Table.Briefing: China (English)

Double standards in territorial disputes + China sets its sights on the commercial vehicle market

Dear reader,

When it comes to Taiwan, Beijing is absolutely uncompromising. Any doubts about Chinese claims to the neighboring country are hyped up as a national affair. Oddly enough, however, this does not happen when it comes to territories that Russia occupied in the middle of the 19th century. At the time, these belonged to the Qing dynasty and even led to military disputes between Moscow and Beijing in the 1960s.

Fabian Peltsch takes us on a journey through Chinese history, which explains why China applies double standards. The realization: The fact that China is no longer arguing about the return of Russian territories but is beating the war drum ever louder when it comes to Taiwan points above all to the People’s Republic’s distorted self-image.

Meanwhile, Christian Domke-Seidel took a closer look at Chinese manufacturers’ presentations at the commercial vehicle version of the IAA in Hanover for us. His conclusion: Chinese manufacturers have also set their sights on this market.

Your
Marcel Grzanna
Image of Marcel  Grzanna

Feature

Territorial dispute: Why Beijing simply leaves its former territory to the Russians

Vladivostok in September: In the People’s Republic, people prefer to call the Russian city by its old Chinese name Haishenwai: Sea Cucumber Bay.

As far as Xi Jinping is concerned, Taiwan should be fully integrated into mainland China by the 100th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic in 2049 at the latest. This would finally heal the wound that the century of humiliation from 1839 to 1949 left in the collective consciousness of the Chinese people.

But why doesn’t China also demand the return of vast parts of Manchuria on the grounds of territorial integrity? These territories were once annexed by Russia in similarly unequal treaties during this humiliating period. Taiwan’s President William Lai recently raised this question. And added provocatively: “Russia is now at its weakest, right?”

Lai deliberately put his finger in the Chinese wound with his statement. After the Second Opium War (1856-1860), the Tsarist Empire – like the Western powers – had exploited the weak position of the ruling Qing dynasty and annexed territories in north-east China three times the size of Germany. It became clear in 1969 that China wanted these territories back, which led to military confrontations because the divided brother states could not agree on how the over 4,000-kilometer-long common border should be drawn.

Partnership of convenience with Russia and North Korea

It was not until July 2001 that the two countries signed a friendship treaty in which they renounced any territorial claims. Even then, China’s “old friend” Putin was sitting at the table, his counterpart was the head of state and party leader Jiang Zemin. However, official Chinese maps still use the old Chinese names for the cities that fell to Russia. “Rule the East,” as Vladivostok is called in English, is probably not so easy for the Chinese to say, even if the Chinese alternative does not necessarily radiate splendor and grandeur. In China, the city is called Haishenwai – Sea Cucumber Bay.

In China, there is a particular historical sensitivity when it comes to territorial integrity, even though China is one of the few countries that managed to regain the most important territories it once lost in the 20th century.” These are the words of sinologist and historian Klaus Muehlhahn from Zeppelin University in Friedrichshafen. He has recently dealt extensively with the Qing period and its impact on the Chinese perception of history for his book “History of Modern China.”

“We are in a situation where North Korea, Russia and China are moving closer together. Beijing will not drive a wedge between them by suddenly asserting any territorial claims.” However, the historian does not rule out the possibility that this could still happen one day or that China could de facto reclaim the territories through its economic influence.

The contradictory impression of the Qing dynasty

The fact that China is no longer discussing the return of Russian territories, but is beating the war drum ever louder when it comes to Taiwan, points above all to the People’s Republic’s distorted self-image.

The idea of a Chinese nation-state developed relatively late and under outside pressure. For a long time, the people of China saw themselves primarily as members of the respective ruling dynasty and not as citizens of a homogeneous cultural nation with thousands of years of history.

The Qing dynasty, to whose greatness today’s China relates, was not only a time of weakness, but also one in which the empire acted as an aggressor to the outside world and annexed large territories. “In the early phase of the dynasty, well before the often cited period of weakness, the Qing had one of the most powerful militaries in the world,” says Muehlhahn. More recent historiography accordingly treats the annexation of territories such as Xinjiang and Tibet as conquest campaigns that were accompanied by the subjugation and oppression of the respective peoples. “In this respect, the Qing were not much better than the foreign imperialists. Their campaigns definitely had a colonialist and expansive character of subjugation.”

For example, the Qing not only oppressed the Dzungar people on the periphery, but almost completely wiped them out. One could also argue that a colonial empire that was never decolonized lives on in today’s nation-state.

The myth of sinicization

“So today’s China identifies with an imperial past that was actually actively shaped by a non-Chinese people, but by the Manchus, who founded the Qing dynasty. That makes things even more complicated,” says Mühlhahn. The Manchus were not so impressed by the radiance of Chinese-Confucian culture that they voluntarily and completely Sinicized themselves, says Muehlhahn.

Incidentally, the same also applies to the other conquered peoples. “This narrative is long outdated,” says Mühlhahn. “Even among Chinese historians, by the way, if you talk to them outside the propaganda.” According to Muehlhahn, the Manchu elite insisted on their peculiarities until the very end, and the Han were clearly subordinate to them. For example, marriages between Han and Manchu were only permitted in 1902, when the empire was already in sharp decline.

China competence means recognizing contradictions

Mühlhahn’s verdict is clear: “For Beijing, history is a decisive form of legitimizing the system. And that is why this disastrous 19th century plays just as overriding a role as the imperial splendor of this regime. As the historical narrative says: The Communist Party has led China out of this disaster, only it can revive the glory of the imperial past and ensure China’s great rebirth in the present – and because the Party is the only force that can achieve this, it must continue to rule.”

However, China’s propaganda continues to propagate the country as the liberator of the world from imperialism. All in all, an unrivaled historical walk on eggshells. Anyone who disagrees with this is deemed guilty of “historical nihilism,” which can result in severe punishment in China.

This is another reason why it is an essential part of China expertise not to simply accept such narratives without reflection, says Muehlhahn. “Historical facts easily fall by the wayside when history is instrumentalized. That is why I believe it is important to counter the Chinese narrative with a more differentiated view of history.”

  • Russland
  • Taiwan
  • Tibet

IAA Transportation: How China shakes up Europe’s commercial vehicles market

BYD’s EYT2.0: A specialized vehicle for transporting containers or trailers in ports, airports and large logistics centers.

Chinese manufacturers are well represented at the IAA Transportation in Hanover. They impressively prove that electromobility also works with heavy loads, on construction sites and in public transport. And it has to, because the transport revolution also includes this sector.

Strict emissions standards force companies to adapt their logistics accordingly. Brands from the People’s Republic such as BYD, Windrose, Anhui Jianghuai Automobile (JAC) and Xiamen King Long also want to benefit from this. According to a study by the Boston Consulting Group (BCG), Chinese manufacturers could gain up to eleven percent of the European market with their trucks and buses.

JAC relies on individual partnerships

Manufacturers have different strategies for securing such a large slice of the pie. JAC, for example, focuses on regional partnerships. The company is well-established in China and can draw on a strong domestic market. With around 600,000 units produced in 2023, the company is among the top five in the Chinese commercial vehicle sector. In Europe, the manufacturer operates a design center in Turin.

If a company is interested in renewing or electrifying its fleet, JAC spends between three and twelve months with the customer to understand the applications down to the last detail and offer individual solutions. In the heavy-duty sector, the superstructures and detailed solutions are often crucial. The design center in Turin then implements the solutions.

“It’s not a Chinese truck. It’s a partnership between the European customer and us,” explains Oscar Yu, Deputy General Manager of JAC International, at the IAA Transportation. JAC has already won over renowned companies such as Carrefour, Heineken, Danone and Dachser in Spain and France.

Windrose: market share first, then returns

Chinese truck manufacturer Windrose, on the other hand, is focusing on a global solution that can be launched on the market at a low price thanks to this scaling. The truck comes with a battery from China Aviation Lithium Battery (CALB) and provides a large capacity of 729 kilowatt-hours, allowing a range of 670 kilometers. The model costs around 250,000 dollars in the United States. “Our investments pay off after selling 10,000 trucks,” Windrose founder Han Wen said in an interview with the NZZ.

According to Han, Daimler already reaches this threshold at 500 units. However, Daimler does not comment on this. As with many Chinese car manufacturers, the aim is first to generate market share before considering returns. In June 2024, the company already had 5,000 pre-orders in the USA alone.

BYD: electric solutions for all areas

BYD is also represented at the IAA Transportation. The brand is currently booming. In the first half of 2024, the NEV specialist was the third-largest car manufacturer in the world. In the commercial sector, BYD wants to stand out by offering an electric solution for every use. This is also evident from the presentation at the trade fair – the EYT2.0, a special vehicle that transports containers or other trailers in ports, airports or large logistics centers.

King Long’s Merry Combo has won the Red Dot Design Award.

King Long attracted much attention at the IAA Transportation with its Merry Combo. The luxurious coach won the Red Dot Design Award. However, the Xiamen-based company is also taking a step forward in terms of sales in Europe. After all, it is bringing its partner Digital Sustainable Transport (DST) along. It provides operational services for customers who opt for King Long’s electric commercial vehicles. This means, among other things, ensuring servicing, clarifying the charging options, providing leasing offers, and taking care of recycling or collection at the end of the life cycle. In short: DST takes care of everything that gives many fleet managers a headache when dealing with electric commercial vehicles.

The good timing of Chinese manufacturers

The fact that Chinese manufacturers are now going on the offensive with their electric commercial vehicles in Europe is no coincidence, as Pinglu Kang, Executive Vice President of DST, emphasized at the IAA Transportation. “Europe’s electrification plans fit perfectly with our product portfolio.” He referred to the European Union’s (EU) roadmap for reducing CO2 emissions from heavy-duty vehicles, which has been set out since the beginning of 2024. They must fall by 45 percent between 2030 and 2034 compared to 2019, and by 65 percent (2035 to 2039) and 90 percent (from 2040) in the following years. Even stricter requirements apply to public transport. New city buses will have to have 90 percent lower emissions from 2030 and be completely (locally) emission-free from 2035.

The development of a corresponding charging infrastructure has long been underway. After all, an EU regulation already sets specific minimum targets. By 2030, Germany alone must have 314 truck charging stations. Every 60 to 100 kilometers along the country’s main motorways. The IAA Transportation shows that many Chinese models will also charge their batteries here.

  • Batterien
  • Lithium
  • Verkehrswende

News

Steel industry: Chinese overcapacity threatens European companies

The Managing Director of the German Steel Association, Martin Theuringer, has called on the EU Commission to “protect the European market from unfair competition.” In an interview with Table.Briefings, Theuringer warned that the recent slump in demand in China has led to an enormous increase in Chinese imports, both on the European market and on third markets. “We are noticing the significant increase in import pressure as a result of the enormous global overcapacity, which is now pushing into the EU market and also displacing EU suppliers on third markets,” said Theuringer.

According to Theuringer, Chinese imports will exceed 100 million tons this year – the highest level since 2016. “The economic situation is dire in both Germany and Europe. This is particularly true for the German steel industry. In some cases, it is even a matter of survival,” warns Theuringer. He urges the EU Commission to utilize its existing options – “the anti-dumping law, but also the option of taking action against Chinese import pressure with broad-based anti-subsidy proceedings.”

The problem with the current practice is that the anti-dumping proceedings have a very selective effect. “They are directed against a specific product and against very specific suppliers. This is often not effective because there are then numerous circumvention options. That is why we are calling for a truly broad-based procedure, because we know that the entire Chinese steel industry is heavily subsidized.” grz

  • Europäische Kommission

KAS head: ‘Europe must not leave Central Asia to Russia and China’

Speaking on the occasion of German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s visit, André Algermissen from the Konrad-Adenauer- Foundation (KAS) has warned against not doing enough to counter the influence of China and Russia in Central Asia. “If these countries turn to Europe in hope, they need to be given an appropriate and reliable response to prevent them from being disappointed. The region mustn’t be left to Russia and China alone,” Algermissen emphasized in an interview with Table.Briefings.

The fact that Central Asia is increasingly turning away from Europe is not generally the case for all countries in the region, explained the head of the KAS regional program for Central Asia. “This is true for Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. But Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan have reduced their dependencies. There are opportunities for closer cooperation with Europe, particularly in economic and security policy.” He urged Brussels to step up its activities in Central Asia and not leave the region to Beijing and Moscow. “An update of the EU’s Central Asia strategy is urgently necessary.”

On the second day of Scholz’s trip to Central Asia, the use of raw materials, the oil supply in Germany and the war in Ukraine took center stage. Scholz said on Monday after a meeting with Kazakhstan’s President Kassym-Shomart Tokayev in Astana that he had held “very good talks.” He said that “many very practical agreements” were signed, which was “a good sign for the improvement of economic and political relations.”

Kazakhstan as an important oil supplier

Scholz said that the visit focused on expanding renewable energies and the possibilities of entering the hydrogen economy. He discussed logistics issues and how to “improve infrastructure to ensure that economic relations with this region can develop further and better.” Specific investments by German companies in the region were also discussed.

The Eastern Committee of the German Economy also stressed the region’s importance following Scholz’s trip to Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan. “The countries in Central Asia play a decisive role in the energy transition,” explained Christian Bruch, Deputy Chairman of the Committee. “The region not only has valuable raw materials (…), but also offers ideal conditions for the production of renewable energy and trains young, motivated specialists that we urgently need in Germany.”

According to the Eastern Committee, Kazakhstan, in particular, is already an important supplier of crude oil and could play a key role in supplying European industry with green hydrogen in the future. Committee members and company representatives are accompanying Scholz on the trip. ari

  • Rohstoffe
  • Ukraine-Krieg

Countervailing duties: Italy sides with the EU Commission

Italy supports the European Commission’s proposed tariffs on Chinese EV exports. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said this before he met with the Chinese trade minister in Rome on Monday. “We support the duties that the EU Commission proposes, to protect the competitiveness of our companies,” Tajani said in an interview with the daily newspaper Corriere della Sera.

The Minister received his Chinese counterpart Wang Wentao, who wants to speak in Europe about the European Union’s anti-subsidy proceedings against electric vehicles from China. Other topics included the protection of intellectual property, trade in the agricultural and food sectors and investments.

“We want to work on a trade plan based on equality, we demand equal access for our products in their markets. Our companies must compete on equal terms,” said Tajani.

Italy had initially favored tariffs in a non-binding vote by EU members in July. However, Industry Minister Adolfo Urso told Reuters last week that he expected a negotiated solution. Spain’s Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez recently reconsidered his position on the tariffs during a visit to Beijing and even pledged support to the Chinese.

Italy remains a major car manufacturer with brands such as Fiat. The European Commission is about to propose definitive tariffs of up to 35.3 percent on electric cars produced in China, on top of the standard 10 percent import tariffs on cars in the EU. rtr

  • Giorgia Meloni

Rare earths: How China further extends its lead

China has discovered new rare earth deposits. As the South China Morning Post reports, rare earth specialists announced at a symposium of the China Rare Earth Group last week that 4.96 million tons of rare earths had been found in the Liangshan Yi Autonomous Prefecture (Sichuan Province).

According to the US Geological Survey, China is already the world’s largest producer of rare earths, with 44 million tons of deposits, including 17 metal oxides. Rare earths are crucial for the technological development of electric vehicles, wind turbines, robots and modern military weapons.

In light of the rivalry between China and the USA in the technology sector, China’s dominant position in rare earths is causing increasing concern. Beijing recently imposed export restrictions on rare earths. Previously, the Ministry of State Security had classified the elements as strategic mineral resources “directly related to national security.” However, official customs data shows that China’s exports of rare earths rose by 6.4 percent year-on-year to 38,755 tons in the first eight months of the year. rad

  • Geopolitik

Hong Kong: Activist faces seven years in prison for slogan on T-shirt

A Hong Kong court has handed down its first verdict under the new National Security Law. On Monday, a 27-year-old man pleaded guilty to “seditious intent.” His crime: He had worn a T-shirt with a protest slogan. Due to the tightening of the Security Act in March 2024, the man now faces seven years in prison instead of just two.

Chu Kai-pong was arrested at a subway station on June 12 wearing a T-shirt with the slogan “Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times,” and a yellow mask printed with “FDNOL” – the shorthand of another pro-democracy slogan, “five demands, not one less.” Both slogans were chanted during the massive, sometimes violent democracy protests in 2019. June 12 is considered the start of the month-long unrest.

Chu told the police he wore the T-shirt to remind people of the protests. Chief Magistrate Victor So, personally appointed by Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee to hear national security cases, adjourned the case until Thursday for the verdict.

Following months of protests in the financial capital, Beijing passed a national security law in 2020 that punishes secession, subversion, terrorism or collaboration with foreign forces with up to life imprisonment. In March 2024, Hong Kong passed a second new security law – a home-grown ordinance known as “Article 23.” It is more drastic and is intended to close loopholes in the previous law. rtr/grz

  • Hongkong
  • John Lee
  • John Lee
  • Justice
  • National Security Act

Judiciary: US pastor released after nearly 20 years in prison

China released US pastor David Lin after he had been imprisoned since 2006. This was announced by the State Department on Sunday. For years, US politicians had urged Beijing to release Lin. The pastor was convicted of alleged contract fraud and sentenced to life in prison. Lin has already returned to the United States.

“We welcome David Lin’s release from prison in the People’s Republic of China,” a State Department spokesperson said, adding that Lin “has returned to the United States and now gets to see his family for the first time in nearly 20 years.” Last November, the United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations urged President Joe Biden to appeal to Chinese leader Xi Jinping for the release of Lin and other detainees Kai Li and Mark Swidan. Washington claims that all three have been unjustly imprisoned. rtr/grz

  • China

Heads

He Jiankui: China’s most controversial researcher wants to go to the US

Archive image: He Jinakui at a symposium in Hong Kong in 2018.

Chinese scientist He Jiankui, who caused global outrage in 2018 when he created the first genetically modified babies, is openly considering moving to the United States to work on a gene treatment for Alzheimer’s disease.

He made global headlines six years ago when he manipulated the genetic material of two embryos to make them resistant to HIV. The intervention sparked ethical debates about the limits of genetic research. Although He claimed that the procedure was successful, there are considerable doubts about the effectiveness and safety of his experiments. Many scientists have criticized that the long-term effects of the interventions are unknown.

An investor from Silicon Valley has offered him money to found a company that develops gene therapies against Alzheimer’s disease, He said in an online roundtable organized by the science magazine MIT Technology Review.

He went to prison for his experiments

He spent three years in prison for illegal medical practices following the 2018 scandal. Since his release in 2022, he has struggled to regain a foothold in science. Plans to work in Hong Kong fell through when his visa was revoked for allegedly providing false information. He currently runs a laboratory in Wuhan and has also opened a new facility in Sanya on Hainan, reportedly funded by American donors and Chinese companies.

The US-educated scientist studied at Rice University and conducted research at Stanford University. He has since decided to focus on Alzheimer’s research, as his mother is suffering from the disease.

Refined technology to bring progress

He plans to use a new gene editing technique called base editing to introduce a genetic mutation into human embryos to protect against dementia. He emphasizes that he wants to continue his research, but appears to be reformed: He said his work would initially be limited to mice, monkeys and non-viable embryos. “The basic research can be completed in two years.”

He said that society decides when the technology will be used in human trials, adding that in 50 years, embryo editing will be as standard as IVF is today and all babies will be born without known diseases. “I believe society will realize that genetic editing improves human health.”

Pencil instead of gene scissors

He used the CRISPR-Cas9 technique on the two babies he manipulated. This method allows targeted cuts to be made in the DNA in order to change genes. He removed the CCR5 gene from the babies to protect them against HIV. The procedure is known for its precision, but carries the risk of off-target effects, in other words unintended changes to the genetic material.

By contrast, base editing is an advanced technique that works without double-strand breaks in the DNA. Double-strand breaks are cracks in both DNA strands that can occur with CRISPR-Cas9, which can cause unintended changes.

Base editing involves the targeted modification of individual DNA building blocks, making it safer and more precise. While CRISPR-Cas9 works like a pair of scissors that cut the DNA, base editing works like a pencil that changes a single letter in the genetic code. This technique promises more precise interventions with fewer risks.

Most countries have strict rules

In the US, federal laws prohibit government funding of experiments on genetically modified embryos, and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not approved genetic modifications in embryos for use on humans. After the He scandal, legislation in China was tightened to prevent unauthorized genetic experiments, leading to stricter controls and harsher penalties.

In the EU, national laws, as well as joint directives, regulate the manipulation of embryos. Most EU countries prohibit germline manipulation to prevent risks. Public and scientific debate on the ethical implications of gene editing remains intense in all three regions. Joern Petring

  • Wissenschaft

Executive Moves

Tim Rühlig has been the new Senior Analyst for Global China at the EU Institute for Security Studies since this week. Previously, he was a Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Geopolitics, Geo-Economics and Technology at the German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP).

Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

Dessert

Motocross-WM-Lauf in Shanghai

The world of sports has long been unable to get past China. Its market is too tempting for sports associations to avoid the People’s Republic as a venue for world championships or World Cup series. Consequently, China now hosts ski jumping and luge competitions, Formula 1 and motocross races. Over the weekend, the off-road machines of the world’s best cross-country riders whizzed past the grandstands in Shanghai at the Oriental Beauty Valley MXGP of China. The event marked the return of the series after a four-year break. Due to the Covid pandemic, the event in China was removed from the calendar in 2020. Chinese riders were also at the start. Although they finished in the last three places, they at least left their eliminated competitors behind them.

China.Table editorial team

CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    When it comes to Taiwan, Beijing is absolutely uncompromising. Any doubts about Chinese claims to the neighboring country are hyped up as a national affair. Oddly enough, however, this does not happen when it comes to territories that Russia occupied in the middle of the 19th century. At the time, these belonged to the Qing dynasty and even led to military disputes between Moscow and Beijing in the 1960s.

    Fabian Peltsch takes us on a journey through Chinese history, which explains why China applies double standards. The realization: The fact that China is no longer arguing about the return of Russian territories but is beating the war drum ever louder when it comes to Taiwan points above all to the People’s Republic’s distorted self-image.

    Meanwhile, Christian Domke-Seidel took a closer look at Chinese manufacturers’ presentations at the commercial vehicle version of the IAA in Hanover for us. His conclusion: Chinese manufacturers have also set their sights on this market.

    Your
    Marcel Grzanna
    Image of Marcel  Grzanna

    Feature

    Territorial dispute: Why Beijing simply leaves its former territory to the Russians

    Vladivostok in September: In the People’s Republic, people prefer to call the Russian city by its old Chinese name Haishenwai: Sea Cucumber Bay.

    As far as Xi Jinping is concerned, Taiwan should be fully integrated into mainland China by the 100th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic in 2049 at the latest. This would finally heal the wound that the century of humiliation from 1839 to 1949 left in the collective consciousness of the Chinese people.

    But why doesn’t China also demand the return of vast parts of Manchuria on the grounds of territorial integrity? These territories were once annexed by Russia in similarly unequal treaties during this humiliating period. Taiwan’s President William Lai recently raised this question. And added provocatively: “Russia is now at its weakest, right?”

    Lai deliberately put his finger in the Chinese wound with his statement. After the Second Opium War (1856-1860), the Tsarist Empire – like the Western powers – had exploited the weak position of the ruling Qing dynasty and annexed territories in north-east China three times the size of Germany. It became clear in 1969 that China wanted these territories back, which led to military confrontations because the divided brother states could not agree on how the over 4,000-kilometer-long common border should be drawn.

    Partnership of convenience with Russia and North Korea

    It was not until July 2001 that the two countries signed a friendship treaty in which they renounced any territorial claims. Even then, China’s “old friend” Putin was sitting at the table, his counterpart was the head of state and party leader Jiang Zemin. However, official Chinese maps still use the old Chinese names for the cities that fell to Russia. “Rule the East,” as Vladivostok is called in English, is probably not so easy for the Chinese to say, even if the Chinese alternative does not necessarily radiate splendor and grandeur. In China, the city is called Haishenwai – Sea Cucumber Bay.

    In China, there is a particular historical sensitivity when it comes to territorial integrity, even though China is one of the few countries that managed to regain the most important territories it once lost in the 20th century.” These are the words of sinologist and historian Klaus Muehlhahn from Zeppelin University in Friedrichshafen. He has recently dealt extensively with the Qing period and its impact on the Chinese perception of history for his book “History of Modern China.”

    “We are in a situation where North Korea, Russia and China are moving closer together. Beijing will not drive a wedge between them by suddenly asserting any territorial claims.” However, the historian does not rule out the possibility that this could still happen one day or that China could de facto reclaim the territories through its economic influence.

    The contradictory impression of the Qing dynasty

    The fact that China is no longer discussing the return of Russian territories, but is beating the war drum ever louder when it comes to Taiwan, points above all to the People’s Republic’s distorted self-image.

    The idea of a Chinese nation-state developed relatively late and under outside pressure. For a long time, the people of China saw themselves primarily as members of the respective ruling dynasty and not as citizens of a homogeneous cultural nation with thousands of years of history.

    The Qing dynasty, to whose greatness today’s China relates, was not only a time of weakness, but also one in which the empire acted as an aggressor to the outside world and annexed large territories. “In the early phase of the dynasty, well before the often cited period of weakness, the Qing had one of the most powerful militaries in the world,” says Muehlhahn. More recent historiography accordingly treats the annexation of territories such as Xinjiang and Tibet as conquest campaigns that were accompanied by the subjugation and oppression of the respective peoples. “In this respect, the Qing were not much better than the foreign imperialists. Their campaigns definitely had a colonialist and expansive character of subjugation.”

    For example, the Qing not only oppressed the Dzungar people on the periphery, but almost completely wiped them out. One could also argue that a colonial empire that was never decolonized lives on in today’s nation-state.

    The myth of sinicization

    “So today’s China identifies with an imperial past that was actually actively shaped by a non-Chinese people, but by the Manchus, who founded the Qing dynasty. That makes things even more complicated,” says Mühlhahn. The Manchus were not so impressed by the radiance of Chinese-Confucian culture that they voluntarily and completely Sinicized themselves, says Muehlhahn.

    Incidentally, the same also applies to the other conquered peoples. “This narrative is long outdated,” says Mühlhahn. “Even among Chinese historians, by the way, if you talk to them outside the propaganda.” According to Muehlhahn, the Manchu elite insisted on their peculiarities until the very end, and the Han were clearly subordinate to them. For example, marriages between Han and Manchu were only permitted in 1902, when the empire was already in sharp decline.

    China competence means recognizing contradictions

    Mühlhahn’s verdict is clear: “For Beijing, history is a decisive form of legitimizing the system. And that is why this disastrous 19th century plays just as overriding a role as the imperial splendor of this regime. As the historical narrative says: The Communist Party has led China out of this disaster, only it can revive the glory of the imperial past and ensure China’s great rebirth in the present – and because the Party is the only force that can achieve this, it must continue to rule.”

    However, China’s propaganda continues to propagate the country as the liberator of the world from imperialism. All in all, an unrivaled historical walk on eggshells. Anyone who disagrees with this is deemed guilty of “historical nihilism,” which can result in severe punishment in China.

    This is another reason why it is an essential part of China expertise not to simply accept such narratives without reflection, says Muehlhahn. “Historical facts easily fall by the wayside when history is instrumentalized. That is why I believe it is important to counter the Chinese narrative with a more differentiated view of history.”

    • Russland
    • Taiwan
    • Tibet

    IAA Transportation: How China shakes up Europe’s commercial vehicles market

    BYD’s EYT2.0: A specialized vehicle for transporting containers or trailers in ports, airports and large logistics centers.

    Chinese manufacturers are well represented at the IAA Transportation in Hanover. They impressively prove that electromobility also works with heavy loads, on construction sites and in public transport. And it has to, because the transport revolution also includes this sector.

    Strict emissions standards force companies to adapt their logistics accordingly. Brands from the People’s Republic such as BYD, Windrose, Anhui Jianghuai Automobile (JAC) and Xiamen King Long also want to benefit from this. According to a study by the Boston Consulting Group (BCG), Chinese manufacturers could gain up to eleven percent of the European market with their trucks and buses.

    JAC relies on individual partnerships

    Manufacturers have different strategies for securing such a large slice of the pie. JAC, for example, focuses on regional partnerships. The company is well-established in China and can draw on a strong domestic market. With around 600,000 units produced in 2023, the company is among the top five in the Chinese commercial vehicle sector. In Europe, the manufacturer operates a design center in Turin.

    If a company is interested in renewing or electrifying its fleet, JAC spends between three and twelve months with the customer to understand the applications down to the last detail and offer individual solutions. In the heavy-duty sector, the superstructures and detailed solutions are often crucial. The design center in Turin then implements the solutions.

    “It’s not a Chinese truck. It’s a partnership between the European customer and us,” explains Oscar Yu, Deputy General Manager of JAC International, at the IAA Transportation. JAC has already won over renowned companies such as Carrefour, Heineken, Danone and Dachser in Spain and France.

    Windrose: market share first, then returns

    Chinese truck manufacturer Windrose, on the other hand, is focusing on a global solution that can be launched on the market at a low price thanks to this scaling. The truck comes with a battery from China Aviation Lithium Battery (CALB) and provides a large capacity of 729 kilowatt-hours, allowing a range of 670 kilometers. The model costs around 250,000 dollars in the United States. “Our investments pay off after selling 10,000 trucks,” Windrose founder Han Wen said in an interview with the NZZ.

    According to Han, Daimler already reaches this threshold at 500 units. However, Daimler does not comment on this. As with many Chinese car manufacturers, the aim is first to generate market share before considering returns. In June 2024, the company already had 5,000 pre-orders in the USA alone.

    BYD: electric solutions for all areas

    BYD is also represented at the IAA Transportation. The brand is currently booming. In the first half of 2024, the NEV specialist was the third-largest car manufacturer in the world. In the commercial sector, BYD wants to stand out by offering an electric solution for every use. This is also evident from the presentation at the trade fair – the EYT2.0, a special vehicle that transports containers or other trailers in ports, airports or large logistics centers.

    King Long’s Merry Combo has won the Red Dot Design Award.

    King Long attracted much attention at the IAA Transportation with its Merry Combo. The luxurious coach won the Red Dot Design Award. However, the Xiamen-based company is also taking a step forward in terms of sales in Europe. After all, it is bringing its partner Digital Sustainable Transport (DST) along. It provides operational services for customers who opt for King Long’s electric commercial vehicles. This means, among other things, ensuring servicing, clarifying the charging options, providing leasing offers, and taking care of recycling or collection at the end of the life cycle. In short: DST takes care of everything that gives many fleet managers a headache when dealing with electric commercial vehicles.

    The good timing of Chinese manufacturers

    The fact that Chinese manufacturers are now going on the offensive with their electric commercial vehicles in Europe is no coincidence, as Pinglu Kang, Executive Vice President of DST, emphasized at the IAA Transportation. “Europe’s electrification plans fit perfectly with our product portfolio.” He referred to the European Union’s (EU) roadmap for reducing CO2 emissions from heavy-duty vehicles, which has been set out since the beginning of 2024. They must fall by 45 percent between 2030 and 2034 compared to 2019, and by 65 percent (2035 to 2039) and 90 percent (from 2040) in the following years. Even stricter requirements apply to public transport. New city buses will have to have 90 percent lower emissions from 2030 and be completely (locally) emission-free from 2035.

    The development of a corresponding charging infrastructure has long been underway. After all, an EU regulation already sets specific minimum targets. By 2030, Germany alone must have 314 truck charging stations. Every 60 to 100 kilometers along the country’s main motorways. The IAA Transportation shows that many Chinese models will also charge their batteries here.

    • Batterien
    • Lithium
    • Verkehrswende

    News

    Steel industry: Chinese overcapacity threatens European companies

    The Managing Director of the German Steel Association, Martin Theuringer, has called on the EU Commission to “protect the European market from unfair competition.” In an interview with Table.Briefings, Theuringer warned that the recent slump in demand in China has led to an enormous increase in Chinese imports, both on the European market and on third markets. “We are noticing the significant increase in import pressure as a result of the enormous global overcapacity, which is now pushing into the EU market and also displacing EU suppliers on third markets,” said Theuringer.

    According to Theuringer, Chinese imports will exceed 100 million tons this year – the highest level since 2016. “The economic situation is dire in both Germany and Europe. This is particularly true for the German steel industry. In some cases, it is even a matter of survival,” warns Theuringer. He urges the EU Commission to utilize its existing options – “the anti-dumping law, but also the option of taking action against Chinese import pressure with broad-based anti-subsidy proceedings.”

    The problem with the current practice is that the anti-dumping proceedings have a very selective effect. “They are directed against a specific product and against very specific suppliers. This is often not effective because there are then numerous circumvention options. That is why we are calling for a truly broad-based procedure, because we know that the entire Chinese steel industry is heavily subsidized.” grz

    • Europäische Kommission

    KAS head: ‘Europe must not leave Central Asia to Russia and China’

    Speaking on the occasion of German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s visit, André Algermissen from the Konrad-Adenauer- Foundation (KAS) has warned against not doing enough to counter the influence of China and Russia in Central Asia. “If these countries turn to Europe in hope, they need to be given an appropriate and reliable response to prevent them from being disappointed. The region mustn’t be left to Russia and China alone,” Algermissen emphasized in an interview with Table.Briefings.

    The fact that Central Asia is increasingly turning away from Europe is not generally the case for all countries in the region, explained the head of the KAS regional program for Central Asia. “This is true for Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. But Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan have reduced their dependencies. There are opportunities for closer cooperation with Europe, particularly in economic and security policy.” He urged Brussels to step up its activities in Central Asia and not leave the region to Beijing and Moscow. “An update of the EU’s Central Asia strategy is urgently necessary.”

    On the second day of Scholz’s trip to Central Asia, the use of raw materials, the oil supply in Germany and the war in Ukraine took center stage. Scholz said on Monday after a meeting with Kazakhstan’s President Kassym-Shomart Tokayev in Astana that he had held “very good talks.” He said that “many very practical agreements” were signed, which was “a good sign for the improvement of economic and political relations.”

    Kazakhstan as an important oil supplier

    Scholz said that the visit focused on expanding renewable energies and the possibilities of entering the hydrogen economy. He discussed logistics issues and how to “improve infrastructure to ensure that economic relations with this region can develop further and better.” Specific investments by German companies in the region were also discussed.

    The Eastern Committee of the German Economy also stressed the region’s importance following Scholz’s trip to Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan. “The countries in Central Asia play a decisive role in the energy transition,” explained Christian Bruch, Deputy Chairman of the Committee. “The region not only has valuable raw materials (…), but also offers ideal conditions for the production of renewable energy and trains young, motivated specialists that we urgently need in Germany.”

    According to the Eastern Committee, Kazakhstan, in particular, is already an important supplier of crude oil and could play a key role in supplying European industry with green hydrogen in the future. Committee members and company representatives are accompanying Scholz on the trip. ari

    • Rohstoffe
    • Ukraine-Krieg

    Countervailing duties: Italy sides with the EU Commission

    Italy supports the European Commission’s proposed tariffs on Chinese EV exports. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said this before he met with the Chinese trade minister in Rome on Monday. “We support the duties that the EU Commission proposes, to protect the competitiveness of our companies,” Tajani said in an interview with the daily newspaper Corriere della Sera.

    The Minister received his Chinese counterpart Wang Wentao, who wants to speak in Europe about the European Union’s anti-subsidy proceedings against electric vehicles from China. Other topics included the protection of intellectual property, trade in the agricultural and food sectors and investments.

    “We want to work on a trade plan based on equality, we demand equal access for our products in their markets. Our companies must compete on equal terms,” said Tajani.

    Italy had initially favored tariffs in a non-binding vote by EU members in July. However, Industry Minister Adolfo Urso told Reuters last week that he expected a negotiated solution. Spain’s Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez recently reconsidered his position on the tariffs during a visit to Beijing and even pledged support to the Chinese.

    Italy remains a major car manufacturer with brands such as Fiat. The European Commission is about to propose definitive tariffs of up to 35.3 percent on electric cars produced in China, on top of the standard 10 percent import tariffs on cars in the EU. rtr

    • Giorgia Meloni

    Rare earths: How China further extends its lead

    China has discovered new rare earth deposits. As the South China Morning Post reports, rare earth specialists announced at a symposium of the China Rare Earth Group last week that 4.96 million tons of rare earths had been found in the Liangshan Yi Autonomous Prefecture (Sichuan Province).

    According to the US Geological Survey, China is already the world’s largest producer of rare earths, with 44 million tons of deposits, including 17 metal oxides. Rare earths are crucial for the technological development of electric vehicles, wind turbines, robots and modern military weapons.

    In light of the rivalry between China and the USA in the technology sector, China’s dominant position in rare earths is causing increasing concern. Beijing recently imposed export restrictions on rare earths. Previously, the Ministry of State Security had classified the elements as strategic mineral resources “directly related to national security.” However, official customs data shows that China’s exports of rare earths rose by 6.4 percent year-on-year to 38,755 tons in the first eight months of the year. rad

    • Geopolitik

    Hong Kong: Activist faces seven years in prison for slogan on T-shirt

    A Hong Kong court has handed down its first verdict under the new National Security Law. On Monday, a 27-year-old man pleaded guilty to “seditious intent.” His crime: He had worn a T-shirt with a protest slogan. Due to the tightening of the Security Act in March 2024, the man now faces seven years in prison instead of just two.

    Chu Kai-pong was arrested at a subway station on June 12 wearing a T-shirt with the slogan “Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times,” and a yellow mask printed with “FDNOL” – the shorthand of another pro-democracy slogan, “five demands, not one less.” Both slogans were chanted during the massive, sometimes violent democracy protests in 2019. June 12 is considered the start of the month-long unrest.

    Chu told the police he wore the T-shirt to remind people of the protests. Chief Magistrate Victor So, personally appointed by Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee to hear national security cases, adjourned the case until Thursday for the verdict.

    Following months of protests in the financial capital, Beijing passed a national security law in 2020 that punishes secession, subversion, terrorism or collaboration with foreign forces with up to life imprisonment. In March 2024, Hong Kong passed a second new security law – a home-grown ordinance known as “Article 23.” It is more drastic and is intended to close loopholes in the previous law. rtr/grz

    • Hongkong
    • John Lee
    • John Lee
    • Justice
    • National Security Act

    Judiciary: US pastor released after nearly 20 years in prison

    China released US pastor David Lin after he had been imprisoned since 2006. This was announced by the State Department on Sunday. For years, US politicians had urged Beijing to release Lin. The pastor was convicted of alleged contract fraud and sentenced to life in prison. Lin has already returned to the United States.

    “We welcome David Lin’s release from prison in the People’s Republic of China,” a State Department spokesperson said, adding that Lin “has returned to the United States and now gets to see his family for the first time in nearly 20 years.” Last November, the United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations urged President Joe Biden to appeal to Chinese leader Xi Jinping for the release of Lin and other detainees Kai Li and Mark Swidan. Washington claims that all three have been unjustly imprisoned. rtr/grz

    • China

    Heads

    He Jiankui: China’s most controversial researcher wants to go to the US

    Archive image: He Jinakui at a symposium in Hong Kong in 2018.

    Chinese scientist He Jiankui, who caused global outrage in 2018 when he created the first genetically modified babies, is openly considering moving to the United States to work on a gene treatment for Alzheimer’s disease.

    He made global headlines six years ago when he manipulated the genetic material of two embryos to make them resistant to HIV. The intervention sparked ethical debates about the limits of genetic research. Although He claimed that the procedure was successful, there are considerable doubts about the effectiveness and safety of his experiments. Many scientists have criticized that the long-term effects of the interventions are unknown.

    An investor from Silicon Valley has offered him money to found a company that develops gene therapies against Alzheimer’s disease, He said in an online roundtable organized by the science magazine MIT Technology Review.

    He went to prison for his experiments

    He spent three years in prison for illegal medical practices following the 2018 scandal. Since his release in 2022, he has struggled to regain a foothold in science. Plans to work in Hong Kong fell through when his visa was revoked for allegedly providing false information. He currently runs a laboratory in Wuhan and has also opened a new facility in Sanya on Hainan, reportedly funded by American donors and Chinese companies.

    The US-educated scientist studied at Rice University and conducted research at Stanford University. He has since decided to focus on Alzheimer’s research, as his mother is suffering from the disease.

    Refined technology to bring progress

    He plans to use a new gene editing technique called base editing to introduce a genetic mutation into human embryos to protect against dementia. He emphasizes that he wants to continue his research, but appears to be reformed: He said his work would initially be limited to mice, monkeys and non-viable embryos. “The basic research can be completed in two years.”

    He said that society decides when the technology will be used in human trials, adding that in 50 years, embryo editing will be as standard as IVF is today and all babies will be born without known diseases. “I believe society will realize that genetic editing improves human health.”

    Pencil instead of gene scissors

    He used the CRISPR-Cas9 technique on the two babies he manipulated. This method allows targeted cuts to be made in the DNA in order to change genes. He removed the CCR5 gene from the babies to protect them against HIV. The procedure is known for its precision, but carries the risk of off-target effects, in other words unintended changes to the genetic material.

    By contrast, base editing is an advanced technique that works without double-strand breaks in the DNA. Double-strand breaks are cracks in both DNA strands that can occur with CRISPR-Cas9, which can cause unintended changes.

    Base editing involves the targeted modification of individual DNA building blocks, making it safer and more precise. While CRISPR-Cas9 works like a pair of scissors that cut the DNA, base editing works like a pencil that changes a single letter in the genetic code. This technique promises more precise interventions with fewer risks.

    Most countries have strict rules

    In the US, federal laws prohibit government funding of experiments on genetically modified embryos, and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not approved genetic modifications in embryos for use on humans. After the He scandal, legislation in China was tightened to prevent unauthorized genetic experiments, leading to stricter controls and harsher penalties.

    In the EU, national laws, as well as joint directives, regulate the manipulation of embryos. Most EU countries prohibit germline manipulation to prevent risks. Public and scientific debate on the ethical implications of gene editing remains intense in all three regions. Joern Petring

    • Wissenschaft

    Executive Moves

    Tim Rühlig has been the new Senior Analyst for Global China at the EU Institute for Security Studies since this week. Previously, he was a Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Geopolitics, Geo-Economics and Technology at the German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP).

    Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

    Dessert

    Motocross-WM-Lauf in Shanghai

    The world of sports has long been unable to get past China. Its market is too tempting for sports associations to avoid the People’s Republic as a venue for world championships or World Cup series. Consequently, China now hosts ski jumping and luge competitions, Formula 1 and motocross races. Over the weekend, the off-road machines of the world’s best cross-country riders whizzed past the grandstands in Shanghai at the Oriental Beauty Valley MXGP of China. The event marked the return of the series after a four-year break. Due to the Covid pandemic, the event in China was removed from the calendar in 2020. Chinese riders were also at the start. Although they finished in the last three places, they at least left their eliminated competitors behind them.

    China.Table editorial team

    CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen