Table.Briefing: China (English)

Outlook 2024 + Party censors economists

Dear reader,

The China.Table editorial team wishes you a successful New Year 2024. Whether you are doing business in China, have academic or diplomatic relations with the country, or came into contact with the rival and partner in politics and administration: It will be an exciting year for us. The many developments that have started in recent years are now entering a critical phase.

Several simmering trade disputes are about to reach their moment of truth. The ball is in the EU’s court: If it imposes tariffs on Chinese cars, it will send a signal as a determined player, but it will also sow further discord in global trade.

In the US, the election in November will decide whether there will be new drama surrounding Trump. Foreign trade is particularly important for China at the moment: Domestically, the property crisis is far from over, and young people are so discouraged that they are turning “lying flat” into “rotting.”

As a specialist editorial team, we have looked at these trends and pondered what could happen in the New Year. By the end of 2024, we will be able to compare our assessments and forecasts with reality.

Your
Finn Mayer-Kuckuk
Image of Finn  Mayer-Kuckuk

Feature

The China.Table editorial team’s forecasts for 2024

2024 could become a pivotal year in China’s relations with the West. In particular, the trade conflicts between Brussels and Beijing could intensify. Meanwhile, the German government seems unlikely to provide any new impetus for the country’s relations with China. International affairs are likely to be overshadowed by the elections in the USA. Meanwhile, the economy of the People’s Republic continues to feel the effects of the property crisis.

The German government’s China policy: not much more to come

On July 13, 2023, German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock presented the German government’s China strategy. Implementation should actually start now.

Since the publication of Germany’s “Strategy on China” in July 2023, the topic has fallen quiet again in political Berlin. Not much seems to be happening, especially when it comes to the much-vaunted strengthening of China expertise. Existing China programs have been scaled back by the Green-led Ministry of Economics, for instance, and no new programs are planned for 2024 at least.

But, a strategy only makes sense if it is consistently implemented. So far, however, there has been no concrete action. Instead, the suspicion arises that the government has ticked off the unpleasant topic as settled by publishing the paper. This inaction may soon backfire.

Over the past year, China has been a key focus of German government policy. Although this was more than necessary, it was not a matter of course. As recently as 2019, a senior politician of the Free Democratic Party (FDP) admitted that, despite the importance of trade policy for the German economy, China was not at the top of the government’s political agenda; after all, foreign policy does not win elections.

However, awareness of the dangers of excessive dependence on dictatorial regimes has grown steadily since then. However, the conclusions are still very different. While the Greens and FDP call for a tougher relationship with China, the Chancellery led by the Social Democratic Party (SPD) is putting the brakes on. The Social Democrats fear for tens of thousands of jobs particularly dependent on business with China. flee

EU-China: trade tensions will increase

Ursula von der Leyen and Xi Jinping at the EU-China Summit in Beijing on December 7, 2023.

The year 2024 is unlikely to ease tensions in the relationship between Brussels and Beijing. China remains an important trading partner for the EU. However, the EU investigation into Chinese EVs and the new investigation launched at the end of December into dumping biodiesel from China harbor a high risk that trade tensions will intensify in the coming year. It is not unlikely that Brussels will extend further investigations into sectors such as medical technology, cosmetics, wind turbines and solar panels.

The EU trade instrument against economic coercion has been in force since the last week of December – the first official application could be in 2024. Beijing had already threatened consequences if the Netherlands tightened its export controls on semiconductor technology.

Geopolitical issues such as the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine and the conflict in the Middle East will also continue to cloud diplomatic talks. The EU representatives should perhaps finally scratch Beijing’s influence on Moscow off their list of feasible options.

The European elections in June will be decisive for the EU’s standing when the European Parliament is elected and the EU Commission and the EU Council Presidency are reappointed. Europe must show unity and not drift into a chaotic election. Targeted disinformation campaigns from China before the election would come as no surprise in order to discredit the voting. ari

Foreign policy: Beijing is waiting for Trump

Ein Deal zwischen Männern: Donald Trump geht es vor allem um Innenpolitik, Xi hat mehr im Blick.
Deals between men: Xi Jinping shows the way, Donald Trump is primarily concerned with domestic policy (November 2017).

The Communist Party is not known to be a fan of democratic elections. Nevertheless, the leadership in Beijing will be watching two presidential elections next year with great interest: In Taiwan on January 13 and in the US on November 5.

Our prediction: William Lai from the ruling Democratic Progressive Party will become Taiwan’s new president. Beijing will protest the election – as it considers the island nation an integral part of the People’s Republic – and label the winner of the election as a “separatist.” Tensions over Taiwan will increase, but will not escalate – unless there is an unforeseen incident.

Because Beijing is hoping for the US election. There is a certain probability that Donald Trump will move into the White House – and that will raise spirits in Zhongnanhai. Trump is by no means a friend of China – examples include punitive tariffs and the “China virus.” He is also considered unpredictable, something that China does not like at all.

But: Trump loves “strong man politics.” The next US president will strive for a “deal” with Xi Jinping – in which Trump only has American domestic policy in mind. Everyone else is in danger of falling by the wayside. Be it Europe, Japan, South Korea or Taiwan. rad

Property crisis: struggling along the brink

Property prices in China continue to fall, as does house building activity. As the construction industry is the driving force behind the Chinese economy, the crisis is dragging down all other sectors.

Despite all the differences, China faces a similar problem to Germany with its debt brake: Unlike his predecessors, Xi Jinping no longer wants to throw money around as freely to trigger economic fireworks. This is in line with what economists demand. However, to fulfill the party’s promise of prosperity, Beijing would need to invest huge sums now.

Our prediction: the leadership will relent and ultimately provide more money for investment. However, instead of increasing the official deficit, the funds will come from all kinds of hidden sources. This is something Germans are also familiar with. fin

Forced labor: supply chains remain highly vulnerable

The debate about the sustainability of their value creation will accompany European companies throughout the year. The EU Due Diligence Act, which is increasingly taking shape, will further tighten the conditions.

Companies whose value creation comes – at least in part – from the People’s Republic of China are particularly affected and are much more in the limelight than others. The reason for this is the forced labor system implemented by the Chinese authorities to integrate the Uyghur minority into the country’s industrial production.

The year 2024 will be dominated by discussions about the degree of responsibility that can be expected of companies and the social question of what role consumers play. grz

Society: refusal and searching for meaning

China’s youth questions the way things are more than ever. They want to work less or at least more meaningfully. Not necessarily start a family. Refuse to bow to tradition. They want to travel, celebrate, be spiritual, and, above all, strive for mental and physical health.

But the search for ways out and balance creates new pressure. Nowhere are the ideals of beauty and the beautiful lives of others as unattainable as in China’s social media world. Everyone is under scrutiny. Everyone competes with each other. The judgment and mockery of the invisible masses are merciless.

Even refusal is degraded to an internet trend. The protest stance “Tǎng píng 躺平” – “lie flat” – became “Bǎi làn 摆烂” – “let it rot” in 2023. It’s hard to imagine what will come next. fpe

  • China strategy
  • Geopolitics
  • Real estate crisis
  • Society
  • Supply Chain Act
  • USA

Expectations management for 2024: leadership censors pessimistic economists

Investor on the last trading day of 2023 in the city of Fuyang: The mood remains unchanged – now the security authorities are to sort it out.

In his New Year’s Address, Xi Jinping made a communicative turnaround: For the first time since the beginning of the property crisis three years ago, he semi-openly addressed economic problems. In a paragraph on the economic situation, he mentioned two details:

  • “Some enterprises had a tough time.”
  • “Some people had difficulty finding jobs and meeting basic needs.”

Admitting the difficulties was, as is typical for New Year’s speeches by politicians all over the world, the springboard for promising an improvement in the new year.

Euphonious announcement, hardly any concrete policy

Overall, China is undertaking massive attempts to raise confidence in the economy for 2024. But so far, Xi is the only one who is allowed to name the problems, and that is likely to remain the case for a while. However, the first visible steps taken by the government have been to tighten censorship and intimidate economic observers who have dared to come out with pessimistic economic assessments.

The top leadership had already called in a major economic meeting in December to boost confidence over the Chinese economy. However, it failed to present a coherent concept as to how

  • China’s growth model can be adapted to the new situation of a developed economy,
  • the woes in the property sector can be corrected,
  • consumption and private investment will be given a stronger role as promised.

Security authorities deployed against analysts

Confidence in the economy consequently did not increase significantly after the conference. Instead, the leadership is now desperate to spread good vibes and uses its toolbox to control information.

Xi is even deploying the security authorities to combat pessimism. Negative economic forecasts or criticism of economic policies are labeled an attack on “China’s unique socialist system” on the WeChat account of the Ministry of State Security.  

As a result, economic analysts and commentators, both Chinese and foreign, said consequently they would be more cautious when publishing research reports in the public sphere or simply stop posting things on public platforms.  

Optimism ordered from above as a universal remedy 

Observers said the government’s interference would further distort information about the economy and hurt the regime’s credibility. Lying won’t fix the underlying problems. The attempt to employ propaganda to influence consumers and investors also reflected the leadership’s misperception of mass communication’s role in economic management, they said.   

The Central Economic Work Conference, chaired by Party Secretary Xi Jinping, was held December 11-12 in Beijing. The conference, held annually in November or December, sets the economic agenda for the next year. “Weak social expectations” was named in the conference’s readout as one of the key challenges the Chinese economy faces. Expectation management for 2024 was named as one of the main remedies.  

No assistance for consumers  

However, two other major issues – local government debts and the property sector slump – were mentioned, but no concrete measures were given. “Xi Jinping doesn’t seem to care what the market really is concerned about and simply wants to say things he loves to say and do things in his own way,” said an analyst in Hong Kong, who, like other people interviewed for this analysis, declined to be named.  

The leadership has long since reached a consensus that private consumption should be made a stronger driving force for China’s growth. Better social welfare, particularly for the low- and middle-range incomers, is believed to hold the key.  

According to the conference readout, however, the government should act “within its capacity” regarding social security. This weak statement, a euphemism for being stingy, echoed an article by Xi Jinping last year, saying China should not pursue “welfarism,” which he said was unsustainable and would “encourage laziness.”  

The CCP’s credibility problem

A lot has been said this year about promoting private investment. Top government officials made rounds of assurances and promises, new preferential policies were introduced; a Bureau for Private Economy was established.  

But the people that all these were aimed at, the company owners and manager, stayed unmoved. “Local private entrepreneurs have been asking themselves the same question as international investors: Shall I believe in their promises?” said a lawyer in Beijing.   

According to a well-circulated lecture transcription by renowned economist Wei Jie (魏杰) of Tsinghua University in November, Chinese entrepreneurs were still reeling from the crackdown on the private sector just a couple of years ago. Only a complete legal framework protecting their property and personal rights could convince them, Wei said. 

The lecture’s veracity could not be confirmed. However, other observers said what was in the lecture was stark truth, which many didn’t bother to say to offend the government.  

Economists have been silenced

So, instead of improving the fundamentals, the leadership tried to control speech. “It is imperative to strengthen publicity concerning the economic situation and to guide public opinion. Confidence about the Chinese economy’s bright prospects should be sung out loud” 加强经济宣传和舆论引导,唱响中国经济光明论, the conference readout says.  

Even before the conference, social media accounts of popular economists and writers on financial topics, such as Wu Xiaobo 吴晓波 and Liu Jipeng 刘继鹏 were already suspended for writing critically about economic policy. One day after the conference’s closing, many less well-known economic and financial channels received platform messages advising them not to publish “negative comments.”   

Warning from intelligence services

Then, the Ministry of State Security joined the censors with a more spooky step. In a stern statement issued on December 14, the ministry lambasted “maliciously fabricated narratives” aimed “to disrupt market expectations and market order” and “to strategically suppress China and to block its development.” The ministry would “resolutely crack down on and punish illegal and criminal activities jeopardizing the country’s economy,” it stated.   

Analysts of China’s financial institutions have already been restraining themselves in recent years in expressing negative views about both the Chinese economy and its financial market. In addition, there have been reports on international institutions‘ offices in China being raided in the past two years after the institutions’ overseas employees published negative opinions on China.   

Flawed communication strategy

A media researcher said the government’s approach may backfire. “The government might get the idea from what they see as success in the manipulation of international news,” a media researcher in Beijing said. “When it comes to the economy, it won’t work. People can simply look at themselves and the people around them, and then decide how much they would spend or whether they should invest.” Liu Yi

  • Censorship
  • Economic Situation

News

Xi speaks of ‘reunification’ with Taiwan in speech

In his New Year’s address, China’s President Xi Jinping brought a “reunification” of China close to a mention of Taiwan. “China will surely be reunified, and all Chinese on both sides of the Taiwan Strait should be bound by a common sense of purpose and share in the glory of the rejuvenation of the Chinese nation,” he said towards the end of his speech on New Year’s Eve.

Taiwan’s outgoing President, Tsai Ing-wen, rejected Xi Jinping’s sovereignty claim. The most important principle for the course of relations with China is democracy, Tsai said at her New Year’s press conference. Taiwan’s relations with China must be decided by the will of the people and peace must be based on “dignity.”

“This is taking the joint will of Taiwan’s people to make a decision. After all, we are a democratic country,” she said.

Last year, Xi said only that people on either side of the strait are “members of one and the same family.” The new wording thus increases the pressure on the island. Taiwan holds elections in January.

Before that, he spoke about the state of the nation. Xi’s main plans for 2024:

  • Celebration of the 75th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China,
  • Development of the country according to Xi Jinping’s ideas, such as the “new development philosophy,” the “new development paradigm,” “high-quality development” and other phrases,
  • strengthening the economic recovery and raising confidence in the economy,
  • a boost for education, science and technology.

Among other things, Xi named the milestones for 2023:

  • the growth of the new Xiongan economic region,
  • Progress in climate action,
  • Record harvests,
  • the maiden flight of China’s first domestic Comac C919 passenger aircraft,
  • China’s first cruise ship,
  • the success of a new smartphone model,
  • the ongoing space missions,
  • the international popularity of Chinese brands,
  • market power in car batteries and e-mobility,
  • the Central Asia Summit and the Silk Road Forum,
  • the hosting of the Asian Games.

There has also been a slight change in the photos in the background, which political observers traditionally attach symbolic importance to. New are:

  • a group photo with other state leaders at the Silk Road Forum,
  • new family pictures, including his father, Xi Zhongxun, and a picture of his nuclear family with wife Peng Liyuan and daughter; possibly an expression of strengthening family values,
  • one showing Xi taking the oath of office for his third term as president – an open challenge to critics of his constitutional amendment to allow unlimited terms.
  • and photos from his trip to provinces along the Yangtze River.

Overall, it was once again a very confident speech with many references to China’s global strength. fin

  • Geopolitics
  • Taiwan
  • Xi Jinping

Hong Kong dissident manages to flee

Hong Kong democracy activist Tony Chung was detained for three and a half years. Now, according to his own statements, he has managed to escape to the UK. He arrived there safely and formally applied for political asylum upon entering the country, the 23-year-old wrote on Instagram. He said he was okay under the circumstances.

Until 2020, Chung chaired a student association that campaigned for Hong Kong’s independence. The group disbanded shortly before the controversial National Security Law came into force in June 2020. In 2021, the then 20-year-old democracy activist was nevertheless convicted. Initially only for four months. But because another trial and conviction followed, he remained in prison until the summer of 2023. He was released in June, but had to report to the security police every two to four weeks. Among other things, the officers demanded that he work for them and provide the names of other activists.

Tony Chung said that he lived in fear every day, even after his release. “I feared stepping out of my home, feared using the phone in public, and worried about the possibility of being detained again by national security police officers on the streets,” Chung said.

After obtaining permission in Hong Kong to go on holiday to the Japanese island of Okinawa, Chung was able to escape to the UK. flee

  • Demokratie
  • Nationales Sicherheitsgesetz

Tech giant Xiaomi wants to be among the top 5 car manufacturers

Chinese smartphone manufacturer Xiaomi announced ambitious goals at the presentation of its first EV. “By working hard over the next 15 to 20 years, we will become one of the world’s top 5 automakers, striving to lift China’s overall automobile industry,” announced CEO Lei Jun last Thursday. The Group also aims to build a “dream car comparable to Porsche and Tesla.”

The smartphone giant from Beijing plans to invest ten billion dollars in the automotive business within a decade. According to an insider, Xiaomi targets a volume of 100,000 vehicles in the first year. The cars will be produced by a division of the state-owned car manufacturer BAIC in a factory in Beijing with an annual capacity of 200,000 vehicles.

However, the SU7 sedan now unveiled is making its debut at a time when the world’s largest car market struggles with overcapacity, price wars and weak demand. Car market experts predict that no more than one in ten of the more than 100 Chinese EV manufacturers will survive in the coming years. flee

  • Car Industry
  • E-Autos
  • E-cars
  • Xiaomi

Central Committee expels nine top military officers

The Central Committee of the Communist Party has expelled nine high-ranking military representatives from the National People’s Congress. They include four generals from the Strategic Rocket Forces, according to the official Xinhua news agency.

This step is part of a comprehensive reshuffle of the country’s military leadership since Defense Minister Li Shangfu was officially ousted in October. Beijing appointed former navy commander Dong Jun as the new defense minister on Friday. In recent months, the leadership of the secret Chinese Rocket Forces, responsible for the nuclear arsenal, has also been replaced. flee

  • Military
  • National People’s Congress

Heads

Dong Jun – China’s new minister of defense

An admiral for times of maritime disputes: Dong Jun replaces a missing minister.

Dong Jun has been appointed the new defense minister of the People’s Republic of China. According to the state news agency Xinhua, President Xi Jinping approved the appointment last Friday.

The post had been vacant for months after General Li Shangfu was ousted as defense minister in September. The promotion of Admiral Dong thus fills the vacancy at the top of the Chinese military. Together with other purges in the Chinese military, this caused much uncertainty and speculation.

In addition, Dong is the first defense minister to come from the ranks of the Chinese Navy. And this fact indicates where China’s military focus will be in the near future: on Taiwan and the South China Sea.

A man of the Navy

Dong Jun 董军 is what is commonly referred to as a man of the sea. He was born in 1961 in Yantai in the Chinese coastal province of Shandong. After graduating from the Dalian Naval Academy, he joined the Chinese Navy in 1979.

In his early career years, he headed the military training department of the People’s Liberation Army’s naval command and was Deputy Chief of Staff of the Beihai Fleet.

Focus on the South China Sea

Dong subsequently served in every major naval division of the PLA: in the North Sea Fleet, which regularly conducts joint exercises with the Russian Navy, as well as in the Baltic Sea Fleet, which focuses on potential conflicts with Japan. In January 2017, Dong was appointed deputy commander of the Southern Theater Command of the PLA.

This post is probably what qualified Dong as the new defense minister, as the main tasks of the Southern Theater Command 南部战区 are security in the South China Sea and supporting the Eastern Theater Command in any major operation against Taiwan.

And so it seems as if Dong’s career was made for the Chinese military’s current strategy: Good contacts with Russia coupled with years of expertise in dealing with Japan, Taiwan and the South China Sea.

But Xi has the power

However, it should be noted that Dong Jun has far less direct power than his counterparts in other countries. Command authority lies with the Central Military Commission – and its chairman is Xi Jinping.

Instead, China’s Defense Minister acts primarily as a public representative of the military. Dong will represent the People’s Liberation Army to the public and other military leaders – and this is likely to be his main focus in the coming months. Dong must improve relations with the USA. These had also deteriorated dramatically in the wake of growing tensions in the South China Sea. In mid-November, Presidents Biden and Xi agreed to resume direct dialogue between their militaries.

Dialog with the US

The start came last week when General Charles Brown, Chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, spoke with his Chinese counterpart, General Liu Zhenli. However, the two countries’ defense ministers have not communicated with each other in over a year.

Yet this is essential, especially in Dong’s area of expertise. In the South China Sea and the Taiwan Strait, there is a risk that a lack of communication channels could lead to misunderstandings or an unwanted escalation. Dong Jun should, therefore, quickly seek dialogue with Lloyd Austin. In any case, the first hurdle has already been taken: Unlike his predecessor, Li Shangfu, Dong Jun has not been sanctioned by the US. Michael Radunski

  • Geopolitics
  • Military
  • South China Sea

Executive Moves

Lu Lei has been appointed as one of the four vice governors of the People’s Bank of China (PBOC). He succeeds Liu Guoqiang, who has held the post since 2018 and is now retiring. Lu comes from the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) and brings with him considerable experience in financial regulation.

Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

Dessert

There was a time when the German Embassy School in Beijing was able to rent Kunming Lake in the famous Summer Palace for the school’s own ice festival. That was in the mid-1980s. China was still poor and there were not many tourists. The Beijing park authorities were grateful for any Western currency that could be used to maintain the former imperial grounds. Today, this is almost unimaginable. Even in freezing temperatures, the Summer Palace is one of the most popular destinations in the capital. flee

China.Table editorial team

CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    The China.Table editorial team wishes you a successful New Year 2024. Whether you are doing business in China, have academic or diplomatic relations with the country, or came into contact with the rival and partner in politics and administration: It will be an exciting year for us. The many developments that have started in recent years are now entering a critical phase.

    Several simmering trade disputes are about to reach their moment of truth. The ball is in the EU’s court: If it imposes tariffs on Chinese cars, it will send a signal as a determined player, but it will also sow further discord in global trade.

    In the US, the election in November will decide whether there will be new drama surrounding Trump. Foreign trade is particularly important for China at the moment: Domestically, the property crisis is far from over, and young people are so discouraged that they are turning “lying flat” into “rotting.”

    As a specialist editorial team, we have looked at these trends and pondered what could happen in the New Year. By the end of 2024, we will be able to compare our assessments and forecasts with reality.

    Your
    Finn Mayer-Kuckuk
    Image of Finn  Mayer-Kuckuk

    Feature

    The China.Table editorial team’s forecasts for 2024

    2024 could become a pivotal year in China’s relations with the West. In particular, the trade conflicts between Brussels and Beijing could intensify. Meanwhile, the German government seems unlikely to provide any new impetus for the country’s relations with China. International affairs are likely to be overshadowed by the elections in the USA. Meanwhile, the economy of the People’s Republic continues to feel the effects of the property crisis.

    The German government’s China policy: not much more to come

    On July 13, 2023, German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock presented the German government’s China strategy. Implementation should actually start now.

    Since the publication of Germany’s “Strategy on China” in July 2023, the topic has fallen quiet again in political Berlin. Not much seems to be happening, especially when it comes to the much-vaunted strengthening of China expertise. Existing China programs have been scaled back by the Green-led Ministry of Economics, for instance, and no new programs are planned for 2024 at least.

    But, a strategy only makes sense if it is consistently implemented. So far, however, there has been no concrete action. Instead, the suspicion arises that the government has ticked off the unpleasant topic as settled by publishing the paper. This inaction may soon backfire.

    Over the past year, China has been a key focus of German government policy. Although this was more than necessary, it was not a matter of course. As recently as 2019, a senior politician of the Free Democratic Party (FDP) admitted that, despite the importance of trade policy for the German economy, China was not at the top of the government’s political agenda; after all, foreign policy does not win elections.

    However, awareness of the dangers of excessive dependence on dictatorial regimes has grown steadily since then. However, the conclusions are still very different. While the Greens and FDP call for a tougher relationship with China, the Chancellery led by the Social Democratic Party (SPD) is putting the brakes on. The Social Democrats fear for tens of thousands of jobs particularly dependent on business with China. flee

    EU-China: trade tensions will increase

    Ursula von der Leyen and Xi Jinping at the EU-China Summit in Beijing on December 7, 2023.

    The year 2024 is unlikely to ease tensions in the relationship between Brussels and Beijing. China remains an important trading partner for the EU. However, the EU investigation into Chinese EVs and the new investigation launched at the end of December into dumping biodiesel from China harbor a high risk that trade tensions will intensify in the coming year. It is not unlikely that Brussels will extend further investigations into sectors such as medical technology, cosmetics, wind turbines and solar panels.

    The EU trade instrument against economic coercion has been in force since the last week of December – the first official application could be in 2024. Beijing had already threatened consequences if the Netherlands tightened its export controls on semiconductor technology.

    Geopolitical issues such as the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine and the conflict in the Middle East will also continue to cloud diplomatic talks. The EU representatives should perhaps finally scratch Beijing’s influence on Moscow off their list of feasible options.

    The European elections in June will be decisive for the EU’s standing when the European Parliament is elected and the EU Commission and the EU Council Presidency are reappointed. Europe must show unity and not drift into a chaotic election. Targeted disinformation campaigns from China before the election would come as no surprise in order to discredit the voting. ari

    Foreign policy: Beijing is waiting for Trump

    Ein Deal zwischen Männern: Donald Trump geht es vor allem um Innenpolitik, Xi hat mehr im Blick.
    Deals between men: Xi Jinping shows the way, Donald Trump is primarily concerned with domestic policy (November 2017).

    The Communist Party is not known to be a fan of democratic elections. Nevertheless, the leadership in Beijing will be watching two presidential elections next year with great interest: In Taiwan on January 13 and in the US on November 5.

    Our prediction: William Lai from the ruling Democratic Progressive Party will become Taiwan’s new president. Beijing will protest the election – as it considers the island nation an integral part of the People’s Republic – and label the winner of the election as a “separatist.” Tensions over Taiwan will increase, but will not escalate – unless there is an unforeseen incident.

    Because Beijing is hoping for the US election. There is a certain probability that Donald Trump will move into the White House – and that will raise spirits in Zhongnanhai. Trump is by no means a friend of China – examples include punitive tariffs and the “China virus.” He is also considered unpredictable, something that China does not like at all.

    But: Trump loves “strong man politics.” The next US president will strive for a “deal” with Xi Jinping – in which Trump only has American domestic policy in mind. Everyone else is in danger of falling by the wayside. Be it Europe, Japan, South Korea or Taiwan. rad

    Property crisis: struggling along the brink

    Property prices in China continue to fall, as does house building activity. As the construction industry is the driving force behind the Chinese economy, the crisis is dragging down all other sectors.

    Despite all the differences, China faces a similar problem to Germany with its debt brake: Unlike his predecessors, Xi Jinping no longer wants to throw money around as freely to trigger economic fireworks. This is in line with what economists demand. However, to fulfill the party’s promise of prosperity, Beijing would need to invest huge sums now.

    Our prediction: the leadership will relent and ultimately provide more money for investment. However, instead of increasing the official deficit, the funds will come from all kinds of hidden sources. This is something Germans are also familiar with. fin

    Forced labor: supply chains remain highly vulnerable

    The debate about the sustainability of their value creation will accompany European companies throughout the year. The EU Due Diligence Act, which is increasingly taking shape, will further tighten the conditions.

    Companies whose value creation comes – at least in part – from the People’s Republic of China are particularly affected and are much more in the limelight than others. The reason for this is the forced labor system implemented by the Chinese authorities to integrate the Uyghur minority into the country’s industrial production.

    The year 2024 will be dominated by discussions about the degree of responsibility that can be expected of companies and the social question of what role consumers play. grz

    Society: refusal and searching for meaning

    China’s youth questions the way things are more than ever. They want to work less or at least more meaningfully. Not necessarily start a family. Refuse to bow to tradition. They want to travel, celebrate, be spiritual, and, above all, strive for mental and physical health.

    But the search for ways out and balance creates new pressure. Nowhere are the ideals of beauty and the beautiful lives of others as unattainable as in China’s social media world. Everyone is under scrutiny. Everyone competes with each other. The judgment and mockery of the invisible masses are merciless.

    Even refusal is degraded to an internet trend. The protest stance “Tǎng píng 躺平” – “lie flat” – became “Bǎi làn 摆烂” – “let it rot” in 2023. It’s hard to imagine what will come next. fpe

    • China strategy
    • Geopolitics
    • Real estate crisis
    • Society
    • Supply Chain Act
    • USA

    Expectations management for 2024: leadership censors pessimistic economists

    Investor on the last trading day of 2023 in the city of Fuyang: The mood remains unchanged – now the security authorities are to sort it out.

    In his New Year’s Address, Xi Jinping made a communicative turnaround: For the first time since the beginning of the property crisis three years ago, he semi-openly addressed economic problems. In a paragraph on the economic situation, he mentioned two details:

    • “Some enterprises had a tough time.”
    • “Some people had difficulty finding jobs and meeting basic needs.”

    Admitting the difficulties was, as is typical for New Year’s speeches by politicians all over the world, the springboard for promising an improvement in the new year.

    Euphonious announcement, hardly any concrete policy

    Overall, China is undertaking massive attempts to raise confidence in the economy for 2024. But so far, Xi is the only one who is allowed to name the problems, and that is likely to remain the case for a while. However, the first visible steps taken by the government have been to tighten censorship and intimidate economic observers who have dared to come out with pessimistic economic assessments.

    The top leadership had already called in a major economic meeting in December to boost confidence over the Chinese economy. However, it failed to present a coherent concept as to how

    • China’s growth model can be adapted to the new situation of a developed economy,
    • the woes in the property sector can be corrected,
    • consumption and private investment will be given a stronger role as promised.

    Security authorities deployed against analysts

    Confidence in the economy consequently did not increase significantly after the conference. Instead, the leadership is now desperate to spread good vibes and uses its toolbox to control information.

    Xi is even deploying the security authorities to combat pessimism. Negative economic forecasts or criticism of economic policies are labeled an attack on “China’s unique socialist system” on the WeChat account of the Ministry of State Security.  

    As a result, economic analysts and commentators, both Chinese and foreign, said consequently they would be more cautious when publishing research reports in the public sphere or simply stop posting things on public platforms.  

    Optimism ordered from above as a universal remedy 

    Observers said the government’s interference would further distort information about the economy and hurt the regime’s credibility. Lying won’t fix the underlying problems. The attempt to employ propaganda to influence consumers and investors also reflected the leadership’s misperception of mass communication’s role in economic management, they said.   

    The Central Economic Work Conference, chaired by Party Secretary Xi Jinping, was held December 11-12 in Beijing. The conference, held annually in November or December, sets the economic agenda for the next year. “Weak social expectations” was named in the conference’s readout as one of the key challenges the Chinese economy faces. Expectation management for 2024 was named as one of the main remedies.  

    No assistance for consumers  

    However, two other major issues – local government debts and the property sector slump – were mentioned, but no concrete measures were given. “Xi Jinping doesn’t seem to care what the market really is concerned about and simply wants to say things he loves to say and do things in his own way,” said an analyst in Hong Kong, who, like other people interviewed for this analysis, declined to be named.  

    The leadership has long since reached a consensus that private consumption should be made a stronger driving force for China’s growth. Better social welfare, particularly for the low- and middle-range incomers, is believed to hold the key.  

    According to the conference readout, however, the government should act “within its capacity” regarding social security. This weak statement, a euphemism for being stingy, echoed an article by Xi Jinping last year, saying China should not pursue “welfarism,” which he said was unsustainable and would “encourage laziness.”  

    The CCP’s credibility problem

    A lot has been said this year about promoting private investment. Top government officials made rounds of assurances and promises, new preferential policies were introduced; a Bureau for Private Economy was established.  

    But the people that all these were aimed at, the company owners and manager, stayed unmoved. “Local private entrepreneurs have been asking themselves the same question as international investors: Shall I believe in their promises?” said a lawyer in Beijing.   

    According to a well-circulated lecture transcription by renowned economist Wei Jie (魏杰) of Tsinghua University in November, Chinese entrepreneurs were still reeling from the crackdown on the private sector just a couple of years ago. Only a complete legal framework protecting their property and personal rights could convince them, Wei said. 

    The lecture’s veracity could not be confirmed. However, other observers said what was in the lecture was stark truth, which many didn’t bother to say to offend the government.  

    Economists have been silenced

    So, instead of improving the fundamentals, the leadership tried to control speech. “It is imperative to strengthen publicity concerning the economic situation and to guide public opinion. Confidence about the Chinese economy’s bright prospects should be sung out loud” 加强经济宣传和舆论引导,唱响中国经济光明论, the conference readout says.  

    Even before the conference, social media accounts of popular economists and writers on financial topics, such as Wu Xiaobo 吴晓波 and Liu Jipeng 刘继鹏 were already suspended for writing critically about economic policy. One day after the conference’s closing, many less well-known economic and financial channels received platform messages advising them not to publish “negative comments.”   

    Warning from intelligence services

    Then, the Ministry of State Security joined the censors with a more spooky step. In a stern statement issued on December 14, the ministry lambasted “maliciously fabricated narratives” aimed “to disrupt market expectations and market order” and “to strategically suppress China and to block its development.” The ministry would “resolutely crack down on and punish illegal and criminal activities jeopardizing the country’s economy,” it stated.   

    Analysts of China’s financial institutions have already been restraining themselves in recent years in expressing negative views about both the Chinese economy and its financial market. In addition, there have been reports on international institutions‘ offices in China being raided in the past two years after the institutions’ overseas employees published negative opinions on China.   

    Flawed communication strategy

    A media researcher said the government’s approach may backfire. “The government might get the idea from what they see as success in the manipulation of international news,” a media researcher in Beijing said. “When it comes to the economy, it won’t work. People can simply look at themselves and the people around them, and then decide how much they would spend or whether they should invest.” Liu Yi

    • Censorship
    • Economic Situation

    News

    Xi speaks of ‘reunification’ with Taiwan in speech

    In his New Year’s address, China’s President Xi Jinping brought a “reunification” of China close to a mention of Taiwan. “China will surely be reunified, and all Chinese on both sides of the Taiwan Strait should be bound by a common sense of purpose and share in the glory of the rejuvenation of the Chinese nation,” he said towards the end of his speech on New Year’s Eve.

    Taiwan’s outgoing President, Tsai Ing-wen, rejected Xi Jinping’s sovereignty claim. The most important principle for the course of relations with China is democracy, Tsai said at her New Year’s press conference. Taiwan’s relations with China must be decided by the will of the people and peace must be based on “dignity.”

    “This is taking the joint will of Taiwan’s people to make a decision. After all, we are a democratic country,” she said.

    Last year, Xi said only that people on either side of the strait are “members of one and the same family.” The new wording thus increases the pressure on the island. Taiwan holds elections in January.

    Before that, he spoke about the state of the nation. Xi’s main plans for 2024:

    • Celebration of the 75th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China,
    • Development of the country according to Xi Jinping’s ideas, such as the “new development philosophy,” the “new development paradigm,” “high-quality development” and other phrases,
    • strengthening the economic recovery and raising confidence in the economy,
    • a boost for education, science and technology.

    Among other things, Xi named the milestones for 2023:

    • the growth of the new Xiongan economic region,
    • Progress in climate action,
    • Record harvests,
    • the maiden flight of China’s first domestic Comac C919 passenger aircraft,
    • China’s first cruise ship,
    • the success of a new smartphone model,
    • the ongoing space missions,
    • the international popularity of Chinese brands,
    • market power in car batteries and e-mobility,
    • the Central Asia Summit and the Silk Road Forum,
    • the hosting of the Asian Games.

    There has also been a slight change in the photos in the background, which political observers traditionally attach symbolic importance to. New are:

    • a group photo with other state leaders at the Silk Road Forum,
    • new family pictures, including his father, Xi Zhongxun, and a picture of his nuclear family with wife Peng Liyuan and daughter; possibly an expression of strengthening family values,
    • one showing Xi taking the oath of office for his third term as president – an open challenge to critics of his constitutional amendment to allow unlimited terms.
    • and photos from his trip to provinces along the Yangtze River.

    Overall, it was once again a very confident speech with many references to China’s global strength. fin

    • Geopolitics
    • Taiwan
    • Xi Jinping

    Hong Kong dissident manages to flee

    Hong Kong democracy activist Tony Chung was detained for three and a half years. Now, according to his own statements, he has managed to escape to the UK. He arrived there safely and formally applied for political asylum upon entering the country, the 23-year-old wrote on Instagram. He said he was okay under the circumstances.

    Until 2020, Chung chaired a student association that campaigned for Hong Kong’s independence. The group disbanded shortly before the controversial National Security Law came into force in June 2020. In 2021, the then 20-year-old democracy activist was nevertheless convicted. Initially only for four months. But because another trial and conviction followed, he remained in prison until the summer of 2023. He was released in June, but had to report to the security police every two to four weeks. Among other things, the officers demanded that he work for them and provide the names of other activists.

    Tony Chung said that he lived in fear every day, even after his release. “I feared stepping out of my home, feared using the phone in public, and worried about the possibility of being detained again by national security police officers on the streets,” Chung said.

    After obtaining permission in Hong Kong to go on holiday to the Japanese island of Okinawa, Chung was able to escape to the UK. flee

    • Demokratie
    • Nationales Sicherheitsgesetz

    Tech giant Xiaomi wants to be among the top 5 car manufacturers

    Chinese smartphone manufacturer Xiaomi announced ambitious goals at the presentation of its first EV. “By working hard over the next 15 to 20 years, we will become one of the world’s top 5 automakers, striving to lift China’s overall automobile industry,” announced CEO Lei Jun last Thursday. The Group also aims to build a “dream car comparable to Porsche and Tesla.”

    The smartphone giant from Beijing plans to invest ten billion dollars in the automotive business within a decade. According to an insider, Xiaomi targets a volume of 100,000 vehicles in the first year. The cars will be produced by a division of the state-owned car manufacturer BAIC in a factory in Beijing with an annual capacity of 200,000 vehicles.

    However, the SU7 sedan now unveiled is making its debut at a time when the world’s largest car market struggles with overcapacity, price wars and weak demand. Car market experts predict that no more than one in ten of the more than 100 Chinese EV manufacturers will survive in the coming years. flee

    • Car Industry
    • E-Autos
    • E-cars
    • Xiaomi

    Central Committee expels nine top military officers

    The Central Committee of the Communist Party has expelled nine high-ranking military representatives from the National People’s Congress. They include four generals from the Strategic Rocket Forces, according to the official Xinhua news agency.

    This step is part of a comprehensive reshuffle of the country’s military leadership since Defense Minister Li Shangfu was officially ousted in October. Beijing appointed former navy commander Dong Jun as the new defense minister on Friday. In recent months, the leadership of the secret Chinese Rocket Forces, responsible for the nuclear arsenal, has also been replaced. flee

    • Military
    • National People’s Congress

    Heads

    Dong Jun – China’s new minister of defense

    An admiral for times of maritime disputes: Dong Jun replaces a missing minister.

    Dong Jun has been appointed the new defense minister of the People’s Republic of China. According to the state news agency Xinhua, President Xi Jinping approved the appointment last Friday.

    The post had been vacant for months after General Li Shangfu was ousted as defense minister in September. The promotion of Admiral Dong thus fills the vacancy at the top of the Chinese military. Together with other purges in the Chinese military, this caused much uncertainty and speculation.

    In addition, Dong is the first defense minister to come from the ranks of the Chinese Navy. And this fact indicates where China’s military focus will be in the near future: on Taiwan and the South China Sea.

    A man of the Navy

    Dong Jun 董军 is what is commonly referred to as a man of the sea. He was born in 1961 in Yantai in the Chinese coastal province of Shandong. After graduating from the Dalian Naval Academy, he joined the Chinese Navy in 1979.

    In his early career years, he headed the military training department of the People’s Liberation Army’s naval command and was Deputy Chief of Staff of the Beihai Fleet.

    Focus on the South China Sea

    Dong subsequently served in every major naval division of the PLA: in the North Sea Fleet, which regularly conducts joint exercises with the Russian Navy, as well as in the Baltic Sea Fleet, which focuses on potential conflicts with Japan. In January 2017, Dong was appointed deputy commander of the Southern Theater Command of the PLA.

    This post is probably what qualified Dong as the new defense minister, as the main tasks of the Southern Theater Command 南部战区 are security in the South China Sea and supporting the Eastern Theater Command in any major operation against Taiwan.

    And so it seems as if Dong’s career was made for the Chinese military’s current strategy: Good contacts with Russia coupled with years of expertise in dealing with Japan, Taiwan and the South China Sea.

    But Xi has the power

    However, it should be noted that Dong Jun has far less direct power than his counterparts in other countries. Command authority lies with the Central Military Commission – and its chairman is Xi Jinping.

    Instead, China’s Defense Minister acts primarily as a public representative of the military. Dong will represent the People’s Liberation Army to the public and other military leaders – and this is likely to be his main focus in the coming months. Dong must improve relations with the USA. These had also deteriorated dramatically in the wake of growing tensions in the South China Sea. In mid-November, Presidents Biden and Xi agreed to resume direct dialogue between their militaries.

    Dialog with the US

    The start came last week when General Charles Brown, Chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, spoke with his Chinese counterpart, General Liu Zhenli. However, the two countries’ defense ministers have not communicated with each other in over a year.

    Yet this is essential, especially in Dong’s area of expertise. In the South China Sea and the Taiwan Strait, there is a risk that a lack of communication channels could lead to misunderstandings or an unwanted escalation. Dong Jun should, therefore, quickly seek dialogue with Lloyd Austin. In any case, the first hurdle has already been taken: Unlike his predecessor, Li Shangfu, Dong Jun has not been sanctioned by the US. Michael Radunski

    • Geopolitics
    • Military
    • South China Sea

    Executive Moves

    Lu Lei has been appointed as one of the four vice governors of the People’s Bank of China (PBOC). He succeeds Liu Guoqiang, who has held the post since 2018 and is now retiring. Lu comes from the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) and brings with him considerable experience in financial regulation.

    Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

    Dessert

    There was a time when the German Embassy School in Beijing was able to rent Kunming Lake in the famous Summer Palace for the school’s own ice festival. That was in the mid-1980s. China was still poor and there were not many tourists. The Beijing park authorities were grateful for any Western currency that could be used to maintain the former imperial grounds. Today, this is almost unimaginable. Even in freezing temperatures, the Summer Palace is one of the most popular destinations in the capital. flee

    China.Table editorial team

    CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen