Table.Briefing: China (English)

BDI absent from Scholz’s visit + Xpeng relies on classic car dealerships

Dear reader,

The German Chancellery already refused to include the former head of the Federation of German Industries (BDI) on the last China visit. Olaf Scholz never officially explained the decision. However, word behind the scenes was that the Chinese hosts did not want the BDI on the trip. One possible reason: The BDI had called for a critical approach to China in a strategy paper. This time, the BDI did not even try to join. It is a regrettable situation, as it clearly demonstrates a successful act of revenge by the Chinese side and a sign of the German Chancellor’s weakness by apparently allowing himself to be told who to take with him on his trips and who not.

In contrast, the sales managers at Xpeng appear much more confident. The Chinese EV manufacturer, which already cooperates with Volkswagen in China, has launched its German business. Xpeng plans to offer the P7 and G9 in Germany in early May. Julia Fiedler was at the German launch and took a closer look at the saloon and the mid-range SUV.

Your
Felix Lee
Image of Felix  Lee

Feature

BDI will not join Scholz’s China visit

When German Chancellor Olaf Scholz travels to Beijing on April 15, he will not be joined by a Federation of German Industries (BDI) representative. As Table.Briefings has learned from political and business circles, the BDI has not even applied to participate this time.

The Chancellery declined to include a BDI representative on the most recent official China visit in November 2022. No official reason was given. However, the background at the time was that the Chinese hosts did not want the BDI to attend. The association had previously expressed increasing criticism of China.

This was the first time in the German government’s history that a BDI representative was barred from traveling to China despite the Chancellor’s explicit wish. The reason the BDI apparently did not submit an application this time is likely to be that the powerful industry association did not want to embarrass itself with another rejection by the Chancellery, according to people familiar with the matter.

Three ministers will be on the plane

Scholz will be accompanied on his trip to China by three German federal ministers. As first reported by Handelsblatt, according to several people familiar with the travel plans, Environment Minister Steffi Lemke (Green Party), Agriculture Minister Cem Ozdemir (Green Party) and Transport Minister Volker Wissing (FDP) will join him. Such an array of federal ministers is unusual and usually only occurs as part of government consultations.

The presence of Ozdemir, Lemke and Wissing clearly shows that the German government sees opportunities for cooperation with the People’s Republic in the areas of climate and the environment, as well as transport policy. Environment Minister Lemke signed a declaration of intent on cooperation on environmental and climate issues with the Chinese Environment Minister at last summer’s German-Chinese intergovernmental consultations.

Transport Minister Wissing recently campaigned in the German government to not completely exclude the Chinese telecommunication supplier Huawei from the rollout of Germany’s 5G network.

German companies are well-represented

As expected, Scholz will also be accompanied by leading representatives of the German economy. Participants include Siemens CEO, Roland Busch. As the company announced, he will also take part in the trip as Chairman and President of the Asia-Pacific Committee of German Business. According to information from Table.Briefings, the CEOs of

  • Siemens,
  • Covestro,
  • BASF,
  • Voith,
  • DHL,
  • Zeiss,
  • BMW,
  • Thyssenkrupp and
  • Volkswagen

will also be there. Mercedes-Benz confirmed that CEO Ola Kaellenius will be attending. Mercedes counts China’s Beijing Automotive Group Co Ltd and Geely’s Chairman Li Shufu among its two main shareholders. Also registered is Belen Garijo, CEO of Merck KGaA, a manufacturer of laboratory equipment and semiconductor chemicals.

In 2019, the BDI published a strategy paper calling for a critical approach to China. This paper was not least one of the foundations for Germany’s China strategy, passed by the government last year after lengthy internal debates. In it, China is no longer just described as a partner, but also as a competitor and systemic rival. “Excessive dependence on one market is always associated with economic and political risks,” it says.

However, the BDI’s consistent de-risking approach went beyond what was planned at corporate headquarters. Volkswagen, BASF and numerous other DAX companies even want to invest more than ever in China. This way, they are hedging against trade risks and strengthening their position in the world’s largest market.

In late October 2022, the association went even further. In a policy paper on European sovereignty, China was again mentioned frequently – as a source of risk. It called China an autocracy, and the dependence on Chinese raw materials was in part higher than the gas dependence on Russia. It also argued that a secure supply would depend on China not continuing to be the dominant supplier of solar cells.

Key topics are Russia and trade

Scholz intends to travel to Beijing under positive auspices, as he also has some wishes. One issue will again be Russia, Noah Barkin from the German Marshall Fund told Table.Briefings. He said that China has always stretched the EU’s red lines when it comes to supplying Russia with military goods, but there are signs that the Europeans’ patience is now wearing thin. Scholz is facing a “difficult conversation” with President Xi Jinping. “Europe cannot maintain normal relations with Beijing as long as it feeds the Russian war machine.”

As Europe’s envoy, Scholz will probably also address China’s cheap exports due to overcapacity. Trade has tended to become more lopsided in recent years. Instead of balancing each other out, Europe’s deficits and China’s surpluses have increased. China experiences unemployment and low prices and exports more goods than ever before. Scholz wants to emphasize that “a flood of cheap exports to the European market will provoke a political response,” Barkin said.

  • De-risking
  • Geopolitics
  • Olaf Scholz
  • Trade

Launch in Germany: Xpeng focuses on sales – and on VW

Xpeng Motors from Guangzhou will launch the P7 saloon and the G9 mid-size SUV on the German market on May 1. Both cars can already be configured on their website and booked for a test drive. The test drives are made at dealerships, as Xpeng relies on the classic dealer model to sell its cars.

Aside from the cars, the focus was on one topic in particular: sales. Xpeng wants to avoid mistakes that lead to low sales figures for many other Chinese newcomers. The brand offers its cars through car dealerships, and Xpeng plans to be represented at 24 locations by the time sales start in May. The manufacturer thus relies on a distribution model that has already brought another Chinese manufacturer success: MG Motor.

Quality service and the availability of spare parts are some of the biggest concerns of car buyers interested in a Chinese EV brand. Markus Schrick, Managing Director for Xpeng Germany, aims to dispel these concerns through dealership sales. As Managing Director, he has already helped promote Hyundai’s growth in Germany and plans a down-to-earth approach for Xpeng.

Deal with VW is supposed to create trust

However, for the plan to work, the brand needs to get as many partners on board as quickly as possible. This is a significant challenge, as the dealers are expected to display a vehicle brand in their showroom that many of them have never heard of and whose long-term potential for success they can hardly assess. On top of this, there is the threat of possible EU punitive tariffs, with the consequences for Chinese EV manufacturers-and therefore also their distributors-not yet foreseeable.

Xpeng tries to make it as appealing as possible for dealers to get on board. While most car brands specify in great detail what the display area for their vehicles must look like, Xpeng keeps the requirements low and is content with just a few logos and advertising pylons. Head of Germany, Markus Schrick, hopes that the deal between Xpeng and VW will also create trust among dealers. “If a company like VW decides to cooperate with Xpeng, they have analyzed it really well.” Volkswagen acquired almost five percent of Xpeng last year and invested 700 million US dollars. In return, Xpeng will develop two VW models for the Chinese market by 2026.

Xpeng positions itself against Audi, BMW and Mercedes

Xpeng is still a start-up and running at a loss. In 2023, the company sold 140,000 cars. Yet the factories in China can already build up to 600,000 vehicles a year. How many of these will end up in Germany? Markus Schrick does not want to set a number. The target is three percent in each segment in which the brand competes.

However, the competition in these segments is fierce. In terms of size, the upper mid-range saloon P7 is somewhere between Tesla’s Model 3 and Model S. Xpeng positions the G9 luxury SUV against models from traditional German brands. Will the G9 stand a chance against cars such as the Audi Q8 e-tron, BMW iX, and Mercedes EQE?

Both models have been on the Chinese market for some time. The P7 was launched in China in 2020 and received a facelift in 2023. It is also available in Germany. The entry-level Long Range Edition with rear-wheel drive costs just under 50,000 euros, but according to WLTP, it puts 276 hp on the road and has a range of 576 km. There is also an all-wheel drive version with 473 hp and a range of 505 km. Those who prefer an eccentric look can also opt for gullwing doors.

The P7 is also available with optional gullwing doors. CEO He Xiaopeng allegedly personally requested this special color.

The G9 luxury SUV has been available in China since 2022. Starting at 57,600 euros, it is much cheaper than the German competition while offering 312 hp with rear-wheel drive and a range of 460 kilometers. A variant with all-wheel drive, 550 hp, and a range of 520 km is also possible. A smaller SUV is set to follow in 2025 and a compact car in 2026.

Great handling, but too much ringing 

The G9 is based on an 800 V platform with a very fast charging capacity of 300 kW. With a suitable charging station, the battery can supposedly be charged from 20 to 80 percent in just 15 minutes. Apart from the charging technology, the car already comes with all the hardware for autonomous driving. Even if this will not be possible in Germany in the foreseeable future.

The P7 and G9 often emit warning sounds when driving, and the reason for this is the driving pleasure. Their handling is excellent, and both models’ acceleration is impressive. However, even slightly exceeding the speed limit triggers a warning beep. The cars’ look, feel, and features make up for their overly cautious nannying.

Xpeng has lined the interior with high-quality materials. Luxurious details include a panoramic glass roof, large displays, seat heating and an intelligent voice control system that even recognizes which seat the person currently speaking to is sitting in. However, the voice control currently only responds in English. The launch edition of the G9 SUV includes front and rear massage seats. There is also an extra screen for the front passenger to watch TV.

Start-up with tech ambitions

In addition to service, driving performance and extras, customers talking to their car dealer are likely to be interested in one question: How do you pronounce it? The answer: Just as it is spelled. The word Xpeng is an abbreviation of the name of Xpeng CEO He Xiaopeng, a tech billionaire born in Hubei in 1977. He founded the internet company UCWeb in 2004, which was acquired by Alibaba ten years later in China’s largest M&A deal. In the same year, 2014, He co-founded Xpeng – a company for autonomous electric vehicles

Xpeng brought the X2 passenger drone to Germany Dreieich in Hesse; it already has a limited flight permit in China.

Xpeng positions itself as a tech innovation brand. To ensure that German journalists understand this, the Chinese company brought an aircraft to the driving event in Germany – the Xpeng X2 passenger drone. The small quadcopter can transport people and baggage weighing up to 200 kilograms and already has a limited flight license in China. Xpeng also has a flying car, which the Chinese presented at the CES electronics trade fair at the beginning of the year. It is a sports car with four large propeller arms that fold from the roof. While it looks like science fiction and the first flight videos inspire little confidence, the vehicle is expected to be available to order in China by the end of 2024.

Xpeng also invests in the development of driver assistance systems. The XNGP system competes with Tesla’s autopilot. Unlike the latter, however, it relies on cameras and uses lidar and radar sensors. It is designed to work even in the most chaotic city traffic and has recently become available for all of China. While the driver’s hands still have to be close to the steering wheel, the G9 SUV has been granted a test license for fully autonomous driving as a robotaxi in Guangzhou since last summer.

  • autonomous driving
  • Electromobility
  • Xpeng

Events

April, 8, 2024; 3 p.m. CEST (9 p.m. Beijing time)
Center for Strategic and International Studies, Webcast: China’s Tech Sector: Economic Champions, Regulatory Targets More

April, 9, 2024; 2:30 p.m. CEST (8:30 p.m. Beijing time)
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Urban China Lecture Series: Planning Exchange: Ideas, People, and Cities in Circulation During China’s Opening and Reform Era More

April, 9, 2024; 4:30 p.m. CEST (10:30 p.m. Beijing time)
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Online Seminar Series: Dreams from China’s Past: Visions of the Future in Popular Science and Literature Magazines, 1927-1949 More

April, 9, 2024; 1:30 p.m. CEST (7:30 p.m. Beijing time)
Center for Strategic and International Studies, Webcast: CSIS-CSDS Transatlantic Dialogue on the Indo-Pacific More

April, 10, 2024; 3 p.m. CEST (9 p.m. Beijing time)
Center for Strategic and International Studies, Webcast: Chinese Interference in Taiwan’s 2024 Elections and Lessons Learned More

April, 10, 2024; 10 p.m. CEST (April 11, 2024; 4 a.m. Beijing time)
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Environment in Asia Series: Ecological States: Politics of Science and Nature in Urbanizing China More

April, 15, 2024; 4 p.m. CEST (10 p.m. Beijing time)
PricewaterhouseCoopers, Automotive Webcast: From China – with love. Sustaining industry transition in a more protectionist world More

April 15, 2024; 6:15 p.m. CEST
Confucius Institute at the Free University of Berlin, Lecture (in Berlin): Prof. Dr. Yab Xuetong, Tsinghua University, The Current Global Order: The Wars in Ukraine and Gaza More

News

Earthquake in Taiwan: missing miners rescued

Rescue workers continued to work tirelessly on the second day after the severe earthquake in Taiwan to free numerous people trapped in tunnels. There are still 42 people missing whose whereabouts are currently unclear. Following a visit to an emergency center in Hualien, Taiwan’s head of government Chen Chien-jen said he hoped that “we can use today’s time to find all people who are stranded and unaccounted for.”

Following the earthquake in Taiwan, more than 600 people are still cut off from the outside world. Most of them have found refuge in hotels. However, dozens of people are still trapped in collapsed tunnels, the authorities said on Thursday.

In a dramatic operation on Thursday, rescuers managed to free 64 trapped miners. A video released by the island’s Central Emergency Operation Center showed helicopter operations to rescue the first six miners trapped in a quarry in Hualien district near the epicenter of the quake. A short time later, the fire brigade announced that all other 58 miners had also been brought to safety.

Fearing severe aftershocks, thousands of residents of the hardest-hit city of Hualien spent Thursday night outdoors. By Thursday morning, more than 300 aftershocks had been detected in Taiwan.

The severe quake on Wednesday killed at least ten people and injured over 1,060. According to the US National Earthquake Information Center, the earthquake had a magnitude of 7.4 on the Richter scale. It was the most severe quake in Taiwan for a quarter of a century. Unlike the last major quake in 1999, this time the number of victims remained relatively low. At the time, the death toll was over 2,400. Taiwan has since invested heavily in disaster prevention and safe building structures. flee

The US struggles with China’s overcapacity

China’s overcapacity is further testing already strained relations between Beijing and Washington. At 67.3 billion dollars, the US trade balance in February was once again in the red. The trade deficit with China remains particularly high. It was almost 20 billion dollars, after just under 24 billion dollars in January.

China is currently exporting large quantities of electric cars, batteries, solar modules, semiconductors and other industrial goods to the global market: the result of years of state subsidies and weak domestic demand. Global market prices for many goods have fallen as a result of the Chinese export offensive, putting pressure on producers in other countries such as the USA. “We see a growing threat of money losing firms that are going to have to sell off their production somewhere,” a senior US Treasury official said of overproduction in key Chinese sectors.

US Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen will travel to Beijing this weekend and intends to put the problem of overcapacity on the agenda. “I do think the stage is set for renewed tensions with China,” said Brad Setser, a former US Trade and Treasury official.

Yellen’s warnings about Chinese overproduction could be a first step by President Joe Biden’s administration towards new tariffs or other trade barriers on Chinese EVs, batteries and other industrial goods. rtr/flee

  • USA

Washington continues to exert pressure on the Netherlands over ASML

According to Reuters, citing people familiar with the matter, the US government plans to increase pressure on the Netherlands to prevent the leading chip manufacturer ASML from servicing certain devices in China.

Alan Estevez, head of US export policy, will meet with representatives of the Dutch government and ASML next Monday to discuss the maintenance contracts. During the talks, Washington could also try to expand the list of Chinese chip factories barred from receiving Dutch equipment.

US President Joe Biden continues to crack down on Beijing’s plans to develop an advanced semiconductor industry. Consequently, the US blocks China’s access to imported technology and urges its allies to support this strategy. rtr

  • ASML
  • ASML
  • Chips
  • Netherlands
  • Semiconductor
  • USA

VW-Traton also fears Chinese competition in commercial vehicles

The head of Volkswagen’s truck holding company Traton (MAN, Scania) sees tough competition for commercial vehicles in Europe coming from the People’s Republic. Chinese electric bus providers have positioned themselves well in a very short time, mainly thanks to their access to very good battery technology, Christian Levin told the Bloomberg news agency: “If you extrapolate that and look at trucks, you can imagine a similar development.”

Although European companies such as Traton and Daimler Truck also offer electric trucks, they have so far sold very poorly. By contrast, Chinese manufacturers like BYD, which also offer electric trucks and buses, are far stronger, especially in the Chinese market.

BYD has been selling electric buses and trucks in Europe for some time. In 2017, BYD opened a plant in Komarom, which manufactures 400 electric buses annually for Europe. flee

  • Autoindustrie

Opinion

Between the lines

By Johnny Erling
Johnny Erling schreibt die Kolumne für die China.Table Professional Briefings

Beijing’s battalions of officially mandated internet watchdogs have sophisticated censorship methods at their disposal to ensure that online criticism and problematic revelations quickly disappear from the web. However, tech-savvy bloggers constantly find new ways to bypass the tight controls. Since 2021, an activist who calls himself “Teacher Li” 李老师 has been helping them from overseas to understand the true situation in the country. Millions read his posts, which have earned him legendary status in China.

“Teacher Li is not your teacher” 李老师不是你老师@whyyoutouzhele is the name of Li’s Twitter (X) account, which keeps tricking the censors. Subversive online news they believed to have successfully deleted is swiftly returned to their inbox.

A helpline for the people of China

The person behind it is a Chinese artist who has lived in Italy since 2015. Li Ying (李颖), now 31, revealed his identity in an interview with New York Times journalist Li Yang in late 2023. Teacher Li is not a typical exiled dissident who attacks China’s leadership from the outside. He is far more dangerous because he has turned his Twitter account into a virtual helpline for the people of China.

He receives daily news and posts from many provinces of the People’s Republic, raw snapshots, and eyewitness accounts of injustice, protests, or absurdities. These often are screenshots that other bloggers take of domestic WeChats and video clips before censorship strikes.

Li receives them, sorts them, evaluates their credibility and usually forwards them as tweets without comment. For Geremie R. Barmé, who portrayed him for “China Heritage” together with reporter Li Yuan, Li operates a “clearing house for unofficial information.” His pseudonym follows the Taoist wisdom: “The teacher who is no teacher is truly a teacher.”

Accidents, misfortunes and regulatory injustice

In 2021, Li initially used his Sina Weibo account within China for such posts. Censorship blocked him. Other bloggers then sent him their mobile phone numbers so that he could register a new account. After 49 accounts were censored, he opened his Twitter page in April 2022 – a foreign account that China’s censors could not touch.

Although Twitter access is blocked in China, privileged users and millions of tech-savvy bloggers use VPN (proxy) servers to bypass the infamous Great Firewall. Li’s Twitter following grew to 1.6 million readers in early 2024. Many share his posts with their friends and acquaintances.

For example, China and the rest of the world quickly learned about Shanghai’s “White Paper” anti-COVID protest movement and recently about many spontaneous expressions of condolence in response to the death of ex-Premier Li Keqiang. Eyewitnesses and those involved reported accidents, misfortunes, or administrative injustices that China’s state media were not allowed to cover.

Longing for a counter-public is growing

The censors were so helpless and angry that they started locating and summoning followers of Lis’ tweets individually to deter them. The teacher himself is also feeling the pressure. His parents are being harassed, and even in Italy, he has to fear for his safety and has already moved four times.

The need for a counter-publicity is growing in China’s opaque, highly censored news situation. Li’s posts come at just the right time. In mid-March, he published a list of the latest absurdities in the cult of personality surrounding China’s current leader, Xi Jinping. Bloggers have investigated how often he allows himself to be praised by the official party media as the nation’s mastermind who leads the way. They sent Li a list of 243 examples that had appeared between 2015 and 2024.

A new feature of the personality cult surrounding Xi Jinping is that he is praised as a thought leader who personally “shows China the way” in all matters. Bloggers already call him the “Chief Compass.” When the renowned monthly literary magazine “Selection of Essays” featured a giant pointing finger on its cover in December, it crashed with it.

The list begins with the official announcement on November 12, 2015, that Party leader Xi is “guiding the future development of the stock market” (为股票市场未来发展指明方向). And it ends with this news from March 11, 2024: Xi shows us the way to overcome the bottlenecks in the development of the new qualitative productive forces (为打通束缚新质生产力发展堵点指明方向).

“Puffing yourself up to intimidate others”

The more power Xi was able to transfer to himself after 2015 at the two major Party Congresses in 2017 and 2022, the more often the Party media praised him as the ultimate guide and advisor for every conceivable problem. Bloggers mockingly call Xi the personified “chief compass” of the country: “Just like Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin and Mao, Xi will also show us the way to hell.”

The founding father of the People’s Republic, Mao Zedong, once condemned such exaggerated adulation in revolutionary times. In his 1942 speech “Against Stereotypes,” he castigated his functionaries’ empty, theoretical ramblings, saying that their Party language was alienating them from the people.

In 1942, Mao published his criticism of the empty and stereotypical speeches and writings of communist functionaries. These resembled the exam essays in the old imperial civil service exams, where candidates had to strictly adhere to an eight-part composition scheme in which only form mattered. Mao persecuted anyone who dared to write more openly and critically. To this day, nothing has changed in China’s propaganda.

Mao compared their writings to the essays that were required of candidates in the Confucian-influenced imperial civil service exams of the Ming and Qing periods. They would fail if they did not strictly adhere to a set “eight-legged writing scheme” (八股文). Mao also criticized the functionaries for filling “endless pages with empty words without substance” (空话连篇, 言之无物), “puffing them up to intimidate others (装腔作势, 借以吓人).” Their essays, Mao scolded, were like the bandages once used to constrict women’s feet, “long and foul-smelling 真是” – “懒婆娘的裹脚,又长又臭”.

Hidden messages in ideological gibberish

Even when Mao lapsed into his own cult of personality, he still urged his Party to avoid stereotypical formalism and bureaucratism and to criticize and self-criticism. However, this was no longer meant seriously and was merely lip service, just as his political grandson Xi Jinping is imitating him today to maintain his power. Under his wing, the theoretical excesses of Chinese Party propagandists have become even more repetitive and incomprehensible.

During China’s liberal reform phase after 1978, there were debates about greater openness. In 1978, satirist Hua Junwu illustrated how difficult it is to read between the lines in the party gibberish of the functionaries. A reader sits on a manuscript and asks another one holding a magnifying glass: “Did you find the author’s angle?” He replies. “No. And I’m already on page 15.”

And yet sometimes explosive messages are hidden in Xi’s ideological gibberish of today. However, it is becoming increasingly difficult to read and understand them between the lines because Xi only allows his essays to be published months or years later and only in selected excerpts.

One such example is a previously unknown speech by Xi, which the Party’s leading theoretical magazine printed for the first time on March 15, 2024. Xi gave the speech 14 months ago, on January 9, 2023, on issues of Party discipline. This was shortly after he previously claimed his lifelong rule and absolute Party leadership at the 20th Party Congress.

Regime security is more important than growth

Instead of triumphing, Xi appears surprisingly nervous about his internal Party problems. Without mentioning names, he complains: “It is easy for some people to form small cliques, circles and gangs” (些人容易出现搞小山头、小圈子、小嘮伙现象) and warns that “it is easy to destroy a fortress from within. Those who can achieve this can only come from within our own ranks.” (堡垒最容易从内部被攻破,能打败我们的只有我们自己)。

In a special “criticism and self-criticism” session on 21 and 22 December 2023, Xi also showed his dissatisfaction when he apparently accused his Politburo comrades of being an echo chamber and not telling him the truth. The meeting went unnoticed outside of China because it was Christmas, and Xi’s speech was only published as a summary.

However, it does say: Xi expects his Politburo to “present the true situation in a timely and objective manner and to describe not only the positive but also the troubling (… ) and not be deceived by external beauty and false figures” (对工作中了解到的真实情况,要及时客观全面反映上来,不能只报喜、不报忧 … 反对华而不实、数据造假).

In 2015, China’s official foreign language publisher released an up-to-date “Handbook on China’s Economic Policy and its New Political Leadership.” Although the book did not really reveal any new insights, it did concede in its afterword: “It is not easy to understand and follow China’s policy, it is always riddled with unclear messages.” Tellingly, the book cover reads: “Reading between the lines.”

These few published quotes at least show that, since early 2023, Xi’s main aim has been to prioritize his regime’s political and systemic security over growth and the economy. We now know for a fact just how bad the People’s Republic’s economy was after the abrupt end of the pandemic in 2023.

We also know about Xi’s domestic political disaster, when he had his foreign and defense ministers and high-ranking military officers disappear overnight, unexplained to this day. Beijing’s propaganda only retrospectively reveals the state of China and its leadership in homeopathic quantities. The loss of transparency is a hallmark of the new era of Xi’s rule. The art of reading between the lines no longer helps. All the more reason why Teacher Li’s tweets are so popular.

  • Censorship
  • Internet
  • Language
  • Society
  • Sprache

Executive Moves

Bart van Hezewijk has been responsible for Geopolitics & Trade, Government & External Affairs at Dutch chip machine manufacturer ASML since the beginning of March. He was previously Head of Asia, Government & External Affairs, also at ASML.

Yu Zhangfu has been Business Development Manager at the China Desk at Roehling Logistics since the beginning of February. He was a project manager at the Chinese Chamber of Commerce in Germany until the end of last year.

Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

Dessert

Before the taste buds can savor it, it is already a feast for the eyes. The hard work of the farmworkers at the tea planting station in Wuxi, Jiangsu Province, makes for a colorful sight. The mostly female pickers only pluck the two finest leaves and the leaf bud and carry them in their basket or a cloth to the collection point. Only the later processing stage decides whether the leaves will become green or black tea.

China.Table editorial team

CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    The German Chancellery already refused to include the former head of the Federation of German Industries (BDI) on the last China visit. Olaf Scholz never officially explained the decision. However, word behind the scenes was that the Chinese hosts did not want the BDI on the trip. One possible reason: The BDI had called for a critical approach to China in a strategy paper. This time, the BDI did not even try to join. It is a regrettable situation, as it clearly demonstrates a successful act of revenge by the Chinese side and a sign of the German Chancellor’s weakness by apparently allowing himself to be told who to take with him on his trips and who not.

    In contrast, the sales managers at Xpeng appear much more confident. The Chinese EV manufacturer, which already cooperates with Volkswagen in China, has launched its German business. Xpeng plans to offer the P7 and G9 in Germany in early May. Julia Fiedler was at the German launch and took a closer look at the saloon and the mid-range SUV.

    Your
    Felix Lee
    Image of Felix  Lee

    Feature

    BDI will not join Scholz’s China visit

    When German Chancellor Olaf Scholz travels to Beijing on April 15, he will not be joined by a Federation of German Industries (BDI) representative. As Table.Briefings has learned from political and business circles, the BDI has not even applied to participate this time.

    The Chancellery declined to include a BDI representative on the most recent official China visit in November 2022. No official reason was given. However, the background at the time was that the Chinese hosts did not want the BDI to attend. The association had previously expressed increasing criticism of China.

    This was the first time in the German government’s history that a BDI representative was barred from traveling to China despite the Chancellor’s explicit wish. The reason the BDI apparently did not submit an application this time is likely to be that the powerful industry association did not want to embarrass itself with another rejection by the Chancellery, according to people familiar with the matter.

    Three ministers will be on the plane

    Scholz will be accompanied on his trip to China by three German federal ministers. As first reported by Handelsblatt, according to several people familiar with the travel plans, Environment Minister Steffi Lemke (Green Party), Agriculture Minister Cem Ozdemir (Green Party) and Transport Minister Volker Wissing (FDP) will join him. Such an array of federal ministers is unusual and usually only occurs as part of government consultations.

    The presence of Ozdemir, Lemke and Wissing clearly shows that the German government sees opportunities for cooperation with the People’s Republic in the areas of climate and the environment, as well as transport policy. Environment Minister Lemke signed a declaration of intent on cooperation on environmental and climate issues with the Chinese Environment Minister at last summer’s German-Chinese intergovernmental consultations.

    Transport Minister Wissing recently campaigned in the German government to not completely exclude the Chinese telecommunication supplier Huawei from the rollout of Germany’s 5G network.

    German companies are well-represented

    As expected, Scholz will also be accompanied by leading representatives of the German economy. Participants include Siemens CEO, Roland Busch. As the company announced, he will also take part in the trip as Chairman and President of the Asia-Pacific Committee of German Business. According to information from Table.Briefings, the CEOs of

    • Siemens,
    • Covestro,
    • BASF,
    • Voith,
    • DHL,
    • Zeiss,
    • BMW,
    • Thyssenkrupp and
    • Volkswagen

    will also be there. Mercedes-Benz confirmed that CEO Ola Kaellenius will be attending. Mercedes counts China’s Beijing Automotive Group Co Ltd and Geely’s Chairman Li Shufu among its two main shareholders. Also registered is Belen Garijo, CEO of Merck KGaA, a manufacturer of laboratory equipment and semiconductor chemicals.

    In 2019, the BDI published a strategy paper calling for a critical approach to China. This paper was not least one of the foundations for Germany’s China strategy, passed by the government last year after lengthy internal debates. In it, China is no longer just described as a partner, but also as a competitor and systemic rival. “Excessive dependence on one market is always associated with economic and political risks,” it says.

    However, the BDI’s consistent de-risking approach went beyond what was planned at corporate headquarters. Volkswagen, BASF and numerous other DAX companies even want to invest more than ever in China. This way, they are hedging against trade risks and strengthening their position in the world’s largest market.

    In late October 2022, the association went even further. In a policy paper on European sovereignty, China was again mentioned frequently – as a source of risk. It called China an autocracy, and the dependence on Chinese raw materials was in part higher than the gas dependence on Russia. It also argued that a secure supply would depend on China not continuing to be the dominant supplier of solar cells.

    Key topics are Russia and trade

    Scholz intends to travel to Beijing under positive auspices, as he also has some wishes. One issue will again be Russia, Noah Barkin from the German Marshall Fund told Table.Briefings. He said that China has always stretched the EU’s red lines when it comes to supplying Russia with military goods, but there are signs that the Europeans’ patience is now wearing thin. Scholz is facing a “difficult conversation” with President Xi Jinping. “Europe cannot maintain normal relations with Beijing as long as it feeds the Russian war machine.”

    As Europe’s envoy, Scholz will probably also address China’s cheap exports due to overcapacity. Trade has tended to become more lopsided in recent years. Instead of balancing each other out, Europe’s deficits and China’s surpluses have increased. China experiences unemployment and low prices and exports more goods than ever before. Scholz wants to emphasize that “a flood of cheap exports to the European market will provoke a political response,” Barkin said.

    • De-risking
    • Geopolitics
    • Olaf Scholz
    • Trade

    Launch in Germany: Xpeng focuses on sales – and on VW

    Xpeng Motors from Guangzhou will launch the P7 saloon and the G9 mid-size SUV on the German market on May 1. Both cars can already be configured on their website and booked for a test drive. The test drives are made at dealerships, as Xpeng relies on the classic dealer model to sell its cars.

    Aside from the cars, the focus was on one topic in particular: sales. Xpeng wants to avoid mistakes that lead to low sales figures for many other Chinese newcomers. The brand offers its cars through car dealerships, and Xpeng plans to be represented at 24 locations by the time sales start in May. The manufacturer thus relies on a distribution model that has already brought another Chinese manufacturer success: MG Motor.

    Quality service and the availability of spare parts are some of the biggest concerns of car buyers interested in a Chinese EV brand. Markus Schrick, Managing Director for Xpeng Germany, aims to dispel these concerns through dealership sales. As Managing Director, he has already helped promote Hyundai’s growth in Germany and plans a down-to-earth approach for Xpeng.

    Deal with VW is supposed to create trust

    However, for the plan to work, the brand needs to get as many partners on board as quickly as possible. This is a significant challenge, as the dealers are expected to display a vehicle brand in their showroom that many of them have never heard of and whose long-term potential for success they can hardly assess. On top of this, there is the threat of possible EU punitive tariffs, with the consequences for Chinese EV manufacturers-and therefore also their distributors-not yet foreseeable.

    Xpeng tries to make it as appealing as possible for dealers to get on board. While most car brands specify in great detail what the display area for their vehicles must look like, Xpeng keeps the requirements low and is content with just a few logos and advertising pylons. Head of Germany, Markus Schrick, hopes that the deal between Xpeng and VW will also create trust among dealers. “If a company like VW decides to cooperate with Xpeng, they have analyzed it really well.” Volkswagen acquired almost five percent of Xpeng last year and invested 700 million US dollars. In return, Xpeng will develop two VW models for the Chinese market by 2026.

    Xpeng positions itself against Audi, BMW and Mercedes

    Xpeng is still a start-up and running at a loss. In 2023, the company sold 140,000 cars. Yet the factories in China can already build up to 600,000 vehicles a year. How many of these will end up in Germany? Markus Schrick does not want to set a number. The target is three percent in each segment in which the brand competes.

    However, the competition in these segments is fierce. In terms of size, the upper mid-range saloon P7 is somewhere between Tesla’s Model 3 and Model S. Xpeng positions the G9 luxury SUV against models from traditional German brands. Will the G9 stand a chance against cars such as the Audi Q8 e-tron, BMW iX, and Mercedes EQE?

    Both models have been on the Chinese market for some time. The P7 was launched in China in 2020 and received a facelift in 2023. It is also available in Germany. The entry-level Long Range Edition with rear-wheel drive costs just under 50,000 euros, but according to WLTP, it puts 276 hp on the road and has a range of 576 km. There is also an all-wheel drive version with 473 hp and a range of 505 km. Those who prefer an eccentric look can also opt for gullwing doors.

    The P7 is also available with optional gullwing doors. CEO He Xiaopeng allegedly personally requested this special color.

    The G9 luxury SUV has been available in China since 2022. Starting at 57,600 euros, it is much cheaper than the German competition while offering 312 hp with rear-wheel drive and a range of 460 kilometers. A variant with all-wheel drive, 550 hp, and a range of 520 km is also possible. A smaller SUV is set to follow in 2025 and a compact car in 2026.

    Great handling, but too much ringing 

    The G9 is based on an 800 V platform with a very fast charging capacity of 300 kW. With a suitable charging station, the battery can supposedly be charged from 20 to 80 percent in just 15 minutes. Apart from the charging technology, the car already comes with all the hardware for autonomous driving. Even if this will not be possible in Germany in the foreseeable future.

    The P7 and G9 often emit warning sounds when driving, and the reason for this is the driving pleasure. Their handling is excellent, and both models’ acceleration is impressive. However, even slightly exceeding the speed limit triggers a warning beep. The cars’ look, feel, and features make up for their overly cautious nannying.

    Xpeng has lined the interior with high-quality materials. Luxurious details include a panoramic glass roof, large displays, seat heating and an intelligent voice control system that even recognizes which seat the person currently speaking to is sitting in. However, the voice control currently only responds in English. The launch edition of the G9 SUV includes front and rear massage seats. There is also an extra screen for the front passenger to watch TV.

    Start-up with tech ambitions

    In addition to service, driving performance and extras, customers talking to their car dealer are likely to be interested in one question: How do you pronounce it? The answer: Just as it is spelled. The word Xpeng is an abbreviation of the name of Xpeng CEO He Xiaopeng, a tech billionaire born in Hubei in 1977. He founded the internet company UCWeb in 2004, which was acquired by Alibaba ten years later in China’s largest M&A deal. In the same year, 2014, He co-founded Xpeng – a company for autonomous electric vehicles

    Xpeng brought the X2 passenger drone to Germany Dreieich in Hesse; it already has a limited flight permit in China.

    Xpeng positions itself as a tech innovation brand. To ensure that German journalists understand this, the Chinese company brought an aircraft to the driving event in Germany – the Xpeng X2 passenger drone. The small quadcopter can transport people and baggage weighing up to 200 kilograms and already has a limited flight license in China. Xpeng also has a flying car, which the Chinese presented at the CES electronics trade fair at the beginning of the year. It is a sports car with four large propeller arms that fold from the roof. While it looks like science fiction and the first flight videos inspire little confidence, the vehicle is expected to be available to order in China by the end of 2024.

    Xpeng also invests in the development of driver assistance systems. The XNGP system competes with Tesla’s autopilot. Unlike the latter, however, it relies on cameras and uses lidar and radar sensors. It is designed to work even in the most chaotic city traffic and has recently become available for all of China. While the driver’s hands still have to be close to the steering wheel, the G9 SUV has been granted a test license for fully autonomous driving as a robotaxi in Guangzhou since last summer.

    • autonomous driving
    • Electromobility
    • Xpeng

    Events

    April, 8, 2024; 3 p.m. CEST (9 p.m. Beijing time)
    Center for Strategic and International Studies, Webcast: China’s Tech Sector: Economic Champions, Regulatory Targets More

    April, 9, 2024; 2:30 p.m. CEST (8:30 p.m. Beijing time)
    Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Urban China Lecture Series: Planning Exchange: Ideas, People, and Cities in Circulation During China’s Opening and Reform Era More

    April, 9, 2024; 4:30 p.m. CEST (10:30 p.m. Beijing time)
    Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Online Seminar Series: Dreams from China’s Past: Visions of the Future in Popular Science and Literature Magazines, 1927-1949 More

    April, 9, 2024; 1:30 p.m. CEST (7:30 p.m. Beijing time)
    Center for Strategic and International Studies, Webcast: CSIS-CSDS Transatlantic Dialogue on the Indo-Pacific More

    April, 10, 2024; 3 p.m. CEST (9 p.m. Beijing time)
    Center for Strategic and International Studies, Webcast: Chinese Interference in Taiwan’s 2024 Elections and Lessons Learned More

    April, 10, 2024; 10 p.m. CEST (April 11, 2024; 4 a.m. Beijing time)
    Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Environment in Asia Series: Ecological States: Politics of Science and Nature in Urbanizing China More

    April, 15, 2024; 4 p.m. CEST (10 p.m. Beijing time)
    PricewaterhouseCoopers, Automotive Webcast: From China – with love. Sustaining industry transition in a more protectionist world More

    April 15, 2024; 6:15 p.m. CEST
    Confucius Institute at the Free University of Berlin, Lecture (in Berlin): Prof. Dr. Yab Xuetong, Tsinghua University, The Current Global Order: The Wars in Ukraine and Gaza More

    News

    Earthquake in Taiwan: missing miners rescued

    Rescue workers continued to work tirelessly on the second day after the severe earthquake in Taiwan to free numerous people trapped in tunnels. There are still 42 people missing whose whereabouts are currently unclear. Following a visit to an emergency center in Hualien, Taiwan’s head of government Chen Chien-jen said he hoped that “we can use today’s time to find all people who are stranded and unaccounted for.”

    Following the earthquake in Taiwan, more than 600 people are still cut off from the outside world. Most of them have found refuge in hotels. However, dozens of people are still trapped in collapsed tunnels, the authorities said on Thursday.

    In a dramatic operation on Thursday, rescuers managed to free 64 trapped miners. A video released by the island’s Central Emergency Operation Center showed helicopter operations to rescue the first six miners trapped in a quarry in Hualien district near the epicenter of the quake. A short time later, the fire brigade announced that all other 58 miners had also been brought to safety.

    Fearing severe aftershocks, thousands of residents of the hardest-hit city of Hualien spent Thursday night outdoors. By Thursday morning, more than 300 aftershocks had been detected in Taiwan.

    The severe quake on Wednesday killed at least ten people and injured over 1,060. According to the US National Earthquake Information Center, the earthquake had a magnitude of 7.4 on the Richter scale. It was the most severe quake in Taiwan for a quarter of a century. Unlike the last major quake in 1999, this time the number of victims remained relatively low. At the time, the death toll was over 2,400. Taiwan has since invested heavily in disaster prevention and safe building structures. flee

    The US struggles with China’s overcapacity

    China’s overcapacity is further testing already strained relations between Beijing and Washington. At 67.3 billion dollars, the US trade balance in February was once again in the red. The trade deficit with China remains particularly high. It was almost 20 billion dollars, after just under 24 billion dollars in January.

    China is currently exporting large quantities of electric cars, batteries, solar modules, semiconductors and other industrial goods to the global market: the result of years of state subsidies and weak domestic demand. Global market prices for many goods have fallen as a result of the Chinese export offensive, putting pressure on producers in other countries such as the USA. “We see a growing threat of money losing firms that are going to have to sell off their production somewhere,” a senior US Treasury official said of overproduction in key Chinese sectors.

    US Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen will travel to Beijing this weekend and intends to put the problem of overcapacity on the agenda. “I do think the stage is set for renewed tensions with China,” said Brad Setser, a former US Trade and Treasury official.

    Yellen’s warnings about Chinese overproduction could be a first step by President Joe Biden’s administration towards new tariffs or other trade barriers on Chinese EVs, batteries and other industrial goods. rtr/flee

    • USA

    Washington continues to exert pressure on the Netherlands over ASML

    According to Reuters, citing people familiar with the matter, the US government plans to increase pressure on the Netherlands to prevent the leading chip manufacturer ASML from servicing certain devices in China.

    Alan Estevez, head of US export policy, will meet with representatives of the Dutch government and ASML next Monday to discuss the maintenance contracts. During the talks, Washington could also try to expand the list of Chinese chip factories barred from receiving Dutch equipment.

    US President Joe Biden continues to crack down on Beijing’s plans to develop an advanced semiconductor industry. Consequently, the US blocks China’s access to imported technology and urges its allies to support this strategy. rtr

    • ASML
    • ASML
    • Chips
    • Netherlands
    • Semiconductor
    • USA

    VW-Traton also fears Chinese competition in commercial vehicles

    The head of Volkswagen’s truck holding company Traton (MAN, Scania) sees tough competition for commercial vehicles in Europe coming from the People’s Republic. Chinese electric bus providers have positioned themselves well in a very short time, mainly thanks to their access to very good battery technology, Christian Levin told the Bloomberg news agency: “If you extrapolate that and look at trucks, you can imagine a similar development.”

    Although European companies such as Traton and Daimler Truck also offer electric trucks, they have so far sold very poorly. By contrast, Chinese manufacturers like BYD, which also offer electric trucks and buses, are far stronger, especially in the Chinese market.

    BYD has been selling electric buses and trucks in Europe for some time. In 2017, BYD opened a plant in Komarom, which manufactures 400 electric buses annually for Europe. flee

    • Autoindustrie

    Opinion

    Between the lines

    By Johnny Erling
    Johnny Erling schreibt die Kolumne für die China.Table Professional Briefings

    Beijing’s battalions of officially mandated internet watchdogs have sophisticated censorship methods at their disposal to ensure that online criticism and problematic revelations quickly disappear from the web. However, tech-savvy bloggers constantly find new ways to bypass the tight controls. Since 2021, an activist who calls himself “Teacher Li” 李老师 has been helping them from overseas to understand the true situation in the country. Millions read his posts, which have earned him legendary status in China.

    “Teacher Li is not your teacher” 李老师不是你老师@whyyoutouzhele is the name of Li’s Twitter (X) account, which keeps tricking the censors. Subversive online news they believed to have successfully deleted is swiftly returned to their inbox.

    A helpline for the people of China

    The person behind it is a Chinese artist who has lived in Italy since 2015. Li Ying (李颖), now 31, revealed his identity in an interview with New York Times journalist Li Yang in late 2023. Teacher Li is not a typical exiled dissident who attacks China’s leadership from the outside. He is far more dangerous because he has turned his Twitter account into a virtual helpline for the people of China.

    He receives daily news and posts from many provinces of the People’s Republic, raw snapshots, and eyewitness accounts of injustice, protests, or absurdities. These often are screenshots that other bloggers take of domestic WeChats and video clips before censorship strikes.

    Li receives them, sorts them, evaluates their credibility and usually forwards them as tweets without comment. For Geremie R. Barmé, who portrayed him for “China Heritage” together with reporter Li Yuan, Li operates a “clearing house for unofficial information.” His pseudonym follows the Taoist wisdom: “The teacher who is no teacher is truly a teacher.”

    Accidents, misfortunes and regulatory injustice

    In 2021, Li initially used his Sina Weibo account within China for such posts. Censorship blocked him. Other bloggers then sent him their mobile phone numbers so that he could register a new account. After 49 accounts were censored, he opened his Twitter page in April 2022 – a foreign account that China’s censors could not touch.

    Although Twitter access is blocked in China, privileged users and millions of tech-savvy bloggers use VPN (proxy) servers to bypass the infamous Great Firewall. Li’s Twitter following grew to 1.6 million readers in early 2024. Many share his posts with their friends and acquaintances.

    For example, China and the rest of the world quickly learned about Shanghai’s “White Paper” anti-COVID protest movement and recently about many spontaneous expressions of condolence in response to the death of ex-Premier Li Keqiang. Eyewitnesses and those involved reported accidents, misfortunes, or administrative injustices that China’s state media were not allowed to cover.

    Longing for a counter-public is growing

    The censors were so helpless and angry that they started locating and summoning followers of Lis’ tweets individually to deter them. The teacher himself is also feeling the pressure. His parents are being harassed, and even in Italy, he has to fear for his safety and has already moved four times.

    The need for a counter-publicity is growing in China’s opaque, highly censored news situation. Li’s posts come at just the right time. In mid-March, he published a list of the latest absurdities in the cult of personality surrounding China’s current leader, Xi Jinping. Bloggers have investigated how often he allows himself to be praised by the official party media as the nation’s mastermind who leads the way. They sent Li a list of 243 examples that had appeared between 2015 and 2024.

    A new feature of the personality cult surrounding Xi Jinping is that he is praised as a thought leader who personally “shows China the way” in all matters. Bloggers already call him the “Chief Compass.” When the renowned monthly literary magazine “Selection of Essays” featured a giant pointing finger on its cover in December, it crashed with it.

    The list begins with the official announcement on November 12, 2015, that Party leader Xi is “guiding the future development of the stock market” (为股票市场未来发展指明方向). And it ends with this news from March 11, 2024: Xi shows us the way to overcome the bottlenecks in the development of the new qualitative productive forces (为打通束缚新质生产力发展堵点指明方向).

    “Puffing yourself up to intimidate others”

    The more power Xi was able to transfer to himself after 2015 at the two major Party Congresses in 2017 and 2022, the more often the Party media praised him as the ultimate guide and advisor for every conceivable problem. Bloggers mockingly call Xi the personified “chief compass” of the country: “Just like Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin and Mao, Xi will also show us the way to hell.”

    The founding father of the People’s Republic, Mao Zedong, once condemned such exaggerated adulation in revolutionary times. In his 1942 speech “Against Stereotypes,” he castigated his functionaries’ empty, theoretical ramblings, saying that their Party language was alienating them from the people.

    In 1942, Mao published his criticism of the empty and stereotypical speeches and writings of communist functionaries. These resembled the exam essays in the old imperial civil service exams, where candidates had to strictly adhere to an eight-part composition scheme in which only form mattered. Mao persecuted anyone who dared to write more openly and critically. To this day, nothing has changed in China’s propaganda.

    Mao compared their writings to the essays that were required of candidates in the Confucian-influenced imperial civil service exams of the Ming and Qing periods. They would fail if they did not strictly adhere to a set “eight-legged writing scheme” (八股文). Mao also criticized the functionaries for filling “endless pages with empty words without substance” (空话连篇, 言之无物), “puffing them up to intimidate others (装腔作势, 借以吓人).” Their essays, Mao scolded, were like the bandages once used to constrict women’s feet, “long and foul-smelling 真是” – “懒婆娘的裹脚,又长又臭”.

    Hidden messages in ideological gibberish

    Even when Mao lapsed into his own cult of personality, he still urged his Party to avoid stereotypical formalism and bureaucratism and to criticize and self-criticism. However, this was no longer meant seriously and was merely lip service, just as his political grandson Xi Jinping is imitating him today to maintain his power. Under his wing, the theoretical excesses of Chinese Party propagandists have become even more repetitive and incomprehensible.

    During China’s liberal reform phase after 1978, there were debates about greater openness. In 1978, satirist Hua Junwu illustrated how difficult it is to read between the lines in the party gibberish of the functionaries. A reader sits on a manuscript and asks another one holding a magnifying glass: “Did you find the author’s angle?” He replies. “No. And I’m already on page 15.”

    And yet sometimes explosive messages are hidden in Xi’s ideological gibberish of today. However, it is becoming increasingly difficult to read and understand them between the lines because Xi only allows his essays to be published months or years later and only in selected excerpts.

    One such example is a previously unknown speech by Xi, which the Party’s leading theoretical magazine printed for the first time on March 15, 2024. Xi gave the speech 14 months ago, on January 9, 2023, on issues of Party discipline. This was shortly after he previously claimed his lifelong rule and absolute Party leadership at the 20th Party Congress.

    Regime security is more important than growth

    Instead of triumphing, Xi appears surprisingly nervous about his internal Party problems. Without mentioning names, he complains: “It is easy for some people to form small cliques, circles and gangs” (些人容易出现搞小山头、小圈子、小嘮伙现象) and warns that “it is easy to destroy a fortress from within. Those who can achieve this can only come from within our own ranks.” (堡垒最容易从内部被攻破,能打败我们的只有我们自己)。

    In a special “criticism and self-criticism” session on 21 and 22 December 2023, Xi also showed his dissatisfaction when he apparently accused his Politburo comrades of being an echo chamber and not telling him the truth. The meeting went unnoticed outside of China because it was Christmas, and Xi’s speech was only published as a summary.

    However, it does say: Xi expects his Politburo to “present the true situation in a timely and objective manner and to describe not only the positive but also the troubling (… ) and not be deceived by external beauty and false figures” (对工作中了解到的真实情况,要及时客观全面反映上来,不能只报喜、不报忧 … 反对华而不实、数据造假).

    In 2015, China’s official foreign language publisher released an up-to-date “Handbook on China’s Economic Policy and its New Political Leadership.” Although the book did not really reveal any new insights, it did concede in its afterword: “It is not easy to understand and follow China’s policy, it is always riddled with unclear messages.” Tellingly, the book cover reads: “Reading between the lines.”

    These few published quotes at least show that, since early 2023, Xi’s main aim has been to prioritize his regime’s political and systemic security over growth and the economy. We now know for a fact just how bad the People’s Republic’s economy was after the abrupt end of the pandemic in 2023.

    We also know about Xi’s domestic political disaster, when he had his foreign and defense ministers and high-ranking military officers disappear overnight, unexplained to this day. Beijing’s propaganda only retrospectively reveals the state of China and its leadership in homeopathic quantities. The loss of transparency is a hallmark of the new era of Xi’s rule. The art of reading between the lines no longer helps. All the more reason why Teacher Li’s tweets are so popular.

    • Censorship
    • Internet
    • Language
    • Society
    • Sprache

    Executive Moves

    Bart van Hezewijk has been responsible for Geopolitics & Trade, Government & External Affairs at Dutch chip machine manufacturer ASML since the beginning of March. He was previously Head of Asia, Government & External Affairs, also at ASML.

    Yu Zhangfu has been Business Development Manager at the China Desk at Roehling Logistics since the beginning of February. He was a project manager at the Chinese Chamber of Commerce in Germany until the end of last year.

    Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

    Dessert

    Before the taste buds can savor it, it is already a feast for the eyes. The hard work of the farmworkers at the tea planting station in Wuxi, Jiangsu Province, makes for a colorful sight. The mostly female pickers only pluck the two finest leaves and the leaf bud and carry them in their basket or a cloth to the collection point. Only the later processing stage decides whether the leaves will become green or black tea.

    China.Table editorial team

    CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen