Table.Briefing: China (English)

German carmakers gather in Beijing for showdown + BMW China boss confident

Dear reader,

German car brands have dominated the premium segment in China for years. Mercedes is number one here, followed by BMW and Audi. The latter two even managed to increase their sales in 2023. So are claims that German car manufacturers are on the decline in China just naysayer talk?

Julia Fiedler checked out the situation on the ground – at the Beijing Auto Show, which kicked off on Thursday. This is where the Germans are showcasing their new products, including the new G-Class. However, they are flanked more than ever by strong Chinese competition. People had already crowded around the attractive, technologically sophisticated cars from BYD and Xiaomi on the first day. The exhibition hall shows that they have long since set their sights on more than just the mass market, but also the premium class – and with remarkable skill in electromobility and connectivity.

Sean Green confirms this trend: “The battery electric vehicle segment is the most competitive in China.” In an interview by Michael Radunski, BMW’s China President and CEO predicts that BMW will remain one of the most coveted brands in the People’s Republic. As for the lower price segments, the development speed is different, he says, with chaos and often a lot of fuss about nothing. But BMW only plays a minor role there.

Nevertheless, BMW must work hard to remain on the growth path. This applies above all to design, digitalization and software expertise. Those who launch game-changers here will come out on top. “What we see in China today definitely starts to affect the rest of the world tomorrow,” Green says.

Your
Fabian Peltsch
Image of Fabian  Peltsch

Feature

German manufacturers face tough competition in the luxury segment

The electric G-Class celebrates its world premiere at Auto China 2024.

ABB – in China, this abbreviation stands for Audi, BMW and Benz. It is an acronym that stands for true institutions. The German premium manufacturers have dominated their segment for years, with Audi and BMW once again boosting their sales in 2023. However, their future in the Chinese market depends on their electric portfolio, which is not doing too well. Audi’s EV sales were even extremely poor in 2023. As the share of electric cars in the overall Chinese market could already pass the 50 percent mark by 2025, ABB urgently needs electric model growth that is more appealing to China’s customers.

The Auto China 2024 car show, which takes place from 25 April to 4 May in Beijing, is one of the most important trade shows in the world. German manufacturers will also showcase their innovations here, flanked by strong Chinese competition.

This year, 278 New Energy Vehicles (NEV, electrified vehicles) will be on show, and 117 new models will be unveiled. ABB also offers electric innovations: Audi has brought along the Audi Q6L e-tron as a highlight, which will be offered exclusively in China, BWM comes with the facelifted version of the i4 as well as the world premiere of the Mini Aceman, and Mercedes presents the electric G-Class.

Electrified icon: V8 sound gives way to G-Roar

Because in the spirit of transformation, the icon also had to change. The body is angular as usual, with a green core underneath: the G 580 delivers 432 kW (587 hp), a range of 570 kilometers according to CLTC (the Chinese test cycle analogous to the Worldwide Harmonised Light-Duty Vehicles Test Procedure WLTP, which is a little more generous) and a top speed of 180 km/h.

Instead of a powerful V8 engine bubbling under the hood, there now is a ‘G-roar,’ a synthetic sound for the otherwise silent off-roader. Will that work? After all, Chinese G-Class drivers love it when heads start turning as they drive the mighty off-roader through the shopping streets of Sanlitun.

Mercedes-Benz celebrates the premiere of the G 580 in a decommissioned gasholder. It is located on the edge of 798, a former factory site where artists moved into the empty brick buildings in the mid-1990s. Between industrial scrap and Mao slogans, they created their art pieces criticizing consumption and society. But then gentrification hit 798. Today, it is a hotspot for young urbanites who have made their fortune and want to show off heritage and (engineering) art: The target group of the G-Class. The price of over 140,000 euros shows that Mercedes is not targeting the mass market.

Competition in the luxury segment still manageable

Luxury is a strategy that has worked well so far. In the segment to which the G-Class belongs, prices remain stable. Mercedes is number one here, followed by BMW and Audi. The brand wants to capitalize on its core competencies, says Mercedes CEO Ola Kallenius: timeless elegance, superior handling, and, of course, safety. However, the stiff Chinese competition, which is currently mainly active in the lower and premium segments, also wants to aim for the top class.

Of all companies, BYD, actually Volkswagen’s toughest competitor, aspires to go beyond the volume segment. The electric super sports car U9 from the Yangwang sub-brand and the massive and very successful SUV Yangwang U8 demonstrate these ambitions very impressively, says Li San, automotive expert and founder of Auto18.com.cn, who also occasionally sits down with top managers from ABB and advises them on developments in China. “BYD has now proven that they are capable of entering the luxury segment. Other large manufacturers such as GAC, FAW, SAIC and Changan are also trying to do this. They don’t have any models yet, but they will come,” he says. And so the pressure will soon increase.

The Chinese dominate EVs in the premium segment

The eight exhibition halls at Auto China are filled to the brim. Here, car enthusiasts flock together, with one or more bloggers reporting live from almost every car, especially at the Chinese booths. Numerous brands such as Xiaomi, Zeekr, Denza, NIO and XPeng display very attractive, technologically advanced vehicles that prove: Chinese competition dominates in the EV segment, and many cars can rightfully call themselves premium. They often cost less than 30,000 euros. A discount battle that Mercedes-Benz will not be getting into, says Mercedes CEO Ola Källenius: “It makes no sense for a brand like Mercedes-Benz to compete against the volume manufacturers. The dynamics we are seeing in the market are extreme, with incredibly intense competition in the segment below 300,000 yuan. But the Mercedes segment starts above that.”

The Glory Edition of the Zeekr 009 comes with captain’s chairs in the rear – and a massive screen.

Audi CEO Gernot Doellner shows determination. “Audi’s product range is strong. We have a clear plan for the localization and regionalization of our models, and with our partners FAW and SAIC, we have everything we need to remain a strong player in the Chinese market.”

It won’t be easy. After all, Chinese car manufacturers have caught up in quality, design and branding over the last 15 years. Or even overtake them when it comes to software and user experience. However, according to automotive expert Li San, this does not mean ABB will soon disappear. “Building a brand and delivering consistent quality takes time. The majority of middle- and upper-class Chinese still trust German car manufacturers. The automotive industry is a business that requires staying power.”

Moreover, almost all companies are losing money due to the brutal price dumping with which the NEV start-ups are trying to gain market share. How long they can hold out depends on the cash flow. That is why experts estimate that the market will soon consolidate significantly. ‘NEVs are not making any money, so I think ABB’s current strategy is the right one,’ says Li San. After all, classic gasoline cars flush money into the coffers needed for innovations. “However, you must observe the transformation closely, because the Chinese market is developing very quickly. Even if nobody is currently earning money with e-mobility, its market share is already considerable.”

Share of NEVs grows very quickly

According to figures from the China Passenger Car Association (CPCA), more than 50 percent of all passenger cars sold in China in the first two weeks of April were NEVs. Despite their good position in the overall Chinese premium market, Audi, Mercedes-Benz and BMW together accounted for less than 10 percent of electric cars in this segment in 2023. The stronger the penetration of electric cars becomes, the shakier ABB’s position gets.

However, even with a lower market share, growth is possible in the EV sector, as the market will continue to expand in the long term. With the right models and innovations, German premium manufacturers can continue to be successful in the long term. According to the innovation report on the German automotive industry in China 2024 by AHK Greater China, 91 percent of the companies surveyed consider product innovations to be the main success factor, with 70 percent implementing them with the help of strategic partnerships in China – universities, suppliers or customers.

Ola Källenius also emphasizes the importance of cooperation. “Both in China and the rest of the world, we choose the technology partnerships we need for our customers. But what is out of the question for us is to use the platform of another manufacturer. Anyone who buys a Mercedes will get 100 percent Mercedes.” When it comes to the rapid pace of Chinese competitors, who launch cars onto the market much faster, the Mercedes boss confidently says: “China speed is Swabian speed.”

  • Audi
  • BMW
  • Car Industry
  • Competition
  • Electromobility
  • Mercedes Benz
Translation missing.

‘BMW is still the most talked about brand in China’

Sean Green, Head of BMW China, at the Beijing Auto Show.

Many foreign car manufacturers in China are under enormous pressure. How is the China business for BMW going?  

It’s a very competitive market. But if you look at the BMW numbers, we had a very successful year. We grew by more than 5 percent last year, actually slightly ahead of the market. And this year we are again in a growth pace. 

So things are not going badly for BMW when it comes to combustion engines. However, this isn’t the case with electromobility.

Of course, the BEV segment is the most highly competitive in China. But also here, out of the 806,000 BMWs last year, we delivered nearly 100,000 BEVs. So, we are participating in the BEV growth in China. Overall, it’s a very balanced mix. We are playing in both worlds, and I think very successfully. 

Premium brands like BMW seem less susceptible to new competition from China… 

The challenge of the electromobility segment in China is that the electrification takes place at different speeds in different segments. In the lower segments, in China below 250,000 renminbi, there is huge activity, a lot of noise, and a lot of new manufacturers coming in – and this is a difficult segment to be in, to be honest. But actually probably 70 percent of our portfolio is above that price level. So we are competing only to a certain extent within that segment. Above that level, we have a very strong footprint – and that drives profitability.  

Software is an important purchase criterion, especially in China. It seems like Chinese manufacturers are building smartphones on four wheels. How does BMW want to keep up here?  

You’re certainly right. The expectations of digital in the car from the Chinese consumer are extremely high. They expect a seamless connection from their individual digital ecosystem into the car. We set up a joint venture three years ago called BA TechWorks. It’s a 50:50 joint venture with ArcherMind in Nanjing, a very successful local software development firm that actually also supplies many of the other Chinese OEMs in the industry. They have huge expertise in automotive IT and in-car connectivity. The purpose of having this company is that we need to integrate much more Chinese content into our cars – not only for China. Because what we see in China today definitely starts to affect the rest of the world tomorrow. 

For example?

‘Our”festive mode.’ On holidays like Christmas, we bring a whole digital experience into your car with sound and video. We launched it in China, and we are rolling it out around the world now because it was so well-received. And that comes from the development team in Nanjing. ‘Our ‘festive mode.’ On holidays like Christmas, we bring a whole digital experience into your car with sound and video. We launched it in China, and we are rolling it out around the world now because it was so well-received. And that comes from the development team in Nanjing. 

How important are such partnerships to remain competitive?  

I think it depends on the partnership. But China is innovative so it’s important to look at the innovations coming out of China. That’s what we do, for example, with Start-Up garages, where we work with very new start-up companies to see what technology, what innovation we can bring at an early stage into our cars. And, of course, we are always talking with the big tech players like Tencent and Alibaba.  

Is BMW planning further collaborations in this area?

We already have a robust footprint in China, with four R&D locations nationwide: Beijing, Shenyang, Nanjing, and Shanghai. We also work with universities such as Tsinghua or Tongji University. Those partnerships are very beneficial, promoting young innovations, new companies, and great ideas at an early development phase. 

How do you generally view the new competition from China?  

The competition is huge, and in Chinese, they have a word with ‘Neijuan,’ which means sort of ‘involution.’ There’s a lot of innovation coming, but it doesn’t really seem to be a game changer. A lot of new brands are coming in at the same time. Some are very bright highlights, but many brands make noise and don’t seem to get that much momentum into the market.  

We already see a tough selection process among Chinese manufacturers…  

… clearly, too many brands are in the market, so there will be some sort of consolidation. It’s inevitable. We already saw some examples this year with Hiphi and Weltmeister stopping production.  

And what about profitability?

We usually don’t comment on competitors, but I think looking at the numbers, BYD and Li Auto seem to have a strong position from a profitability perspective.  

You said the situation is slightly chaotic with so many brands popping up. What are the impacts on German manufacturers like BMW?  

BMW is still the most talked-about brand in China, and we still have the strongest brand strength in China. So, from a brand position, we’re still in a very strong position. Now, we have to defend our position. We’re playing in a price segment that is mostly above where the main competition sits. 

What will be a key factor for defending your position? 

Design, digitalization, software experience – all those things are important to the Chinese consumer. But on top of that, BMW also has product content and a design language that really attracts Chinese consumers. We’re not looking to be a mass brand. We are talking about a 4 percent share. And here design becomes probably one of the main purchase factors. If you look at some Chinese OEMs from a design stance, honestly, if you take the badges off, you would struggle to differentiate what product. BMW is different, you recognize a BMW. Whether that’s BMW, MINI or Rolls-Royce – all three brands stand for more than just being a car. This is the important factor. You have to bring this emotion, this heritage, a whole storyline.  

The Chinese car market is still growing. But this development also includes the emergence of a used car market. What consequences will this have?  

I think there’s a massive opportunity. We already started our own certified used car program. Last year, it grew by nearly 20 percent. Used car transactions were always a little bit of a grey system in China: and it started to really clean that up. In 2023, China offered tax adjustments to encourage the used car market. And we get a lot of support from industry bodies like the Chinese Dealer Association. Once you have an established used car network, you can start talking about leasing. That’s also still in its infancy in China. But it will come at some point and become a very interesting proposition, which can also stimulate the new car market.  

Last point: overcapacity also has an impact on the car market. How big is the problem?

That depends on who you talk to. When I speak to the Chinese government, there is no overcapacity. But look at the German car market: there you have a 1 to 3 ratio, one domestic car towards three exported. So I would say you also have an overcapacity issue in Germany. Whereas in China, it’s 5 to 1. Five is domestic, one is exported. So there is still room to grow the export business until it’s in the same balance as the German market.  

So do you think that overcapacity is likely to get worse?

I mean, you have to put it into context. What you see is that the Chinese government regulates and limits licensing. They are not giving out licenses for further production capacities, so they set the limits to control capacity in China.  

Sean Green is President and CEO of BMW Group Region China. Green joined BMW in 1988 and held management positions in several markets and departments. 

  • BMW
  • Car Industry
  • Elektromobilität
  • Technology
  • Trade

Events

April 29, 2024; 11:30 a.m. Beijing time
Dezan Shira & Associates, Fair (in Hong Kong): Ushering in the Silver Economy for Retail Business More

April 29, 2024; 9:30 a.m. CEST (3:30 p.m. Beijing time)
EU SME Center, Zoom event: Pricing Strategies for the Chinese Market More

29.04.2024, 22:00 Uhr (30.04.2024, 4:00 Uhr Beijing time) April 29, 2024; 10 p.m. CEST (April 30, 4 a.m. Beijing time)
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Lecture (hybrid): Environment in Asia Series Lecture featuring Huaiyu Chen – Human-Animal Studies and Religions in Medieval Chinese Society More

April 30, 2024; 2:30 p.m. CEST (8:30 p.m. Beijing time)
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Lecture series (hybrid): Urban China Lecture Series featuring Isabella Jackson – Shaping Modern Shanghai: Colonialism in China’s Global City More

April 30, 2024; 6 p.m. CEST (10 p.m. Beijing time)
Heinrich Boell Foundation, online seminar: Value addition in the context of mineral processing More

30.04.2024, 19:00 Uhr (1.5.2024, 1:00 Uhr Beijing time) April 30, 2024; 9 p.m. CEST (May 1, 1 a.m. Beijing time)
SOAS Shapoorji Pallonji Institute of Zoroastrian Studies (SSPIZS), Webinar: To Hong Kong and back again: Parsi charity and building Bombay More

May 7, 2024; 2:30 p.m. CEST (8:30 p.m. Beijing time)
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Lecture series (hybrid): Urban China Lecture Series featuring Zhang Guanchi More

News

After espionage cases: Beijing summons German ambassador

Following the espionage allegations against several Germans earlier this week, the Chinese Foreign Ministry has summoned the German ambassador Patricia Flor in Beijing. Flor made the statement Thursday on the X platform. She called the summons “a quite telling move.” However, she used the opportunity to clarify a few things. “We do not tolerate espionage in Germany, regardless of which country it comes from [and] we protect our democracy and our constitutional state by constitutional means.” She concluded: “The Federal Public Prosecutor General conducts the investigations. In the end, an independent court will decide on the accusations.”

The Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution previously revealed that China’s state security had apparently recruited three individuals in Germany to obtain technical secrets. One day later, an employee of AfD politician Maximilian Krah was arrested on suspicion of spying for China. The Chinese embassy in Berlin rejected the accusations, accusing Germany of “exploiting the espionage accusation to politically manipulate the image of China and defame China.” fpe

  • Spionage

Xi arrives in Hungary on May 8

The first appointments of Xi Jinping’s Europe visit have been confirmed. As Gergely Gulyas, Chief of Staff to Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, explained at a press conference on Thursday, China’s head of state and party leader will visit Hungary from 8 to 10 May. It is in Hungary’s interest to maintain good economic relations with as many countries as possible, said Gulyas, adding that China is one of the leading powers in the world, “stronger than the European Union.”

“Hungary thinks that it is not worth setting up ideological boundaries when it comes to economic relationships and we are happy about the Chinese president’s two-day visit,” Gulyas continued. It is expected that Xi will then visit France for two days and then the Serbian capital Belgrade. Xi Jinping last paid an official four-day visit to Hungary almost 15 years ago, in October 2009. At that time, he was still Vice President of China. Orbán is considered Xi Jinping’s most influential supporter in Europe. fpe/rtr

  • Diplomacy
  • EU
  • Europe
  • Xi Jinping

Blinken insists on a level playing field

At the beginning of his visit to China, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken called for a level playing field for US companies in the People’s Republic. At a Thursday meeting with Shanghai party leader Chen Jining, Blinken raised concerns about China’s “trade policies and non-market economic practices.” Blinken also “stressed that the United States seeks a healthy economic competition with the PRC.” Both sides would have to manage their differences “responsibly.”

Responding to the comments later in the day, the spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Wang Wenbin, told a regular media conference that “China has always been carrying out economic and trade cooperation in accordance with the principles of the market.” Initially, there were no known statements from Chen. He is the highest-ranking politician in Shanghai and the successor to current Premier Li Qiang.

Blinken arrived in China on Wednesday. It is his second visit to China in less than a year. On Friday, he will meet his counterpart Wang Yi in Beijing. A meeting with President Xi Jinping is also expected. In addition to economic and trade issues, the Ukraine war, the Taiwan issue and the US TikTok ban are also likely to be on the agenda. Just this Wednesday, the second chamber of the US Congress, the Senate, also passed a bill forcing TikTok’s parent company ByteDance to sell the social network. rtr/fpe

  • Geopolitik

Lai fills ministerial post and sends message to Beijing

Taiwan’s President-elect Lai Ching-te announced important positions for his government cabinet on Thursday. He also reiterated his offer of talks with Beijing. China should have the confidence to talk to Taiwan’s legally elected government, Lai said

Lai, who will take office on May 20, appointed the former Secretary General of the National Security Council, lawyer Wellington Koo, as Defense Minister. He will take over the key ministry from Chiu Kuo-cheng. Koo said he was determined to discourage any Chinese adventurism over Taiwan with “coordinated actions” with allies in the region and show the world Taiwan’s determination to defend itself by strengthening its combat capabilities.

Koo’s successor as head of the National Security Council will be the current Foreign Minister Joseph Wu. Lin Chia-lung, currently Secretary-General of the Presidential Office, will take over as Foreign Minister. The post of the head of the top China policy maker, the Mainland Affairs Council has gone to Chiu Chui-cheng, a former deputy on the council with years of China policy experience. Intelligence chief Tsai Ming-yen stays on as head of the National Security Bureau.

China has steadily increased the pressure on Taiwan in recent years. Beijing refuses to talk to Lai as it considers him a separatist. Beijing seeks reunification with Taiwan and does not rule out military means to achieve this. rtr

  • Taiwan-Wahlen

New CATL battery offers a range of 1,000 kilometers

The Chinese electric car battery manufacturer CATL promises a new dimension of range: On Thursday, the company presented a lithium iron phosphate (LFP) battery at the Beijing Auto Show that can achieve a range of more than 1,000 kilometers on a single charge. The “Shenxing Plus” battery is the world’s first LFP battery with such a range, said Gao Huan, Head of Technology of the EV division.

Last year’s predecessor version with a range of 700 kilometers is already being used in four car models, Gao added. By the end of the year, an additional 50 EVs models will be equipped with it.

The world’s largest manufacturer of electric car batteries posted rising profits in the first quarter after a decline at the end of last year. According to data from the consulting firm Counterpoint Research, over two-thirds of global battery capacity comes from Chinese manufacturers. rtr

  • E-Autos

Correction: executive moves – BASF Jens Hildebrandt

China.Table falsely reported in its April 25, 2024 issue that Jens Hildebrandt would become BASF’s new “Managing Director” in China. Hildebrandt will actually become Vice President Government Relations Greater China at BASF, based in Beijing, effective July 1, but he will not manage the business. The term “BASF CEO” in the headline is also incorrect. We apologize for the error. See the corrected report here. ari

  • BASF

Column

Gretchen question about marijuana

Both German and Chinese audiences were somewhat amused by a student’s question to Chancellor Olaf Scholz about cannabis legalization in Germany when he visited Tongji University in Shanghai on April 15. This anecdote, which added a rare splash of color to a boring politician’s fruitless trip, was widely reported in the German media and also briefly became a hot topic on Chinese social media.

Surprisingly, very few people bothered to ask: Were the questions from the students, the one on marijuana included, freely chosen by the students without any “guidance” or “approval” from others? The answer is no.    

Orchestration as deeply-ingrained tradition 

All authoritarian regimes are run by control freaks, which are natural products of the nature of authoritarianism.  In China, even in the times of Jiang Zemin (as the party chief 1989 – 2002) and Hu Jintao (2002 – 2012), when the regime was relatively relaxed, events such as foreign leaders’ conversations with university students and press conferences with presence of overseas journalists were also orchestrated. 

For such occasions as the one Scholz was on in Tongji, preparing meetings would certainly be held among foreign ministry officials, university administrators and students; In the meetings, participants – questioners in particular – would be carefully selected; questions and the sequence of the questions decided upon. Just like a stage play. The only improvising part would be left to the foreign speaker.  

Even greater control since Xi

Under the totalitarian Xi Jinping, bureaucrats’ tendency to control all the details in high-profile diplomatic events has become even more compulsive for fear of making the smallest mistake.  

With the US-China relations chronically frosty, China is keen to be in good terms with the biggest European economy. It must have been Germany that proposed a session of exchange of ideas (Gedankenaustausch in German, 交流in Chinese, as appeared on the background board) with students, and the Chinese side felt obliged to satisfy the guests’ desire to make the Chancellor happy. It is not so difficult after all. 

Preparations for the show

Preparations for this seemingly easy event would also be meticulous. The following steps would be carried out: 

  • First, the right questioners were picked: They should look and sound smart and be able to speak decent German to project a nice image of Chinese youth. The requirement for German is understandable because it would save translation time for the one-hour time slotted for the event. 
  • Next came brainstorming to decide on questions to be asked. Guidelines should be: 1) Reflecting the Chinese government’s agenda. 2) To ensure a pleasant atmosphere, questions should sound serious but not challenging, or simply put, stay generic or bland. Therefore, there were questions about trade and investment, energy and sustained development, but no questions on the German position on wars in Ukraine and Gaza, on future of EU or trans-Atlantic relations, and no stupid or irrelevant questions. 

Aiming for the perfect effect 

Now it would sound like a boring press conference. So the Chinese bureaucrats decided to do something bright and interesting to make the whole event feel more real: the cannabis issue – topical, relevant and personal .

Now it would sound like a dull press conference. So Chinese bureaucrats decided to have something light and interesting to make the whole performance look more real: then came the marijuana question: it’s current, relevant and personal.

It also caters to the domestic audience, the vast majority of whom take Western countries’ legalization of cannabis as proof of an absurdly corrupt lifestyle. In addition, the participants would be intrusted to act naturally. I won’t be surprised if they have rehearsed. But the whole thing, when staged, would still look feigned because they actually are. 

Public relations with Chinese characteristics

Open dialogues between politicians and ordinary citizens on equal footing has never been a China thing. Real politics has always been done behind the curtains. The occasional “warm” conversations between Chinese politicians and villagers or people, say, in a supermarket, are always stage-managed, and everybody knows it.  

When foreigners are present, particularly Westerners, Chinese are generally unconfident in presenting themselves. This is due, to a large extent, to the history education stressing the humiliation the nation suffered from Western powers. So they always go out of their way to project a positive image. There is also the aforementioned habit of controlling every aspect of official events. 

In major press conferences with foreign journalists participating, all questions posed by Chinese reporters are set-ups for delivering messages the government wants to deliver. Sometimes, even foreign correspondents, Western ones from respected organizations included, are also controlled to different extents. Foreign journalists have to balance themselves between professional integrity and friendly relationships with the Chinese officials in charge for better access to resources.

  • Propaganda

Executive Moves

Lu Fang has been appointed Chairman of the Chinese investment banking division of JPMorgan Chase & Co. He succeeds previous Chairman Park Pu after almost ten years. Lu will be responsible for overall management, overseeing local governance and the strategic agenda in China.

Ning Zhou has been a project manager at Metzler in Germany since April. The medium-sized company specializes in door intercom systems, among other things. Zhou was previously Channel Sales Manager at Dahua, a Chinese video surveillance company, in Duesseldorf.

Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

Dessert

The Zhongguancun Forum (ZGC Forum) opened its doors in Beijing on Wednesday. The five-day high-tech summit showcases the latest technologies in fields such as artificial intelligence and life sciences. Over 3,100 participants from 75 countries have registered for the event in the Zhongguancun Industrial Development Zone in northwest Beijing. A highlight of the opening ceremony was the presentation of this cyborg sporting a bobbed hairstyle and a chrome-plated backside, which looks like it has come straight out of a video game.

China.Table editorial team

CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    Dear reader,

    German car brands have dominated the premium segment in China for years. Mercedes is number one here, followed by BMW and Audi. The latter two even managed to increase their sales in 2023. So are claims that German car manufacturers are on the decline in China just naysayer talk?

    Julia Fiedler checked out the situation on the ground – at the Beijing Auto Show, which kicked off on Thursday. This is where the Germans are showcasing their new products, including the new G-Class. However, they are flanked more than ever by strong Chinese competition. People had already crowded around the attractive, technologically sophisticated cars from BYD and Xiaomi on the first day. The exhibition hall shows that they have long since set their sights on more than just the mass market, but also the premium class – and with remarkable skill in electromobility and connectivity.

    Sean Green confirms this trend: “The battery electric vehicle segment is the most competitive in China.” In an interview by Michael Radunski, BMW’s China President and CEO predicts that BMW will remain one of the most coveted brands in the People’s Republic. As for the lower price segments, the development speed is different, he says, with chaos and often a lot of fuss about nothing. But BMW only plays a minor role there.

    Nevertheless, BMW must work hard to remain on the growth path. This applies above all to design, digitalization and software expertise. Those who launch game-changers here will come out on top. “What we see in China today definitely starts to affect the rest of the world tomorrow,” Green says.

    Your
    Fabian Peltsch
    Image of Fabian  Peltsch

    Feature

    German manufacturers face tough competition in the luxury segment

    The electric G-Class celebrates its world premiere at Auto China 2024.

    ABB – in China, this abbreviation stands for Audi, BMW and Benz. It is an acronym that stands for true institutions. The German premium manufacturers have dominated their segment for years, with Audi and BMW once again boosting their sales in 2023. However, their future in the Chinese market depends on their electric portfolio, which is not doing too well. Audi’s EV sales were even extremely poor in 2023. As the share of electric cars in the overall Chinese market could already pass the 50 percent mark by 2025, ABB urgently needs electric model growth that is more appealing to China’s customers.

    The Auto China 2024 car show, which takes place from 25 April to 4 May in Beijing, is one of the most important trade shows in the world. German manufacturers will also showcase their innovations here, flanked by strong Chinese competition.

    This year, 278 New Energy Vehicles (NEV, electrified vehicles) will be on show, and 117 new models will be unveiled. ABB also offers electric innovations: Audi has brought along the Audi Q6L e-tron as a highlight, which will be offered exclusively in China, BWM comes with the facelifted version of the i4 as well as the world premiere of the Mini Aceman, and Mercedes presents the electric G-Class.

    Electrified icon: V8 sound gives way to G-Roar

    Because in the spirit of transformation, the icon also had to change. The body is angular as usual, with a green core underneath: the G 580 delivers 432 kW (587 hp), a range of 570 kilometers according to CLTC (the Chinese test cycle analogous to the Worldwide Harmonised Light-Duty Vehicles Test Procedure WLTP, which is a little more generous) and a top speed of 180 km/h.

    Instead of a powerful V8 engine bubbling under the hood, there now is a ‘G-roar,’ a synthetic sound for the otherwise silent off-roader. Will that work? After all, Chinese G-Class drivers love it when heads start turning as they drive the mighty off-roader through the shopping streets of Sanlitun.

    Mercedes-Benz celebrates the premiere of the G 580 in a decommissioned gasholder. It is located on the edge of 798, a former factory site where artists moved into the empty brick buildings in the mid-1990s. Between industrial scrap and Mao slogans, they created their art pieces criticizing consumption and society. But then gentrification hit 798. Today, it is a hotspot for young urbanites who have made their fortune and want to show off heritage and (engineering) art: The target group of the G-Class. The price of over 140,000 euros shows that Mercedes is not targeting the mass market.

    Competition in the luxury segment still manageable

    Luxury is a strategy that has worked well so far. In the segment to which the G-Class belongs, prices remain stable. Mercedes is number one here, followed by BMW and Audi. The brand wants to capitalize on its core competencies, says Mercedes CEO Ola Kallenius: timeless elegance, superior handling, and, of course, safety. However, the stiff Chinese competition, which is currently mainly active in the lower and premium segments, also wants to aim for the top class.

    Of all companies, BYD, actually Volkswagen’s toughest competitor, aspires to go beyond the volume segment. The electric super sports car U9 from the Yangwang sub-brand and the massive and very successful SUV Yangwang U8 demonstrate these ambitions very impressively, says Li San, automotive expert and founder of Auto18.com.cn, who also occasionally sits down with top managers from ABB and advises them on developments in China. “BYD has now proven that they are capable of entering the luxury segment. Other large manufacturers such as GAC, FAW, SAIC and Changan are also trying to do this. They don’t have any models yet, but they will come,” he says. And so the pressure will soon increase.

    The Chinese dominate EVs in the premium segment

    The eight exhibition halls at Auto China are filled to the brim. Here, car enthusiasts flock together, with one or more bloggers reporting live from almost every car, especially at the Chinese booths. Numerous brands such as Xiaomi, Zeekr, Denza, NIO and XPeng display very attractive, technologically advanced vehicles that prove: Chinese competition dominates in the EV segment, and many cars can rightfully call themselves premium. They often cost less than 30,000 euros. A discount battle that Mercedes-Benz will not be getting into, says Mercedes CEO Ola Källenius: “It makes no sense for a brand like Mercedes-Benz to compete against the volume manufacturers. The dynamics we are seeing in the market are extreme, with incredibly intense competition in the segment below 300,000 yuan. But the Mercedes segment starts above that.”

    The Glory Edition of the Zeekr 009 comes with captain’s chairs in the rear – and a massive screen.

    Audi CEO Gernot Doellner shows determination. “Audi’s product range is strong. We have a clear plan for the localization and regionalization of our models, and with our partners FAW and SAIC, we have everything we need to remain a strong player in the Chinese market.”

    It won’t be easy. After all, Chinese car manufacturers have caught up in quality, design and branding over the last 15 years. Or even overtake them when it comes to software and user experience. However, according to automotive expert Li San, this does not mean ABB will soon disappear. “Building a brand and delivering consistent quality takes time. The majority of middle- and upper-class Chinese still trust German car manufacturers. The automotive industry is a business that requires staying power.”

    Moreover, almost all companies are losing money due to the brutal price dumping with which the NEV start-ups are trying to gain market share. How long they can hold out depends on the cash flow. That is why experts estimate that the market will soon consolidate significantly. ‘NEVs are not making any money, so I think ABB’s current strategy is the right one,’ says Li San. After all, classic gasoline cars flush money into the coffers needed for innovations. “However, you must observe the transformation closely, because the Chinese market is developing very quickly. Even if nobody is currently earning money with e-mobility, its market share is already considerable.”

    Share of NEVs grows very quickly

    According to figures from the China Passenger Car Association (CPCA), more than 50 percent of all passenger cars sold in China in the first two weeks of April were NEVs. Despite their good position in the overall Chinese premium market, Audi, Mercedes-Benz and BMW together accounted for less than 10 percent of electric cars in this segment in 2023. The stronger the penetration of electric cars becomes, the shakier ABB’s position gets.

    However, even with a lower market share, growth is possible in the EV sector, as the market will continue to expand in the long term. With the right models and innovations, German premium manufacturers can continue to be successful in the long term. According to the innovation report on the German automotive industry in China 2024 by AHK Greater China, 91 percent of the companies surveyed consider product innovations to be the main success factor, with 70 percent implementing them with the help of strategic partnerships in China – universities, suppliers or customers.

    Ola Källenius also emphasizes the importance of cooperation. “Both in China and the rest of the world, we choose the technology partnerships we need for our customers. But what is out of the question for us is to use the platform of another manufacturer. Anyone who buys a Mercedes will get 100 percent Mercedes.” When it comes to the rapid pace of Chinese competitors, who launch cars onto the market much faster, the Mercedes boss confidently says: “China speed is Swabian speed.”

    • Audi
    • BMW
    • Car Industry
    • Competition
    • Electromobility
    • Mercedes Benz
    Translation missing.

    ‘BMW is still the most talked about brand in China’

    Sean Green, Head of BMW China, at the Beijing Auto Show.

    Many foreign car manufacturers in China are under enormous pressure. How is the China business for BMW going?  

    It’s a very competitive market. But if you look at the BMW numbers, we had a very successful year. We grew by more than 5 percent last year, actually slightly ahead of the market. And this year we are again in a growth pace. 

    So things are not going badly for BMW when it comes to combustion engines. However, this isn’t the case with electromobility.

    Of course, the BEV segment is the most highly competitive in China. But also here, out of the 806,000 BMWs last year, we delivered nearly 100,000 BEVs. So, we are participating in the BEV growth in China. Overall, it’s a very balanced mix. We are playing in both worlds, and I think very successfully. 

    Premium brands like BMW seem less susceptible to new competition from China… 

    The challenge of the electromobility segment in China is that the electrification takes place at different speeds in different segments. In the lower segments, in China below 250,000 renminbi, there is huge activity, a lot of noise, and a lot of new manufacturers coming in – and this is a difficult segment to be in, to be honest. But actually probably 70 percent of our portfolio is above that price level. So we are competing only to a certain extent within that segment. Above that level, we have a very strong footprint – and that drives profitability.  

    Software is an important purchase criterion, especially in China. It seems like Chinese manufacturers are building smartphones on four wheels. How does BMW want to keep up here?  

    You’re certainly right. The expectations of digital in the car from the Chinese consumer are extremely high. They expect a seamless connection from their individual digital ecosystem into the car. We set up a joint venture three years ago called BA TechWorks. It’s a 50:50 joint venture with ArcherMind in Nanjing, a very successful local software development firm that actually also supplies many of the other Chinese OEMs in the industry. They have huge expertise in automotive IT and in-car connectivity. The purpose of having this company is that we need to integrate much more Chinese content into our cars – not only for China. Because what we see in China today definitely starts to affect the rest of the world tomorrow. 

    For example?

    ‘Our”festive mode.’ On holidays like Christmas, we bring a whole digital experience into your car with sound and video. We launched it in China, and we are rolling it out around the world now because it was so well-received. And that comes from the development team in Nanjing. ‘Our ‘festive mode.’ On holidays like Christmas, we bring a whole digital experience into your car with sound and video. We launched it in China, and we are rolling it out around the world now because it was so well-received. And that comes from the development team in Nanjing. 

    How important are such partnerships to remain competitive?  

    I think it depends on the partnership. But China is innovative so it’s important to look at the innovations coming out of China. That’s what we do, for example, with Start-Up garages, where we work with very new start-up companies to see what technology, what innovation we can bring at an early stage into our cars. And, of course, we are always talking with the big tech players like Tencent and Alibaba.  

    Is BMW planning further collaborations in this area?

    We already have a robust footprint in China, with four R&D locations nationwide: Beijing, Shenyang, Nanjing, and Shanghai. We also work with universities such as Tsinghua or Tongji University. Those partnerships are very beneficial, promoting young innovations, new companies, and great ideas at an early development phase. 

    How do you generally view the new competition from China?  

    The competition is huge, and in Chinese, they have a word with ‘Neijuan,’ which means sort of ‘involution.’ There’s a lot of innovation coming, but it doesn’t really seem to be a game changer. A lot of new brands are coming in at the same time. Some are very bright highlights, but many brands make noise and don’t seem to get that much momentum into the market.  

    We already see a tough selection process among Chinese manufacturers…  

    … clearly, too many brands are in the market, so there will be some sort of consolidation. It’s inevitable. We already saw some examples this year with Hiphi and Weltmeister stopping production.  

    And what about profitability?

    We usually don’t comment on competitors, but I think looking at the numbers, BYD and Li Auto seem to have a strong position from a profitability perspective.  

    You said the situation is slightly chaotic with so many brands popping up. What are the impacts on German manufacturers like BMW?  

    BMW is still the most talked-about brand in China, and we still have the strongest brand strength in China. So, from a brand position, we’re still in a very strong position. Now, we have to defend our position. We’re playing in a price segment that is mostly above where the main competition sits. 

    What will be a key factor for defending your position? 

    Design, digitalization, software experience – all those things are important to the Chinese consumer. But on top of that, BMW also has product content and a design language that really attracts Chinese consumers. We’re not looking to be a mass brand. We are talking about a 4 percent share. And here design becomes probably one of the main purchase factors. If you look at some Chinese OEMs from a design stance, honestly, if you take the badges off, you would struggle to differentiate what product. BMW is different, you recognize a BMW. Whether that’s BMW, MINI or Rolls-Royce – all three brands stand for more than just being a car. This is the important factor. You have to bring this emotion, this heritage, a whole storyline.  

    The Chinese car market is still growing. But this development also includes the emergence of a used car market. What consequences will this have?  

    I think there’s a massive opportunity. We already started our own certified used car program. Last year, it grew by nearly 20 percent. Used car transactions were always a little bit of a grey system in China: and it started to really clean that up. In 2023, China offered tax adjustments to encourage the used car market. And we get a lot of support from industry bodies like the Chinese Dealer Association. Once you have an established used car network, you can start talking about leasing. That’s also still in its infancy in China. But it will come at some point and become a very interesting proposition, which can also stimulate the new car market.  

    Last point: overcapacity also has an impact on the car market. How big is the problem?

    That depends on who you talk to. When I speak to the Chinese government, there is no overcapacity. But look at the German car market: there you have a 1 to 3 ratio, one domestic car towards three exported. So I would say you also have an overcapacity issue in Germany. Whereas in China, it’s 5 to 1. Five is domestic, one is exported. So there is still room to grow the export business until it’s in the same balance as the German market.  

    So do you think that overcapacity is likely to get worse?

    I mean, you have to put it into context. What you see is that the Chinese government regulates and limits licensing. They are not giving out licenses for further production capacities, so they set the limits to control capacity in China.  

    Sean Green is President and CEO of BMW Group Region China. Green joined BMW in 1988 and held management positions in several markets and departments. 

    • BMW
    • Car Industry
    • Elektromobilität
    • Technology
    • Trade

    Events

    April 29, 2024; 11:30 a.m. Beijing time
    Dezan Shira & Associates, Fair (in Hong Kong): Ushering in the Silver Economy for Retail Business More

    April 29, 2024; 9:30 a.m. CEST (3:30 p.m. Beijing time)
    EU SME Center, Zoom event: Pricing Strategies for the Chinese Market More

    29.04.2024, 22:00 Uhr (30.04.2024, 4:00 Uhr Beijing time) April 29, 2024; 10 p.m. CEST (April 30, 4 a.m. Beijing time)
    Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Lecture (hybrid): Environment in Asia Series Lecture featuring Huaiyu Chen – Human-Animal Studies and Religions in Medieval Chinese Society More

    April 30, 2024; 2:30 p.m. CEST (8:30 p.m. Beijing time)
    Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Lecture series (hybrid): Urban China Lecture Series featuring Isabella Jackson – Shaping Modern Shanghai: Colonialism in China’s Global City More

    April 30, 2024; 6 p.m. CEST (10 p.m. Beijing time)
    Heinrich Boell Foundation, online seminar: Value addition in the context of mineral processing More

    30.04.2024, 19:00 Uhr (1.5.2024, 1:00 Uhr Beijing time) April 30, 2024; 9 p.m. CEST (May 1, 1 a.m. Beijing time)
    SOAS Shapoorji Pallonji Institute of Zoroastrian Studies (SSPIZS), Webinar: To Hong Kong and back again: Parsi charity and building Bombay More

    May 7, 2024; 2:30 p.m. CEST (8:30 p.m. Beijing time)
    Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Lecture series (hybrid): Urban China Lecture Series featuring Zhang Guanchi More

    News

    After espionage cases: Beijing summons German ambassador

    Following the espionage allegations against several Germans earlier this week, the Chinese Foreign Ministry has summoned the German ambassador Patricia Flor in Beijing. Flor made the statement Thursday on the X platform. She called the summons “a quite telling move.” However, she used the opportunity to clarify a few things. “We do not tolerate espionage in Germany, regardless of which country it comes from [and] we protect our democracy and our constitutional state by constitutional means.” She concluded: “The Federal Public Prosecutor General conducts the investigations. In the end, an independent court will decide on the accusations.”

    The Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution previously revealed that China’s state security had apparently recruited three individuals in Germany to obtain technical secrets. One day later, an employee of AfD politician Maximilian Krah was arrested on suspicion of spying for China. The Chinese embassy in Berlin rejected the accusations, accusing Germany of “exploiting the espionage accusation to politically manipulate the image of China and defame China.” fpe

    • Spionage

    Xi arrives in Hungary on May 8

    The first appointments of Xi Jinping’s Europe visit have been confirmed. As Gergely Gulyas, Chief of Staff to Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, explained at a press conference on Thursday, China’s head of state and party leader will visit Hungary from 8 to 10 May. It is in Hungary’s interest to maintain good economic relations with as many countries as possible, said Gulyas, adding that China is one of the leading powers in the world, “stronger than the European Union.”

    “Hungary thinks that it is not worth setting up ideological boundaries when it comes to economic relationships and we are happy about the Chinese president’s two-day visit,” Gulyas continued. It is expected that Xi will then visit France for two days and then the Serbian capital Belgrade. Xi Jinping last paid an official four-day visit to Hungary almost 15 years ago, in October 2009. At that time, he was still Vice President of China. Orbán is considered Xi Jinping’s most influential supporter in Europe. fpe/rtr

    • Diplomacy
    • EU
    • Europe
    • Xi Jinping

    Blinken insists on a level playing field

    At the beginning of his visit to China, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken called for a level playing field for US companies in the People’s Republic. At a Thursday meeting with Shanghai party leader Chen Jining, Blinken raised concerns about China’s “trade policies and non-market economic practices.” Blinken also “stressed that the United States seeks a healthy economic competition with the PRC.” Both sides would have to manage their differences “responsibly.”

    Responding to the comments later in the day, the spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Wang Wenbin, told a regular media conference that “China has always been carrying out economic and trade cooperation in accordance with the principles of the market.” Initially, there were no known statements from Chen. He is the highest-ranking politician in Shanghai and the successor to current Premier Li Qiang.

    Blinken arrived in China on Wednesday. It is his second visit to China in less than a year. On Friday, he will meet his counterpart Wang Yi in Beijing. A meeting with President Xi Jinping is also expected. In addition to economic and trade issues, the Ukraine war, the Taiwan issue and the US TikTok ban are also likely to be on the agenda. Just this Wednesday, the second chamber of the US Congress, the Senate, also passed a bill forcing TikTok’s parent company ByteDance to sell the social network. rtr/fpe

    • Geopolitik

    Lai fills ministerial post and sends message to Beijing

    Taiwan’s President-elect Lai Ching-te announced important positions for his government cabinet on Thursday. He also reiterated his offer of talks with Beijing. China should have the confidence to talk to Taiwan’s legally elected government, Lai said

    Lai, who will take office on May 20, appointed the former Secretary General of the National Security Council, lawyer Wellington Koo, as Defense Minister. He will take over the key ministry from Chiu Kuo-cheng. Koo said he was determined to discourage any Chinese adventurism over Taiwan with “coordinated actions” with allies in the region and show the world Taiwan’s determination to defend itself by strengthening its combat capabilities.

    Koo’s successor as head of the National Security Council will be the current Foreign Minister Joseph Wu. Lin Chia-lung, currently Secretary-General of the Presidential Office, will take over as Foreign Minister. The post of the head of the top China policy maker, the Mainland Affairs Council has gone to Chiu Chui-cheng, a former deputy on the council with years of China policy experience. Intelligence chief Tsai Ming-yen stays on as head of the National Security Bureau.

    China has steadily increased the pressure on Taiwan in recent years. Beijing refuses to talk to Lai as it considers him a separatist. Beijing seeks reunification with Taiwan and does not rule out military means to achieve this. rtr

    • Taiwan-Wahlen

    New CATL battery offers a range of 1,000 kilometers

    The Chinese electric car battery manufacturer CATL promises a new dimension of range: On Thursday, the company presented a lithium iron phosphate (LFP) battery at the Beijing Auto Show that can achieve a range of more than 1,000 kilometers on a single charge. The “Shenxing Plus” battery is the world’s first LFP battery with such a range, said Gao Huan, Head of Technology of the EV division.

    Last year’s predecessor version with a range of 700 kilometers is already being used in four car models, Gao added. By the end of the year, an additional 50 EVs models will be equipped with it.

    The world’s largest manufacturer of electric car batteries posted rising profits in the first quarter after a decline at the end of last year. According to data from the consulting firm Counterpoint Research, over two-thirds of global battery capacity comes from Chinese manufacturers. rtr

    • E-Autos

    Correction: executive moves – BASF Jens Hildebrandt

    China.Table falsely reported in its April 25, 2024 issue that Jens Hildebrandt would become BASF’s new “Managing Director” in China. Hildebrandt will actually become Vice President Government Relations Greater China at BASF, based in Beijing, effective July 1, but he will not manage the business. The term “BASF CEO” in the headline is also incorrect. We apologize for the error. See the corrected report here. ari

    • BASF

    Column

    Gretchen question about marijuana

    Both German and Chinese audiences were somewhat amused by a student’s question to Chancellor Olaf Scholz about cannabis legalization in Germany when he visited Tongji University in Shanghai on April 15. This anecdote, which added a rare splash of color to a boring politician’s fruitless trip, was widely reported in the German media and also briefly became a hot topic on Chinese social media.

    Surprisingly, very few people bothered to ask: Were the questions from the students, the one on marijuana included, freely chosen by the students without any “guidance” or “approval” from others? The answer is no.    

    Orchestration as deeply-ingrained tradition 

    All authoritarian regimes are run by control freaks, which are natural products of the nature of authoritarianism.  In China, even in the times of Jiang Zemin (as the party chief 1989 – 2002) and Hu Jintao (2002 – 2012), when the regime was relatively relaxed, events such as foreign leaders’ conversations with university students and press conferences with presence of overseas journalists were also orchestrated. 

    For such occasions as the one Scholz was on in Tongji, preparing meetings would certainly be held among foreign ministry officials, university administrators and students; In the meetings, participants – questioners in particular – would be carefully selected; questions and the sequence of the questions decided upon. Just like a stage play. The only improvising part would be left to the foreign speaker.  

    Even greater control since Xi

    Under the totalitarian Xi Jinping, bureaucrats’ tendency to control all the details in high-profile diplomatic events has become even more compulsive for fear of making the smallest mistake.  

    With the US-China relations chronically frosty, China is keen to be in good terms with the biggest European economy. It must have been Germany that proposed a session of exchange of ideas (Gedankenaustausch in German, 交流in Chinese, as appeared on the background board) with students, and the Chinese side felt obliged to satisfy the guests’ desire to make the Chancellor happy. It is not so difficult after all. 

    Preparations for the show

    Preparations for this seemingly easy event would also be meticulous. The following steps would be carried out: 

    • First, the right questioners were picked: They should look and sound smart and be able to speak decent German to project a nice image of Chinese youth. The requirement for German is understandable because it would save translation time for the one-hour time slotted for the event. 
    • Next came brainstorming to decide on questions to be asked. Guidelines should be: 1) Reflecting the Chinese government’s agenda. 2) To ensure a pleasant atmosphere, questions should sound serious but not challenging, or simply put, stay generic or bland. Therefore, there were questions about trade and investment, energy and sustained development, but no questions on the German position on wars in Ukraine and Gaza, on future of EU or trans-Atlantic relations, and no stupid or irrelevant questions. 

    Aiming for the perfect effect 

    Now it would sound like a boring press conference. So the Chinese bureaucrats decided to do something bright and interesting to make the whole event feel more real: the cannabis issue – topical, relevant and personal .

    Now it would sound like a dull press conference. So Chinese bureaucrats decided to have something light and interesting to make the whole performance look more real: then came the marijuana question: it’s current, relevant and personal.

    It also caters to the domestic audience, the vast majority of whom take Western countries’ legalization of cannabis as proof of an absurdly corrupt lifestyle. In addition, the participants would be intrusted to act naturally. I won’t be surprised if they have rehearsed. But the whole thing, when staged, would still look feigned because they actually are. 

    Public relations with Chinese characteristics

    Open dialogues between politicians and ordinary citizens on equal footing has never been a China thing. Real politics has always been done behind the curtains. The occasional “warm” conversations between Chinese politicians and villagers or people, say, in a supermarket, are always stage-managed, and everybody knows it.  

    When foreigners are present, particularly Westerners, Chinese are generally unconfident in presenting themselves. This is due, to a large extent, to the history education stressing the humiliation the nation suffered from Western powers. So they always go out of their way to project a positive image. There is also the aforementioned habit of controlling every aspect of official events. 

    In major press conferences with foreign journalists participating, all questions posed by Chinese reporters are set-ups for delivering messages the government wants to deliver. Sometimes, even foreign correspondents, Western ones from respected organizations included, are also controlled to different extents. Foreign journalists have to balance themselves between professional integrity and friendly relationships with the Chinese officials in charge for better access to resources.

    • Propaganda

    Executive Moves

    Lu Fang has been appointed Chairman of the Chinese investment banking division of JPMorgan Chase & Co. He succeeds previous Chairman Park Pu after almost ten years. Lu will be responsible for overall management, overseeing local governance and the strategic agenda in China.

    Ning Zhou has been a project manager at Metzler in Germany since April. The medium-sized company specializes in door intercom systems, among other things. Zhou was previously Channel Sales Manager at Dahua, a Chinese video surveillance company, in Duesseldorf.

    Is something changing in your organization? Let us know at heads@table.media!

    Dessert

    The Zhongguancun Forum (ZGC Forum) opened its doors in Beijing on Wednesday. The five-day high-tech summit showcases the latest technologies in fields such as artificial intelligence and life sciences. Over 3,100 participants from 75 countries have registered for the event in the Zhongguancun Industrial Development Zone in northwest Beijing. A highlight of the opening ceremony was the presentation of this cyborg sporting a bobbed hairstyle and a chrome-plated backside, which looks like it has come straight out of a video game.

    China.Table editorial team

    CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen