Table.Briefing: Europe

Criticism of the Single Market Emergency Instrument + Interview with Albania’s Prime Minister + Taxonomy lawsuit

  • Strong criticism of the Single Market Emergency Instrument
  • Albania’s Prime Minister Rama: ‘EU accession will not be easy’
  • Taxonomy: Greenpeace threatens legal action
  • ECB wants to take climate score into account
  • Study: EU wastes more food than it imports
  • Baltic states and Poland restrict entry for Russians
  • EU cuts funds for Hungary: Poland to ‘strongly oppose’
  • Terry Reintke to run for Green group leader in EU Parliament
  • Exploratory mission for conservative Ulf Kristersson in Sweden
  • Heads: Christian Johann – The bridger of gaps
Dear reader,

with the Single Market Emergency Instrument (SMEI), the EU Commission intends to learn the lessons taught by the pandemic. The emergency instrument enables the Commission to make deep interventions in the single market in the event of a crisis. “We don’t want a planned economy,” said the responsible commissioner, Thierry Breton, when presenting the proposal. However, that is precisely the accusation of the critics. The crisis measures would have “strong interventionist and planned economy features,” said Wolfgang Niedermark, a BDI’s executive board member. Also harsh in criticizing the proposal is Matthias Kullas, an internal market expert at the Center for European Policy. Berlin, on the other hand, welcomes the plans. Markus Grabitz knows the details.

“In the end, it depends on us how quickly we will meet all the conditions,” says Edi Rama, Prime Minister of Albania since 2013, about his country’s accession process to the EU. In an interview with Hans-Peter Siebenhaar, he talks about Brussels’ role in reforms in Albania, the impact of climate change on energy supplies, and the influence of China and Turkey. When it comes to freedom of the press, the news coming from the Balkan country are worrying – but Rama rejects accusations to that effect. “I am not an enemy of free media,” he says in an interview.

The Commission’s decision to include nuclear power and natural gas projects in the environmental taxonomy continues to cause heated debate. At the beginning of July, a veto motion by several MEPs to prevent the inclusion failed. Greenpeace is threatening to take the matter to the European Court of Justice. Read more in the news.

Your
Sarah Schaefer
Image of Sarah  Schaefer

Feature

Strong criticism of SMEI emergency instrument

Wolfgang Niedermark, a BDI’s Executive Board member, sees disproportionately profound intervention in the economy: “The EU Commission is shooting far beyond the announced goal of ensuring a functioning single market in times of crisis.” The crisis measures have “strong interventionist and planned economy features,” he said.

Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton had already tried to dispel precisely these concerns when presenting the proposal: “No, we do not want a planned economy. We want exactly the opposite. It’s about ensuring the smooth functioning of the internal market even in crises.”

The Single Market Emergency Instrument (SMEI) is one of the key measures that Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has planned for the coming months. With the emergency instrument, the Commission wants to draw the consequences of the Covid crisis. In the process, supply chains were threatened because member states went it alone nationally, did not allow medical personnel to leave the country, or prohibit the export of masks and respirators. “I was on the phone for days trying to reopen the borders and clear supply routes for strategically important products,” Breton said.

It should never come to that again. That is why the Commission has put together an emergency toolbox to keep the single market alive in the event of a pandemic or war.

Those who do not cooperate risk a fine

And these are the measures that companies could face in an emergency: Companies may be required to provide information about their production. The Commission can order them to prioritize the production of certain products. Failure to comply could result in fines and periodic penalty payments. The Commission can also crack down on member states: it can order them to take measures to secure supply chains.

It can ask member states to remove measures that jeopardize the single market. In emergency mode, member states are also required to notify the Commission of measures that threaten the supply of strategically important goods and services. The Commission can instruct the Member States to build national reserves of strategically important goods.

Andreas Schwab (CDU), an internal market expert in the EU Parliament, praises the Commission’s initiative: “The emergency instrument is the right response to the challenges of the Covid pandemic and Russia’s war of aggression on Ukraine.” He added that the EU must remain functional even in crisis mode. The MEP calls for “the EU to be smart on supply chain monitoring measures, strategic reserves, and prioritization of public procurement.”

After all, the point is to strengthen the single market and not to “restrict entrepreneurial freedom too much,” he said. This is especially true in non-crisis times, he said, adding that in an emergency supply chain resilience can best be ensured in close cooperation with companies and functioning markets.

SMEI follows traffic light circuit

The crisis instrument is to have three phases – red, yellow, and green – like traffic lights. At normal times – i.e., when the light is green – the Commission simply collects information from member states and companies to regularly present a well-founded risk assessment. When crises are looming, the traffic light jumps to yellow. In this phase of heightened vigilance, the Commission analyzes the risk of interrupted supply chains for strategically important products and services. Products are identified for which member states are to build national reserves.

If the member states fail to set aside the necessary reserves, the Commission can instruct them. In crisis mode, the traffic light switches to red, at which point restrictive measures are possible. For some products, the Commission has its own instruments to avoid shortages. Therefore, the SMEI is not applied to chips, medical devices, and energy sources.

The Commission decides whether to activate the yellow (“vigilance”) phase. It is counseled by the Advisory Group, which comprises representatives of the Commission and one member from each Member State. The phase of increased vigilance is declared for up to six months and controlled by the Member states in the so-called comitology procedure.

The red phase (emergency mode) is triggered by a qualified majority in the Council of Ministers. The emergency mode can also be imposed for six months and is renewable depending on how the crisis develops.

‘No added value in managing a crisis’

The BDI criticizes the decision-making processes as too vague: “Great uncertainty arises for business if it is impossible to understand the definition of a crisis and which goods and commodities are of strategic importance.”

Matthias Kullas, an expert on the internal market at the Center for European Policy (CEP), takes a hard line on the proposal, saying it is “an arrogation of knowledge and a massive encroachment on entrepreneurial freedom.” It is the task of companies to adapt quickly to changing circumstances and thus counteract shortages; the prospect of higher profits provides the incentive to do so. The Commission could help companies by reducing bureaucracy.

But: “Entrusting state administrations with the task of counteracting shortages will have no added value in managing a crisis.” At best, he says, “only” unnecessary bureaucracy is created. “At worst, resources will be misdirected,” Kullas warns.

The Green-led Federal Ministry of Economics said in Berlin on Monday that the government welcomes the proposal to maintain the free movement of goods and services in the EU’s internal market in case of future crises. The European Union must improve its crisis preparedness, it said. The corresponding EU regulation should thus now be analyzed in detail. With rtr

  • European policy
  • Supply chains

Edi Rama: ‘EU accession will not be easy’

Edi Rama has been Prime Minister of Albania since 2013. He was last confirmed in parliament with an absolute majority in September 2021.

Prime Minister, how much does the Ukraine war threaten stability and peace in the Balkans?

Edi Rama: It is a potential threat to our region. Because Russia has traditionally had a strong influence in parts of the Balkan. This is particularly true of Serbia, Montenegro, northern Macedonia, and the Republic of Srpska in Bosnia-Herzegovina.

What does this mean for the EU’s sanctions policy against Russia?

We must do everything possible to keep the potential threat away from the Balkans. Therefore, there should be no more pressure on Serbia to impose sanctions against Russia. Such sanctions are impossible because Serbia cannot survive without Russia. Moreover, the government and President Aleksandar Vučić would not survive sanctions against Russia politically. Serbia has already shown its stance. We must not forget that Belgrade has already voted against Russia three times in the UN. This is a big surprise. It is also a sign that there is a strong will in Belgrade to integrate into the EU.

In the Western Balkans, cooperation between the individual countries is growing very slowly. You would like to establish a kind of mini-Schengen between Serbia, Albania, and Montenegro. What are the chances for this to happen?

We need the free movement of people, goods, and services between our countries. This is part of our way into the EU. It is very important because it increases the chances for higher economic growth. All of us in the Western Balkans are very small markets. Therefore, further isolation is very disadvantageous for us economically. Already today we see the benefits of rapprochement in the Western Balkans through increased trade volume.

On July 19, the EU opened accession negotiations with Albania and northern Macedonia. How quickly will the talks progress?

It is very difficult to predict possible progress in the accession talks. It will not be easy. It will take us years to complete the road to the EU. In the end, it depends on ourselves how quickly we will meet all the conditions. But the EU’s constructive attitude to an expansion in the Western Balkans is also very important.

How does this constructive attitude manifest itself?

We are very happy about the transfer of know-how by the EU to move our country forward. No other institution in the world is more able to improve state organizations and support countries in their reform efforts to establish a functioning administration or an independent judiciary. It is thus fortunate for countries like Albania to receive this EU support at present.

‘Merkel has been a godsend for the Western Balkans’

Is Albania receiving sufficient support from Germany on its way to Europe? What do you expect from Chancellor Olaf Scholz?

I am very pleased with the way Germany and other EU member states are supporting the expansion process in our region. I am pleased that Chancellor Scholz is continuing the policy of his predecessor Angela Merkel. Scholz told me that Angela Merkel had specifically asked him to continue to regard the Western Balkans as a foreign policy priority.

You have a special relationship with Angela Merkel

Chancellor Merkel has a deep understanding of the Western Balkans. A possible reason is that she has gained experience in a dictatorship. Therefore, she understood better than others what this historical legacy from communist times means for us. With the Berlin Process, she developed a real vision for the entire region. She succeeded in gathering all heads of state and government around one table for the first time in the history of the Western Balkans. Angela Merkel was a godsend for the Western Balkans.

Europe is struggling with a threatening energy crisis. What do the high electricity and gas prices mean for Albania?

We are blessed with an advantage. We can cover our electricity needs with hydropower. Thus, our energy production is already 100 percent green. We are in no way dependent on Russian gas. But we do depend on the blessing of the Lord in heaven to send us sufficient rainfall despite climate change (laughs). After all, in the past five years, we have had the driest period in our history. We run the risk of being dependent on energy imports in the future and would then fall into the same dependency as our neighbors in the region.

What measures has your government taken to guarantee the security of supply in times of climate change?

Basically, we will diversify our energy production. We are currently building two large solar parks in Albania. Further projects are in the pipeline. We will also expand wind energy. Furthermore, LNG is an issue for us. After all, the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline delivers gas from Azerbaijan via Greece to our southern coast and to Italy. We are also involved in the Ionian-Adriatic Pipeline project, which will deliver gas from Albania through Montenegro and Herzegovina to Croatia. This new pipeline will be connected to the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline.

Albania has oil and gas fields. Is there any progress in the exploration of fossil fuels?

We are waiting with great anticipation for the research results of the British oil company Shell. Large reserves of oil and gas have been discovered in the southeast of our country. The question is how economically viable extraction can be. The deposits lie very deep. Shell is currently carrying out appropriate tests. Separately from this field, I am convinced that Albania will become an energy exporter by 2030.

How do you deal with the high electricity price?

We have decided to keep energy prices for households and small businesses stable. We are thus at the same price level as last September. For us as a government, this means that we have to finance the gap between the capped energy price and the market price with large sums from the budget.

Currently, inflation has put the European economy in a headlock. How are you coping with the price increases in Albania?

With a forecast inflation rate of 5.5 percent, we have the lowest in our region. This is also due to our policy of capping energy prices. We are feeling the economic pain caused by inflation. Although it’s little consolation, that pain is more severe among our neighbors.

Planned NATO base

Let’s talk about the security policy of the NATO country Albania. Will there be a NATO base in Durrës? What significance will the naval base have?

The NATO naval base is related to the construction of a modern and commercial port outside the city of Durrës. We are working closely with NATO to create this NATO base. It is important for Albania at the entrance to the Adriatic Sea, but also for the security of the entire region. However, we are still at the beginning of the project.

How influential is China in the region?

In Albania, we do not have a strong Chinese presence. For example, the Chinese no longer own the airport in Tirana. They still own an important oil field and a number of smaller companies. That is all. But one thing is clear, Beijing has strong long-term economic interests in the region.

What about Turkey’s influence?

It is a myth that Turkey has allegedly built many mosques in Albania. This is not true. There is just one mosque that was built with Turkish support. In trade, on the other hand, the importance is growing.

And what about political influence?

Turkey has never interfered in our path to the European Union or in security policy issues. Because of our history, we have strong relations with Turkey – but nothing more.

Let’s return to the present. Most recently, in a guest article in the “Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung,” you were strongly attacked for not respecting the freedom of the press and journalists …

… I am really very sad about this fake news spread by respected quality media in big democracies. Honestly, I wonder how we can respond to such baseless accusations?

The text says: “Rama already denigrated journalists in front of running cameras as garbage cans, parasites, pigs and prostitutes.” Recently, you allegedly threatened a journalist with re-education.

In this article in the newspaper, which I hold in high esteem, quotes were put into my mouth that I never said in this way. Statements were taken out of context. This is all very sad for me. Such contributions move Albania regarding the question of freedom of the press into a corner, in which we do not belong. We are a country where anyone can say anything anywhere – without being discriminated against or disadvantaged.

In the current Reporters Without Borders ranking, however, your country is the 103rd out of 180 states. Not exactly a compliment.

That is a terrible assessment! The fact is that we do not have journalists who are threatened or even imprisoned. There are no restrictions on editorial offices and no government court cases against journalists. I am not an enemy of free media. Despite everything, I am the target of attacks. I have never said to journalists, you are garbage, pigs, or parasites. Never! But such unjustified attacks make for bad reviews.

Note: For some time now, various media – not only the “FAZ” – have been reporting on concerns about press freedom in Albania and the Prime Minister’s tense dealings with journalists.

  • Albania
  • Balkans
  • Energy policy
  • EU accession
  • European policy

News

Taxonomy: Greenpeace threatens legal action

Several country offices of the environmental organization Greenpeace have announced an action before the European Court of Justice if the Commission does not revise the Delegated Act, which includes nuclear power and natural gas projects in the environmental taxonomy. Greenpeace Germany, in cooperation with its country offices in Spain, Italy, Belgium, France, Luxembourg, the EU, and Central and Eastern Europe, lodged a formal objection to the Commission’s decision in early September.

“With this taxonomy, the EU betrays its self-imposed environmental and climate goals of the Green New Deal,” said Martin Kaiser, Executive Director of Greenpeace Germany. “That’s why we urge the Commission to correct this blatant failure and repeal the Delegated Act on gas and nuclear.” Otherwise, Greenpeace will appeal to the European Court of Justice, Kaiser said. The Commission has until the end of December to respond to the appeal. It can extend the deadline until February 2023.

Austria and Luxembourg also want to sue

In Parliament, the veto motion of several MEPs to prevent the inclusion of natural gas and nuclear power projects in the green taxonomy failed at the beginning of July. The corresponding Delegated Act will thus enter into force on January 1, 2023.

“With Greenpeace’s lawsuit on the green taxonomy and the inclusion of gas and nuclear, civil society must take on what the institutions have failed to do: create a green taxonomy that is not a hoax,” said Green MEP Michael Bloss. At the same time, the Parliament must also use its ability to sue, he said: “The EU Parliament must not watch on the sidelines while civil society and member states fight greenwashing for gas and nuclear in court.”

In addition to other environmental associations such as Deutsche Umwelthilfe, the Austrian government has announced that it will appeal against this decision. It is receiving support from Luxembourg, among others. The Austrian Environment Ministry said it would take legal action before mid-October. leo

  • Natural gas
  • Nuclear power
  • Taxonomy

ECB wants to take climate score into account

The European Central Bank (ECB) intends to pay even closer attention to climate protection criteria when buying corporate bonds in the future. For this purpose, it will take into account a so-called climate score – a score regarding the emission of greenhouse gases and the company’s climate targets – in all purchases of such bonds from October. As the ECB further announced on Monday, this will initially apply to the reinvestment of maturing cash from existing bonds.

However, the ECB will not reject securities even if the issuer has a low climate score. However, the climate score assigned to each company will not be made transparent. “One objective is to reduce the exposure of the Eurosystem to climate-related financial risks,” the ECB said of its plans. The measures are aimed at the green transformation of the economy and are in line with the European Union’s climate neutrality goals. rtr

  • Climate & Environment
  • ECB

Study: EU wastes more food than it imports

In 2021, the EU imported nearly 138 million tons of agricultural products. A study citing recent data from the UN Food Waste Index shows that at the same time, the EU wastes 153.5 million tons of food each year. “At a time of high food prices and a cost of living crisis, it is a scandal that the EU is throwing away more food than it imports,” criticizes Frank Mechielsen, Executive Director at Feedback EU. The NGO conducted the research.

Mechielsen calls for legally binding EU-wide targets to halve food waste from farm to fork by 2030, combat climate change and improve food security. This demand is supported by numerous environmental organizations in a joint statement.

According to the European Environmental Bureau(EEB), food waste costs businesses and households in the EU about €143 billion yearly and accounts for at least 6 percent of EU greenhouse gas emissions. About 20 percent of EU food production is wasted, so halving food waste could save 4.7 million hectares of agricultural land by 2030, the EEB said.

Commission proposal before the end of this year

EU countries had pledged at the UN to halve food waste, recalls Piotr Barczak, Senior Policy Officer at EEB. “However, almost ten years later, they have not achieved much, and our economies still generate incredibly high amounts of food waste.”

The Commission is already planning to present a proposal for legally binding targets for food waste in EU member states this year. Martin Häusling, MEP and agricultural policy spokesman for the Green Group, says that mere targets are not enough. He demands that the Commission also present concrete legislative proposals on how the targets are to be achieved.

“The European Parliament has made it clear in its resolution on the farm-to-fork strategy that instruments such as the revision of the expiration date need to be addressed ambitiously. In addition, we need binding targets at every stage of the supply chain to achieve the necessary reduction in food waste,” says Häusling. luk

  • Climate & Environment
  • Climate Policy
  • European policy
  • Food
  • Klimapolitik
  • Nutrition

Baltic states and Poland restrict entry for Russians

The Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, as well as Poland, are further restricting entry for Russian citizens. As of Monday, they will keep the borders closed for citizens of the neighboring country with a Schengen visa for tourist stays, business trips, sports, and cultural events. Corresponding regulations will come into force simultaneously in the four EU and NATO countries. However, certain exceptions apply, for example, to Russians with residence, right of abode, or relatives, as well as for humanitarian reasons. Dissidents will also be allowed to enter the country.

In response to Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine, the governments of the Baltic states and Poland had already largely suspended the issuance of visas and residence permits to Russians. With a valid visa, however, it was still possible to enter the Schengen area via the borders of the four countries. This will no longer be possible in the future: all Russian citizens with Schengen visas will now be denied entry – regardless of which member country issued the visa. The Schengen area includes 22 EU states and 4 other European countries.

Lithuania targets citizens from Belarus

Estonia’s Head of Government Kaja Kallas renewed calls for other countries to join the entry ban, which is controversial within the EU. “We should use all the tools in the toolbox to actually pressure Russia into ending this war,” she said Saturday. “Only 30 percent of Russian citizens have a foreign passport, most of them are residents of St Petersburg and Moscow, the Russian elites. If they are not satisfied with the deeds of the Kremlin, if they are feeling this on their skin, also they will put pressure on the Kremlin to end this war.”

Lithuania is also considering closing its border to citizens of neighboring Belarus. “This issue is under consideration, discussions are taking place,” Interior Minister Agnė Bilotaitė said Monday during a visit to the Baltic EU and NATO country’s border with Belarus. “I think that there are very serious arguments to consider the inclusion of Belarus as well,” she said, according to the BNS agency. The goal, she said, is to reach an agreement at the regional and even European level. dpa

  • baltic states
  • European policy
  • Poland

EU funds reduction for Hungary: Poland intends to ‘strongly oppose’

Poland intends to resist the EU Commission’s planned cut in EU funds for Hungary. “Poland will strongly oppose any actions of European institutions that intend to illegally deprive any member states of funds, in this case, Hungary in particular,” Head of Government Mateusz Morawiecki said Sunday in the Silesian town of Kamienica. However, he said, there were signals from Budapest and Brussels that a solution to the dispute was being worked on.

Due to corruption and other violations of the rule of law in Hungary, the EU Commission proposed on Sunday to cut payments of around €7.5 billion from the EU budget to the country. It is the first time that the EU Commission proposed this step due to shortcomings in the rule of law in an EU country. In order to actually cut money from the EU budget to the country, at least 15 countries with at least 65 percent of the EU population would now have to agree to the proposal. dpa

  • EU
  • European Commission

Terry Reintke runs for Greens group leader in EU Parliament

German Terry Reintke wants to become Chairwoman of the Greens in the European Parliament. “After intensive deliberations and numerous discussions, I have decided to run for Co-president in October,” reads a letter sent to the group on Monday and obtained by Deutsche Presse-Agentur.

The previous chairwoman, Ska Keller, had resigned only last week. The 40-year-old German had led the group since 2016 together with Belgian Philippe Lamberts and justified the move by saying she wanted to make room for a new generation. Her successor is to be elected in mid-October. The Green Group is currently the fourth-largest group in the European Parliament, with 72 members.

In her letter, Reintke, 35, points to increasing challenges in the coming months that could only be solved at the European level. She cites, among other things, the Russian war against Ukraine, the energy crisis, a too-slow response to the climate crisis, and increasing social inequality. In addition, she said, the groundwork for the 2024 European elections must be laid.

Reintke was born in the Ruhr region, has been a member of the European Parliament since 2014, and has been Deputy Leader of the Parliamentary Group since the current legislative period in 2019. Among other things, she campaigns for women’s rights, the protection of democracy and the rule of law, and the rights of LGBTI people. dpa

  • European Parliament
  • European policy

Exploratory mission for conservative Ulf Kristersson in Sweden

Conservative Ulf Kristersson may try his hand at forming a government after Sweden’s close parliamentary election. Parliamentary Speaker Andreas Norlén gave the Moderate Party Leader the exploratory mandate on Monday to sound out the possibilities of forming a new government. Norlén made the announcement at a press conference in Stockholm on Monday after talks with the leaders of Sweden’s parliamentary parties.

As the leader of the Moderates, Kristersson is counting on a narrow majority of a four-party bloc. For the first time after a Swedish election, this camp also includes the anti-immigration Sweden Democrats. About a week ago, they achieved a record result of 20.5 percent in the parliamentary elections, replacing the Moderates as the second strongest party in the country behind the Social Democrats for the first time. However, whether the four parties can agree on a basis for government is still unclear, as is the future role of the right-wing populists in such a constellation. dpa

  • Sweden

Heads

Christian Johann – bridging gaps

Christian Johann is the Director of the European Academy Berlin (EAB).

Christian Johann sticks his tongue out. And on the highly official website of the European Academy Berlin at that. On a picture that introduces him as the director. What a great title: Director of an academy, based in a villa in Grunewald. It all sounds so statesmanlike, he thinks. He could be photographed in tails and tie, but that would defeat the academy’s purpose. The only help is a break in style, hence the picture with the tongue.

Johann is 40 and has been Director of the European Academy Berlin for two years. When he meets new people, he introduces himself like this: “I’m part of an organization that bridges the gap between people and Europe.” The EAB is a political education center hosting conferences, meetings, and seminars on topics related to European politics. Johann thinks the whole purpose of his work is to be approachable. Here, anyone and everyone should find access to Europe. Without previous education. People should be encouraged to question: What does Europe have to do with my life?

The specialty: The house’s guest groups are very diverse. It happens that at noon the commanders of the Air Force come in for a training course. In the afternoon, students meet to discuss the extinction of species.

Hunger for co-design

Johann did not grow up a fan of Europe. His parents fled the GDR for West Berlin when he was three years old. He no longer remembers the place “over there.” But his parents do, and they took something with them: skepticism about politics. Such topics were never discussed at the dinner table. But Johann himself always had a hunger for understanding, for participation. At 18, he joined the SPD.

Judo and political education are similar. Johann takes many of his skills from Japanese martial arts. He was eight years old when he first went to judo lessons. He was 15 when he started teaching himself.

He taught his students how to take responsibility for their opponents. How they can let off steam, but under firm rules. And how they keep a big goal in mind – maybe the next belt color – even though it takes years to reach it. Perseverance is the most crucial skill for Johann. “In my work, it’s hard to see direct results immediately. I want to encourage critical thinking. How do you measure that?” he says.

The academy now has a Tiktok channel

The EAB has been around since the 1960s. When he took office, Johann set out to knead the EAB like pizza dough. For example, he made an effort to create a Tiktok channel for the EAB. Since he works there, there have also been new forms of events: Together with the fashion platform Zalando, Johann brought Ukrainian fashion labels to Berlin in the Villa’s garden. There they were allowed to exhibit their new designs.

1,500 visitors came and donated. Among them were many hipsters, who spoke only English and had made their way to the bourgeois Grunewald for the first time. Anna Scheld

  • European policy
  • Ukraine

Europe.Table Editorial Office

EUROPE.TABLE EDITORS

Licenses:
    • Strong criticism of the Single Market Emergency Instrument
    • Albania’s Prime Minister Rama: ‘EU accession will not be easy’
    • Taxonomy: Greenpeace threatens legal action
    • ECB wants to take climate score into account
    • Study: EU wastes more food than it imports
    • Baltic states and Poland restrict entry for Russians
    • EU cuts funds for Hungary: Poland to ‘strongly oppose’
    • Terry Reintke to run for Green group leader in EU Parliament
    • Exploratory mission for conservative Ulf Kristersson in Sweden
    • Heads: Christian Johann – The bridger of gaps
    Dear reader,

    with the Single Market Emergency Instrument (SMEI), the EU Commission intends to learn the lessons taught by the pandemic. The emergency instrument enables the Commission to make deep interventions in the single market in the event of a crisis. “We don’t want a planned economy,” said the responsible commissioner, Thierry Breton, when presenting the proposal. However, that is precisely the accusation of the critics. The crisis measures would have “strong interventionist and planned economy features,” said Wolfgang Niedermark, a BDI’s executive board member. Also harsh in criticizing the proposal is Matthias Kullas, an internal market expert at the Center for European Policy. Berlin, on the other hand, welcomes the plans. Markus Grabitz knows the details.

    “In the end, it depends on us how quickly we will meet all the conditions,” says Edi Rama, Prime Minister of Albania since 2013, about his country’s accession process to the EU. In an interview with Hans-Peter Siebenhaar, he talks about Brussels’ role in reforms in Albania, the impact of climate change on energy supplies, and the influence of China and Turkey. When it comes to freedom of the press, the news coming from the Balkan country are worrying – but Rama rejects accusations to that effect. “I am not an enemy of free media,” he says in an interview.

    The Commission’s decision to include nuclear power and natural gas projects in the environmental taxonomy continues to cause heated debate. At the beginning of July, a veto motion by several MEPs to prevent the inclusion failed. Greenpeace is threatening to take the matter to the European Court of Justice. Read more in the news.

    Your
    Sarah Schaefer
    Image of Sarah  Schaefer

    Feature

    Strong criticism of SMEI emergency instrument

    Wolfgang Niedermark, a BDI’s Executive Board member, sees disproportionately profound intervention in the economy: “The EU Commission is shooting far beyond the announced goal of ensuring a functioning single market in times of crisis.” The crisis measures have “strong interventionist and planned economy features,” he said.

    Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton had already tried to dispel precisely these concerns when presenting the proposal: “No, we do not want a planned economy. We want exactly the opposite. It’s about ensuring the smooth functioning of the internal market even in crises.”

    The Single Market Emergency Instrument (SMEI) is one of the key measures that Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has planned for the coming months. With the emergency instrument, the Commission wants to draw the consequences of the Covid crisis. In the process, supply chains were threatened because member states went it alone nationally, did not allow medical personnel to leave the country, or prohibit the export of masks and respirators. “I was on the phone for days trying to reopen the borders and clear supply routes for strategically important products,” Breton said.

    It should never come to that again. That is why the Commission has put together an emergency toolbox to keep the single market alive in the event of a pandemic or war.

    Those who do not cooperate risk a fine

    And these are the measures that companies could face in an emergency: Companies may be required to provide information about their production. The Commission can order them to prioritize the production of certain products. Failure to comply could result in fines and periodic penalty payments. The Commission can also crack down on member states: it can order them to take measures to secure supply chains.

    It can ask member states to remove measures that jeopardize the single market. In emergency mode, member states are also required to notify the Commission of measures that threaten the supply of strategically important goods and services. The Commission can instruct the Member States to build national reserves of strategically important goods.

    Andreas Schwab (CDU), an internal market expert in the EU Parliament, praises the Commission’s initiative: “The emergency instrument is the right response to the challenges of the Covid pandemic and Russia’s war of aggression on Ukraine.” He added that the EU must remain functional even in crisis mode. The MEP calls for “the EU to be smart on supply chain monitoring measures, strategic reserves, and prioritization of public procurement.”

    After all, the point is to strengthen the single market and not to “restrict entrepreneurial freedom too much,” he said. This is especially true in non-crisis times, he said, adding that in an emergency supply chain resilience can best be ensured in close cooperation with companies and functioning markets.

    SMEI follows traffic light circuit

    The crisis instrument is to have three phases – red, yellow, and green – like traffic lights. At normal times – i.e., when the light is green – the Commission simply collects information from member states and companies to regularly present a well-founded risk assessment. When crises are looming, the traffic light jumps to yellow. In this phase of heightened vigilance, the Commission analyzes the risk of interrupted supply chains for strategically important products and services. Products are identified for which member states are to build national reserves.

    If the member states fail to set aside the necessary reserves, the Commission can instruct them. In crisis mode, the traffic light switches to red, at which point restrictive measures are possible. For some products, the Commission has its own instruments to avoid shortages. Therefore, the SMEI is not applied to chips, medical devices, and energy sources.

    The Commission decides whether to activate the yellow (“vigilance”) phase. It is counseled by the Advisory Group, which comprises representatives of the Commission and one member from each Member State. The phase of increased vigilance is declared for up to six months and controlled by the Member states in the so-called comitology procedure.

    The red phase (emergency mode) is triggered by a qualified majority in the Council of Ministers. The emergency mode can also be imposed for six months and is renewable depending on how the crisis develops.

    ‘No added value in managing a crisis’

    The BDI criticizes the decision-making processes as too vague: “Great uncertainty arises for business if it is impossible to understand the definition of a crisis and which goods and commodities are of strategic importance.”

    Matthias Kullas, an expert on the internal market at the Center for European Policy (CEP), takes a hard line on the proposal, saying it is “an arrogation of knowledge and a massive encroachment on entrepreneurial freedom.” It is the task of companies to adapt quickly to changing circumstances and thus counteract shortages; the prospect of higher profits provides the incentive to do so. The Commission could help companies by reducing bureaucracy.

    But: “Entrusting state administrations with the task of counteracting shortages will have no added value in managing a crisis.” At best, he says, “only” unnecessary bureaucracy is created. “At worst, resources will be misdirected,” Kullas warns.

    The Green-led Federal Ministry of Economics said in Berlin on Monday that the government welcomes the proposal to maintain the free movement of goods and services in the EU’s internal market in case of future crises. The European Union must improve its crisis preparedness, it said. The corresponding EU regulation should thus now be analyzed in detail. With rtr

    • European policy
    • Supply chains

    Edi Rama: ‘EU accession will not be easy’

    Edi Rama has been Prime Minister of Albania since 2013. He was last confirmed in parliament with an absolute majority in September 2021.

    Prime Minister, how much does the Ukraine war threaten stability and peace in the Balkans?

    Edi Rama: It is a potential threat to our region. Because Russia has traditionally had a strong influence in parts of the Balkan. This is particularly true of Serbia, Montenegro, northern Macedonia, and the Republic of Srpska in Bosnia-Herzegovina.

    What does this mean for the EU’s sanctions policy against Russia?

    We must do everything possible to keep the potential threat away from the Balkans. Therefore, there should be no more pressure on Serbia to impose sanctions against Russia. Such sanctions are impossible because Serbia cannot survive without Russia. Moreover, the government and President Aleksandar Vučić would not survive sanctions against Russia politically. Serbia has already shown its stance. We must not forget that Belgrade has already voted against Russia three times in the UN. This is a big surprise. It is also a sign that there is a strong will in Belgrade to integrate into the EU.

    In the Western Balkans, cooperation between the individual countries is growing very slowly. You would like to establish a kind of mini-Schengen between Serbia, Albania, and Montenegro. What are the chances for this to happen?

    We need the free movement of people, goods, and services between our countries. This is part of our way into the EU. It is very important because it increases the chances for higher economic growth. All of us in the Western Balkans are very small markets. Therefore, further isolation is very disadvantageous for us economically. Already today we see the benefits of rapprochement in the Western Balkans through increased trade volume.

    On July 19, the EU opened accession negotiations with Albania and northern Macedonia. How quickly will the talks progress?

    It is very difficult to predict possible progress in the accession talks. It will not be easy. It will take us years to complete the road to the EU. In the end, it depends on ourselves how quickly we will meet all the conditions. But the EU’s constructive attitude to an expansion in the Western Balkans is also very important.

    How does this constructive attitude manifest itself?

    We are very happy about the transfer of know-how by the EU to move our country forward. No other institution in the world is more able to improve state organizations and support countries in their reform efforts to establish a functioning administration or an independent judiciary. It is thus fortunate for countries like Albania to receive this EU support at present.

    ‘Merkel has been a godsend for the Western Balkans’

    Is Albania receiving sufficient support from Germany on its way to Europe? What do you expect from Chancellor Olaf Scholz?

    I am very pleased with the way Germany and other EU member states are supporting the expansion process in our region. I am pleased that Chancellor Scholz is continuing the policy of his predecessor Angela Merkel. Scholz told me that Angela Merkel had specifically asked him to continue to regard the Western Balkans as a foreign policy priority.

    You have a special relationship with Angela Merkel

    Chancellor Merkel has a deep understanding of the Western Balkans. A possible reason is that she has gained experience in a dictatorship. Therefore, she understood better than others what this historical legacy from communist times means for us. With the Berlin Process, she developed a real vision for the entire region. She succeeded in gathering all heads of state and government around one table for the first time in the history of the Western Balkans. Angela Merkel was a godsend for the Western Balkans.

    Europe is struggling with a threatening energy crisis. What do the high electricity and gas prices mean for Albania?

    We are blessed with an advantage. We can cover our electricity needs with hydropower. Thus, our energy production is already 100 percent green. We are in no way dependent on Russian gas. But we do depend on the blessing of the Lord in heaven to send us sufficient rainfall despite climate change (laughs). After all, in the past five years, we have had the driest period in our history. We run the risk of being dependent on energy imports in the future and would then fall into the same dependency as our neighbors in the region.

    What measures has your government taken to guarantee the security of supply in times of climate change?

    Basically, we will diversify our energy production. We are currently building two large solar parks in Albania. Further projects are in the pipeline. We will also expand wind energy. Furthermore, LNG is an issue for us. After all, the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline delivers gas from Azerbaijan via Greece to our southern coast and to Italy. We are also involved in the Ionian-Adriatic Pipeline project, which will deliver gas from Albania through Montenegro and Herzegovina to Croatia. This new pipeline will be connected to the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline.

    Albania has oil and gas fields. Is there any progress in the exploration of fossil fuels?

    We are waiting with great anticipation for the research results of the British oil company Shell. Large reserves of oil and gas have been discovered in the southeast of our country. The question is how economically viable extraction can be. The deposits lie very deep. Shell is currently carrying out appropriate tests. Separately from this field, I am convinced that Albania will become an energy exporter by 2030.

    How do you deal with the high electricity price?

    We have decided to keep energy prices for households and small businesses stable. We are thus at the same price level as last September. For us as a government, this means that we have to finance the gap between the capped energy price and the market price with large sums from the budget.

    Currently, inflation has put the European economy in a headlock. How are you coping with the price increases in Albania?

    With a forecast inflation rate of 5.5 percent, we have the lowest in our region. This is also due to our policy of capping energy prices. We are feeling the economic pain caused by inflation. Although it’s little consolation, that pain is more severe among our neighbors.

    Planned NATO base

    Let’s talk about the security policy of the NATO country Albania. Will there be a NATO base in Durrës? What significance will the naval base have?

    The NATO naval base is related to the construction of a modern and commercial port outside the city of Durrës. We are working closely with NATO to create this NATO base. It is important for Albania at the entrance to the Adriatic Sea, but also for the security of the entire region. However, we are still at the beginning of the project.

    How influential is China in the region?

    In Albania, we do not have a strong Chinese presence. For example, the Chinese no longer own the airport in Tirana. They still own an important oil field and a number of smaller companies. That is all. But one thing is clear, Beijing has strong long-term economic interests in the region.

    What about Turkey’s influence?

    It is a myth that Turkey has allegedly built many mosques in Albania. This is not true. There is just one mosque that was built with Turkish support. In trade, on the other hand, the importance is growing.

    And what about political influence?

    Turkey has never interfered in our path to the European Union or in security policy issues. Because of our history, we have strong relations with Turkey – but nothing more.

    Let’s return to the present. Most recently, in a guest article in the “Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung,” you were strongly attacked for not respecting the freedom of the press and journalists …

    … I am really very sad about this fake news spread by respected quality media in big democracies. Honestly, I wonder how we can respond to such baseless accusations?

    The text says: “Rama already denigrated journalists in front of running cameras as garbage cans, parasites, pigs and prostitutes.” Recently, you allegedly threatened a journalist with re-education.

    In this article in the newspaper, which I hold in high esteem, quotes were put into my mouth that I never said in this way. Statements were taken out of context. This is all very sad for me. Such contributions move Albania regarding the question of freedom of the press into a corner, in which we do not belong. We are a country where anyone can say anything anywhere – without being discriminated against or disadvantaged.

    In the current Reporters Without Borders ranking, however, your country is the 103rd out of 180 states. Not exactly a compliment.

    That is a terrible assessment! The fact is that we do not have journalists who are threatened or even imprisoned. There are no restrictions on editorial offices and no government court cases against journalists. I am not an enemy of free media. Despite everything, I am the target of attacks. I have never said to journalists, you are garbage, pigs, or parasites. Never! But such unjustified attacks make for bad reviews.

    Note: For some time now, various media – not only the “FAZ” – have been reporting on concerns about press freedom in Albania and the Prime Minister’s tense dealings with journalists.

    • Albania
    • Balkans
    • Energy policy
    • EU accession
    • European policy

    News

    Taxonomy: Greenpeace threatens legal action

    Several country offices of the environmental organization Greenpeace have announced an action before the European Court of Justice if the Commission does not revise the Delegated Act, which includes nuclear power and natural gas projects in the environmental taxonomy. Greenpeace Germany, in cooperation with its country offices in Spain, Italy, Belgium, France, Luxembourg, the EU, and Central and Eastern Europe, lodged a formal objection to the Commission’s decision in early September.

    “With this taxonomy, the EU betrays its self-imposed environmental and climate goals of the Green New Deal,” said Martin Kaiser, Executive Director of Greenpeace Germany. “That’s why we urge the Commission to correct this blatant failure and repeal the Delegated Act on gas and nuclear.” Otherwise, Greenpeace will appeal to the European Court of Justice, Kaiser said. The Commission has until the end of December to respond to the appeal. It can extend the deadline until February 2023.

    Austria and Luxembourg also want to sue

    In Parliament, the veto motion of several MEPs to prevent the inclusion of natural gas and nuclear power projects in the green taxonomy failed at the beginning of July. The corresponding Delegated Act will thus enter into force on January 1, 2023.

    “With Greenpeace’s lawsuit on the green taxonomy and the inclusion of gas and nuclear, civil society must take on what the institutions have failed to do: create a green taxonomy that is not a hoax,” said Green MEP Michael Bloss. At the same time, the Parliament must also use its ability to sue, he said: “The EU Parliament must not watch on the sidelines while civil society and member states fight greenwashing for gas and nuclear in court.”

    In addition to other environmental associations such as Deutsche Umwelthilfe, the Austrian government has announced that it will appeal against this decision. It is receiving support from Luxembourg, among others. The Austrian Environment Ministry said it would take legal action before mid-October. leo

    • Natural gas
    • Nuclear power
    • Taxonomy

    ECB wants to take climate score into account

    The European Central Bank (ECB) intends to pay even closer attention to climate protection criteria when buying corporate bonds in the future. For this purpose, it will take into account a so-called climate score – a score regarding the emission of greenhouse gases and the company’s climate targets – in all purchases of such bonds from October. As the ECB further announced on Monday, this will initially apply to the reinvestment of maturing cash from existing bonds.

    However, the ECB will not reject securities even if the issuer has a low climate score. However, the climate score assigned to each company will not be made transparent. “One objective is to reduce the exposure of the Eurosystem to climate-related financial risks,” the ECB said of its plans. The measures are aimed at the green transformation of the economy and are in line with the European Union’s climate neutrality goals. rtr

    • Climate & Environment
    • ECB

    Study: EU wastes more food than it imports

    In 2021, the EU imported nearly 138 million tons of agricultural products. A study citing recent data from the UN Food Waste Index shows that at the same time, the EU wastes 153.5 million tons of food each year. “At a time of high food prices and a cost of living crisis, it is a scandal that the EU is throwing away more food than it imports,” criticizes Frank Mechielsen, Executive Director at Feedback EU. The NGO conducted the research.

    Mechielsen calls for legally binding EU-wide targets to halve food waste from farm to fork by 2030, combat climate change and improve food security. This demand is supported by numerous environmental organizations in a joint statement.

    According to the European Environmental Bureau(EEB), food waste costs businesses and households in the EU about €143 billion yearly and accounts for at least 6 percent of EU greenhouse gas emissions. About 20 percent of EU food production is wasted, so halving food waste could save 4.7 million hectares of agricultural land by 2030, the EEB said.

    Commission proposal before the end of this year

    EU countries had pledged at the UN to halve food waste, recalls Piotr Barczak, Senior Policy Officer at EEB. “However, almost ten years later, they have not achieved much, and our economies still generate incredibly high amounts of food waste.”

    The Commission is already planning to present a proposal for legally binding targets for food waste in EU member states this year. Martin Häusling, MEP and agricultural policy spokesman for the Green Group, says that mere targets are not enough. He demands that the Commission also present concrete legislative proposals on how the targets are to be achieved.

    “The European Parliament has made it clear in its resolution on the farm-to-fork strategy that instruments such as the revision of the expiration date need to be addressed ambitiously. In addition, we need binding targets at every stage of the supply chain to achieve the necessary reduction in food waste,” says Häusling. luk

    • Climate & Environment
    • Climate Policy
    • European policy
    • Food
    • Klimapolitik
    • Nutrition

    Baltic states and Poland restrict entry for Russians

    The Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, as well as Poland, are further restricting entry for Russian citizens. As of Monday, they will keep the borders closed for citizens of the neighboring country with a Schengen visa for tourist stays, business trips, sports, and cultural events. Corresponding regulations will come into force simultaneously in the four EU and NATO countries. However, certain exceptions apply, for example, to Russians with residence, right of abode, or relatives, as well as for humanitarian reasons. Dissidents will also be allowed to enter the country.

    In response to Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine, the governments of the Baltic states and Poland had already largely suspended the issuance of visas and residence permits to Russians. With a valid visa, however, it was still possible to enter the Schengen area via the borders of the four countries. This will no longer be possible in the future: all Russian citizens with Schengen visas will now be denied entry – regardless of which member country issued the visa. The Schengen area includes 22 EU states and 4 other European countries.

    Lithuania targets citizens from Belarus

    Estonia’s Head of Government Kaja Kallas renewed calls for other countries to join the entry ban, which is controversial within the EU. “We should use all the tools in the toolbox to actually pressure Russia into ending this war,” she said Saturday. “Only 30 percent of Russian citizens have a foreign passport, most of them are residents of St Petersburg and Moscow, the Russian elites. If they are not satisfied with the deeds of the Kremlin, if they are feeling this on their skin, also they will put pressure on the Kremlin to end this war.”

    Lithuania is also considering closing its border to citizens of neighboring Belarus. “This issue is under consideration, discussions are taking place,” Interior Minister Agnė Bilotaitė said Monday during a visit to the Baltic EU and NATO country’s border with Belarus. “I think that there are very serious arguments to consider the inclusion of Belarus as well,” she said, according to the BNS agency. The goal, she said, is to reach an agreement at the regional and even European level. dpa

    • baltic states
    • European policy
    • Poland

    EU funds reduction for Hungary: Poland intends to ‘strongly oppose’

    Poland intends to resist the EU Commission’s planned cut in EU funds for Hungary. “Poland will strongly oppose any actions of European institutions that intend to illegally deprive any member states of funds, in this case, Hungary in particular,” Head of Government Mateusz Morawiecki said Sunday in the Silesian town of Kamienica. However, he said, there were signals from Budapest and Brussels that a solution to the dispute was being worked on.

    Due to corruption and other violations of the rule of law in Hungary, the EU Commission proposed on Sunday to cut payments of around €7.5 billion from the EU budget to the country. It is the first time that the EU Commission proposed this step due to shortcomings in the rule of law in an EU country. In order to actually cut money from the EU budget to the country, at least 15 countries with at least 65 percent of the EU population would now have to agree to the proposal. dpa

    • EU
    • European Commission

    Terry Reintke runs for Greens group leader in EU Parliament

    German Terry Reintke wants to become Chairwoman of the Greens in the European Parliament. “After intensive deliberations and numerous discussions, I have decided to run for Co-president in October,” reads a letter sent to the group on Monday and obtained by Deutsche Presse-Agentur.

    The previous chairwoman, Ska Keller, had resigned only last week. The 40-year-old German had led the group since 2016 together with Belgian Philippe Lamberts and justified the move by saying she wanted to make room for a new generation. Her successor is to be elected in mid-October. The Green Group is currently the fourth-largest group in the European Parliament, with 72 members.

    In her letter, Reintke, 35, points to increasing challenges in the coming months that could only be solved at the European level. She cites, among other things, the Russian war against Ukraine, the energy crisis, a too-slow response to the climate crisis, and increasing social inequality. In addition, she said, the groundwork for the 2024 European elections must be laid.

    Reintke was born in the Ruhr region, has been a member of the European Parliament since 2014, and has been Deputy Leader of the Parliamentary Group since the current legislative period in 2019. Among other things, she campaigns for women’s rights, the protection of democracy and the rule of law, and the rights of LGBTI people. dpa

    • European Parliament
    • European policy

    Exploratory mission for conservative Ulf Kristersson in Sweden

    Conservative Ulf Kristersson may try his hand at forming a government after Sweden’s close parliamentary election. Parliamentary Speaker Andreas Norlén gave the Moderate Party Leader the exploratory mandate on Monday to sound out the possibilities of forming a new government. Norlén made the announcement at a press conference in Stockholm on Monday after talks with the leaders of Sweden’s parliamentary parties.

    As the leader of the Moderates, Kristersson is counting on a narrow majority of a four-party bloc. For the first time after a Swedish election, this camp also includes the anti-immigration Sweden Democrats. About a week ago, they achieved a record result of 20.5 percent in the parliamentary elections, replacing the Moderates as the second strongest party in the country behind the Social Democrats for the first time. However, whether the four parties can agree on a basis for government is still unclear, as is the future role of the right-wing populists in such a constellation. dpa

    • Sweden

    Heads

    Christian Johann – bridging gaps

    Christian Johann is the Director of the European Academy Berlin (EAB).

    Christian Johann sticks his tongue out. And on the highly official website of the European Academy Berlin at that. On a picture that introduces him as the director. What a great title: Director of an academy, based in a villa in Grunewald. It all sounds so statesmanlike, he thinks. He could be photographed in tails and tie, but that would defeat the academy’s purpose. The only help is a break in style, hence the picture with the tongue.

    Johann is 40 and has been Director of the European Academy Berlin for two years. When he meets new people, he introduces himself like this: “I’m part of an organization that bridges the gap between people and Europe.” The EAB is a political education center hosting conferences, meetings, and seminars on topics related to European politics. Johann thinks the whole purpose of his work is to be approachable. Here, anyone and everyone should find access to Europe. Without previous education. People should be encouraged to question: What does Europe have to do with my life?

    The specialty: The house’s guest groups are very diverse. It happens that at noon the commanders of the Air Force come in for a training course. In the afternoon, students meet to discuss the extinction of species.

    Hunger for co-design

    Johann did not grow up a fan of Europe. His parents fled the GDR for West Berlin when he was three years old. He no longer remembers the place “over there.” But his parents do, and they took something with them: skepticism about politics. Such topics were never discussed at the dinner table. But Johann himself always had a hunger for understanding, for participation. At 18, he joined the SPD.

    Judo and political education are similar. Johann takes many of his skills from Japanese martial arts. He was eight years old when he first went to judo lessons. He was 15 when he started teaching himself.

    He taught his students how to take responsibility for their opponents. How they can let off steam, but under firm rules. And how they keep a big goal in mind – maybe the next belt color – even though it takes years to reach it. Perseverance is the most crucial skill for Johann. “In my work, it’s hard to see direct results immediately. I want to encourage critical thinking. How do you measure that?” he says.

    The academy now has a Tiktok channel

    The EAB has been around since the 1960s. When he took office, Johann set out to knead the EAB like pizza dough. For example, he made an effort to create a Tiktok channel for the EAB. Since he works there, there have also been new forms of events: Together with the fashion platform Zalando, Johann brought Ukrainian fashion labels to Berlin in the Villa’s garden. There they were allowed to exhibit their new designs.

    1,500 visitors came and donated. Among them were many hipsters, who spoke only English and had made their way to the bourgeois Grunewald for the first time. Anna Scheld

    • European policy
    • Ukraine

    Europe.Table Editorial Office

    EUROPE.TABLE EDITORS

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen