal presented yesterday, the EU Commission wants to get to grips with some particularly persistent procedural tricks. For example, it will be more clearly regulated which rules apply to which procedural steps in the cooperation between supervisory authorities in Europe. The question of how to deal with complainants based in other countries is also part of the Reynders proposal, as are rules on access to documents and the handling of procedural documents.

Jourová: ‘Work faster and more decisively’

At the same time, the supplementary regulation is also intended to ensure uniform protection of trade secrets and confidential information in transnational proceedings. Here, Reynders wants a high level of confidentiality to be guaranteed – however, the proposal also contains some specifications as to how information may be classified as confidential or as a trade secret in the first place.

The background to the proposal is incidents, particularly in connection with the Irish data protection supervisory authority DPC Ireland. This caused a lot of displeasure, especially in the ongoing proceedings against the Meta subsidiary Facebook.

EU Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders now justified the new proposals saying, “It is clear that enforcement of the GDPR is working, but procedures in cross-border cases can still be improved.” Commission Vice-President Věra Jourová spoke of the time being “to ensure that we can work faster and more decisively”. The success of the GDPR depends on enforcement, she said.

Fear of the great reform

The EU Commission, member states and the EU Parliament have so far refrained from a major and comprehensive reform of the GDPR. The main reason for this is the feared lobbying battle.

The response to the Reynders proposals yesterday already provided a taste of this: While industry associations such as Bitkom and the Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA) criticized the lack of a greater will to reform – as did CDU Member of the European Parliament Axel Voss – data and consumer protection groups were dissatisfied with the regulations presented for completely different reasons.

The consumer protection umbrella organization BEUC, for example, criticized the fact that the proposal does not include any rules on the prompt provision of information to complainants on the status of proceedings. In addition, it must be ensured in the further procedure that the regulation does not prevent any procedural rights that go beyond the rules now proposed, said BEUC Deputy Director General Ursula Pachl. Parts of the proposals are based on suggestions from the European data protection supervisory authorities themselves. fst

NATO: Stoltenberg extends by one year

Jens Stoltenberg seems difficult to replace as Secretary-General of the military alliance. The ambassadors of NATO countries on Tuesday extended the Norwegian’s mandate by one year until Oct. 1, 2024. The decision comes just in time for next week’s summit in Vilnius. He felt “honored”, Stoltenberg wrote on the short message service Twitter. The 64-year-old Norwegian had made no secret of the fact that he had no desire for a further extension and would have preferred to follow his wife back to Oslo.

Jens Stoltenberg must stay on because the allies could not agree on a successor. British Defense Minister Ben Wallace is the only one who had publicly expressed interest in the job. But a Briton as secretary general of the military alliance was out of the question for weighty EU states in NATO. They did not want to reward London with the prestigious job after Brexit, diplomats said. After thirteen men in the post, the time was also ripe for a woman.

Poles and Balts want succession from Eastern Europe

Estonia’s Prime Minister Kaja Kallas was in the conversation early on, known for clear statements on Russia and Vladimir Putin’s war of aggression against Ukraine. For some Western Europeans, however, the Estonian was too pointed. Denmark’s head of government, Mette Frederiksen, was promised good chances in the meantime. But in the end, Poland and the Baltic states objected. Now it was time for an Eastern European. Frederiksen would have been the third Scandinavian in a row, after Norway’s Stoltenberg and Denmark’s Anders Fogh Rasmussen.

For Jens Stoltenberg, this is the fourth extension. First, he made a name for himself as the tamer of former US President Donald Trump. Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine, he has distinguished himself with his level-headed manner.

For the alliance, the so far unsuccessful search for a successor is not necessarily a sign of strength. Stoltenberg will still be in office when NATO celebrates its 75th anniversary in April 2024. At the summit in Washington, however, it should be definitely over and the succession settled, in time for the US elections and a possible comeback by Donald Trump. For the Europeans, the renewed postponement of the personnel issue is not inconvenient. It opens up more scope for a larger personnel package after the European elections in June next year. sti

EU and Mercosur: Lula rejects amendment to trade treaty

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has rejected the additional declaration demanded by Brussels on the planned free trade agreement between the European Union and the South American economic alliance Mercosur. “This is unacceptable”, he said Tuesday at the Mercosur leaders’ summit in Puerto Iguazú, Argentina. “We don’t want an agreement that condemns us to be forever just suppliers of raw materials“, Lula said.

He had previously announced a counter-proposal. “I want to work so that in these six months we can conclude the agreement with the European Union and think about other things”, the head of state said, referring to Brazil’s Mercosur presidency for the next six months. “We want to discuss the agreement, but we don’t want to have anything imposed on us.”

Criticism also from Argentina

Argentina’s President Alberto Fernández also criticized the additional declaration on climate, environment and human rights proposed by the EU. “It puts too much focus on environmental protection without keeping economic and social sustainability in mind”, he said. He also accused EU countries of protectionism, especially in agriculture.

The EU-Mercosur free trade agreement has been on hold since negotiations concluded in 2019. The treaty would create the world’s largest free trade area with 780 million people. The agreement still needs to be ratified by all member states. However, it is controversial in both South America and Europe. During her recent trip to South America, EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen campaigned for the free trade agreement to be implemented as quickly as possible.

Lula also said he wanted Mercosur countries to move forward in talks with Canada, South Korea and Singapore. In addition, Mercosur could also explore “new negotiating fronts” with China, Indonesia, Vietnam and countries in Central America and the Caribbean. dpa/rtr

Heads

Michael Sterner – a mastermind of the energy transition

Michael Sterner is Professor of Energy Systems and Energy Storage at the OTH Regensburg.

In a good mood, energy expert Michael Sterner tells us that he spent the weekend tinkering with the photovoltaic system on the roof of his house. It quickly becomes clear that the famous gap between theory and practice does not exist for this man. “I am 83 percent self-sufficient in electricity, heat and mobility with my own solar power”, says Sterner.

The 45-year-old professor of energy systems and energy storage, who teaches and conducts research at the Ostbayerische Technische Hochschule (OTH) in Regensburg, has a practical background. He trained in the electrical trade and has already installed solar cells on school roofs in Kenya.

Sterner is not afraid to seek the widest possible publicity for his topic: In the German ZDF satire program “Heute Show” he promoted wind power, and when the Regensburg City Council presented an energy master plan that does without a solar obligation, Sterner, in association with Fridays for Future, sometimes called for a protest in front of the city hall. What motivates him? “I know that I am doing something that is good for my family and all the people who live on earth”, says the energy expert.

‘Gas storage facilities are the essential hedge against blackouts’

His parents had already influenced him ecologically: “As farmers, we were already working biotopes with a scythe in the 1980s. Other people were still laughing at us then.” Sterner has been working on the energy transition since the end of the 1990s.

After studying mechatronics in Regensburg, earning a master’s degree in renewable energies in Oldenburg, a doctorate in renewable energy systems and research stays in Spain, Chile and India, he joined the German Advisory Council on Global Change (WBGU). In the meantime, the professor from Regensburg has become one of the most distinguished thought leaders of the energy transition. For example, he is considered one of the originators of Power to Gas – a technology that uses the decomposition of water into oxygen and hydrogen to produce climate-friendly gases and fuels from renewable energies. “With this technology, the blackout debate has disappeared. Gas storage is the essential safeguard against blackouts”, Sterner says.

Out of the climate and energy crisis

For the energy expert, the crux of the energy transition lies in its social implementation. So Sterner is fighting against trenches – he wants to offer solutions, to think pragmatically. With his book “How We Can Save the Climate” he has developed a master plan for the energy transition in 2022. “So that everyone understands how we can find our way out of the climate and energy crisis and make our lives and economies climate-neutral.” After all, the necessary technologies have long been available, he says, you just have to want the change.

Sterner wrote his book for the boomer generation. For the people who can now implement the energy turnaround, because they can decide to buy climate-friendly cars and heating systems and to renovate buildings. In the big energy debate, he wants to bring as many people along as possible: “If people only think electric, we’ll scare many away.” Climate neutrality, Sterner says, is a fine line. And so he urges action: “We have to pragmatically agree on the middle path. That will only work if we all want it together.” Gabriele Voßkühler

  • Gasspeicher

Europe.Table Editorial Office

EUROPE.TABLE EDITORS

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    It would be the epitome of speed: Negotiations in Parliament on the electricity market reform could be over as early as tomorrow – almost two weeks before the vote in the Industry Committee on July 19. At least that’s what the Greens hope. But the question is whether the race beyond the fast lane won’t lead to a bang on the energy markets.

    The Spanish Socialists are desperate to score a success before the elections on the 23rd. Voters suffering from energy poverty are to be reassured by a profit levy on high electricity prices. If implemented incorrectly, however, this could discourage investment in renewables, which would reduce prices most sustainably.

    Some people, such as Luxembourg’s Claude Turmes, even see the entire domestic market threatened by the French nuclear course. Where there’s a lot of nuclear power, there’s no competition – again, the price-cutting renewables could end up on the hard shoulder.

    One would like to wish the negotiators a not-too-cramped step on the electric pedal. They can see in real-time from their parliamentary colleagues in Berlin what kind of muddle results from overly rapid negotiations. The Bundestag also plans to pass the “heating law” on Thursday.

    Your
    Manuel Berkel
    Image of Manuel  Berkel

    Feature

    Reconstruction fund: Germany leaves €28 billion unused

    At issue are grants to which Germany is entitled from the Corona Recovery and Resilience Facility. So far, the German government has not succeeded in clearing the way for even the first partial payment. According to information from Table.Media, the “Operational Agreement” with the EU Commission has not even been signed yet. The document regulates the formalities and burden of proof requirements and is a prerequisite for the EU funds to flow. In addition, the German government has not yet implemented some reforms that it must provide for the funds to be disbursed.

    Other member states are faster: So far, the Commission has already approved 26 applications from 18 member states for payment of billions. Especially in countries such as Spain, Italy and Greece, which German politicians have frequently accused of reform fatigue in the past, large amounts in the billions have already been invested from Next Generation EU. However, the money pledged to these member states also represents a higher share in terms of economic output.

    €338 billion for post-pandemic reconstruction

    Time is pressing. The billions must be spent by the end of 2026. After the pandemic, the restructuring of the national economy is to be driven forward in the spirit of the Green Deal and digitization accelerated. The aim is also to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.

    To this end, the EU is making a total of €338 billion in grants available to the member states. Germany is entitled to around €30 billion. €2.3 billion was disbursed to Berlin in August 2021 as advance funding, with no conditions attached.

    The disbursement of the next tranches, on the other hand, depends on the government achieving the milestones agreed individually with the Commission. Here, the German government has so far failed to deliver. The basis for this is the National Recovery and Resilience Plan. According to this plan, 42 percent of the funds in Germany are to be allocated to climate protection measures, while 52 percent of the funds are to benefit digitization.

    Less bureaucracy, sustainable solutions in transport

    The Federal Ministry of Finance is responsible for applying for the billions in funds from the EU budget. The ministry confirmed on request that Germany has not yet submitted a payment application. The first Reconstruction and Resilience Plan (DARP), which was already approved by the Council in July 2021, had to be amended again. However, an initial application for payment is to be submitted “before the end of the year”.

    Of the 129 milestones and targets agreed with the Commission, 58 have been achieved so far, the spokesman said. What the spokesman does not say is that for some reforms that Germany must complete, the federal government has so far failed to provide proof.

    These include faster approval procedures. In concrete terms, the aim is to reduce investment barriers and bureaucracy in administrative processes. Measures for decarbonization, the development of an economy with green hydrogen and sustainable solutions in transport are also required of Germany. The Commission does not provide any information on what specific reforms are involved and which of them have not yet been implemented.

    Greece demonstrates willingness to reform

    Other member states are much further ahead. The government of Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis, for example, has given top political priority to disbursing the funds. In September 2022, the government laid the groundwork for applying to the Commission for the second installment of €3.6 billion. Three months later, the billions flowed. In mid-May, Athens requested the third disbursement of the funds. By September at the latest, the Council should give the green light and transfer the next €1.72 billion.

    Italy is entitled to grants of €68 billion, €28.95 billion of which have already been paid out. Spain is entitled to €69.5 billion in grants, of which €37 billion have already been paid out. Behind closed doors and with certain malice one speaks in these weeks in Brussels about Germany. Countries that were described by German politicians as unwilling to reform, not least during the debt crisis, have meanwhile been acting in an exemplary manner: They have completed the reforms demanded of them by the EU Commission as part of the European Semester, for example in the judiciary and tax administration, and are therefore already benefiting from the Brussels billions.

    Berlin works on RePowerEU chapter

    German consumers and companies are suffering particularly from high energy prices. The Commission has grants of €2.1 billion available for Germany under RePowerEU. The aim is to drive forward decarbonization. To access the Brussels billions, each member state must submit a plan to the EU as a chapter of the national build-up and resilience plan.

    According to reports in Brussels, plans have already been received from seven member states, including Portugal, France, Malta, Denmark, Estonia and Slovakia. About a handful of plans have already been reviewed and adopted. Here, too, Germany is lagging behind. When will Germany deliver? A ministry spokesman can’t give a specific date: “Germany is currently in the process of preparing and voting on a revised plan, including a RePowerEU chapter.” The deadline for applications is December.

    • Germany
    • NextGenerationEU
    • REPowerEU
    • Wiederaufbaufonds

    Trade dispute with China affects important industrial metals

    China’s Ministry of Commerce Mofcom has made exports of the key industrial metals gallium and germanium subject to approval. As of August 1, exporters will require a license to ship these elements to other countries. The basis for the ministry’s directive is the Export Control Law of 2020. According to the ministry, the purpose of the controls is to protect “national security”.

    “This mirrors the strategic use of export control measures by the US,” writes Mathieu Duchâtel, an expert on the Chinese economy at the French think tank Institut Montaigne. So far, however, it is not an export ban: Any exporter can still request a license.

    Nevertheless, “European semiconductor companies will consider themselves again in the crossfire of US-China competition“, adds Duchâtel. After all, China is the biggest producer of both metals. The new regulation already creates uncertainty about availability and prices. Gallium is particularly vital for a new, more cost-effective generation of semiconductors.

    Gallium nitride is the future of car chips

    Germany has a high interest in the availability of both metals. This is because gallium is a raw material for power semiconductor devices, which are necessary for the automotive industry. Power semiconductors are chips capable of switching high current voltages, thus an essential part of EV electronics. They can adjust the current seamlessly and are not affected by high temperatures.

    Power semiconductors can also be made from silicon, the traditional material for microchips. However, gallium nitride is currently becoming very attractive as a cost-effective and energy-saving alternative. One important manufacturer of gallium nitride-based power semiconductors is Infineon. The company already operates a plant for power semiconductors in Malaysia. It has now also absorbed Canadian special manufacturer GaN Systems to strengthen this area.

    Applications include laser and solar

    The EU currently promotes the development of gallium-based electronic components. Apart from vehicle manufacturing, gallium nitride chips are also used in many other advanced technologies, for example, in

    • chargers,
    • data centers,
    • radar equipment,
    • laser,
    • LEDs or
    • solar panels.

    At present, around 98 percent of the gallium consumed worldwide is imported from China. The EU imports over 70 percent of its gallium and almost half of its germanium from China. But the reason for this is not that the metal is not found elsewhere – gallium is also found in Japan, South Korea, Russia or Kazakhstan. The decisive factor for the high market share is China’s low export price.

    Germany seeks new gallium sources

    Germany also used to be a gallium producer but ceased production in 2016 as it was no longer lucrative given the surpluses on the global market. However, plans to resume producing gallium emerged in late 2021 as part of efforts to reduce strategic dependencies.

    Research is currently underway on how to achieve this. But it will take time before a significant yield can be achieved. Experts believe Europe will require another ten years to reduce its dependence on industrial metals.

    Response to US tech sanctions

    The Chinese export controls are part of the trade dispute between the US and China. Presidents Trump and Biden have imposed a long list of sanctions on China’s tech companies. On the one hand, they are hardly allowed to do business in the US anymore; on the other hand, Washington has cut off the Chinese economy from advanced US semiconductors and their production facilities.

    China now responds by using the leverage at its disposal. If the United States no longer supplies chips, China, in turn, no longer supplies raw materials. However, the US is completely dependent on imported metals. In this respect, China’s controls are not new. The export of rare earth elements has already been regulated since 2010.

    EU calls for moderate application

    Due to the technical and industrial significance of gallium and germanium, both elements are included on the EU’s list of strategic raw materials for the digital economy and the energy transition. On Tuesday, a spokesperson for the Commission in Brussels expressed “concern” about the Chinese trade measure.

    The EU urged China to only deny export licenses over “genuine security concerns”. The Brussels authority currently examines the impact of China’s decision – and whether it is compatible with WTO trade rules.

    German industry urges diversification

    The Federation of German Industries (BDI) regards the new regulations as a wake-up call to accelerate de-risking. “Beijing’s announced export control measures for the raw materials gallium and germanium, which are important for the semiconductor industry, illustrate the urgency of quickly reducing dependence on critical raw materials now,” according to Wolfgang Niedermark, member of the BDI’s Executive Board. This is why it is positive that the EU is progressing toward securing the supply of critical raw materials. he said.

    Companies seeking to apply for export licenses in China must specify the country of destination and the intended industrial application of the shipment. This allows Mofcom to very precisely regulate the export restrictions. For instance, exports to certain EU countries could be denied and permitted to others. However, the law’s main addressee is the United States, which buys almost all its gallium on the global market.

    • E-Autos

    News

    DMA: Gatekeepers make themselves known

    Seven companies say they meet the new EU criteria for gatekeepers under the Digital Markets Act (DMA). “We will now review their applications and appoint gatekeepers for certain platform services by Sep. 6“, Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton said Tuesday. After that, the gatekeepers will have six months to comply with the DMA regulations.

    The following companies have declared that they will meet the thresholds:

    • Alphabet (Google)
    • Amazon
    • Apple
    • Bytedance (Tiktok)
    • Meta (Facebook, Instagram)
    • Microsoft
    • Samsung

    Under the DMA, which came into force in November, companies with more than 45 million monthly active users and a market capitalization of €75 billion are considered gatekeepers if they offer a core platform service. Stricter rules will apply to these platforms in the future.

    “Consumers will have more services to choose from, more opportunities to switch providers, and they will benefit from better prices and higher quality of service“, Breton said. In addition, innovative companies would no longer be prevented from reaching new customers.

    Tiktok does not see itself as gatekeeper

    Surprisingly, Samsung and Tiktok owner Bytedance have also come forward. According to Tiktok, the company meets the quantitative criteria of the DMA, but not the general requirements of the directive. Those stipulate that the gatekeeper has an “unavoidable platform for conducting online business in the EU” and be a “fixed” link between consumers and businesses.

    Booking.com expects to fall into the gatekeeper category next year. In the reference period, Booking had suffered revenue losses due to the Corona pandemic.

    Commission to examine other companies

    “We want competition and want the best offer to win in the EU in the end, not the monopolist with the best networking options for customers”, Andreas Schwab (CDU) told Table.Media. The rapporteur for the DMA in the European Parliament said the Commission must now look at each company and say what the DMA means for the individual platforms.

    Example: Google Maps. If the service were considered part of Google Search, then Google’s commitments to the search engine would also apply to Google Maps. “And that would be desirable from my point of view”, Schwab said.

    The Commission also examines companies that have not made themselves known. If it finds that these companies have a de facto role as gatekeepers, even though they may fall short of the thresholds by a few euros, the commission can classify them as gatekeepers under Article 3(8), Schwab said. Even if they don’t meet the formal requirements. As an example, Schwab cited Vivendi or Alibaba. vis

    ECJ strengthens antitrust authorities and data protection

    Data protection violations may be part of audits under competition law. This was decided by the European Court of Justice in a ruling published yesterday. The background is a dispute between Meta Ireland and the German Federal Cartel Office. In addition, the Luxembourg judges also ruled on a second important issue: Tracking on third-party sites could now be on the verge of being outlawed.

    This was prompted by proceedings brought by the German Federal Cartel Office against Facebook on the grounds of suspected abuse of a dominant market position. The Facebook parent company had argued that the antitrust authorities were not competent in the area of personal data processing and in particular the company’s terms of use and accordingly could not base their decisions on them.

    Cooperation with supervisory authorities

    The ECJ took a different view and emphasized that the antitrust authorities are obliged to cooperate loyally with the competent data protection supervisory authorities. They may not deviate from their assessment without first consulting the data protection supervisory authority, the judges said. In this specific case, the competent supervisory authority was the controversial Irish data protection supervisory authority.

    The president of the German Federal Cartel Office, Andreas Mundt, sees the ruling as a breakthrough in the application of antitrust law to digital companies, saying, “The ruling will have far-reaching effects on the business models of the data economy.” At stake, he said, is the data-based market power of companies. Ramona Pop, executive director of the Federation of German Consumer Organizations, spoke of an “important interim success in curbing the data collection frenzy of the big platforms”. The consumer advocates were involved in the Luxembourg case as parties to the proceedings.

    CDU MEP Andreas Schwab was also pleased with the ruling: “We are moving in the right direction: cooperation and coordination between different authoritiesas already provided for by the DMA – is becoming increasingly important.” Due to the large number of competent authorities for individual sub-areas of digital regulation, a different ruling would have foreseeably caused greater problems for the EU competition and digital regulation system.

    Tracking on third-party sites massively restricted

    The effects of a second aspect of yesterday’s ECJ decision are still barely foreseeable: The judges determined that data derived from cookies is not “manifestly public” in the sense of the General Data Protection Regulation. This concerns, among other things, the integration of Like buttons and other elements on third-party sites. This is only to be assumed if a user “has previously, if necessary by means of individual settings made in full knowledge of the facts, explicitly expressed his decision to make the data concerning him publicly accessible to an unlimited number of persons”.

    The judges also stated that the merging of data originating from embedded elements in third-party websites or other offers is only justified within a very narrow legal framework: in the case of a legal obligation, when it is actually necessary and the processing is proportionate to the objective and, moreover, is also limited to what is absolutely necessary. This concerns, among other things, the merging of Whatsapp, which was taken over by Facebook, where Meta was happy to merge user data for advertising purposes.

    “Today’s landmark ruling by the European Court of Justice likely means the end of this commonly used surfing logging“, said Patrick Breyer, a member of the Pirate Party in the European Parliament. fst

    DIW study: Regulators must classify data more strongly as competitive advantage

    Through network and scale effects, platforms with data can gain an unassailable competitive advantage. Google probably benefits the most from additional data. This was the finding of a recent study by DIW Berlin. “In the past, competition authorities and regulators have not paid sufficient attention to the value of data“, says study author Hannes Ullrich, a research fellow at DIW’s Enterprise and Markets department. This is how Google, among others, has been able to secure advantages in the market.

    “Competition authorities should consider access to data as a key factor when they want to regulate new technologies such as artificial intelligence“, says Ullrich. “Otherwise, undesirable market power can accumulate, for example, even in large-scale voice models such as ChatGPT.”

    All companies benefit from having larger amounts of data at their disposal. But in the study, Ullrich and colleagues show that Google derives a greater advantage from additional data than others. “So far, there is very little empirical evidence in the area because Google, Meta and others don’t let us look at their cards”, Ullrich explains. But the DIW study shows that companies could use their data volumes to lead digital markets to tipping points that create insurmountable hurdles for competitors.

    DIW uses novel analysis dataset

    For users, this means they have fewer choices and poorer offers than in markets without barriers to competition. “We therefore welcome the fact that the EU Commission is taking more and more steps to require companies to share data“, says Ullrich. “Even if the implementation is not trivial in many cases.”

    Using a novel analytics dataset, the researchers say they were able to measure for the first time how the quantity of data relates to the quality of predictions about user characteristics. The study shows that all companies in the tracking market benefit from additional data – both in terms of the number of users tracked and the number of websites tracked. The quality of the predictions is improving, but the more data is added, the lower this quality increases.

    However, Google stands out from the crowd: Thanks to the enormous volumes and depth of data to which the company has access, it can systematically assess users more precisely. This competitive advantage could potentially mean that Google can no longer be caught up by other market players. vis

    DIW publishes the study in its weekly report at 9 a.m. here.

    Commission wants to standardize GDPR procedural rights

    EU Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders wants to improve enforcement of the General Data Protection Regulation across Europe by means of a small reform. At the heart of the project are rules for the parties involved in the procedure, cooperation between the data protection supervisory authorities and the introduction of fixed deadlines. Even the question of when a deadline begins and what constitutes a working day is addressed in a separate article. In addition, a procedure for the peaceful resolution of disputes is to be introduced, whereby the original complainant would have to object within one month and can also challenge the discontinuation of the procedure in court.

    With the proposal presented yesterday, the EU Commission wants to get to grips with some particularly persistent procedural tricks. For example, it will be more clearly regulated which rules apply to which procedural steps in the cooperation between supervisory authorities in Europe. The question of how to deal with complainants based in other countries is also part of the Reynders proposal, as are rules on access to documents and the handling of procedural documents.

    Jourová: ‘Work faster and more decisively’

    At the same time, the supplementary regulation is also intended to ensure uniform protection of trade secrets and confidential information in transnational proceedings. Here, Reynders wants a high level of confidentiality to be guaranteed – however, the proposal also contains some specifications as to how information may be classified as confidential or as a trade secret in the first place.

    The background to the proposal is incidents, particularly in connection with the Irish data protection supervisory authority DPC Ireland. This caused a lot of displeasure, especially in the ongoing proceedings against the Meta subsidiary Facebook.

    EU Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders now justified the new proposals saying, “It is clear that enforcement of the GDPR is working, but procedures in cross-border cases can still be improved.” Commission Vice-President Věra Jourová spoke of the time being “to ensure that we can work faster and more decisively”. The success of the GDPR depends on enforcement, she said.

    Fear of the great reform

    The EU Commission, member states and the EU Parliament have so far refrained from a major and comprehensive reform of the GDPR. The main reason for this is the feared lobbying battle.

    The response to the Reynders proposals yesterday already provided a taste of this: While industry associations such as Bitkom and the Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA) criticized the lack of a greater will to reform – as did CDU Member of the European Parliament Axel Voss – data and consumer protection groups were dissatisfied with the regulations presented for completely different reasons.

    The consumer protection umbrella organization BEUC, for example, criticized the fact that the proposal does not include any rules on the prompt provision of information to complainants on the status of proceedings. In addition, it must be ensured in the further procedure that the regulation does not prevent any procedural rights that go beyond the rules now proposed, said BEUC Deputy Director General Ursula Pachl. Parts of the proposals are based on suggestions from the European data protection supervisory authorities themselves. fst

    NATO: Stoltenberg extends by one year

    Jens Stoltenberg seems difficult to replace as Secretary-General of the military alliance. The ambassadors of NATO countries on Tuesday extended the Norwegian’s mandate by one year until Oct. 1, 2024. The decision comes just in time for next week’s summit in Vilnius. He felt “honored”, Stoltenberg wrote on the short message service Twitter. The 64-year-old Norwegian had made no secret of the fact that he had no desire for a further extension and would have preferred to follow his wife back to Oslo.

    Jens Stoltenberg must stay on because the allies could not agree on a successor. British Defense Minister Ben Wallace is the only one who had publicly expressed interest in the job. But a Briton as secretary general of the military alliance was out of the question for weighty EU states in NATO. They did not want to reward London with the prestigious job after Brexit, diplomats said. After thirteen men in the post, the time was also ripe for a woman.

    Poles and Balts want succession from Eastern Europe

    Estonia’s Prime Minister Kaja Kallas was in the conversation early on, known for clear statements on Russia and Vladimir Putin’s war of aggression against Ukraine. For some Western Europeans, however, the Estonian was too pointed. Denmark’s head of government, Mette Frederiksen, was promised good chances in the meantime. But in the end, Poland and the Baltic states objected. Now it was time for an Eastern European. Frederiksen would have been the third Scandinavian in a row, after Norway’s Stoltenberg and Denmark’s Anders Fogh Rasmussen.

    For Jens Stoltenberg, this is the fourth extension. First, he made a name for himself as the tamer of former US President Donald Trump. Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine, he has distinguished himself with his level-headed manner.

    For the alliance, the so far unsuccessful search for a successor is not necessarily a sign of strength. Stoltenberg will still be in office when NATO celebrates its 75th anniversary in April 2024. At the summit in Washington, however, it should be definitely over and the succession settled, in time for the US elections and a possible comeback by Donald Trump. For the Europeans, the renewed postponement of the personnel issue is not inconvenient. It opens up more scope for a larger personnel package after the European elections in June next year. sti

    EU and Mercosur: Lula rejects amendment to trade treaty

    Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has rejected the additional declaration demanded by Brussels on the planned free trade agreement between the European Union and the South American economic alliance Mercosur. “This is unacceptable”, he said Tuesday at the Mercosur leaders’ summit in Puerto Iguazú, Argentina. “We don’t want an agreement that condemns us to be forever just suppliers of raw materials“, Lula said.

    He had previously announced a counter-proposal. “I want to work so that in these six months we can conclude the agreement with the European Union and think about other things”, the head of state said, referring to Brazil’s Mercosur presidency for the next six months. “We want to discuss the agreement, but we don’t want to have anything imposed on us.”

    Criticism also from Argentina

    Argentina’s President Alberto Fernández also criticized the additional declaration on climate, environment and human rights proposed by the EU. “It puts too much focus on environmental protection without keeping economic and social sustainability in mind”, he said. He also accused EU countries of protectionism, especially in agriculture.

    The EU-Mercosur free trade agreement has been on hold since negotiations concluded in 2019. The treaty would create the world’s largest free trade area with 780 million people. The agreement still needs to be ratified by all member states. However, it is controversial in both South America and Europe. During her recent trip to South America, EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen campaigned for the free trade agreement to be implemented as quickly as possible.

    Lula also said he wanted Mercosur countries to move forward in talks with Canada, South Korea and Singapore. In addition, Mercosur could also explore “new negotiating fronts” with China, Indonesia, Vietnam and countries in Central America and the Caribbean. dpa/rtr

    Heads

    Michael Sterner – a mastermind of the energy transition

    Michael Sterner is Professor of Energy Systems and Energy Storage at the OTH Regensburg.

    In a good mood, energy expert Michael Sterner tells us that he spent the weekend tinkering with the photovoltaic system on the roof of his house. It quickly becomes clear that the famous gap between theory and practice does not exist for this man. “I am 83 percent self-sufficient in electricity, heat and mobility with my own solar power”, says Sterner.

    The 45-year-old professor of energy systems and energy storage, who teaches and conducts research at the Ostbayerische Technische Hochschule (OTH) in Regensburg, has a practical background. He trained in the electrical trade and has already installed solar cells on school roofs in Kenya.

    Sterner is not afraid to seek the widest possible publicity for his topic: In the German ZDF satire program “Heute Show” he promoted wind power, and when the Regensburg City Council presented an energy master plan that does without a solar obligation, Sterner, in association with Fridays for Future, sometimes called for a protest in front of the city hall. What motivates him? “I know that I am doing something that is good for my family and all the people who live on earth”, says the energy expert.

    ‘Gas storage facilities are the essential hedge against blackouts’

    His parents had already influenced him ecologically: “As farmers, we were already working biotopes with a scythe in the 1980s. Other people were still laughing at us then.” Sterner has been working on the energy transition since the end of the 1990s.

    After studying mechatronics in Regensburg, earning a master’s degree in renewable energies in Oldenburg, a doctorate in renewable energy systems and research stays in Spain, Chile and India, he joined the German Advisory Council on Global Change (WBGU). In the meantime, the professor from Regensburg has become one of the most distinguished thought leaders of the energy transition. For example, he is considered one of the originators of Power to Gas – a technology that uses the decomposition of water into oxygen and hydrogen to produce climate-friendly gases and fuels from renewable energies. “With this technology, the blackout debate has disappeared. Gas storage is the essential safeguard against blackouts”, Sterner says.

    Out of the climate and energy crisis

    For the energy expert, the crux of the energy transition lies in its social implementation. So Sterner is fighting against trenches – he wants to offer solutions, to think pragmatically. With his book “How We Can Save the Climate” he has developed a master plan for the energy transition in 2022. “So that everyone understands how we can find our way out of the climate and energy crisis and make our lives and economies climate-neutral.” After all, the necessary technologies have long been available, he says, you just have to want the change.

    Sterner wrote his book for the boomer generation. For the people who can now implement the energy turnaround, because they can decide to buy climate-friendly cars and heating systems and to renovate buildings. In the big energy debate, he wants to bring as many people along as possible: “If people only think electric, we’ll scare many away.” Climate neutrality, Sterner says, is a fine line. And so he urges action: “We have to pragmatically agree on the middle path. That will only work if we all want it together.” Gabriele Voßkühler

    • Gasspeicher

    Europe.Table Editorial Office

    EUROPE.TABLE EDITORS

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen