In his nearly two-hour-long speech on Sunday, Xi Jinping once again emphasized China’s energy security. But he also reiterated that the country must continue to drive forward the green transformation. So a departure from China’s climate goals is not to be expected during Xi’s third term in office. However, it will be interesting to see how he will set priorities when things get tough. “How quickly political instability and supply fears can call climate ambitions into question is something we currently witness globally,” explains Nis Gruenberg of the Merics Institute in an interview with Nico Beckert. Because when it comes to fulfilling climate issues, China’s head of state is primarily also concerned with maintaining his own power, the energy policy expert says. “The more uncertain the overall situation, the more uncertain the green transition will be.”
Meanwhile, the official pictures from the Great Hall of the People in Beijing show how firmly Xi currently sits in the saddle. Sometimes in wide angle and sometimes in long shot pictures, Xi is the center of attention in the Middle Kingdom. No one can match him, no one can get close to him. But even an autocrat needs a loyal sidekick. As for who will be the new prime minister at his side in March 2023, we can currently only read between the lines and, at best, from gestures.
One man who Xi pays particular attention to is Hu Chunhua. The 59-year-old is the youngest of China’s four vice presidents under Premier Li Keqiang, and is currently in charge of poverty reduction, agriculture and trade. For the German economy, Hu would be a preferred candidate, says Frank Sieren. He analyzes that Hu is considered a credible and pragmatic crisis manager, as he proved, for example, in the milk powder scandal of 2008. But more importantly, Hu has never lost sight of the goal of further opening China. As recently as August of this year, he declared that China must further “liberalize and simplify” trade and investment for foreign companies. Unheard-of in times of decoupling and zero-Covid isolation.
Carbon emissions have risen less sharply than before since Xi Jinping took office. How much credit can the CP leader take for this? And how important is climate protection to Xi Jinping?
It is of course always difficult to pin this on one person. But in any case, the long-term phase-out of coal and the reduction of carbon emissions are among the most important items on Xi’s political agenda. Xi sees climate protection and adaptation to climate change as a prerequisite for the party’s long-term grip on power and the current form of government. Unfortunately, in the medium term, energy security is also valued more important in China than climate policy; this is currently hurting the ambitions for emission targets.
To what extent can Xi “overrule” on climate protection? How big is the influence of the provinces and state-owned enterprises on this?
This is, of course, an extremely complex game because China is so big. There are provinces that benefit more from rapid transformation than others. But the coal provinces are losing jobs and growth. The provinces are a relatively powerful player, maybe not when it comes to standing up to the central government, but to implementing what comes from Beijing – or delaying the implementation of climate policy. And the central government also likes to turn a blind eye sometimes, especially in times of crisis.
How important is the fact that the central government’s policies are sometimes vague and leave a lot of room for interpretation?
That certainly plays a role. The central government tends to set macro targets: By how many percent per year should emissions fall or renewable energies be expanded? The provinces, the power companies – which are state-owned enterprises – and local players then have to implement these targets. And there are various interests, so of course there are delays.
Where do you see the biggest shortcomings in China’s climate policy of recent years?
China does not have adequate climate plans that would be compatible with the Paris Agreement. So even if the People’s Republic achieves its 2030/2060 targets, it would not contribute a sufficiently large share to meet the Paris climate goals. Another major shortcoming is: China does have the political will and the technical capabilities to rapidly advance the green transition. But still, with every little crisis, the coal lobby manages to slow down the phase-out. And new coal-fired power plants are still being built. This, in turn, will make the phase-out more difficult in the future.
Announced reforms in the power sector to push coal faster out of the grids have also been around for almost 20 years. But not much has happened. Yet there is a lot of potential for cutting carbon emissions in these areas.
What do you expect from Xi Jinping’s third term in office regarding climate protection?
In terms of climate policy, there will generally not be much change during the third term in office. It will move in a greener direction, with coal decreasing by a good one percent per year in the energy mix. But whether it can go faster will also be determined by realpolitik factors – be it economic crises or international tensions. The more uncertain the overall situation, the more uncertain the green transition will be. The transformation will continue, but probably at a slower pace than in a calmer global situation. We currently see globally how quickly political instability and supply fears call climate ambitions into question.
This summer, China experienced the worst heat wave ever recorded. The year before, there were floods after extreme weather. Does the central government change its climate policy after such extreme events?
No, I don’t see that happening. Far more extreme events would have to happen. The government is sticking to its Five-Year Plan, which also defines a number of climate targets. And the government has also achieved some successes. Carbon emissions have been falling for four quarters now, and the share of coal in the electricity mix is dropping by around one percent year by year. But of course, progress is still far too slow and not enough to achieve the Paris climate targets – like in many other countries.
In Germany, there has been a large climate movement for several years. It goes without saying that similar social movements are hardly possible in China. But is awareness of climate change growing among the population? Are grassroots organizations emerging that are calling for more climate protection in some form?
Of course, it is difficult to organize a civil society movement in China. But in the existing civil society, environmental protection is one of the main issues. And a part of them is also actively involved, but so far mainly in classical environmental protection, and usually in cooperation or agreement with the local governments. Large international organizations such as Greenpeace are also still active in China. Civil society has, for example, contributed to reducing air pollution in major cities.
It is also interesting to see what is happening in the press. Until now, floods or other extreme weather events have not been associated with climate change in the media. But that seems to have changed somewhat this summer. We have not yet systematically analyzed this, but first articles show that something is happening. A large part of the population is aware of the climate problems, probably even more people than in the USA. They believe in science.
Nis Gruenberg researches the relationship between the Chinese state and the Communist Party, elite politics, and China’s sustainable development at the Merics China Institute in Berlin. His publications focused on China’s energy sector and the reform of Chinese state-owned enterprises. Before joining Merics, Gruenberg conducted research at the Copenhagen Business School (CBS) and the Sino-Danish Center in Beijing. Gruenberg received his PhD from CBS and holds BA and MA degrees in Chinese Studies from Copenhagen University
“He genuinely paid interest and attention to what I had to say, as well as to my colleagues from other chambers,” says Joerg Wuttke, President of the EU Chamber of Commerce in China. He is talking about Hu Chunhua (胡春华), who at 59 is the youngest of the four vice premiers under Premier Li Keqiang, and is currently in charge of poverty reduction, agriculture and trade. He is considered one of the most promising candidates to succeed the departing Premier Li Keqiang.
Hu’s biggest disadvantage: He is no protégé of state and party leader Xi Jinping. Instead, Hu climbed the ranks of the Communist Youth League, the power base of Xi’s predecessor Hu Jintao – with whom the current strongman is said to not be particularly close with. Hu Jintao supported the younger Hu (no relation), as did the current premier, Li Keqiang.
But if Xi Jinping has to pay a price for securing a third term, Hu will have a good chance. The conciliatory gesture with which Xi demonstratively turned toward Hu Jintao after his opening speech at the 20th Party Congress might indicate this.
It is very likely that Xi will also have to give posts to officials who do not belong to his own, now dominant, CP faction. Otherwise, unrest could grow too strong. And Xi could probably settle for Hu Chunhua as premier. Hu already has a successful track record as vice premier, especially in the fight against poverty, something that was very important to Xi. It is also thanks to him that Xi could announce the end of absolute poverty in China in 2021.
More importantly, the farmer’s son from Hubei is very broadly positioned and has successfully managed provinces that could not be more diverse. This is considered an important criterion for the highest honors.
After an elite education at Peking University and joining the party in 1983 – under the impact of Deng Xiaoping’s opening policy – Hu was assigned to Tibet, China’s poorest province, for five years. Hu’s predecessor, Hu Jintao, was the local CP leader, which marked the beginning of the professional relationship between the two. Hu Chunhua himself belongs to the Tujia minority, which are native to western China and whose language is similar to Tibetan. In 2006, Hu was rewarded for his time in Tibet with the position of head of the Youth League – a post once held by his mentor Hu Jintao.
In 2008, Hu first became vice governor, then governor in Beijing’s neighboring province of Hebei. In 2009, however, he was offered the highest provincial job of party secretary in Inner Mongolia, a province dominated by agriculture and mineral resources and with the longest shared border with Russia. From there, Hu made it to the Politburo at the 2012 Party Congress and simultaneously became party secretary of Guangdong, China’s economically strongest and most advanced province in the deep south. He sparked a surge of innovation there, and made a name for himself as a high-tech economic reformer.
“For his policy record, I would pick Hu,” said Yu Jie, Senior Research Fellow at think tank Chatham House. “He has a very good reputation, whether in the provinces or in his position as vice premier. He’s someone who delivers.”
Beijing also considers Hu Chunhua a skilled crisis manager. In Tibet, he promoted economic development while, from Beijing’s perspective, fighting separatist organizations. He was the governor when Hebei became the epicenter of a huge scandal involving tainted milk. Hu survived the scandal and even received praise in the Party for his efficient handling of the crisis. As Mongolia’s party leader, he quelled violent riots in 2011 that left ten people dead. Local shepherds had revolted against the environmentally destructive mining industry. Hu resolved the conflict with a combination of toughness and a willingness to negotiate. The fight against corruption and the overexploitation of nature were his central themes thereafter.
Hu’s biggest rival is Wang Yang, also vice premier and Hu’s direct predecessor as party secretary in Guangdong. Wang is also considered an economic reformer. He gave Shenzhen the necessary boost to become China’s Silicon Valley. After Xi’s opening speech, Wang was the only vice premier quoted at the party congress as saying that “unity” and “strength” must now be shown. Lately, Wang always expressed noticeable loyalty to Xi.
Still, Hu Chunhua has two decisive advantages. He has experience in very poor and very rich provinces – and above all: He is eight years younger than Wang Yang. So, unlike Wang, he could govern for the next two legislative periods without exceeding the age limit of 70. In this way, Xi Jinping would also send a clear signal that he will lift the next generation to a central position.
One indication that Hu is considered a potential candidate came in July. He was allowed to write a hymn of praise about Xi’s “historic achievements”: He “personally takes command, personally goes to battle and personally supervises the battle,” Hu praised Xi’s fight against poverty.
Hu has repeatedly shown himself to be an internationally-minded economic reformer as well. In his speech to the meeting of China, South Korea, Japan and the ASEAN countries (10+3), for example, Hu called for “more entrepreneurs from around the world to invest in China.” In a speech to the France-China Committee on June 27, Hu even spoke of China’s commitment to “further open up” the country, to further “liberalize and simplify” trade and investment in China In August, in light of the zero-Covid policy, Hu urged CP cadres to once again promote greater consumption and an internationalization of the economy. Foreign trade logistics must run “more smoothly,” he said.
Hu even joked about the EU chamber’s long list of complaints about Chinese economic policy, Reuters quoted chamber chief Wuttke as saying. “Other leaders would not have taken that quite (as) well.” Companies would likely be comfortable with Hu as a premier.
Sinolytics is a European consulting and analysis company specializing in China. It advises European companies on their strategic orientation and concrete business activities in the People’s Republic.
Up to 30 former British Royal Air Force pilots reportedly have been recruited by China’s military as instructors. This was reported on Tuesday by the BBC and other British media. According to the report, the former pilots were offered up to the equivalent of €275,000 to share their expertise with the Chinese air force.
The information sought by China includes details of how Western military aircraft and pilots operate. In the event of a war over Taiwan, such knowledge would be vital for devising tactics, the BBC quotes a Western official as saying. Pilots from other countries are also said to have been contacted by headhunters on behalf of the Chinese military.
According to the BBC, British security agencies first became aware of recruitment attempts of former but also active pilots in 2019. A spokesman for the British Ministry of Defense told the newspaper that the recruitment of former military pilots does not violate current law. However, former pilots are expressly warned not to work for the Chinese military.
A spokesperson for the British Government said that “decisive steps” are being taken to stop Chinese recruitment programs. The spokesperson further said that the government was “reviewing the use of confidentiality contracts and non-disclosure agreements.” A new National Security Bill is also expected to quickly address the current security threat.
On Tuesday, British Home Secretary Suella Braverman declared, unrelated to the news about China’s military influence, that British citizens who act on behalf of hostile states, subvert democracy and endanger national security will face up to five years in prison. Legislation to that effect is said to be on the way. It has not yet been clarified which states will be subject to it. fpe
A diplomatic crisis is brewing between London and Beijing after the violent incident at a protest outside the Chinese consulate in Manchester. On Tuesday, British Foreign Secretary James Cleverley summoned the Chinese deputy ambassador. The latter was asked to explain the “apparent scenes of violence.” The ambassador is currently out of the country. According to Manchester police, a protester had been dragged into the building and beaten by staff of the Chinese consulate on Sunday. Secretary of State, Jesse Norman, stressed that the government was “extremely concerned” about the actions of the consulate staff. Police had been called because of the protest, and “intervened to restore order,” Norman said. Police reportedly launched an investigation.
China’s Foreign Ministry, meanwhile, defended its diplomats’ physical violence against the Hong Kong activists. Diplomatic missions have the right to “take necessary measures to maintain the peace and dignity of the premises” Foreign Office spokesman Wang Wenbin said in Beijing. The protesters had allegedly gained “illegal access” and jeopardized the consulate’s security. China expressed hope that the British side would take “effective measures” to improve the consulate’s security.
On Sunday, Hong Kong protesters had set up posters and shouted slogans in front of the building – coinciding with the start of the Communist Party Congress in Beijing – to protest CCP rule in their city as well (China.Table reported). Videos on social media showed several men dragging one of the protesters onto the consulate grounds and kicking and punching him. The situation had only calmed down after the police intervened. ck
China instructed its state-owned gas importers to stop reselling liquefied natural gas (LNG) to customers in Europe and Asia. The move is intended to secure the country’s own supply for the winter heating season.
China’s National Development and Reform Commission ordered PetroChina Co, Sinopec and CNOOC Ltd to keep winter shipments for domestic consumption, Bloomberg reported on Tuesday. China is one of the main gas exporters to Europe since Russia cut deliveries. It managed to buy Russian fuel at a cheap price as a result of the sanctions.
Faced with weak domestic demand, Chinese traders diverted some of these supplies to Europe this year. However, as European gas storage quickly filled and transportation costs reached record highs, the attractiveness of LNG resale dwindled, according to Bloomberg.
Beijing also pledged to keep China’s homes warm this winter. In his speech at the Party Congress on Sunday, President Xi Jinping stressed the importance of energy security and reiterated that the country must avoid the risks of a supply crisis at all costs. fpe
The EU Commission urged European governments to safeguard their 5G mobile networks. “Member States which have not yet enacted restrictions on high-risk suppliers should do so without further delay, considering that time lost can increase the vulnerability of networks in the Union,” the EU Commission wrote in a proposal for a council recommendation regarding the protection of critical infrastructure, published on Tuesday.
The term “high-risk supplier” is used in Brussels to refer primarily to the Chinese telecommunications providers Huawei and ZTE. While Huawei’s technology plays a central role in many European mobile networks, it faces a de facto exclusion from 5G rollout in many important markets (China.Table reported). The network equipment supplier is considered to be technically sophisticated and comparatively cheap on the global market. However, there are doubts about its trustworthiness; the group is suspected of spying on rivals for its country’s intelligence services and gaining control of critical infrastructure. (China.Table reported)
The EU Commission warns not to rely on information provided by manufacturers. “It is essential that all Member States urgently achieve the implementation of the measures recommended in the Toolbox and in particular apply the relevant restrictions on high-risk suppliers for key assets defined as critical and sensitive in the EU coordinated risk assessment,” the proposal continues.
Coinciding with the EU’s warning, however, Huawei strengthened its presence in Europe. The technology giant announced plans to invest €150 million in its first European cloud center in Dublin. Over the next two years, 60 jobs are to be created, rising to 200 by 2027. mw
China’s leading battery manufacturer Contemporary Amperex Technology (CATL) will supply the batteries for a massive solar and power storage project called Gemini in Nevada. To this end, CATL signed a contract as sole battery supplier with US-based utility and energy company Primergy Solar LLC, as the business magazine Caixin reported on Tuesday. The investment volume is $1.2 billion.
CATL announced that the Gemini project will use its EnerOne modular battery storage system. It will be one of the largest solar and storage projects in the United States, the company said, with a solar array of 690 megawatts of alternating current (MWac) capacity, or 966 megawatts of direct current (DC) capacity, and 1,416 MWh of storage capacity. “Together with CATL, we are building a market leading and highly sophisticated battery storage system,” Primergy CEO Ty Daul said, according to Caixin. It will reportedly collect excess solar power during the day and store it for use in Nevada after sundown. ck
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) has approved a clinical trial of Chinese-manufactured COVID-19 vaccine. The mRNA vaccine, made by Suzhou Abogen Biosciences, is particularly effective against the widely spread Cmicron variants BA.4 and BA.5. Suzhou Abogen Biosciences now has four mRNA vaccines in development.
Earlier this month, an mRNA vaccine co-developed by Abogen already received emergency approval in Indonesia (China.Table reported). In contrast, China’s health authorities themselves have not yet approved any emergency use with an mRNA vaccine in their own country – although candidates from various companies have been approved for clinical trials in the last three years.
German manufacturer Biontech, which has partnered with Shanghai Fosun Pharmaceutical in Mainland China, is stuck in regulatory review procedures for the past year. So far, China relied on inactivated vaccines to protect its citizens, although they are less effective against the Omicron and Delta variants. Some analysts believe that China might wait for a domestic mRNA vaccine to avoid dependence on foreign countries. fpe
“Both things came together: A whole new life for my country, and a whole new life for me,” Diana Mickevičienė tells about her youth. She was 18 years old when Lithuania declared independence from the Soviet Union in 1990. A historic moment. But the rulers in Moscow tried to forcefully quell Lithuania’s push for freedom on January 13, 1991. Mickevičienė was on the streets of Vilnius that night and had to witness Russian special forces opening fire on her fellow students.
The soldiers were unable to stop Lithuania’s independence, but they left scars that continue to shape Mickevičienė to this day. “Losing freedom and regaining it is part of my story,” says the now 48-year-old. In her newfound freedom, Mickevičienė studied philosophy, history and international relations.
And it qualified her for Lithuania’s diplomatic service, which is looking for fresh talent. For Mickevičienė, diplomacy is her gateway to the world, after a youth spent behind the Iron Curtain. What inspires her is that she can tell Lithuania’s story as a diplomat. The story of Soviet oppression, but also the success story of the young democratic Lithuania.
In 2020, she was appointed ambassador to China. By then, relations between Lithuania and China cooled noticeably. In 2019, Chinese nationalists assaulted peaceful protesters in Vilnius who showed solidarity with the Hong Kong protests. A shock for Lithuania, which celebrated its own independence from Soviet repression on that very day.
After further intimidation attempts, disappointed Lithuania left China’s 17+1 format in 2021. This also made life more difficult for Mickevičienė, as the ambassador is henceforth barred from all official appointments. Soon after, Taiwan opened a representative office under the name “Taiwan Office” in Vilnius. Beijing was furious, expelled Mickevičienė – and blocked almost all exports from Lithuania to China ever since. Things got ugly in Beijing. China downgraded the status of the embassy in Beijing, cut Lithuania off from diplomatic e-mails, simulated a bomb alert in the embassy building and gave staff seven days to leave China.
“In seven days we had to give up our whole lives in China, with families, bank accounts and pets,” recalls Mickevičienė. In the end, Western diplomats escorted the Lithuanian staff to the airport – fearing their Lithuanian colleagues with expiring accreditations would be targeted by the border police. “We understood: Because we are a small country standing up to China, they want to make an example of us,” summarizes Mickevičienė.
And she couples her analysis with a message. The EU needs to position itself better, she says, to ensure that smaller member countries do not fall under the wheels of China’s economic power. The European Commission’s Anti-Coercion Instrument (ACI) is a step in the right direction, she believes. “We need instruments that show the other side: The single market is our strength, not our weakness.”
She also has a clear message for Germany: Dependence on the Chinese market deprives Germany of its political breathing room. “The situation with Russian gas should have opened Germany’s eyes,” Mickevičienė said. Jonathan Kaspar Teacher
Chenye Yu has taken on the role of Business Operations & Strategy Analyst at NIO in Munich. The EV manufacturer from Hefei wants to move to the European market with locations in Germany and also set up battery swap stations and its own charging infrastructure.
Marcus Peikert took over the position of Industrial Engineering Director at ebm-papst China in September. Peikert has been working for the Baden-Wurttemberg-based global fan market leader in Shanghai since 2013. Most recently, he served there as Technical Plant Director.
Is something changing in your organization? Why not let us know at heads@table.media!
While the CCP convenes in the Great Hall of the People, the Daxing International Hydrogen Energy Demonstration Zone on the outskirts of the capital is all about future technologies. The zone is part of a “3+N” hydrogen industry ecosystem jointly developed by the cities of Beijing and Tianjin and the province of Hebei (Jing-Jin-Ji). At a presentation, this employee presents a hydrogen hybrid motorcycle concept.
In his nearly two-hour-long speech on Sunday, Xi Jinping once again emphasized China’s energy security. But he also reiterated that the country must continue to drive forward the green transformation. So a departure from China’s climate goals is not to be expected during Xi’s third term in office. However, it will be interesting to see how he will set priorities when things get tough. “How quickly political instability and supply fears can call climate ambitions into question is something we currently witness globally,” explains Nis Gruenberg of the Merics Institute in an interview with Nico Beckert. Because when it comes to fulfilling climate issues, China’s head of state is primarily also concerned with maintaining his own power, the energy policy expert says. “The more uncertain the overall situation, the more uncertain the green transition will be.”
Meanwhile, the official pictures from the Great Hall of the People in Beijing show how firmly Xi currently sits in the saddle. Sometimes in wide angle and sometimes in long shot pictures, Xi is the center of attention in the Middle Kingdom. No one can match him, no one can get close to him. But even an autocrat needs a loyal sidekick. As for who will be the new prime minister at his side in March 2023, we can currently only read between the lines and, at best, from gestures.
One man who Xi pays particular attention to is Hu Chunhua. The 59-year-old is the youngest of China’s four vice presidents under Premier Li Keqiang, and is currently in charge of poverty reduction, agriculture and trade. For the German economy, Hu would be a preferred candidate, says Frank Sieren. He analyzes that Hu is considered a credible and pragmatic crisis manager, as he proved, for example, in the milk powder scandal of 2008. But more importantly, Hu has never lost sight of the goal of further opening China. As recently as August of this year, he declared that China must further “liberalize and simplify” trade and investment for foreign companies. Unheard-of in times of decoupling and zero-Covid isolation.
Carbon emissions have risen less sharply than before since Xi Jinping took office. How much credit can the CP leader take for this? And how important is climate protection to Xi Jinping?
It is of course always difficult to pin this on one person. But in any case, the long-term phase-out of coal and the reduction of carbon emissions are among the most important items on Xi’s political agenda. Xi sees climate protection and adaptation to climate change as a prerequisite for the party’s long-term grip on power and the current form of government. Unfortunately, in the medium term, energy security is also valued more important in China than climate policy; this is currently hurting the ambitions for emission targets.
To what extent can Xi “overrule” on climate protection? How big is the influence of the provinces and state-owned enterprises on this?
This is, of course, an extremely complex game because China is so big. There are provinces that benefit more from rapid transformation than others. But the coal provinces are losing jobs and growth. The provinces are a relatively powerful player, maybe not when it comes to standing up to the central government, but to implementing what comes from Beijing – or delaying the implementation of climate policy. And the central government also likes to turn a blind eye sometimes, especially in times of crisis.
How important is the fact that the central government’s policies are sometimes vague and leave a lot of room for interpretation?
That certainly plays a role. The central government tends to set macro targets: By how many percent per year should emissions fall or renewable energies be expanded? The provinces, the power companies – which are state-owned enterprises – and local players then have to implement these targets. And there are various interests, so of course there are delays.
Where do you see the biggest shortcomings in China’s climate policy of recent years?
China does not have adequate climate plans that would be compatible with the Paris Agreement. So even if the People’s Republic achieves its 2030/2060 targets, it would not contribute a sufficiently large share to meet the Paris climate goals. Another major shortcoming is: China does have the political will and the technical capabilities to rapidly advance the green transition. But still, with every little crisis, the coal lobby manages to slow down the phase-out. And new coal-fired power plants are still being built. This, in turn, will make the phase-out more difficult in the future.
Announced reforms in the power sector to push coal faster out of the grids have also been around for almost 20 years. But not much has happened. Yet there is a lot of potential for cutting carbon emissions in these areas.
What do you expect from Xi Jinping’s third term in office regarding climate protection?
In terms of climate policy, there will generally not be much change during the third term in office. It will move in a greener direction, with coal decreasing by a good one percent per year in the energy mix. But whether it can go faster will also be determined by realpolitik factors – be it economic crises or international tensions. The more uncertain the overall situation, the more uncertain the green transition will be. The transformation will continue, but probably at a slower pace than in a calmer global situation. We currently see globally how quickly political instability and supply fears call climate ambitions into question.
This summer, China experienced the worst heat wave ever recorded. The year before, there were floods after extreme weather. Does the central government change its climate policy after such extreme events?
No, I don’t see that happening. Far more extreme events would have to happen. The government is sticking to its Five-Year Plan, which also defines a number of climate targets. And the government has also achieved some successes. Carbon emissions have been falling for four quarters now, and the share of coal in the electricity mix is dropping by around one percent year by year. But of course, progress is still far too slow and not enough to achieve the Paris climate targets – like in many other countries.
In Germany, there has been a large climate movement for several years. It goes without saying that similar social movements are hardly possible in China. But is awareness of climate change growing among the population? Are grassroots organizations emerging that are calling for more climate protection in some form?
Of course, it is difficult to organize a civil society movement in China. But in the existing civil society, environmental protection is one of the main issues. And a part of them is also actively involved, but so far mainly in classical environmental protection, and usually in cooperation or agreement with the local governments. Large international organizations such as Greenpeace are also still active in China. Civil society has, for example, contributed to reducing air pollution in major cities.
It is also interesting to see what is happening in the press. Until now, floods or other extreme weather events have not been associated with climate change in the media. But that seems to have changed somewhat this summer. We have not yet systematically analyzed this, but first articles show that something is happening. A large part of the population is aware of the climate problems, probably even more people than in the USA. They believe in science.
Nis Gruenberg researches the relationship between the Chinese state and the Communist Party, elite politics, and China’s sustainable development at the Merics China Institute in Berlin. His publications focused on China’s energy sector and the reform of Chinese state-owned enterprises. Before joining Merics, Gruenberg conducted research at the Copenhagen Business School (CBS) and the Sino-Danish Center in Beijing. Gruenberg received his PhD from CBS and holds BA and MA degrees in Chinese Studies from Copenhagen University
“He genuinely paid interest and attention to what I had to say, as well as to my colleagues from other chambers,” says Joerg Wuttke, President of the EU Chamber of Commerce in China. He is talking about Hu Chunhua (胡春华), who at 59 is the youngest of the four vice premiers under Premier Li Keqiang, and is currently in charge of poverty reduction, agriculture and trade. He is considered one of the most promising candidates to succeed the departing Premier Li Keqiang.
Hu’s biggest disadvantage: He is no protégé of state and party leader Xi Jinping. Instead, Hu climbed the ranks of the Communist Youth League, the power base of Xi’s predecessor Hu Jintao – with whom the current strongman is said to not be particularly close with. Hu Jintao supported the younger Hu (no relation), as did the current premier, Li Keqiang.
But if Xi Jinping has to pay a price for securing a third term, Hu will have a good chance. The conciliatory gesture with which Xi demonstratively turned toward Hu Jintao after his opening speech at the 20th Party Congress might indicate this.
It is very likely that Xi will also have to give posts to officials who do not belong to his own, now dominant, CP faction. Otherwise, unrest could grow too strong. And Xi could probably settle for Hu Chunhua as premier. Hu already has a successful track record as vice premier, especially in the fight against poverty, something that was very important to Xi. It is also thanks to him that Xi could announce the end of absolute poverty in China in 2021.
More importantly, the farmer’s son from Hubei is very broadly positioned and has successfully managed provinces that could not be more diverse. This is considered an important criterion for the highest honors.
After an elite education at Peking University and joining the party in 1983 – under the impact of Deng Xiaoping’s opening policy – Hu was assigned to Tibet, China’s poorest province, for five years. Hu’s predecessor, Hu Jintao, was the local CP leader, which marked the beginning of the professional relationship between the two. Hu Chunhua himself belongs to the Tujia minority, which are native to western China and whose language is similar to Tibetan. In 2006, Hu was rewarded for his time in Tibet with the position of head of the Youth League – a post once held by his mentor Hu Jintao.
In 2008, Hu first became vice governor, then governor in Beijing’s neighboring province of Hebei. In 2009, however, he was offered the highest provincial job of party secretary in Inner Mongolia, a province dominated by agriculture and mineral resources and with the longest shared border with Russia. From there, Hu made it to the Politburo at the 2012 Party Congress and simultaneously became party secretary of Guangdong, China’s economically strongest and most advanced province in the deep south. He sparked a surge of innovation there, and made a name for himself as a high-tech economic reformer.
“For his policy record, I would pick Hu,” said Yu Jie, Senior Research Fellow at think tank Chatham House. “He has a very good reputation, whether in the provinces or in his position as vice premier. He’s someone who delivers.”
Beijing also considers Hu Chunhua a skilled crisis manager. In Tibet, he promoted economic development while, from Beijing’s perspective, fighting separatist organizations. He was the governor when Hebei became the epicenter of a huge scandal involving tainted milk. Hu survived the scandal and even received praise in the Party for his efficient handling of the crisis. As Mongolia’s party leader, he quelled violent riots in 2011 that left ten people dead. Local shepherds had revolted against the environmentally destructive mining industry. Hu resolved the conflict with a combination of toughness and a willingness to negotiate. The fight against corruption and the overexploitation of nature were his central themes thereafter.
Hu’s biggest rival is Wang Yang, also vice premier and Hu’s direct predecessor as party secretary in Guangdong. Wang is also considered an economic reformer. He gave Shenzhen the necessary boost to become China’s Silicon Valley. After Xi’s opening speech, Wang was the only vice premier quoted at the party congress as saying that “unity” and “strength” must now be shown. Lately, Wang always expressed noticeable loyalty to Xi.
Still, Hu Chunhua has two decisive advantages. He has experience in very poor and very rich provinces – and above all: He is eight years younger than Wang Yang. So, unlike Wang, he could govern for the next two legislative periods without exceeding the age limit of 70. In this way, Xi Jinping would also send a clear signal that he will lift the next generation to a central position.
One indication that Hu is considered a potential candidate came in July. He was allowed to write a hymn of praise about Xi’s “historic achievements”: He “personally takes command, personally goes to battle and personally supervises the battle,” Hu praised Xi’s fight against poverty.
Hu has repeatedly shown himself to be an internationally-minded economic reformer as well. In his speech to the meeting of China, South Korea, Japan and the ASEAN countries (10+3), for example, Hu called for “more entrepreneurs from around the world to invest in China.” In a speech to the France-China Committee on June 27, Hu even spoke of China’s commitment to “further open up” the country, to further “liberalize and simplify” trade and investment in China In August, in light of the zero-Covid policy, Hu urged CP cadres to once again promote greater consumption and an internationalization of the economy. Foreign trade logistics must run “more smoothly,” he said.
Hu even joked about the EU chamber’s long list of complaints about Chinese economic policy, Reuters quoted chamber chief Wuttke as saying. “Other leaders would not have taken that quite (as) well.” Companies would likely be comfortable with Hu as a premier.
Sinolytics is a European consulting and analysis company specializing in China. It advises European companies on their strategic orientation and concrete business activities in the People’s Republic.
Up to 30 former British Royal Air Force pilots reportedly have been recruited by China’s military as instructors. This was reported on Tuesday by the BBC and other British media. According to the report, the former pilots were offered up to the equivalent of €275,000 to share their expertise with the Chinese air force.
The information sought by China includes details of how Western military aircraft and pilots operate. In the event of a war over Taiwan, such knowledge would be vital for devising tactics, the BBC quotes a Western official as saying. Pilots from other countries are also said to have been contacted by headhunters on behalf of the Chinese military.
According to the BBC, British security agencies first became aware of recruitment attempts of former but also active pilots in 2019. A spokesman for the British Ministry of Defense told the newspaper that the recruitment of former military pilots does not violate current law. However, former pilots are expressly warned not to work for the Chinese military.
A spokesperson for the British Government said that “decisive steps” are being taken to stop Chinese recruitment programs. The spokesperson further said that the government was “reviewing the use of confidentiality contracts and non-disclosure agreements.” A new National Security Bill is also expected to quickly address the current security threat.
On Tuesday, British Home Secretary Suella Braverman declared, unrelated to the news about China’s military influence, that British citizens who act on behalf of hostile states, subvert democracy and endanger national security will face up to five years in prison. Legislation to that effect is said to be on the way. It has not yet been clarified which states will be subject to it. fpe
A diplomatic crisis is brewing between London and Beijing after the violent incident at a protest outside the Chinese consulate in Manchester. On Tuesday, British Foreign Secretary James Cleverley summoned the Chinese deputy ambassador. The latter was asked to explain the “apparent scenes of violence.” The ambassador is currently out of the country. According to Manchester police, a protester had been dragged into the building and beaten by staff of the Chinese consulate on Sunday. Secretary of State, Jesse Norman, stressed that the government was “extremely concerned” about the actions of the consulate staff. Police had been called because of the protest, and “intervened to restore order,” Norman said. Police reportedly launched an investigation.
China’s Foreign Ministry, meanwhile, defended its diplomats’ physical violence against the Hong Kong activists. Diplomatic missions have the right to “take necessary measures to maintain the peace and dignity of the premises” Foreign Office spokesman Wang Wenbin said in Beijing. The protesters had allegedly gained “illegal access” and jeopardized the consulate’s security. China expressed hope that the British side would take “effective measures” to improve the consulate’s security.
On Sunday, Hong Kong protesters had set up posters and shouted slogans in front of the building – coinciding with the start of the Communist Party Congress in Beijing – to protest CCP rule in their city as well (China.Table reported). Videos on social media showed several men dragging one of the protesters onto the consulate grounds and kicking and punching him. The situation had only calmed down after the police intervened. ck
China instructed its state-owned gas importers to stop reselling liquefied natural gas (LNG) to customers in Europe and Asia. The move is intended to secure the country’s own supply for the winter heating season.
China’s National Development and Reform Commission ordered PetroChina Co, Sinopec and CNOOC Ltd to keep winter shipments for domestic consumption, Bloomberg reported on Tuesday. China is one of the main gas exporters to Europe since Russia cut deliveries. It managed to buy Russian fuel at a cheap price as a result of the sanctions.
Faced with weak domestic demand, Chinese traders diverted some of these supplies to Europe this year. However, as European gas storage quickly filled and transportation costs reached record highs, the attractiveness of LNG resale dwindled, according to Bloomberg.
Beijing also pledged to keep China’s homes warm this winter. In his speech at the Party Congress on Sunday, President Xi Jinping stressed the importance of energy security and reiterated that the country must avoid the risks of a supply crisis at all costs. fpe
The EU Commission urged European governments to safeguard their 5G mobile networks. “Member States which have not yet enacted restrictions on high-risk suppliers should do so without further delay, considering that time lost can increase the vulnerability of networks in the Union,” the EU Commission wrote in a proposal for a council recommendation regarding the protection of critical infrastructure, published on Tuesday.
The term “high-risk supplier” is used in Brussels to refer primarily to the Chinese telecommunications providers Huawei and ZTE. While Huawei’s technology plays a central role in many European mobile networks, it faces a de facto exclusion from 5G rollout in many important markets (China.Table reported). The network equipment supplier is considered to be technically sophisticated and comparatively cheap on the global market. However, there are doubts about its trustworthiness; the group is suspected of spying on rivals for its country’s intelligence services and gaining control of critical infrastructure. (China.Table reported)
The EU Commission warns not to rely on information provided by manufacturers. “It is essential that all Member States urgently achieve the implementation of the measures recommended in the Toolbox and in particular apply the relevant restrictions on high-risk suppliers for key assets defined as critical and sensitive in the EU coordinated risk assessment,” the proposal continues.
Coinciding with the EU’s warning, however, Huawei strengthened its presence in Europe. The technology giant announced plans to invest €150 million in its first European cloud center in Dublin. Over the next two years, 60 jobs are to be created, rising to 200 by 2027. mw
China’s leading battery manufacturer Contemporary Amperex Technology (CATL) will supply the batteries for a massive solar and power storage project called Gemini in Nevada. To this end, CATL signed a contract as sole battery supplier with US-based utility and energy company Primergy Solar LLC, as the business magazine Caixin reported on Tuesday. The investment volume is $1.2 billion.
CATL announced that the Gemini project will use its EnerOne modular battery storage system. It will be one of the largest solar and storage projects in the United States, the company said, with a solar array of 690 megawatts of alternating current (MWac) capacity, or 966 megawatts of direct current (DC) capacity, and 1,416 MWh of storage capacity. “Together with CATL, we are building a market leading and highly sophisticated battery storage system,” Primergy CEO Ty Daul said, according to Caixin. It will reportedly collect excess solar power during the day and store it for use in Nevada after sundown. ck
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) has approved a clinical trial of Chinese-manufactured COVID-19 vaccine. The mRNA vaccine, made by Suzhou Abogen Biosciences, is particularly effective against the widely spread Cmicron variants BA.4 and BA.5. Suzhou Abogen Biosciences now has four mRNA vaccines in development.
Earlier this month, an mRNA vaccine co-developed by Abogen already received emergency approval in Indonesia (China.Table reported). In contrast, China’s health authorities themselves have not yet approved any emergency use with an mRNA vaccine in their own country – although candidates from various companies have been approved for clinical trials in the last three years.
German manufacturer Biontech, which has partnered with Shanghai Fosun Pharmaceutical in Mainland China, is stuck in regulatory review procedures for the past year. So far, China relied on inactivated vaccines to protect its citizens, although they are less effective against the Omicron and Delta variants. Some analysts believe that China might wait for a domestic mRNA vaccine to avoid dependence on foreign countries. fpe
“Both things came together: A whole new life for my country, and a whole new life for me,” Diana Mickevičienė tells about her youth. She was 18 years old when Lithuania declared independence from the Soviet Union in 1990. A historic moment. But the rulers in Moscow tried to forcefully quell Lithuania’s push for freedom on January 13, 1991. Mickevičienė was on the streets of Vilnius that night and had to witness Russian special forces opening fire on her fellow students.
The soldiers were unable to stop Lithuania’s independence, but they left scars that continue to shape Mickevičienė to this day. “Losing freedom and regaining it is part of my story,” says the now 48-year-old. In her newfound freedom, Mickevičienė studied philosophy, history and international relations.
And it qualified her for Lithuania’s diplomatic service, which is looking for fresh talent. For Mickevičienė, diplomacy is her gateway to the world, after a youth spent behind the Iron Curtain. What inspires her is that she can tell Lithuania’s story as a diplomat. The story of Soviet oppression, but also the success story of the young democratic Lithuania.
In 2020, she was appointed ambassador to China. By then, relations between Lithuania and China cooled noticeably. In 2019, Chinese nationalists assaulted peaceful protesters in Vilnius who showed solidarity with the Hong Kong protests. A shock for Lithuania, which celebrated its own independence from Soviet repression on that very day.
After further intimidation attempts, disappointed Lithuania left China’s 17+1 format in 2021. This also made life more difficult for Mickevičienė, as the ambassador is henceforth barred from all official appointments. Soon after, Taiwan opened a representative office under the name “Taiwan Office” in Vilnius. Beijing was furious, expelled Mickevičienė – and blocked almost all exports from Lithuania to China ever since. Things got ugly in Beijing. China downgraded the status of the embassy in Beijing, cut Lithuania off from diplomatic e-mails, simulated a bomb alert in the embassy building and gave staff seven days to leave China.
“In seven days we had to give up our whole lives in China, with families, bank accounts and pets,” recalls Mickevičienė. In the end, Western diplomats escorted the Lithuanian staff to the airport – fearing their Lithuanian colleagues with expiring accreditations would be targeted by the border police. “We understood: Because we are a small country standing up to China, they want to make an example of us,” summarizes Mickevičienė.
And she couples her analysis with a message. The EU needs to position itself better, she says, to ensure that smaller member countries do not fall under the wheels of China’s economic power. The European Commission’s Anti-Coercion Instrument (ACI) is a step in the right direction, she believes. “We need instruments that show the other side: The single market is our strength, not our weakness.”
She also has a clear message for Germany: Dependence on the Chinese market deprives Germany of its political breathing room. “The situation with Russian gas should have opened Germany’s eyes,” Mickevičienė said. Jonathan Kaspar Teacher
Chenye Yu has taken on the role of Business Operations & Strategy Analyst at NIO in Munich. The EV manufacturer from Hefei wants to move to the European market with locations in Germany and also set up battery swap stations and its own charging infrastructure.
Marcus Peikert took over the position of Industrial Engineering Director at ebm-papst China in September. Peikert has been working for the Baden-Wurttemberg-based global fan market leader in Shanghai since 2013. Most recently, he served there as Technical Plant Director.
Is something changing in your organization? Why not let us know at heads@table.media!
While the CCP convenes in the Great Hall of the People, the Daxing International Hydrogen Energy Demonstration Zone on the outskirts of the capital is all about future technologies. The zone is part of a “3+N” hydrogen industry ecosystem jointly developed by the cities of Beijing and Tianjin and the province of Hebei (Jing-Jin-Ji). At a presentation, this employee presents a hydrogen hybrid motorcycle concept.