Table.Briefing: China

6th plenum: Xi’s ambitions + German firms pessimistic

  • Xi elevates himself to Mao’s level at CC plenum
  • German companies see deteriorating business environment
  • Real estate: reform of property tax to dampen prices
  • Emissions per capita at German level
  • China rejects pact against coal financing
  • European MEPs visit Taiwan, talk with Tsai
  • German frigate docks in Tokyo
  • Shaanxi introduces one year maternity leave
  • Johnny Erling: The time-honored business card goes digital
Dear reader,

For China observers, a plenum of the Central Committee is like a small celebration every year. The word alone confirms that we are still dealing with a system whose structures were once shaped by Lenin. For all intransparency of China’s political processes, this at least provides some safe guessing. When the CC convenes to make significant decisions, then significant decisions are to be expected. And things kick off again on Monday, with the sixth and final plenum of the current CC. Michael Radunski analyses which signals might already give away China’s ideological direction. And it doesn’t make Xi Jinping seem not particularly modest.

As Xi consolidates his power, the country’s former pro-business agenda is to some extent falling by the wayside. Local German companies are feeling this more and more, as a survey by the Chamber of Commerce shows. There is nothing left of the optimism of the spring. Rather than the economy brightening up, a perfect storm is brewing. Problems with supply chains, logistics, Covid, power supply, and rising prices continue to deteriorate each other in a vicious circle, analyses Amelie Richter.

Meanwhile, the government is trying to tackle a pressing problem of Chinese citizens, namely high real estate prices. The plan is to use an instrument that has long been known in Germany: property tax. However, the introduction of a new burden on millions of homeowners is a delicate legal, organizational, and propaganda operation, and one that needs to be well-prepared. Our team in Beijing gives you an overview of the state of the debate.

Your
Finn Mayer-Kuckuk
Image of Finn  Mayer-Kuckuk

Feature

The 6th plenum will be a historical one for Xi

Next week will be historic. And not just figuratively, but literally. Because when the 6th plenum of the 19th Central Committee convenes in Beijing on Monday, the 370 delegates will adopt, among other things, a “historic resolution.” What exactly President Xi Jinping’s resolution will include is not yet known, but Chinese media have been reporting for days that it is to celebrate “the great successes and historic achievements of the party in its 100-year struggle.”

The 6th Plenum proceeding from November 8th to 11 would certainly be a fitting occasion for an announcement of epic proportions. In China, the gatherings of the respective Central Committees in office are numbered consecutively. The 3rd Plenum and the 6th Plenum usually receive special attention: While special reform projects are announced at the 3rd Plenum, far-reaching fundamental decisions are made at the 6th Plenum as the final meeting before the Party Congress, which will have effects for decades to come. And it is supposed to be another “historic resolution” this time.

Xi has many plans. Resolutions that bear the label of a “historic resolution” are very rare and stand out from the flood of party pronouncements. In 100 years of party history, there have only been two such resolutions:

  • in 1945 , under Mao Zedong, the “Resolution on Certain Historical Questions” (关于若干历史问题的决议) and
  • in 1981, under Deng Xiaoping, the “Resolution on Certain Questions in Party History since the Founding of the People’s Republic of China” (关于建国以来党的若干历史问题的决议).

The same level with Mao and Deng already clearly shows how President Xi Jinping sees himself.

Historical resolutions – retrospect and foresight

But such resolutions not only have a high symbolic value, but they are also an important instrument in Chinese politics. At its core, they fulfill two practical functions: First, they are used to evaluating past events. With the “historical resolution” Xi thus claims interpretive sovereignty over history. He decides how past events are to be assessed, what is good and what is bad for the Chinese people. On the other hand, the leadership always sets the future path for the party and the country with such resolutions.

The “historic resolutions” of Mao and Deng followed this very pattern. They were characterized by critical retrospection and ideological foresight. In 1945 Mao called for a “Rectification Movement”, which basically meant one thing: settling scores with his inner-party opponents. They were forced to acknowledge their own mistakes through harsh self-criticism. In the end, Mao stood as the undisputed leader of party and nation.

Deng Xiaoping’s historic revolution went in the exact opposite direction. He resorted to this means in 1981 to come to terms with the mistakes of the Mao era, especially with the Cultural Revolution and its consequences. In doing so, Deng successfully introduced a fine distinction between Mao’s achievements – especially around the founding of the People’s Republic – and Mao’s mistakes, which Deng located primarily in the years prior to Mao’s death. In prudence, Deng then laid the ideological groundwork for his subsequent policy of opening up and reform.

A hierarchy of leaders

A critical view on the past – be it Mao’s Cultural Revolution or even the events of the Tiananmen Square in 1989 – probably won’t be included in Xi’s “historical resolution”. On the contrary. It will mainly be set around praise and self-praise, writes rogue party historian Deng Yuwen on Yibao.

A look at the Politburo’s latest report, issued in mid-October, gives an idea of the tone in which the resolution will be announced. It says: “The CPC has led all ethnic groups of the country in making remarkable achievements over the past 100 years in the history of human development” China’s people had been subjugated and tyrannized. But now they have risen up. Under Xi Jinping’s leadership, the country is on the path toward common prosperity and spiritual and national rejuvenation. In short, the 100 years since the founding of the Chinese Communist Party in Shanghai in 1921 have been a success story, and Xi Jinping is the right man for China.

It is clear what Xi wants to achieve at the 6th Plenum: By proclaiming a “historic resolution”, he is once again underlining his prominent position in Chinese history. It puts him on a par with Mao and Deng. At the least. For Xi is striving to surpass the two party icons by establishing a hierarchy of Chinese leaders at the 6th Plenum. Then, only he and Mao will be at the top. Deng Xiaoping will follow at some distance, then Jiang Zemin and Hu Jintao. If Xi has his way, it will be possible to divide the history of the Communist Party into three periods from now on: The first phase under Mao, then a less important interim period, and finally, the Xi era. The great reformer Deng Xiaoping thus becomes a mere episode.

A Cultural Revolution 2.0

This clear hierarchy is important for Xi for two reasons: his leadership style and his goals. Xi’s leadership style represents a clear departure from Deng Xiaoping, after all. It was Deng who, after the turmoils of the Mao era, including the famine and the Cultural Revolution, warned strongly against allowing a single person to become so powerful ever again. In China’s political culture, the cult of personality ended. Before Xi, the terms of Chinese presidents were limited to two periods of five years each. Xi has cashed in on both.

And Xi is also following in Mao’s footsteps when it comes to his measures. Many observers are convinced that Xi is currently imposing nothing less than a kind of Cultural Revolution 2.0 on the country. Initially, extremely harsh action was taken against corrupt and otherwise loathed cadres; a great many observers spoke of a “cleansing” of party ranks in reference to the Mao era. China’s economy (crackdown on large tech corporations) and education (new curricula at schools and universities, bans of private education providers) are also being completely restructured. All coupled with a strong re-ideologization of society (towards old values, away from foreign countries).

A few weeks ago, influential blogger Li Guangman (李光满) illustrated just how widely these events are being perceived, even within China, with his essay “Everyone Can Sense That a Profound Transformation is Underway!” (每个人都能感受到,一场深刻的变革正在进行.) Li first published the essay on his WeChat account, but his lines were quickly picked up by state news agency Xinhua, the newspaper People’s Daily, and television channel CCTV. In it, Li praises that vulgar, money-obsessed individuals are finally getting what they deserve – much like a revolution. The idea of Xi’s revolution is to change a society focused on money and profit into a community that once again focuses on its people and the common good. It is a return to the true intentions (初心) and quintessence (本质) of the Chinese Communist Party and true Chinese socialism.

It is these ideas and slogans that Xi Jinping wants to use to determine China’s policy for years to come – and which will in all likelihood also shape the “historic resolution” at the 6th Plenum.

Xi wants to consolidate his position

But why is there still a need for a “historic resolution”? One often-heard reason is that, as strong as Xi Jinping may appear to the outside world, both his leadership style and his substantive goals are controversial within China. But cracks rarely appear in the outwardly often monolith-like structure of the CP. But they do exist: doubts, discontent, occasional discord, and sometimes even criticism. Like Zhang Weiying (张维迎), for example. The Peking University economics professor questioned the concept of “common prosperity” in early September. The approach contradicts the principles of a market economy and could even result in “common poverty.”

And this is why Xi’s “historic resolution” at the 6th Plenum will revolve around three things:

  • historically, to consolidate its place high in the party hierarchy;
  • power-politically, to close ranks in face of economic, pandemic and international challenges;
  • and to lay the ideological groundwork for the future with “Xi Jinping new era for socialism with Chinese characteristics” (习近平新时代中国特色社会主义思想).
  • Central Committee
  • Chinese Communist Party
  • Cultural Revolution
  • Deng Xiaoping
  • Domestic policy of the CP China
  • Mao Zedong
  • Xi Jinping

German companies expect poorer business

Power and resource shortages, unclear economic policy guidelines, and travel restrictions have massively impacted the economic expectations of German companies in China. Only 37 percent of the German companies surveyed in the People’s Republic now expect an improvement – compared to 69 percent back in spring 2021. This is the result of a survey by the Association of German Chambers of Industry and Commerce (DIHK) and the Chamber of Foreign Trade (AHK), which was presented on Thursday.

At the same time, the number of companies that expect the business environment in China to deteriorate over the next twelve months quadrupled: Whereas in the spring the figure was just five percent, 21 percent of the companies surveyed now expect their business to deteriorate in autumn. According to DIHK Head of Foreign Trade, Volker Treier, this assessment also has an impact on future investments: “German companies’ investment plans are on the rise, except in China.”

Companies relocate supply chains

The economic upturn still expected in spring thus does not appear to materialize in the end, the “AHK World Business Outlook” states. “In autumn 2020 and spring 2021, the expectations of companies in China had still been far above the global average.” However, in the DIHK’s view, the global economic environment is also generally becoming “more uncomfortable”, as Treier said. Supply chain problems in particular are coming to a head.

According to the survey, 69 percent of companies in China complained about problems in their supply chains or logistics as a result of the Covid pandemic. Industrial and construction companies were particularly affected by supply chain disruptions and their results. In addition to increased demand on one hand, and insufficient production capacities on the other, companies see shipping problems – especially due to a lack of containers and freight capacities on ships, as well as production downtimes at suppliers, according to the survey.

In light of the challenges in international business, 54 percent of companies worldwide now want to adapt their supply chains accordingly, as Treier explained. Of these companies, 72 percent were looking for new suppliers, while 32 percent were planning to change or shorten their supply routes. Treier called it striking that 15 percent of the companies wanted to relocate their production or parts of their production to new locations. The report did not provide details of the corresponding responses in China.

However, there are shifts out of China and into the Indo-Pacific region, Treier said. “Malaysia and India are becoming more attractive.” At the same time, however, an expansion of German companies’ supply chains in China is also an issue. One reason for this is local content regulations, i.e. the requirement to source a minimum proportion of parts domestically.

Hildebrandt: raw material and energy bottlenecks until spring 2022

The topics of decoupling and localization of supply chains play a major role in China, according to the head of the AHK in Beijing, Jens Hildebrandt. According to Hildebrandt, the nationalization of Chinese supply chains is the main source of uncertainty. In addition, vaguely worded economic policy initiatives such as “Common Prosperity” (China.Table reported) left companies wondering, Hildebrandt said. According to the survey, 45 percent of the companies cited economic policy framework conditions as the greatest business risk.

The outlook in the People’s Republic is also clouded by raw material and power-supply bottlenecks, Hildebrandt explained. The power bottlenecks are now better coordinated. It has been observed that demand has fueled the production of coal, and electricity rates have been adjusted (China.Table reported). Hildebrandt nevertheless expects the impacts of power and commodity shortages will be felt till the spring of next year. High commodity prices are the biggest business risk for 61 percent of companies in China, according to the survey.

Another important point is the impact of the Covid pandemic: 85 percent of companies in China are affected by travel restrictions. Hildebrandt expects continued travel restrictions throughout 2022.

The “AHK World Business Outlook” is based on a regular DIHK survey of member companies of the German Chambers of Commerce Abroad, delegations, and representative offices. The current survey collected feedback from more than 3,200 German companies worldwide in autumn 2021. According to the survey, 41 percent of the responding companies are from the industrial and construction sector, 37 percent from the service sector and another 22 percent are trading companies.

  • DIHK
  • Jens Hildebrandt
  • Supply chains
  • Trade

New property tax to make housing more affordable

China’s government wants to get serious with its plans that were years in the making, and plan to gradually introduce a real estate tax. This is a highly emotionally-charged issue that affects just about everyone in the People’s Republic. After all, more than 90 percent of households in China have their own property. That is significantly more than in Germany, where it is much more common to rent an apartment. Here, the proportion of property owners is around 50 percent.

The fact that most people live in their own homes is, of course, pleases the Chinese leadership. On the other hand, the never-ending speculation on the real estate market is considered problematic. As state news agency Xinhua reported, 31 percent of Chinese homeowners already own two apartments and 10.5 percent even have three or more apartments.

Purchasing real estate in China is considered a lucrative one-way street: The widespread belief is that prices can only go up. Those who have money therefore invest it in concrete gold. Yet many of the second and third properties purchased are not even rented out afterwards. According to some estimates, around one-fifth of the available apartments in China are empty.

But while wealthy families buy apartment after apartment, affordable real estate has become nigh-impossible for young first-time buyers, especially in big cities like Beijing, Shanghai, and Shenzhen. China’s President Xi Jinping wants to use the proposed property tax as another tool to cool down the inflated real estate market. At the same time, he wants to advance his plans of “common prosperity.” Xi considers affordable housing to be a part of it.

In late October, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress instructed the State Council to launch a five-year trial program for the new property tax in selected regions. According to a Reuters report, ten cities, including Shenzhen, Haikou and Hangzhou, will participate. Nanjing, Suzhou and Beijing are also considered candidates.

Doubts about the instrument’s suitability

However, many experts doubt whether a broader property tax is the right instrument to make housing more affordable again. Shanghai and Chongqing, two of China’s largest urban centers, provide an indication of how a property tax could work. In 2011, the two metropolises were the first cities to test such a levy.

  • In Shanghai, the tax is primarily aimed at buyers who own more than one property. Anyone who buys a new second home with an area of more than 60 square meters must pay an annual tax in Shanghai of 0.4 to 0.6 percent of the property’s market value.
  • Chongqing levies a progressive property tax that starts at 0.5 percent and rises up to 1.2 percent. The rate applies to owners of existing and new homes that cost more than twice the average price of new homes in the metropolis.

China lacks a universal property tax for residential real estate, apart from local taxes levied by the municipalities,

Other countries also rely on property taxes: In the US, rates range from 0.5 to 2.13 percent annually, while the UK levies a 1.93 percent tax, and Hong Kong taxes 5 percent based on the estimated annual rent of the property. In Germany, the property tax varies by municipality. In the past, it was calculated through a particularly complicated procedure. As a result, the federal and state governments have reformed it after a long discussion, but the changes will not take effect until 2025. So property tax is also a hot topic in other countries.

The exact details of China’s new tax plans are currently unknown. Bloomberg reported that it is very likely that all existing residential properties will be included this time in order to broaden the tax base. This would likely not exempt primary residences from the levy, but would likely result in a low tax rate. Local governments could also exempt 30 to 60 square meters per household member. This mechanism would mainly tax predominantly wealthy families with spacious homes.

Even if observers remain skeptical that the new tax will cool prices on the real estate market. It should certainly become lucrative for China’s local governments. The Australian-New Zealand ANZ Bank, for example, estimates that up to $200 billion could be earned annually. Jörn Petring/ Gregor Koppenburg

  • Finance
  • Property tax
  • Real Estate

News

CO2-emissions increased in 2020

China was responsible for more than 30 percent of global CO2 emissions in 2020, according to new figures released Thursday night. Between 2019 and 2020, China’s share of global emissions rose by two percentage points. However, this was tied to the Covid pandemic. As a result of the prolonged lockdown in Western states, emissions in these states dropped significantly. Climate scientists assume that this Covid effect on emissions was only short-term. For the year 2021, CO2 emissions in the US and Europe are expected to rise.

Converted to the population, greenhouse gas emissions in China averaged 7.4 tons per capita and were thus only just behind those of Germany (7.7 tons per capita). US Americans emitted an average of over 14 tons of CO2 per year in 2020. However, these figures should also be treated with caution. This is because about a tenth of greenhouse gas emitted in China is due to the high export surplus and is thus indirectly caused abroad. Nevertheless, China remains one of the most important players at the climate conference currently held in Glasgow.

China pulls out of pact against coal financing

However, China refused to sign a treaty of 22 countries against the financing of fossil fuel projects. This puts Beijing in the company of South Korea, Japan, and Spain, which also consider the requirements too far-reaching. The agreement came about at the instigation of British Energy Minister Greg Hands. It provides for a complete phase-out of investments in the production or use of coal, gas, and oil by 2022. However, the document is not binding. Moreover, it only concerns new plans; financing for ongoing projects remains unaffected. Still, Hands trusts the pact to redirect $15 billion in public funds from dirty to clean projects. nib/fin

  • Climate
  • Coal power
  • COP26
  • Emissions

EU delegation pledges support for Taiwan

A European MEP delegation has pledged support for Taiwan and called for a strengthening of relations between Brussels and Taipei. “We came here with a very simple, very clear message: You are not alone. Europe is standing with you,” French EU politician Raphaël Glucksmann said in the presence of Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen in a meeting broadcast live on Facebook. “Our visit should be considered as an important first step,” said Glucksmann, who is leading the delegation. Next, he said, there needs to be “a very concrete agenda of high-level meetings” to build a stronger partnership between the EU and Taiwan. Taiwan’s democracy is a treasure that must be protected, Glucksmann said.

Tsai warned against growing Chinese attempts to gain influence in Taiwan. She called on security agencies to counter efforts to infiltrate Taiwan – with the help of the EU. “We hope to establish a democratic alliance against disinformation,” Tsai said. It is the first official delegation from the EU Parliament to visit Taiwan. The MEPs are members of the Special Committee on Foreign Interference in all Democratic Processes (INGE).

The government in Beijing condemned the meeting: China’s foreign office expressed “strong dissatisfaction and firm opposition” to the visit. “We have urged the EU to correct these mistakes and not send wrong signals to separatist forces advocating Taiwan independence.” An official said MEPs “should fully understand the complexity and sensitivity of the Taiwan issue, abide by the EU’s commitment to the One-China Principle… and safeguard the political basis of the development of China-EU relations.”

Taipei is putting out feelers towards the EU in the face of increasing aggression from Beijing – but Brussels is still struggling to find a unified line (China.Table reported). ari

  • Geopolitics
  • Taiwan

German frigate docks in Tokyo

The German Armed Forces frigate “Bayern” will dock in Tokyo’s harbor on Friday. Following her visit to the Japanese capital, she is taking part in a joint maneuver with the US, Australia, Japan, and Canada as part of her Indo-Pacific mission. China feels increasingly surrounded by these nations. Most recently, a Pacific coalition against China has moved closer together with the Anglo-Saxon “Aukus” alliance (China.Table reported). The frigate had previously celebrated the Germany Unity Day in Australia in the friendliest way. In Shanghai, however, the Bayern was not welcome.

In fact, Defence Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer has explicitly defended the mission by stating that she wants to contribute to the “preservation of the rule-based maritime order”. It is about “showing colors”, said its Vice Admiral. While the identity of the party that is disrupting order is not explicitly named, that talk is about China. The country is making sprawling territorial claims in the South China Sea. Meanwhile, the Japanese interpretation of the frigate’s visit to Tokyo is equally clear: Germany wants to strengthen allied democracies in the Pacific region. The business paper Nikkei assumes that in the post-Merkel era, the German government will take a more critical stance on China. fin

  • Geopolitics
  • Indo-Pacific
  • Military
  • South China Sea

Shaanxi to introduce one year maternity leave

The Chinese province of Shaanxi is planning to extend paid maternity leave to just under a year. The proposal is intended to increase the birth rate. So far, mothers are entitled to 168 days of maternity leave. Extending it by another six months would put Shaanxi’s standard on par with Germany and Norway, Reuters reported. The province is also pursuing plans to double paternity leave to 30 days for the third child, according to the report.

In May, China had allowed couples to have three children. Even then, there were doubts whether the introduction of the three-child policy alone would lead to more births. In many cities, the cost of living is so high that couples can hardly afford to have children. Even then, there were calls for supportive measures for families. nib

  • Children
  • Demographics
  • Drei-Kind-Politik
  • Society

Column

Chinese games of confusion with business cards

By Johnny Erling
Ein Bild von Johnny Erling

Ever since business people from all over the world are drawn to China – in the wake of Beijing’s reform and policy of opening-up – training courses on intercultural behavior to avoid gaffes have been booming. The correct way of handing over business cards is right at the top of the list of etiquette issues at consulting companies. After all, the People’s Republic follows ancient traditions. The only truth to this is that business cards were first used in China more than 2,000 years ago, but modern-day name and business cards and how to present or receive them were copied by the Chinese from Europeans and Japanese. Only since the digitalization of business cards has Beijing once again taken the lead.

Two very specific traditional name cards played a role in global political events 121 years ago. They contributed to the sense of humiliation of the Chinese Empire. At issue was how the German commander-in-chief of the Allied intervention forces that stopped the Boxer Rebellion handled it. Alfred Graf von Waldersee kept the court’s highest-ranking envoys, Li Hongzhang and Prince Qing, waiting for a long time before deigning to receive them, even though both had announced themselves with their business cards in perfect form.

This is how China’s calling cards once looked like. The two name cards of Prince Qing and Li Hongzhang, which they, as emissaries of the imperial court, had presented to the German commander-in-chief Graf von Waldersee days before he finally received them on November 15, 1900. From the estate of Hauptmann von Schönberg.

Even more provocatively, Empress Dowager Cixi’s emissaries had to pay him their respects at Beijing’s imperial garden and lake complex Zhongnanhai (中南海), for that was where Waldersee had set up his headquarters. He lived in the Ziguangge (紫光阁), the more than 200-year-old “purple radiant pavilion”. The buildings next door housed his German entourage.

It was November 15, 1900. “At 3 in the afternoon, we were graced with a historic moment,” wrote Oberstallmeister Fedor von Rauch in his diary: “The chief was expecting the two Chinese dignitaries… They may have found it hard to offer their reverential greeting to the German field marshal in the chambers of their sovereign. The audience lasted about an hour and a half.

Illustration from the turn of the 19th and 20th century: A visitor carries a visiting card and strikes the door gong.

The imperial court had appointed Li Hongzhang “envoy extraordinary and minister plenipotentiary for the purpose of restoring peace between China and foreign powers.” Prince Qing assisted. Waldersee, however, was not willing to meet with them until “after weeks of negotiation, they were comfortable in addressing a written audience request to him,” von Rauch reported. Both mandarins had their visit announced in the traditional Chinese manner and sent him their visiting cards in advance.

In the estate of Captain von Schönberg, I discovered the name cards of Li and Prince Qing. They had written them with three characters, each in black ink from top to bottom, and brushed them on oblong red paper. The cards of other representatives of allied troops from eight countries, be it from the Japanese, Russians, Americans, or French, looked quite different. They were already printed in square formats on thin white paper, just as we know them today. In the UK, the Oscar Friedheim company, founded in 1884, was able to produce up to 100,000 individual cards a day by 1889. Their card cutting and engraving machines came from Germany.

Business cards were traditionally delivered in special wooden boxes.

It was not Europe that learned from China when it comes to handling the modern “Mingpian” (名片) business card, as many China etiquette books want us to believe. It was the other way around: The Chinese copied the European format, the bilingualism of the card, and their printing technique. From the Japanese, they learned how to use it. The Japanese had adopted the characters for the term “mingci” (名刺) from ancient Chinese, but they were the ones to conceive a perfectly formed ritual for them. It begins with holding the flat card between the thumb and index finger of both hands, and then handing it to the other person with a bow.

China was a quick study. In 2018, the Beijing daily called the mass distribution of name cards in the People’s Republic today an important “tool for social contact” (“社会交往的重要工具”). Used for more than 2,000 years in China, nobles from distant principalities or kingdoms who visited higher-ranking rulers would enclose with their gifts and tributes platelets made of bamboo or wood called ye (谒). On them were the names of the bearers, and often details of their rank and their origin. Later dynasties used silk, cloth, and, from the Ming period onwards, paper.

Modern printed cards appeared en masse with the economic boom after the Cultural Revolution in China in 1978. At first, the customers of Beijing’s small-scale printers despaired. They did not know any foreign languages and could not type foreign names without error. Only copying and scanning techniques solved the stubborn problem.

The IT revolution helped China catch up and even pioneer the electronic business card of today. Especially after WeChat emerged in 2011 and the digital business card replaced the printed name card. According to recent data, more than 230 million Chinese used business cards from 2011 to 2021, including more than 50 million only digitally via apps, WeChat, and QR codes since 2017. In metropolises such as Shanghai, Beijing, and Shenzhen, the printed card is dying out.

The digitization of the business card began in 2011. By 2021, more than 50 million Chinese will already be presenting their business cards online using QR codes, apps, and WeChat programs. There is enough advertising for the service, as the picture shows.

Half a century after Waldersee made his brief guest appearance at Zhongnanhai, China’s Communists moved into the former Park of Emperors on June 15, 1949, even before they proclaimed their People’s Republic. Mao Zedong made Zhongnanhai the seat of the party and also lived there privately. The people have since called the heavily guarded area west of the imperial palace the “new forbidden city.”

In its Purple Palace (Ziguange), China’s leadership nowadays sometimes receives illustrious foreign guests. It does not like to be reminded of the imperial pre-inhabitants. Still, even less of the time when a German commander-in-chief resided here and emissaries of the imperial house had to hand in their visiting cards to him. These were not the only things the Germans took with them when they left. They are also said to have taken all kinds of other art treasures.

  • Culture
  • Germany
  • Society
  • Trade

Executive Moves

Gerardo Madonna has returned for his new position from China: Madonna has been working in project control at VW in Wolfsburg since the beginning of the month. He was previously a manager at FAW-Volkswagen in Changchun.

Wolfgang Schröer is the new HR Director for Production Joint Venture at Daimler Greater China. Schröer previously held various positions at Daimler AG.

Dessert

Fog in Tianjin. Or rather clouds? In any case, the roof of the Tianjin World Financial Center sticks out of the white soup. From the drone’s bird’s eye view, it looks like a ship in a sea of white waves. At 337 meters, the “Jin Tower” is high enough to provide a view from its highest floors as if from an airplane.

China.Table Editors

CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    • Xi elevates himself to Mao’s level at CC plenum
    • German companies see deteriorating business environment
    • Real estate: reform of property tax to dampen prices
    • Emissions per capita at German level
    • China rejects pact against coal financing
    • European MEPs visit Taiwan, talk with Tsai
    • German frigate docks in Tokyo
    • Shaanxi introduces one year maternity leave
    • Johnny Erling: The time-honored business card goes digital
    Dear reader,

    For China observers, a plenum of the Central Committee is like a small celebration every year. The word alone confirms that we are still dealing with a system whose structures were once shaped by Lenin. For all intransparency of China’s political processes, this at least provides some safe guessing. When the CC convenes to make significant decisions, then significant decisions are to be expected. And things kick off again on Monday, with the sixth and final plenum of the current CC. Michael Radunski analyses which signals might already give away China’s ideological direction. And it doesn’t make Xi Jinping seem not particularly modest.

    As Xi consolidates his power, the country’s former pro-business agenda is to some extent falling by the wayside. Local German companies are feeling this more and more, as a survey by the Chamber of Commerce shows. There is nothing left of the optimism of the spring. Rather than the economy brightening up, a perfect storm is brewing. Problems with supply chains, logistics, Covid, power supply, and rising prices continue to deteriorate each other in a vicious circle, analyses Amelie Richter.

    Meanwhile, the government is trying to tackle a pressing problem of Chinese citizens, namely high real estate prices. The plan is to use an instrument that has long been known in Germany: property tax. However, the introduction of a new burden on millions of homeowners is a delicate legal, organizational, and propaganda operation, and one that needs to be well-prepared. Our team in Beijing gives you an overview of the state of the debate.

    Your
    Finn Mayer-Kuckuk
    Image of Finn  Mayer-Kuckuk

    Feature

    The 6th plenum will be a historical one for Xi

    Next week will be historic. And not just figuratively, but literally. Because when the 6th plenum of the 19th Central Committee convenes in Beijing on Monday, the 370 delegates will adopt, among other things, a “historic resolution.” What exactly President Xi Jinping’s resolution will include is not yet known, but Chinese media have been reporting for days that it is to celebrate “the great successes and historic achievements of the party in its 100-year struggle.”

    The 6th Plenum proceeding from November 8th to 11 would certainly be a fitting occasion for an announcement of epic proportions. In China, the gatherings of the respective Central Committees in office are numbered consecutively. The 3rd Plenum and the 6th Plenum usually receive special attention: While special reform projects are announced at the 3rd Plenum, far-reaching fundamental decisions are made at the 6th Plenum as the final meeting before the Party Congress, which will have effects for decades to come. And it is supposed to be another “historic resolution” this time.

    Xi has many plans. Resolutions that bear the label of a “historic resolution” are very rare and stand out from the flood of party pronouncements. In 100 years of party history, there have only been two such resolutions:

    • in 1945 , under Mao Zedong, the “Resolution on Certain Historical Questions” (关于若干历史问题的决议) and
    • in 1981, under Deng Xiaoping, the “Resolution on Certain Questions in Party History since the Founding of the People’s Republic of China” (关于建国以来党的若干历史问题的决议).

    The same level with Mao and Deng already clearly shows how President Xi Jinping sees himself.

    Historical resolutions – retrospect and foresight

    But such resolutions not only have a high symbolic value, but they are also an important instrument in Chinese politics. At its core, they fulfill two practical functions: First, they are used to evaluating past events. With the “historical resolution” Xi thus claims interpretive sovereignty over history. He decides how past events are to be assessed, what is good and what is bad for the Chinese people. On the other hand, the leadership always sets the future path for the party and the country with such resolutions.

    The “historic resolutions” of Mao and Deng followed this very pattern. They were characterized by critical retrospection and ideological foresight. In 1945 Mao called for a “Rectification Movement”, which basically meant one thing: settling scores with his inner-party opponents. They were forced to acknowledge their own mistakes through harsh self-criticism. In the end, Mao stood as the undisputed leader of party and nation.

    Deng Xiaoping’s historic revolution went in the exact opposite direction. He resorted to this means in 1981 to come to terms with the mistakes of the Mao era, especially with the Cultural Revolution and its consequences. In doing so, Deng successfully introduced a fine distinction between Mao’s achievements – especially around the founding of the People’s Republic – and Mao’s mistakes, which Deng located primarily in the years prior to Mao’s death. In prudence, Deng then laid the ideological groundwork for his subsequent policy of opening up and reform.

    A hierarchy of leaders

    A critical view on the past – be it Mao’s Cultural Revolution or even the events of the Tiananmen Square in 1989 – probably won’t be included in Xi’s “historical resolution”. On the contrary. It will mainly be set around praise and self-praise, writes rogue party historian Deng Yuwen on Yibao.

    A look at the Politburo’s latest report, issued in mid-October, gives an idea of the tone in which the resolution will be announced. It says: “The CPC has led all ethnic groups of the country in making remarkable achievements over the past 100 years in the history of human development” China’s people had been subjugated and tyrannized. But now they have risen up. Under Xi Jinping’s leadership, the country is on the path toward common prosperity and spiritual and national rejuvenation. In short, the 100 years since the founding of the Chinese Communist Party in Shanghai in 1921 have been a success story, and Xi Jinping is the right man for China.

    It is clear what Xi wants to achieve at the 6th Plenum: By proclaiming a “historic resolution”, he is once again underlining his prominent position in Chinese history. It puts him on a par with Mao and Deng. At the least. For Xi is striving to surpass the two party icons by establishing a hierarchy of Chinese leaders at the 6th Plenum. Then, only he and Mao will be at the top. Deng Xiaoping will follow at some distance, then Jiang Zemin and Hu Jintao. If Xi has his way, it will be possible to divide the history of the Communist Party into three periods from now on: The first phase under Mao, then a less important interim period, and finally, the Xi era. The great reformer Deng Xiaoping thus becomes a mere episode.

    A Cultural Revolution 2.0

    This clear hierarchy is important for Xi for two reasons: his leadership style and his goals. Xi’s leadership style represents a clear departure from Deng Xiaoping, after all. It was Deng who, after the turmoils of the Mao era, including the famine and the Cultural Revolution, warned strongly against allowing a single person to become so powerful ever again. In China’s political culture, the cult of personality ended. Before Xi, the terms of Chinese presidents were limited to two periods of five years each. Xi has cashed in on both.

    And Xi is also following in Mao’s footsteps when it comes to his measures. Many observers are convinced that Xi is currently imposing nothing less than a kind of Cultural Revolution 2.0 on the country. Initially, extremely harsh action was taken against corrupt and otherwise loathed cadres; a great many observers spoke of a “cleansing” of party ranks in reference to the Mao era. China’s economy (crackdown on large tech corporations) and education (new curricula at schools and universities, bans of private education providers) are also being completely restructured. All coupled with a strong re-ideologization of society (towards old values, away from foreign countries).

    A few weeks ago, influential blogger Li Guangman (李光满) illustrated just how widely these events are being perceived, even within China, with his essay “Everyone Can Sense That a Profound Transformation is Underway!” (每个人都能感受到,一场深刻的变革正在进行.) Li first published the essay on his WeChat account, but his lines were quickly picked up by state news agency Xinhua, the newspaper People’s Daily, and television channel CCTV. In it, Li praises that vulgar, money-obsessed individuals are finally getting what they deserve – much like a revolution. The idea of Xi’s revolution is to change a society focused on money and profit into a community that once again focuses on its people and the common good. It is a return to the true intentions (初心) and quintessence (本质) of the Chinese Communist Party and true Chinese socialism.

    It is these ideas and slogans that Xi Jinping wants to use to determine China’s policy for years to come – and which will in all likelihood also shape the “historic resolution” at the 6th Plenum.

    Xi wants to consolidate his position

    But why is there still a need for a “historic resolution”? One often-heard reason is that, as strong as Xi Jinping may appear to the outside world, both his leadership style and his substantive goals are controversial within China. But cracks rarely appear in the outwardly often monolith-like structure of the CP. But they do exist: doubts, discontent, occasional discord, and sometimes even criticism. Like Zhang Weiying (张维迎), for example. The Peking University economics professor questioned the concept of “common prosperity” in early September. The approach contradicts the principles of a market economy and could even result in “common poverty.”

    And this is why Xi’s “historic resolution” at the 6th Plenum will revolve around three things:

    • historically, to consolidate its place high in the party hierarchy;
    • power-politically, to close ranks in face of economic, pandemic and international challenges;
    • and to lay the ideological groundwork for the future with “Xi Jinping new era for socialism with Chinese characteristics” (习近平新时代中国特色社会主义思想).
    • Central Committee
    • Chinese Communist Party
    • Cultural Revolution
    • Deng Xiaoping
    • Domestic policy of the CP China
    • Mao Zedong
    • Xi Jinping

    German companies expect poorer business

    Power and resource shortages, unclear economic policy guidelines, and travel restrictions have massively impacted the economic expectations of German companies in China. Only 37 percent of the German companies surveyed in the People’s Republic now expect an improvement – compared to 69 percent back in spring 2021. This is the result of a survey by the Association of German Chambers of Industry and Commerce (DIHK) and the Chamber of Foreign Trade (AHK), which was presented on Thursday.

    At the same time, the number of companies that expect the business environment in China to deteriorate over the next twelve months quadrupled: Whereas in the spring the figure was just five percent, 21 percent of the companies surveyed now expect their business to deteriorate in autumn. According to DIHK Head of Foreign Trade, Volker Treier, this assessment also has an impact on future investments: “German companies’ investment plans are on the rise, except in China.”

    Companies relocate supply chains

    The economic upturn still expected in spring thus does not appear to materialize in the end, the “AHK World Business Outlook” states. “In autumn 2020 and spring 2021, the expectations of companies in China had still been far above the global average.” However, in the DIHK’s view, the global economic environment is also generally becoming “more uncomfortable”, as Treier said. Supply chain problems in particular are coming to a head.

    According to the survey, 69 percent of companies in China complained about problems in their supply chains or logistics as a result of the Covid pandemic. Industrial and construction companies were particularly affected by supply chain disruptions and their results. In addition to increased demand on one hand, and insufficient production capacities on the other, companies see shipping problems – especially due to a lack of containers and freight capacities on ships, as well as production downtimes at suppliers, according to the survey.

    In light of the challenges in international business, 54 percent of companies worldwide now want to adapt their supply chains accordingly, as Treier explained. Of these companies, 72 percent were looking for new suppliers, while 32 percent were planning to change or shorten their supply routes. Treier called it striking that 15 percent of the companies wanted to relocate their production or parts of their production to new locations. The report did not provide details of the corresponding responses in China.

    However, there are shifts out of China and into the Indo-Pacific region, Treier said. “Malaysia and India are becoming more attractive.” At the same time, however, an expansion of German companies’ supply chains in China is also an issue. One reason for this is local content regulations, i.e. the requirement to source a minimum proportion of parts domestically.

    Hildebrandt: raw material and energy bottlenecks until spring 2022

    The topics of decoupling and localization of supply chains play a major role in China, according to the head of the AHK in Beijing, Jens Hildebrandt. According to Hildebrandt, the nationalization of Chinese supply chains is the main source of uncertainty. In addition, vaguely worded economic policy initiatives such as “Common Prosperity” (China.Table reported) left companies wondering, Hildebrandt said. According to the survey, 45 percent of the companies cited economic policy framework conditions as the greatest business risk.

    The outlook in the People’s Republic is also clouded by raw material and power-supply bottlenecks, Hildebrandt explained. The power bottlenecks are now better coordinated. It has been observed that demand has fueled the production of coal, and electricity rates have been adjusted (China.Table reported). Hildebrandt nevertheless expects the impacts of power and commodity shortages will be felt till the spring of next year. High commodity prices are the biggest business risk for 61 percent of companies in China, according to the survey.

    Another important point is the impact of the Covid pandemic: 85 percent of companies in China are affected by travel restrictions. Hildebrandt expects continued travel restrictions throughout 2022.

    The “AHK World Business Outlook” is based on a regular DIHK survey of member companies of the German Chambers of Commerce Abroad, delegations, and representative offices. The current survey collected feedback from more than 3,200 German companies worldwide in autumn 2021. According to the survey, 41 percent of the responding companies are from the industrial and construction sector, 37 percent from the service sector and another 22 percent are trading companies.

    • DIHK
    • Jens Hildebrandt
    • Supply chains
    • Trade

    New property tax to make housing more affordable

    China’s government wants to get serious with its plans that were years in the making, and plan to gradually introduce a real estate tax. This is a highly emotionally-charged issue that affects just about everyone in the People’s Republic. After all, more than 90 percent of households in China have their own property. That is significantly more than in Germany, where it is much more common to rent an apartment. Here, the proportion of property owners is around 50 percent.

    The fact that most people live in their own homes is, of course, pleases the Chinese leadership. On the other hand, the never-ending speculation on the real estate market is considered problematic. As state news agency Xinhua reported, 31 percent of Chinese homeowners already own two apartments and 10.5 percent even have three or more apartments.

    Purchasing real estate in China is considered a lucrative one-way street: The widespread belief is that prices can only go up. Those who have money therefore invest it in concrete gold. Yet many of the second and third properties purchased are not even rented out afterwards. According to some estimates, around one-fifth of the available apartments in China are empty.

    But while wealthy families buy apartment after apartment, affordable real estate has become nigh-impossible for young first-time buyers, especially in big cities like Beijing, Shanghai, and Shenzhen. China’s President Xi Jinping wants to use the proposed property tax as another tool to cool down the inflated real estate market. At the same time, he wants to advance his plans of “common prosperity.” Xi considers affordable housing to be a part of it.

    In late October, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress instructed the State Council to launch a five-year trial program for the new property tax in selected regions. According to a Reuters report, ten cities, including Shenzhen, Haikou and Hangzhou, will participate. Nanjing, Suzhou and Beijing are also considered candidates.

    Doubts about the instrument’s suitability

    However, many experts doubt whether a broader property tax is the right instrument to make housing more affordable again. Shanghai and Chongqing, two of China’s largest urban centers, provide an indication of how a property tax could work. In 2011, the two metropolises were the first cities to test such a levy.

    • In Shanghai, the tax is primarily aimed at buyers who own more than one property. Anyone who buys a new second home with an area of more than 60 square meters must pay an annual tax in Shanghai of 0.4 to 0.6 percent of the property’s market value.
    • Chongqing levies a progressive property tax that starts at 0.5 percent and rises up to 1.2 percent. The rate applies to owners of existing and new homes that cost more than twice the average price of new homes in the metropolis.

    China lacks a universal property tax for residential real estate, apart from local taxes levied by the municipalities,

    Other countries also rely on property taxes: In the US, rates range from 0.5 to 2.13 percent annually, while the UK levies a 1.93 percent tax, and Hong Kong taxes 5 percent based on the estimated annual rent of the property. In Germany, the property tax varies by municipality. In the past, it was calculated through a particularly complicated procedure. As a result, the federal and state governments have reformed it after a long discussion, but the changes will not take effect until 2025. So property tax is also a hot topic in other countries.

    The exact details of China’s new tax plans are currently unknown. Bloomberg reported that it is very likely that all existing residential properties will be included this time in order to broaden the tax base. This would likely not exempt primary residences from the levy, but would likely result in a low tax rate. Local governments could also exempt 30 to 60 square meters per household member. This mechanism would mainly tax predominantly wealthy families with spacious homes.

    Even if observers remain skeptical that the new tax will cool prices on the real estate market. It should certainly become lucrative for China’s local governments. The Australian-New Zealand ANZ Bank, for example, estimates that up to $200 billion could be earned annually. Jörn Petring/ Gregor Koppenburg

    • Finance
    • Property tax
    • Real Estate

    News

    CO2-emissions increased in 2020

    China was responsible for more than 30 percent of global CO2 emissions in 2020, according to new figures released Thursday night. Between 2019 and 2020, China’s share of global emissions rose by two percentage points. However, this was tied to the Covid pandemic. As a result of the prolonged lockdown in Western states, emissions in these states dropped significantly. Climate scientists assume that this Covid effect on emissions was only short-term. For the year 2021, CO2 emissions in the US and Europe are expected to rise.

    Converted to the population, greenhouse gas emissions in China averaged 7.4 tons per capita and were thus only just behind those of Germany (7.7 tons per capita). US Americans emitted an average of over 14 tons of CO2 per year in 2020. However, these figures should also be treated with caution. This is because about a tenth of greenhouse gas emitted in China is due to the high export surplus and is thus indirectly caused abroad. Nevertheless, China remains one of the most important players at the climate conference currently held in Glasgow.

    China pulls out of pact against coal financing

    However, China refused to sign a treaty of 22 countries against the financing of fossil fuel projects. This puts Beijing in the company of South Korea, Japan, and Spain, which also consider the requirements too far-reaching. The agreement came about at the instigation of British Energy Minister Greg Hands. It provides for a complete phase-out of investments in the production or use of coal, gas, and oil by 2022. However, the document is not binding. Moreover, it only concerns new plans; financing for ongoing projects remains unaffected. Still, Hands trusts the pact to redirect $15 billion in public funds from dirty to clean projects. nib/fin

    • Climate
    • Coal power
    • COP26
    • Emissions

    EU delegation pledges support for Taiwan

    A European MEP delegation has pledged support for Taiwan and called for a strengthening of relations between Brussels and Taipei. “We came here with a very simple, very clear message: You are not alone. Europe is standing with you,” French EU politician Raphaël Glucksmann said in the presence of Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen in a meeting broadcast live on Facebook. “Our visit should be considered as an important first step,” said Glucksmann, who is leading the delegation. Next, he said, there needs to be “a very concrete agenda of high-level meetings” to build a stronger partnership between the EU and Taiwan. Taiwan’s democracy is a treasure that must be protected, Glucksmann said.

    Tsai warned against growing Chinese attempts to gain influence in Taiwan. She called on security agencies to counter efforts to infiltrate Taiwan – with the help of the EU. “We hope to establish a democratic alliance against disinformation,” Tsai said. It is the first official delegation from the EU Parliament to visit Taiwan. The MEPs are members of the Special Committee on Foreign Interference in all Democratic Processes (INGE).

    The government in Beijing condemned the meeting: China’s foreign office expressed “strong dissatisfaction and firm opposition” to the visit. “We have urged the EU to correct these mistakes and not send wrong signals to separatist forces advocating Taiwan independence.” An official said MEPs “should fully understand the complexity and sensitivity of the Taiwan issue, abide by the EU’s commitment to the One-China Principle… and safeguard the political basis of the development of China-EU relations.”

    Taipei is putting out feelers towards the EU in the face of increasing aggression from Beijing – but Brussels is still struggling to find a unified line (China.Table reported). ari

    • Geopolitics
    • Taiwan

    German frigate docks in Tokyo

    The German Armed Forces frigate “Bayern” will dock in Tokyo’s harbor on Friday. Following her visit to the Japanese capital, she is taking part in a joint maneuver with the US, Australia, Japan, and Canada as part of her Indo-Pacific mission. China feels increasingly surrounded by these nations. Most recently, a Pacific coalition against China has moved closer together with the Anglo-Saxon “Aukus” alliance (China.Table reported). The frigate had previously celebrated the Germany Unity Day in Australia in the friendliest way. In Shanghai, however, the Bayern was not welcome.

    In fact, Defence Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer has explicitly defended the mission by stating that she wants to contribute to the “preservation of the rule-based maritime order”. It is about “showing colors”, said its Vice Admiral. While the identity of the party that is disrupting order is not explicitly named, that talk is about China. The country is making sprawling territorial claims in the South China Sea. Meanwhile, the Japanese interpretation of the frigate’s visit to Tokyo is equally clear: Germany wants to strengthen allied democracies in the Pacific region. The business paper Nikkei assumes that in the post-Merkel era, the German government will take a more critical stance on China. fin

    • Geopolitics
    • Indo-Pacific
    • Military
    • South China Sea

    Shaanxi to introduce one year maternity leave

    The Chinese province of Shaanxi is planning to extend paid maternity leave to just under a year. The proposal is intended to increase the birth rate. So far, mothers are entitled to 168 days of maternity leave. Extending it by another six months would put Shaanxi’s standard on par with Germany and Norway, Reuters reported. The province is also pursuing plans to double paternity leave to 30 days for the third child, according to the report.

    In May, China had allowed couples to have three children. Even then, there were doubts whether the introduction of the three-child policy alone would lead to more births. In many cities, the cost of living is so high that couples can hardly afford to have children. Even then, there were calls for supportive measures for families. nib

    • Children
    • Demographics
    • Drei-Kind-Politik
    • Society

    Column

    Chinese games of confusion with business cards

    By Johnny Erling
    Ein Bild von Johnny Erling

    Ever since business people from all over the world are drawn to China – in the wake of Beijing’s reform and policy of opening-up – training courses on intercultural behavior to avoid gaffes have been booming. The correct way of handing over business cards is right at the top of the list of etiquette issues at consulting companies. After all, the People’s Republic follows ancient traditions. The only truth to this is that business cards were first used in China more than 2,000 years ago, but modern-day name and business cards and how to present or receive them were copied by the Chinese from Europeans and Japanese. Only since the digitalization of business cards has Beijing once again taken the lead.

    Two very specific traditional name cards played a role in global political events 121 years ago. They contributed to the sense of humiliation of the Chinese Empire. At issue was how the German commander-in-chief of the Allied intervention forces that stopped the Boxer Rebellion handled it. Alfred Graf von Waldersee kept the court’s highest-ranking envoys, Li Hongzhang and Prince Qing, waiting for a long time before deigning to receive them, even though both had announced themselves with their business cards in perfect form.

    This is how China’s calling cards once looked like. The two name cards of Prince Qing and Li Hongzhang, which they, as emissaries of the imperial court, had presented to the German commander-in-chief Graf von Waldersee days before he finally received them on November 15, 1900. From the estate of Hauptmann von Schönberg.

    Even more provocatively, Empress Dowager Cixi’s emissaries had to pay him their respects at Beijing’s imperial garden and lake complex Zhongnanhai (中南海), for that was where Waldersee had set up his headquarters. He lived in the Ziguangge (紫光阁), the more than 200-year-old “purple radiant pavilion”. The buildings next door housed his German entourage.

    It was November 15, 1900. “At 3 in the afternoon, we were graced with a historic moment,” wrote Oberstallmeister Fedor von Rauch in his diary: “The chief was expecting the two Chinese dignitaries… They may have found it hard to offer their reverential greeting to the German field marshal in the chambers of their sovereign. The audience lasted about an hour and a half.

    Illustration from the turn of the 19th and 20th century: A visitor carries a visiting card and strikes the door gong.

    The imperial court had appointed Li Hongzhang “envoy extraordinary and minister plenipotentiary for the purpose of restoring peace between China and foreign powers.” Prince Qing assisted. Waldersee, however, was not willing to meet with them until “after weeks of negotiation, they were comfortable in addressing a written audience request to him,” von Rauch reported. Both mandarins had their visit announced in the traditional Chinese manner and sent him their visiting cards in advance.

    In the estate of Captain von Schönberg, I discovered the name cards of Li and Prince Qing. They had written them with three characters, each in black ink from top to bottom, and brushed them on oblong red paper. The cards of other representatives of allied troops from eight countries, be it from the Japanese, Russians, Americans, or French, looked quite different. They were already printed in square formats on thin white paper, just as we know them today. In the UK, the Oscar Friedheim company, founded in 1884, was able to produce up to 100,000 individual cards a day by 1889. Their card cutting and engraving machines came from Germany.

    Business cards were traditionally delivered in special wooden boxes.

    It was not Europe that learned from China when it comes to handling the modern “Mingpian” (名片) business card, as many China etiquette books want us to believe. It was the other way around: The Chinese copied the European format, the bilingualism of the card, and their printing technique. From the Japanese, they learned how to use it. The Japanese had adopted the characters for the term “mingci” (名刺) from ancient Chinese, but they were the ones to conceive a perfectly formed ritual for them. It begins with holding the flat card between the thumb and index finger of both hands, and then handing it to the other person with a bow.

    China was a quick study. In 2018, the Beijing daily called the mass distribution of name cards in the People’s Republic today an important “tool for social contact” (“社会交往的重要工具”). Used for more than 2,000 years in China, nobles from distant principalities or kingdoms who visited higher-ranking rulers would enclose with their gifts and tributes platelets made of bamboo or wood called ye (谒). On them were the names of the bearers, and often details of their rank and their origin. Later dynasties used silk, cloth, and, from the Ming period onwards, paper.

    Modern printed cards appeared en masse with the economic boom after the Cultural Revolution in China in 1978. At first, the customers of Beijing’s small-scale printers despaired. They did not know any foreign languages and could not type foreign names without error. Only copying and scanning techniques solved the stubborn problem.

    The IT revolution helped China catch up and even pioneer the electronic business card of today. Especially after WeChat emerged in 2011 and the digital business card replaced the printed name card. According to recent data, more than 230 million Chinese used business cards from 2011 to 2021, including more than 50 million only digitally via apps, WeChat, and QR codes since 2017. In metropolises such as Shanghai, Beijing, and Shenzhen, the printed card is dying out.

    The digitization of the business card began in 2011. By 2021, more than 50 million Chinese will already be presenting their business cards online using QR codes, apps, and WeChat programs. There is enough advertising for the service, as the picture shows.

    Half a century after Waldersee made his brief guest appearance at Zhongnanhai, China’s Communists moved into the former Park of Emperors on June 15, 1949, even before they proclaimed their People’s Republic. Mao Zedong made Zhongnanhai the seat of the party and also lived there privately. The people have since called the heavily guarded area west of the imperial palace the “new forbidden city.”

    In its Purple Palace (Ziguange), China’s leadership nowadays sometimes receives illustrious foreign guests. It does not like to be reminded of the imperial pre-inhabitants. Still, even less of the time when a German commander-in-chief resided here and emissaries of the imperial house had to hand in their visiting cards to him. These were not the only things the Germans took with them when they left. They are also said to have taken all kinds of other art treasures.

    • Culture
    • Germany
    • Society
    • Trade

    Executive Moves

    Gerardo Madonna has returned for his new position from China: Madonna has been working in project control at VW in Wolfsburg since the beginning of the month. He was previously a manager at FAW-Volkswagen in Changchun.

    Wolfgang Schröer is the new HR Director for Production Joint Venture at Daimler Greater China. Schröer previously held various positions at Daimler AG.

    Dessert

    Fog in Tianjin. Or rather clouds? In any case, the roof of the Tianjin World Financial Center sticks out of the white soup. From the drone’s bird’s eye view, it looks like a ship in a sea of white waves. At 337 meters, the “Jin Tower” is high enough to provide a view from its highest floors as if from an airplane.

    China.Table Editors

    CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen